In Ukraine and worldwide, sovereignty is under siege

President Trump’s rhetoric about Canada as “the 51st state” is treated by many as political theater — a ploy by the president to destabilize the opposition, perhaps. But his remarks allude to something much less innocuous and more unsettling.

By now, all of us have heard the rather boisterous rhetoric of America's new president. Headlines from Fox News say, “Trump suggests Canada become 51st state after Trudeau said tariff would kill economy.” Politico reports that “Trump threatens to retake Panama Canal.” And the Associated Press says “Trump again calls to buy Greenland after eyeing Canada and the Panama Canal.”

Admittedly, audacious remarks from Trump are neither new nor are they taken too seriously in most quarters — just more political messaging by an incoming president with much to live up to.

Yet Trump's bold talk about these states does mine something much deeper than mere rhetoric. And while his admonitions may not eventuate, that is beside the point.

President Trump is stirring the cauldron of world politics. Comments about tariffs as well as annexing, buying and reclaiming sovereign territories have elicited a caustic response as well as their own share of media humor.

Beyond its entertainment value, Trump’s provocations (even if he is not aware of it), do point to a subtle and potentially more dangerous issue: Could nation-state sovereignty no longer be the inviolable precept we have believed in since the 17th century?

Although the concept of the sovereign nation-state has its origin in 1648 with the Peace of Westphalia and the end of the Thirty Years’ War of Religion, the “inviolability of borders” is a relatively recent phenomenon.

The idea of a “right to statehood” emerged in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, embraced by two counterposing entities: the Bolsheviks of Russia and the liberal U.S. President Woodrow Wilson. Both sought to dismantle empires — Russia’s for ideological reasons and the U.S. to expand its own influence.

The result was a proliferation of relatively weak, dependent states that (for all practical purposes) became tools of Moscow and Washington's foreign policy. The sovereignty of these “neo-states” — essentially reliant on foreign support (militarily, economically and politically) for their existence — was little more than a bargaining chip.

This dynamic has persisted beyond World War II into the neoliberal era of today. In fact, nearly every conflict until the mid-20th century ended with redrawn borders.

So, here's the question: Are we not doing the same thing today in Ukraine?

Certainly, there have been previous examples of sovereignty being sacrificed for peace: the Sudetenland of Czechoslovakia in 1938, Serbia/Kosovo in 1999 and others.

In a world where power increasingly relies on military might, sovereignty has shifted from a precept of international law to an issue of practical control. And the control comes from beyond the borders of the alleged sovereign state — often for the benefit of foreign power agendas.

Ukraine's sovereignty is contested for reasons that have little to do with the country itself.

Consider the turn of events in Ukraine. Since Moscow’s 2022 “special military operation,” (i.e. invasion) that country has been unable to maintain control over about one-fifth (20 percent) of its sovereign territory.

Moreover, its prospects for regaining it are diminishing daily. After Tuesday’s phone call between Trump and Putin, the process towards a ceasefire and redrawing Ukraine’s borders has begun.

At the same time, except for the U.S. and a few East European countries like Hungary and Slovakia, Britain and the European Union — in response to Trump's peace initiative — continue to support Ukraine militarily and financially with billions of dollars. And while the response from the United Kingdom and EU appear to support Ukraine’s fight against Moscow, these countries have ulterior motives.

Britain has historically viewed Moscow through a “Russophobic lens,” believing it to be a threat to its interests — especially its crown jewel — India. Today, Britain is a “middle power,” and it is not adjusting well to the loss of empire status.

The Europeans actually need Russia as a perceived adversary for two reasons: First, Europe needs an “enemy” in order to justify spending $840 billion on security out of fear of Trump abandoning them. Second, Russia is needed as a perceived threat in order to hold together Europe’s “Balkanizing” Union.

With Trump making deals for energy, natural resources and reintegration of Russia back into the G-7 — who exactly are Britain and the EU rearming to fight?

Ukraine is being used in a proxy war for reasons that have nothing to do with what is in the best interest of the country. And the borders of Ukraine are being redrawn and its sovereign territory is being redefined by powers external to the country.

In this shifting global landscape, it seems that territory and external control are once again becoming central to international politics. Given this reality, the idea of sovereignty — and the U.S.-led rules-based order that preserves it — must not become a casualty of flawed political initiatives.

Trump’s comments about annexing Canada, taking back Panama and buying Greenland (from a country that doesn't have the legal right to sell it) highlight the subtle hypocrisy in the international community. Sovereignty, once treated as sacrosanct, increasingly seems to be giving ground to political agendas of assorted foreign policies East and West.

Westphalian nation-state sovereignty, the notion of “sovereign state entities possessing the monopoly of force within their mutually recognized territories” is built on a key premise: The principle of non-interference asserts that no state should interfere in the internal affairs of another state. It upholds the idea that each state has the right to govern itself without external intervention.

The entire Ukraine debacle is antithetical to this principle. The 2014 coup to remove President Viktor Yanukovych, which some argue was Western-influenced, the Russian invasion, the sabotage of the 2022 peace talks and the hundreds of thousands killed, speak to the critical lack of regard for the concept of sovereignty within the international community.

Could globalism and a troubled EU be symptoms of an underlying malady — an assault on sovereignty?

Today, Ukraine is sovereign in name only, with the U.K., U.S., EU and Russia ultimately deciding through territorial concessions and political control what its sovereignty will look like.

In the 21st century, the people of Eastern Europe must never take their sovereignty — and the freedom it secures — for granted. Just ask the people of Ukraine today and those of yesterday's Sudetenland.

F. Andrew Wolf Jr. is the director of The Fulcrum Institute, an organization of current and former scholars in the humanities, arts and sciences.

Topics

European strongmen under siege

Protests in Serbia, Slovakia, Hungary and Georgia show that the thirst for civic and national dignity is unquenchable
Financial Times - 1d
Rainbow Six Siege X Aims To Breathe New Life Into The Shooter, But Don't Call It Siege 2

Ubisoft has unveiled Rainbow Six Siege X, the next evolution of the multiplayer shooter, coming at the start of Y10 S2 on June 10. Not to be confused with the Rainbow Six Siege 2 some may have been ...
GameSpot - Mar. 13
Dual Front Brings Fast-Paced 6v6 Action To Rainbow Six Siege

Ubisoft has unveiled Rainbow Six Siege X , and alongside that a new permanent game mode coming to the shooter, Dual Front. Dual Front is a 6v6 game mode featuring respawns, but it still preserves ...
GameSpot - Mar. 13
US says Ukraine 'ready to move forward' on truce demand

Ukraine is under US pressure to accept a quick truce to end the war with Russia, with US-Ukrainian talks set to begin in Saudi Arabia.
BBC News - Mar. 10
Israel’s renewed siege of Gaza

The Trump administration should press Netanyahu to allow aid to flow
Financial Times - Mar. 11
Rainbow Six Siege Crossover With The Boys Out Now With Homelander And Black Noir

Ubisoft has announced the newest crossover collaboration in Rainbow Six Siege, and it's none other than Prime Video's The Boys TV show. Two of the show's stars, Homelander and Black Noir, are now ...
GameSpot - 4d
Trump and Newsom Are Attacking the California Coastal Commission

The California Coastal Commission has been under siege like never before, alarming environmentalists and raising questions about the future of the 53-year-old state agency.
The New York Times - 1d
Ukraine’s retreat from Kursk appears to mark end of audacious operation

Some say incursion achieved many goals while others wonder if it cost Ukrainian lives for no tangible gain. Russia-Ukraine war – latest news updates Under constant attack from drones attached ...
The Guardian - Mar. 14
Rainbow Six Siege X Closed Beta Starts Today, Here's How To Sign Up

Siege X, the new version of the popular Rainbow Six Siege, is getting a closed beta--and it starts today, March 13. The closed beta will feature the just-announced 6v6 game mode, Dual Front .. The ...
GameSpot - Mar. 13
Canada's incoming prime minister says he'll meet Trump if Canadian sovereignty is respected

Incoming Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney says he’s ready to meet with U.S. Donald Trump if he respects Canadian sovereignty and is open to talk about a common approach to trade
ABC News - Mar. 12
Canadian ambassador to US on Trump's 51st state remarks: 'We take seriously our sovereignty'

Kirsten Hillman, Canadian ambassador to the U.S., said on Sunday that her country takes its sovereignty “seriously” as President Trump appears to be holding firm in his ambitions to make Canada the ...
The Hill - 6d
Somali forces end a 24-hour siege by al-Shabab militants on a hotel, leaving all fighters dead

Somali officials say security forces have ended a 24-hour siege at a hotel in the central city of Beledwyne, leaving an unknown number of people dead, including all the al-Shabab militants who ...
ABC News - Mar. 12
Trump hints at financial repercussions if Russia rejects Ukraine ceasefire

US president’s comments come after Ukrainian counterpart said he believed ‘strong steps’ were under consideration. Donald Trump has suggested he could target Russia financially as Ukraine’s ...
The Guardian - Mar. 12
It's a dirty job, but Ukraine's women are doing it for the war effort

The miners are creating power for Ukrainian electricity and heating stations, key energy infrastructure that has come under frequent Russian attacks.
NBC News - 2d
US seeks to reopen terms of Ukraine minerals deal

Trump administration wants to include nuclear plant under Russian control in broader economic agreement
Financial Times - 2d
Heathrow Airport Closure Wreaks Havoc on Travelers Worldwide

