Iran vs. Israel: The dangerous leap to ‘what’s next?’
One of the problems with breaking news and spur-of-the-moment punditry is the exclusion of the time necessary to absorb, digest and understand meaningful events. That’s exactly what’s happening with Iran’s attack on Israel, and nowhere on earth it is more useless to offer snapshot analyses of complex, eternal dynamics than the Middle East.
Decades ago, Tom Friedman wrote about how to understand the Middle East. The passage of time hasn’t obscured its clarity; it comes to mind especially now, in a region not defined by horizons but constantly shifting brinks.
Friedman argued that symbols are important indicators of how societies frame existential events across eons. Western civilization is largely defined by the cross: an impatient image of only two directions, yes or no, right or wrong, today or tomorrow. The emblem of Israel is the six-pointed star: confusing, complicated, built on multi-directional inner conflict. The symbol of the Muslim world is the crescent, a long, slow, timeless curvature.
In other words, we want instant answers applied to a world of maybes. Black and white clarity on a million shades of gray.
Nowhere is the snapshot reflection more distorted than when applied to Iran, whose civilization mastered the intricate, time-consuming weaving of carpets.
Like an episode of the Israeli TV thrillers “Fauda” or “Tehran,” we want to know what will happen next, and by next, we mean no later than next week, or, perish the agonizing wait, next season. We ask breathlessly: What is Israel’s next move? Proportional or asymmetric? A rocket assault or cyberattack? What will Hezbollah do in southern Lebanon? The Houthis in Yemen?
The most complex geopolitical calculations are reduced to the frenetic play-by-play of a hockey game.
The instant punditry was significantly misguided in January 2020, when Maj. Gen. Qasem Soleimani, who led the powerful Quds Force of the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps, was killed by an American MQ-9 Reaper drone. We heard predictions about the likelihood of a swift, kinetic retaliation by Iran; the outbreak of war and even the breakout of Tehran’s nuclear missile program.
In fact, Iran’s response was more calibrated. A full year after the assassination, NPR evaluated the regime’s actions: “Within days of the assassination, Iran launched Operation Martyr Soleimani, which included a number of missile attacks mainly against the Al Asad base in western Iraq. Iraq had been warned of that attack in advance by Tehran, and there were no U.S. casualties, although eventually the Pentagon said more than a hundred military personnel had suffered traumatic brain injuries.” To be clear, Iran, over time, orchestrated additional lethal attacks on U.S. military personnel. Not a direct confrontation, but Tehran’s usual pulling the strings of, and hiding behind, its puppets (the word “proxies” gives its cowardly terrorist fixers too much credit).
I am disturbed by one news development that preceded the attacks. Lost in the swirl of headlines about the solar eclipse last week was FBI Director Chris Wray’s testimony to the House Appropriations Committee in which he warned about renewed calls by terrorist groups for strikes in the U.S. Wray told lawmakers, “Our most immediate concern has been that individuals or small groups will draw twisted inspiration from the events in the Middle East to carry out attacks here at home.” His assessment before the attack, and Tehran’s warning to the U.S. not to defend Israel immediately after the attack, suggest a troubling possibility. But we’re talking about the Middle East, where even two plus two has an unforeseeable outcome.
But two things seem clear enough. First, Iran’s attack not only changed the conventional rules of the game, but started an entirely new long game. I’m disciplined to appreciate the long view because I’m a Mets fan. I know that no matter how good the first inning goes, it’s a long, meandering path to the bottom of the ninth.
Second, the safest prediction of where this ends is that there will be no end. The history of Middle East conflict is that events ebb and flow, spike and spiral, largely unresolved, in a constant state between simmering, percolating and exploding. Most important will be how various parties calculate long-term interests, which often conflict with or eclipse short-term interests.
There’s one clear truth: Iran’s reckless decision has astronomically raised the potential for a range of catastrophic scenarios. We’re best served observing and calculating not in the moment, but over the foreseeable future.
Not based on “breaking news,” but “stay tuned.”
Steve Israel represented New York in the U.S. House of Representatives over eight terms and was chairman of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee from 2011 to 2015. Follow him @RepSteveIsrael.
Date: | |
Tag: | Iran |
Topics
Filter
-
Synthesia takes next leap in AI video with ‘expressive avatars’
Synthesia says healthcare companies could use the new technology to create more empathetic videos for their patients or marketing teams could use it to convey excitement and optimism in their demo clips.VentureBeat - Tech -
Synthesia takes next leap in AI video with ‘expressive avatars’
Synthesia says healthcare companies could use the new technology to create more empathetic videos for their patients or marketing teams could use it to convey excitement and optimism in their demo clips.VentureBeat - Tech -
What happens next to TikTok
Welcome to The Hill's Technology newsletter {beacon} Technology Technology The Big Story What happens next to TikTok President Biden signed a bill Wednesday that could lead to a ban on TikTok, but the video-sharing app won’t be cut off from ...The Hill - Politics - Tiktok -
Yousaf Resigns! What Next For Scotland?
The SNP leader was facing two votes of no confidence later this weekBBC News - Top stories -
Israel and Hezbollah Flirt With Dangerous Mideast Escalation
The two foes are locked in an escalating cycle of violence that risks spiraling further in the aftermath of an unprecedented exchange of direct fire between Israel and Iran.The Wall Street Journal - World - Israel -
Israel and Hezbollah Flirt With Dangerous Mideast Escalation
The two foes are locked in an escalating cycle of violence that risks spiraling further in the aftermath of an unprecedented exchange of direct fire between Israel and Iran.The Wall Street Journal - World - Israel -
Iran's Raisi says Israel must be brought to justice for 'usurpation' of Palestinian territories
Yahoo News - World - Israel -
Have Iran-Israel missile strikes changed the Middle East?
Political and military leaders are still absorbing the extraordinary exchange of fire, writes James Landale.BBC News - Top stories - Israel -
Iran's Attack on Israel Has Deepened Concerns About Its Nuclear Program
The exchange of direct fire between the two foes opens an era of more dangerous competition.The Wall Street Journal - World - Israel -
Blinken to Return to Israel to Discuss Hostages and Planned Rafah Incursion
The visit next week will come as talks on a cease-fire deal have stalled and tensions have risen over the treatment of civilians in the war.The New York Times - World - Israel
More from The Hill
-
Speaker Johnson slams reports that ICC is considering arrest warrants for Israeli leaders
Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) on Monday slammed reports that the International Criminal Court (ICC) is planning on issuing arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and other senior Israeli officials. In a statement, Johnson ...The Hill - Politics - Israel -
Bob Bakish steps down as head of Paramount
Bob Bakish is stepping down as head of media conglomerate Paramount, the company announced on Monday. Bakish's resignation comes as the massive legacy media brand is negotiating a potential sale with Skydance after months of fielding offers from ...The Hill - Politics -
Pelosi accuses MSNBC host of being 'apologist for Donald Trump'
Former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) accused MSNBC's Katy Tur of being an "apologist" for former President Trump on Monday. During an appearance on the network, Pelosi touted President Biden's record on the economy, saying, he "created 9 ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Trump-RFK Jr. feud heats up as polls tighten
A fiery battle between former President Trump and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is heating up as polls begin to show that the third-party candidate represents just as much of a threat to the former president as President Biden. “RFK Jr. is a Democrat ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
AT&T, Verizon, T-Mobile hit with $200M FCC fine for sharing user location data without consent
The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) issued a fine totaling $200 million to the nation’s four largest mobile carriers after concluding an investigation that found the companies illegally shared access to customers’ location data, the agency ...The Hill - Politics