I was fired for insisting that transgender people exist
![I was fired for insisting that transgender people exist](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/02/samuels_jocelyn_02062025_GettyImages-2197901870.jpg?w=900)
Call me an extremist — that’s what President Trump thinks I am.
Why? Because I believe that transgender people exist and deserve respect, and that, under binding Supreme Court precedent, they are entitled to protection from harassment in the workplace.
For this “extremism,” I was unlawfully fired as a commissioner of the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission on Jan. 27, just a week into the Trump administration.
In reality, it’s Trump who has taken an extreme view by declaring that there is no such thing as a transgender person. One of his day one executive orders states that there are only two sexes, male and female. This, he said, reflects “an immutable biological classification” that vanquishes the “false claim that males can identify as and thus become women and vice versa.”
It is unfathomable that the new administration denies the existence of the approximately 1.6 million Americans who are transgender (per a 2022 Williams Institute study). Further, it is cruel and inhumane, contrary to law and bad business to deny transgender people the protections that apply when workers are harassed based on race, national origin or other forms of sex discrimination.
In 2020, the Supreme Court held that prohibitions on sex discrimination in employment cover discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity. And for decades, the court has recognized that harassment that creates a hostile work environment is unlawful.
Reflecting this authority, the EEOC last year adopted a guidance barring harassment of transgender workers, including by deliberately and repeatedly ignoring a worker’s gender status. For example, routine misgendering could violate the law by creating a hostile environment. So could "deadnaming" — deliberately referring to transgender persons by the names they used before their transitions.
When, for example, Asher Lucas, a transgender manager at a Culver’s restaurant in Michigan, reported that his co-workers repeatedly misgendered him, deadnamed him, and revealed his birth name to other employees, the EEOC filed suit to vindicate his rights.
The EEOC also secured relief for Quinn Gambino, a transgender employee of T.C. Wheelers restaurant in Buffalo, New York, who was targeted with crude and derogatory references to his transgender status, including telling him that he “wasn’t a real man,” and asking invasive questions about his transition and genitalia.
These protections are at grave risk in this administration. Andrea Lucas, the new acting chair of the EEOC, has announced her view that misgendering and deadnaming are perfectly legal. In a press release, she says that sex “is binary . . . and immutable [and] it is not harassment to acknowledge these truths — or to use language like pronouns that flow from these realities.”
Lucas’s offensive views are backed by the White House: The day one executive order instructs the EEOC to prioritize investigations and litigation to enforce workers’ freedom to express the binary nature of sex, thereby effectively green-lighting workplace harassment of transgender people.
So once (or even before) the president secures a Republican majority on the commission — an outcome that would otherwise have had to wait until my term expired in 2026 — the agency will undoubtedly reject any efforts to redress the type of abuse that Gambino and Lucas endured.
And there’s more. The Office of Personnel Management has directed an end to agency programs and policies that “promote or reflect gender ideology” (that is, that recognize the existence of transgender people) and placed employees of such programs on leave.
The government will require transgender men to have passports identifying them as women and vice versa, leading to inevitable humiliation when traveling. transgender men and women will be ejected from the military. And as a practical matter, it may be impossible for transgender people to use bathrooms outside their homes: Those who present as men will not be welcome in women’s restrooms, nor will those presenting as women be comfortable entering men’s rooms.
It is perhaps hard for non-transgender people like myself to understand the threats this administration poses to some of the most vulnerable among us. But make no mistake: These directives target and dehumanize 1.6 million Americans, and they will inflict immense and gratuitous suffering.
They can fire me a million times, but it won’t change these truths: Transgender people are people. They serve our country in uniform. They serve you at the drive-through line. They have rights.
We all have a stake in rolling back this cruel assault on transgender people and on fundamental principles of civil rights.
Jocelyn Samuels was a commissioner of the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from 2020 until the last week of January 2025, having been confirmed by a bipartisan majority of the U.S. Senate for a term lasting until 2026. She was the acting head of the Department of Justice Civil Rights Division from 2013 to 2014 and director of the Health and Human Services Office for Civil Rights from 2014 to 2017.
Topics
-
America Is Full of People Trump Doesn’t Like
If, according to the president, so many people in the United States are the wrong kind, who makes up the right kind?The New York Times - 3h -
A Promising New Development for the Millions of People with Liver Disease
Recent research suggests that a new approach could help even patients with advanced forms of fatty liver disease.The New York Times - 7h -
Judge temporarily reinstates fired ethics watchdog
Hampton Dellinger filed a lawsuit claiming President Donald Trump illegally dismissed him last week.NBC News - 13h -
Hegseth orders pause on gender-affirming care for transgender service members
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth ordered an immediate pause on gender-affirming care for all active duty service members in a memo to senior Pentagon and military leaders.ABC News - 20h -
In Relationships, Am I the Asshole?
For more than a decade, Reddit’s “Am I the Asshole?” sub has served as a trove of cautionary tales and (very) real relationship advice. WIRED talked to two OPs about what happened after their posts.Wired - 1d -
How Trump is Using Language to Target Transgender Rights
President Trump has signed five executive orders targeting transgender rights since coming to office. What’s striking about these executive orders isn’t just the sheer volume of policies that might ...The New York Times - 1h -
‘I am pretty much uninsurable’: My 20-year term life insurance is up, but I was diagnosed with throat cancer. Do I renew it?
