Instagram's shift away from political content raises questions about what counts as 'political'
Instagram’s recent decision to move the platform away from political content has sparked concerns among content creators and advocacy groups over which issues will be included.
The social media site began rolling out changes last month, following through on previously announced plans to stop recommending political content across Instagram and Threads.
Unless users change their settings, they will no longer see political content on various “recommendation surfaces,” such Explore, Reels. In-Feed Recommendations and Suggested Users.
According to Instagram parent company Meta, this includes content that is likely to be about topics related to government or elections, such as posts about laws, elections or social topics.
Shoshana Weissmann, digital director and policy fellow at R Street Institute, suggested that Instagram will likely “run into some weird lines” as it attempts to delineate political and nonpolitical content on the platform.
“There's some stuff that's explicit, like a campaign, people running for office,” she said. “But there's so much in between.”
“I think it's going to be a bit of a weird time for creators who aren't sure how close you have to get to politics for it to be considered politics by the algorithm,” Weismann added.
In an open letter to Instagram chief Adam Mosseri, more than 200 creators urged the platform to reverse course and require users to manually opt out of political content instead, criticizing Meta’s definition as “vague.”
“This undermines the reach of marginalized folks speaking to their own lived experience on Meta’s platforms and undermines the reach of advocacy work in important areas that have become ‘social topics’ including climate change, gun violence prevention, racial justice, transgender rights, and reproductive freedom to name just a few,” the letter reads.
GLAAD, an LGBTQ advocacy group that organized the open letter from creators alongside Accountable Tech, called the decision to include social topics as part of political content an “appalling move.”
“LGBTQ people’s lives are simply that, our lives,” a GLAAD spokesperson said. “Our lives are not ‘political content’ or political fodder. This is a dangerous move that not only suppresses LGBTQ voices, but decimates opportunities for LGBTQ people to connect with each other, and allies, as our content will be excluded from the algorithm.”
Ky Polanco, co-founder and co-executive director of Feminist, an Instagram community serving women, girls and gender expansive people, also expressed frustration over the possibility that reproductive health issues might be considered political.
“Our lives shouldn't be considered political, and I think our right to reproductive health and information is not really political,” Polanco told The Hill. “It's literally just a human right.”
What content is impacted by Instagram’s new approach will likely depend on what keywords the platform chooses to filter for, said Jennifer Grygiel, a Syracuse University communications professor and expert on social media.
“What is the list of keywords that you are filtering for politically? Is the word LGBT a political word? Is Roe a political word?” Grygiel said, referencing Roe v. Wade, the landmark Supreme Court decision establishing the right to abortion that was overturned in 2022.
These decisions by Instagram could potentially influence billions of people, Grygiel noted.
“It really just kind of speaks to the level of power that they have over the media consumption of not just Americans but people globally, you know, anyone who can have access to these platforms,” they added.
Instagram's new approach to political content comes as part of longer-term shift away from politics across Meta platforms.
Facebook first began efforts to reduce political content in early 2021 and “spent the last few years refining our approach,” Meta said in February, after announcing its decision to extend this approach to Instagram.
“This expands on years of work on how we approach and treat political content based on what people have told us they wanted,” Meta spokesperson Ryan Daniels said in a statement to The Hill.
“And now, people are going to be able to control whether they would like to have these types of posts recommended to them,” he added.
Weissmann suggested that Meta’s recent shift away from political content may have been informed by increasing scrutiny over how its platforms promote certain content.
“I'm sure a real piece of this is the regulatory side, that Facebook's been hit for having algorithms that promote extremist content or even just very political content,” Weissmann told The Hill.
“People will spend a lot of ad money, but being hauled into Congress over and over again is also a real cost," she added.
Date: |
Filter
-
My friends are passionate about politics – but they don’t vote. There’s no sense in that | Joyce Yang
As someone who is unable to vote in the UK’s local elections, I hope my peers don’t waste the precious gift they’ve been given. Local elections are coming this week. After receiving far-right leaflets (“Close the borders! Pause all immigration!”) ...The Guardian - World -
Biden’s election-year move on weed: From the Politics Desk
The Biden administration is easing federal restrictions on marijuana ahead of the 2024 election, a move that could boost his standing with young voters.NBC News - Politics - Joe Biden -
Biden’s election-year move on weed: From the Politics Desk
The Biden administration is easing federal restrictions on marijuana ahead of the 2024 election, a move that could boost his standing with young voters.NBC News - Top stories - Joe Biden -
Escape From Tarkov Boss Didn't Expect Players To Get Mad About Paid PvE Content
BattleState Games, the developer behind Escape from Tarkov, didn't expect the backlash of only granting access to its PvE mode for those who purchased the $250 collector's edition. It has since issued an apology and made several changes.. "First ...GameSpot - Tech -
Matt Gaetz becomes the latest Kevin McCarthy defector to draw a primary challenger: From the Politics Desk
Matt Gaetz is the latest House Republican who voted to oust Kevin McCarthy as speaker to draw a primary challenger in the 2024 elections.NBC News - Politics -
What we learn about Kafka from his uncensored diaries
On the centenary of his death, a new English translation of the great writer’s journals reveals some surprising details. After his death on 3 June 1924, a letter was found in Franz Kafka’s office in Prague addressed to Max Brod. “Dear Max, My last ...The Guardian - World -
Ranking each team's 2024 NFL Draft class: Bears, Commanders, Steelers, Cardinals aces; Falcons raise questions
Keep reading to see how your team did, everything from our favorite picks to best values to most surprising selectionsCBS Sports - Sports - NFL -
Stormy Daniels’ ex-lawyer questioned about texts with former Enquirer editor
Hush-money trial hears about ex-National Enquirer editor Dylan Howard asking Keith Davidson: ‘Did he cheat on Melania?’. Donald Trump’s New York criminal trial heated up on Tuesday afternoon as Keith Davidson, former attorney for both Stormy ...The Guardian - World -
Trump on political violence in 2024: 'If we don't win, you know, it depends'
Donald Trump said he doesn't think there'll be political violence this election because he'll win — but that it "always depends on the fairness of an election."NBC News - Politics - Donald Trump -
Former Fox News executive is named president of news and politics for NewsNation
Cherie Grzech is promoted at NewsNation, while former president of news Michael Corn moves to New York to oversee prime-time programming.Los Angeles Times - Entertainment
More from The Hill
-
'Leave-it-to-the-states' won't work: Why we need a federal abortion law
Dobbs did not simply “return abortion to the states.” Rather, it returned the power to the voters, who can exercise it through both their state and federal elected officials.The Hill - Politics - Abortion -
The Pentagon is lying about UFOs
The decades-long “nothing-to-see-here” approach to UFOs continues, unabated.The Hill - Politics -
DNC uses billboards around Trump rallies in Wisconsin, Michigan to attack him on abortion
The Democratic National Committee (DNC) is greeting former President Trump's arrival in Wisconsin and Michigan for rallies on Wednesday with billboards aiming to remind voters of his record on abortion. The DNC is putting up two billboards in ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Morning Report — Democrats vow to shield GOP Speaker
House Democratic leaders say they’re prepared to shield Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) from a potential conservative coup within his own ranks, an unprecedented vow that inflamed one of his most outspoken GOP critics Tuesday. “If the Democrats want ...The Hill - Politics -
Democrats cast aside worries of campus protests hurting Biden
Democrats are casting aside worries that college campus protests opposing the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza could spell trouble for President Biden in November. Biden and his White House aides have mostly opted to keep their distance when it comes to ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden