Is Turkey a threat to Israel?
This week, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's Commission for the Evaluation of the Defense Establishment Budget and the Balance of Power released a report addressing the country’s future strategy, military modernization, industrial expansion and defense spending.
The commission, led by Prof. Yaakov Nagel, a retired brigadier general and a former national security advisor to Netanyahu, includes eight other officers, seven of them retired generals and one of whom is another former Netanyahu national security adviser. That the report has a hawkish tone therefore should not come as a surprise.
Israel is still at war with Hamas — and, for that matter, the Houthis of Yemen. But the report underscores that little is stable in the Middle East — today’s friend could be tomorrow’s enemy.
While the report stresses the importance of maintaining the closest possible ties with the U.S., it also asserts that Israel needs to expand its industrial base, because even America might not be a reliable supplier of military equipment if a Democrat succeeds Donald Trump in the White House.
Most importantly, the commission offers a truism about Israel’s future survival: The Jewish state cannot afford to lose even one major war. In that regard — unsurprisingly given its composition — the commission points to Iran as the country’s long-term primary threat.
Yet it identifies an additional threat that has made headlines in Israel. Not only might the new rebel-led Sunni regime in Syria become radicalized, but under Turkish influence, and with Turkish support, it could create a more serious threat on Israel’s northern border than the Assad regime ever was.
As the report states: “One cannot forget the origins of the [Syrian] rebels and their leaders. … Israel could find itself confronting a new threat that would emerge in Syria — one no less serious than its predecessor, that would take the form of an extremist Sunni power that would not accept the existence of Israel. Moreover, because the Sunni rebels will have the power of the state … their threat could be greater [even] than that of Iran. … The problem will intensify if the Syrian regime will in practice become a ‘Turkish’ proxy, as a substantive part of Turkey’s dream to restore its former Ottoman crown. The presence of Turkish emissaries or Turkish forces in Syria could intensify the danger of a direct Turkish-Israeli confrontation.”
The new Syrian regime’s future orientation certainly is a cause for Israeli concern. Indeed, the refusal of its leader, Ahmed al Sharaa, to shake hands with German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock because she is a woman hardly indicates that the regime will be a force for moderation. Nevertheless, Israel faced a hostile Sunni Syria from its creation in 1948 until Hafez al-Assad seized the reins of power in 1971. It deterred Damascus at that time and can do so again, especially given a power balance that is now entirely in Jerusalem’s favor.
It is not surprising that the commission should consider the worst-case effects of Turkish influence on the new Syrian regime. Nevertheless, Turkish support need not result in a confrontation, much less an actual conflict with Israel — Israeli media headlines about war with Turkey notwithstanding. The term that the commission employs, “confrontation,” does not mean conflict. The U.S. Marines had a tense “confrontation” with Israeli forces in Lebanon in 1983; the U.S. Navy confronted the Soviets during the 1962 Cuban Missile Crisis. In neither case did war break out.
Indeed, Israel and Turkey confronted each other during the 2010 Mavi Marmara incident, in which Israeli commandos boarded a civilian ship heading towards Gaza and killed eight Turkish citizens. Not only did the two countries not go to war, they actually restored relations after several years.
President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s hostility to Israel has fluctuated with Israel’s relations with Hamas, a subsidiary of the Muslim Brotherhood that Erdogan supports. Once Israel’s war with Hamas comes to an end — perhaps when the Trump administration is fully ensconced in office and the new president pressures the group to release Israeli hostages, as he has promised he would do — Turkish-Israeli relations could once again be on the upswing.
While the Nagel Commission might worry that Israel and Turkey could find themselves on the verge of war, it certainly is not in America’s interest for two of its key allies to edge toward such a conflict. On the contrary, Washington should encourage Ankara to act as a moderating influence on the new Syrian regime. It is not an accident that America helped quell the tensions arising from the Mavi Marmara crisis. And American influence in Turkey is certain to grow once the Trump administration takes office.
Therefore, should Jerusalem and Ankara appear headed on a collision course, Washington should again quickly intervene to ensure that the Nagel Commission’s worst-case scenario does not become reality.