Flights for thousands of passengers were disrupted by the shutdown at the London airport, one of the world’s major transport hubs.
The New York Times - 1d
US-backed miner TechMet seeks to develop Ukraine lithium site

Dobra project could be one of first built under minerals deal between Washington and Kyiv
Financial Times - Mar. 11
'Killed in front of our eyes': How the Pakistan train hijacking unfolded

Passengers tell the BBC of the 30-hour siege and their escape.
BBC News - Mar. 13
Marco Rubio: one-time Russia hawk makes stunning U-turn under Trump

The secretary of state was once a prominent Ukraine supporter and called Putin a ‘war criminal’ – not any more. Marco Rubio , the US secretary of state, looked on as Donald Trump demanded more ...
The Guardian - Mar. 8
Carney ready to talk trade with Trump if 'there's respect for Canada's sovereignty'

Prime minister-designate's comments follow Canada's reciprocal tariffs on US imports after Trump slapped taxes on steel and aluminium.
BBC News - Mar. 12
Lang Lang's journey from concert halls to classrooms worldwide

From sold-out performances to a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame, Lang Lang continues to shape the music world. When Lang Lang isn't on stage, his international foundation provides instruments ...
CBS News - Mar. 14
How tariff trouble worldwide could hit your local bar

Tariff trouble around the world could hit your local bar. On Thursday, President Donald Trump threatened to place a 200% tariff on some alcoholic products from the European Union after they issued ...
CBS News - Mar. 15
Siemens to cut some 6,000 jobs worldwide, including 2,850 in Germany

Yahoo News - 5d
It’s time for Europe’s deep tech companies to go big

Reasserting technological sovereignty is becoming increasingly urgent
Financial Times - Mar. 13
The Guardian view on Trump and Ukraine: respite is possible, but resolution looks distant | Editorial

Will-they-won’t-they over a ceasefire does not change the underlying dynamics of US retreat from supporting Kyiv . A three-year conflict has taken bewildering, lurching turns in under a fortnight. ...
The Guardian - Mar. 13
30-Day ceasefire for Ukraine?

Ukraine says it is ready to accept a US proposal for an initial 30-day ceasefire.
BBC News - Mar. 11
The government wants your data — here’s how to protect your privacy

If we don’t protect tech sovereignty today, we are going to regret it tomorrow.
The Hill - Mar. 9
Only seven countries worldwide meet WHO dirty air guidelines, study shows

Annual survey by IQAir based on toxic PM2.5 particles reveals some progress in pollution levels in India and China. Nearly every country on Earth has dirtier air than doctors recommend breathing, ...
The Guardian - Mar. 11
Trump Administration Dialing Back Support for H.I.V. Prevention

The move follows cuts to prevention and treatment efforts worldwide with the shuttering of U.S.A.I.D.
The New York Times - 1d
Trump Administration Dialing Back Support for H.I.V. Prevention

The move follows cuts to prevention and treatment efforts worldwide with the shuttering of U.S.A.I.D.
The New York Times - 1d
Trump Administration Dialing Back Support for H.I.V. Prevention

The move follows cuts to prevention and treatment efforts worldwide with the shuttering of U.S.A.I.D.
The New York Times - 1d
Defender Cirkin out of England Under-21 games

Sunderland defender Dennis Cirkin is forced to withdraw from the England Under-21 squad because of a hamstring injury.
Yahoo Sports - 3d
Countries can't be forced into Ukraine peace coalition - minister

The UK and France are leading efforts to set up a "coalition of the willing" to protect Ukraine.
BBC News - Mar. 9
A minerals agreement with Ukraine would be a bad deal for America

Giving Americans an “economic upside in the future of Ukraine” will never be worth the security downsides.
The Hill - Mar. 11
Military planning for Ukraine peace to begin, says PM

Military chiefs will meet on Thursday to discuss practical plans to ensure Ukraine's security.
BBC News - Mar. 15
In Ukraine, it's Putin's way or the highway

Russian President Vladimir Putin is intent on having it be his way or the highway in Ukraine, while Team Trump is attempting to get Putin to the negotiation table by giving in to every Russian demand.
The Hill - Mar. 13
Sadly, Trump is right on Ukraine

Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky provoked wider war by violating peace deals with Russia and seeking NATO military aid and membership, while Joe Biden also contributed crucially to the ...
The Hill - 4d
Russians wary of ceasefire deal with Ukraine

Steve Witkoff, President Trump's special envoy for Russia and Ukraine, has arrived in Moscow to discuss a proposed 30-day ceasefire between Russia and Ukraine. But Russian officials do not seem ...
CBS News - Mar. 13
Bitcoin falls to November low under $80,000 on heightened recession fears

Bitcoin slipped under the $80,000 level on Monday, dragged by the continued selling pressure in the equities market.
CNBC - Mar. 10