Is it 1833 yet? The long history of the partisan press in America.

The media is filled with stories blaring details of political scandal, the immorality of politicians and seditious behavior of candidates running for president. Vicious allegations of corruption and misbehavior are standard fare as politicians are relentlessly attacked in the media.

Campaign 2024? No, this was America in the early 1800s, the era characterized by what is now known as the partisan press. At the turn of the century, what are now considered the august founders of the United States were subject to abusive attacks on their character and roles as public servants and candidates for the presidency. Thomas Jefferson, Alexander Hamilton and John Quincy Adams were portrayed as dangers to democracy.

The media consisted of newspapers and pamphlets that were mouthpieces, for all intents and purposes, owned and operated, by the political parties and powerful interests behind candidates running and serving in office. This was a propaganda attack machine designed to discredit political opponents as seditious, corrupt and immoral threats to the young republic.

In 2025 we have a contemporary partisan press on steroids. Despite a precipitous drop in the audience for network broadcast news and cable news, this media exacerbates the role of partisanship in the presentation of the news. Journalists appear regularly as analysts on broadcast and cable channels reviving the ethos of the era of the partisan press by pronouncing their opinions and version of the facts of a story.

Cable news has evolved into cable talk, dominated by panels of “experts” pontificating about the perils of the political opposition. 24/7 news is 24/7 partisan attacks. The pundit corps is dominated by former political, government and military officials with an axe to grind and a platform to relentlessly chop away at their perceived enemies.

The effect of partisanship is a massive increase in the number of Americans who cannot depend on the media to provide reporting they can trust. Gallup reports 69 percent of U.S. adults have little or no trust in the media. A great deal or quite a lot of confidence in television news is 14 percent and 18 percent for newspapers.

Surveys by the American Press Institute and The Associated Press-NORC Center show 44 percent believe information in the press is one-sided. Four in ten people believe the press is harming democracy.

In its attempt to avoid the oft mentioned impending existential crisis for democracy, the media is contributing to the distress of the average American. If “democracy dies in darkness,” the media is bringing midnight to America, the exact opposite of the Ronald Reagan television commercial from 1984.

Perhaps there is light at the end of the tunnel and there is a possible end to current era of the partisan press. In 1833 Benjamin Day introduced The New York Sun, bringing the penny press and a new epoch to communications. This was a mass audience of urban working-class citizens who would buy their own newspaper rather than the more communal readership during the colonial era. To appeal to the broader audience, the Sun was more non-partisan and carried news of the day that leaned toward stories that were sensational. The era of the first partisan press was over.

Shortly after the rise of the penny press, newspapers evolved on the foundations of modern American journalism, based on an internal industry philosophy of objectivity and fairness. Editorials presented the opinions of the publishers, but a less overtly partisan approach was central to the rise of newspapers exemplified by The New York Tribune and New York Times.

Like nature, the marketplace abhors a vacuum. This might generate the opportunity today for non-partisan content to attract a viable audience.

Is it 1833 yet? Time for a major evolutionary change in the media? Probably not. The failure of the mainstream media to rise to the occasion and report the start of the second Trump administration in a manner that is perceived as trustworthy might be the straw that breaks the camel’s back.

News coverage has been dominated with an obsession on Elon Musk, condemnation of many nominees for government positions and mockery of a variety of typical Donald Trump pronouncements such as the purchase of Greenland. Yes, all are worthy of coverage, but the lack of positive stories reinforces public attitudes regarding a partisan press.

With trust currently close to rock bottom with no impact on how the media performs, it looks like America might have to wait for 2033 for a systemic change in journalism.

Tobe Berkovitz, Ph.D., is an associate professor of advertising emeritus at Boston University.

Topics

Yes, Trump is back. Yet I remain hopeful about America | Robert Reich

Even before Trump, we were on the way to losing our democracy – but we did not pay attention. Now, we have no choice but to attend to it. If you’re feeling despair over Trump’s second regime, which ...
The Guardian - 17h
Newsom knocks Johnson for 'partisan games' over wildfire response

California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) took a swipe at Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) Friday for his criticism over his administration's handling of the deadly Los Angeles wildfires. “Mr. Speaker, when ...
The Hill - 3d
Democrats press for long-delayed plaque to honor Jan. 6 victims, police heroes

A 2022 law required a plaque to be placed on the west front of the Capitol complex to honor Jan. 6 heroes. It hasn't been installed.
CBS News - 4d
White House holds press briefing

Watch live coverage as White House Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre holds a press briefing.
NBC News - 5d
The Pitched Battles for Partisan Control in State Legislatures

As state legislatures convene, they face the same political polarization seen in Congress. Some are in near-deadlock.
The New York Times - Jan. 13
With Hearings Imminent, Partisan Fight Escalates Over Trump Cabinet

Democrats are demanding that Republicans slow consideration of picks for the new administration until they can review background checks, as the G.O.P. faces major pressure to quickly confirm them.
The New York Times - Jan. 10
Meet the Press – January 5, 2025

Sen. John Thune (R-S.D.), Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.), Sen. Adam Schiff (D-Calif.), Carol Lee, Jonathan Martin, Symone Sanders Townsend and Marc Short
NBC News - Jan. 5
The Memo: New Orleans mass killing gets pulled into partisan political battle

It took less than 48 hours for the mass killing in New Orleans to be pulled into the partisan debates that are roiling the nation. In the process, some of the political rhetoric ran roughshod over ...
The Hill - Jan. 3
Are we slowing down yet?

People are worried about the economy
Financial Times - Jan. 3