Dov S. Zakheim is a senior adviser at the Center for Strategic and International Studies and vice chairman of the board for the Foreign Policy Research Institute. He was undersecretary of Defense (comptroller) and chief financial officer for the Department of Defense from 2001 to 2004 and a deputy undersecretary of Defense from 1985 to 1987.
-
Arab States Race Turkey for Influence in New Syria
Saudi Arabia and others are overlooking the new leadership’s jihadist past, hoping to gain an advantage on rivals in the strategically positioned country.The Wall Street Journal - 12h -
Conflict between Turkey and Kurdish groups rises around key dam in northern Syria
A key dam in northern Syria has become a flash point in the conflict between Kurdish forces and Turkish-backed armed groupsABC News - 23h -
Old photo of Turkey quake falsely linked to Tibet jolt
Yahoo News - 1d -
The forces driving Turkey’s resurgence as a superpower
Peter Frankopan on a book that argues that Sunni Islam has reversed the declining influence of religion on Turkish societyFinancial Times - 1d -
The Musk threat to European democracy
Free speech push, now backed by Meta’s Zuckerberg, risks spread of disinformationFinancial Times - 1d -
Turkey insists on two states for ethnically divided Cyprus as the UN looks to restart peace talks
Turkey has again insisted on a two-state peace accord in ethnically divided Cyprus as the United Nations prepares to meet with all sides in early springABC News - 1d -
Turkey insists on two states for ethnically divided Cyprus as the UN looks to restart peace talks
Yahoo News - 2d -
Israel's judiciary reins in far-right police minister
Yahoo News - Jan. 2 -
The Erdoğan whisperer behind Turkey’s economic pivot
Vice-president Cevdet Yılmaz has played a crucial backstage role managing the turn to financial orthodoxyFinancial Times - Jan. 2
More from The Hill
-
Listen: Trump hush money sentencing hearing
President-elect Trump was sentenced in his hush money conviction on Friday, but faced no punishment by a judge during a hearing in New York in which he appeared virtually with one of his defense ...The Hill - 29m -
Carville: Reported $40M budget for Melania Trump Amazon documentary 'breathtaking'
James Carville questioned the $40 million budget for Melania Trump’s documentary set to debut on Amazon Prime later this year. “You can produce a world-class documentary for $2 million. I know it,” ...The Hill - 31m -
2 spy agencies float possibility of foreign weapon behind 'Havana syndrome,' but most find no links
A report from the intelligence community released Friday maintains its conclusion that a foreign adversary is not behind the mysterious ailments plaguing government workers, but it opened the door ...The Hill - 33m -
Prosecutors seek 15-year sentence for Menendez after bribery, foreign agent conviction
Federal prosecutors recommended a 15-year prison sentence for former Sen. Bob Menendez (D-N.J.), who was convicted this summer of trading his political influence for bribes. Prosecutors accused the ...The Hill - 35m -
Xi to send high-level representative to Trump inauguration: Report
Chinese President Xi Jinping is reportedly choosing a high-level official to represent him at President-elect Trump’s inauguration on Jan. 20, in a break from diplomatic protocol of years past. ...The Hill - 44m
More in Politics
-
Supreme Court considers whether to allow TikTok ban to take effect
The fate of a law that would likely ban social media platform TikTok in the United States goes before the Supreme Court as the justices consider whether to block it.NBC News - 17m -
Listen Live: Supreme Court hears arguments over TikTok ban
The Supreme Court is hearing arguments over a law that could lead to TikTok shutting down in the U.S. in less than two weeks.CBS News - 27m -
Listen: Trump hush money sentencing hearing
President-elect Trump was sentenced in his hush money conviction on Friday, but faced no punishment by a judge during a hearing in New York in which he appeared virtually with one of his defense ...The Hill - 29m -
Carville: Reported $40M budget for Melania Trump Amazon documentary 'breathtaking'
James Carville questioned the $40 million budget for Melania Trump’s documentary set to debut on Amazon Prime later this year. “You can produce a world-class documentary for $2 million. I know it,” ...The Hill - 31m -
2 spy agencies float possibility of foreign weapon behind 'Havana syndrome,' but most find no links
A report from the intelligence community released Friday maintains its conclusion that a foreign adversary is not behind the mysterious ailments plaguing government workers, but it opened the door ...The Hill - 33m