“I am pretty much uninsurable.”MarketWatch - 2h -
How Trump Uses Language to Attack the Idea of Transgender Identity
Using words like “maiming” and “junk science,” the directives try to portray trans people as lacking honesty and integrity, and thus unworthy of legal rights.The New York Times - 3h -
Hegseth moves to implement Trump’s ban on transgender troops
Welcome to The Hill's Defense & NatSec newsletter {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story Hegseth moves to implement Trump’s ban on transgender troops ...The Hill - 16h -
Trump fires Office of Government Ethics chief
President Trump has fired the director of the Office of Government Ethics, the agency announced Monday. The office posted on its website that it had been notified Trump was removing David Huitema, ...The Hill - 19h -
Hegseth moves to implement Trump's ban on transgender troops
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has directed the military to pause integrating new transgender recruits and suspend planned medical procedures meant to treat current service members diagnosed with ...The Hill - 22h -
Support slips for openly transgender service members: Gallup
A new Gallup poll found support among Americans for transgender individuals serving in the military has decreased to 58 percent, down from 71 percent in 2019 and 66 percent in 2021. The survey was ...The Hill - 22h -
I know I have made mistakes, says under-fire archbishop
The Archbishop of York says "trust has been broken" as he opens a the Church of England's General Synod.BBC News - 22h -
Wait! The Sims is a lot bleaker than I remember
When EA surprise-dropped a rerelease of The Sims 1 and 2, I was delighted to return to a defining video game of millennial childhoods – but it feels different 25 years later. When I was growing up, ...The Guardian - 1d -
Noem says Trump should 'get rid of FEMA the way it exists today'
Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said she wants President Trump to “get rid” of the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) as it exists today. Noem joined CNN’s “State of the Union” on ...The Hill - 1d -
Ancelotti on VAR pen: 'Football people' confused
Carlo Ancelotti said "football people don't understand" penalties like the one awarded to Atlético Madrid in their 1-1 derby draw with Real Madrid on Saturday.ESPN - 1d -
I saw illegality and complicity with war crimes. That’s why I quit the UK Foreign Office | Mark Smith
Ministers and senior officials protected arms deals facilitating death and horror in Gaza and Yemen. I urge my former colleagues to resist them. Britain’s system for controlling arms exports is ...The Guardian - 1d -
Clothes bound for Africa destroyed in fire
Yahoo News - 2d -
I Do Not Want Revenge for My Father’s Death
My father’s killer is being released to save hostages.The New York Times - 2d -
Trump’s Shameful Campaign Against Transgender Americans
Trump’s attacks on trans people are on the wrong side of history and humanity.The New York Times - 2d -
All 10 people on missing plane that crashed in Alaska confirmed dead
All 10 people aboard a small plane that went missing and was later discovered crashed in Alaska have been confirmed dead, officials said in a statement.NBC News - 2d -
The moment I knew: I was mourning the end of my summer fling – then a parcel arrived at my door
When Steph Vizard hooked up with Hugh during a trip back home, it was like living inside a romantic comedy. But could they have a happy ending?. Find more stories from The moment I knew series ...The Guardian - 2d -
Groundbreaking botanical discoveries on Captain Cook voyage were thanks to Indigenous people
New book reveals that Pacific islands inhabitants helped European scientists identify hundreds of plant species. In 1769, nearly nine months after setting sail with Capt James Cook on his first ...The Guardian - 3d -
Even if France’s budget doesn’t tackle the public deficit, let’s give thanks it exists | Agnès Poirer
Politics have sunk so low since Emmanuel Macron’s snap election, we’re just grateful when foretold catastrophes don’t materialise. Houra! Or rather, hurrah! On Monday, the French government, led ...The Guardian - 3d -
Transgender, nonbinary people sue Trump administration over passport policy
A new lawsuit accuses the State Department of freezing document changes for transgender or nonbinary people.ABC News - 3d -
Why People Act So Weirdly at Airports
Time and boundaries dissolve in these spaces while people become charged with stress, anxiety, and excitement. Throw in a drink or two, and it’s no wonder people aren’t themselves.Wired - 3d -
Sanders if passed at 1: 'Why would I be mad?'
Former Colorado quarterback Shedeur Sanders isn't worried about whether he is selected first overall in the NFL draft, saying he's more concerned with landing with a team with the right scheme fit.ESPN - 3d -
Rescuers search for some 30 people after a landslide in southwest China
Chinese rescuers are searching for some 30 people after a landslide in southwestern Sichuan province buried 10 houses The Ministry of Emergency Management deployed hundreds of rescuers including ...ABC News - 3d -
Why Are People Wearing Apple Watches on Their Ankles?
In pursuit of tracking fitness goals in a comfortable manner, a growing number of people are relocating their watches (and causing some confusion along the way).The New York Times - 3d -
'I know 34 people who have taken their own lives'
Film producer Andrew Jenkins is selling an Aston Martin to fund a film to raise awareness of suicide.BBC News - 3d -
Trump fires archivist of the United States
President Trump has fired the nation's top record keeper, Archivist of the United States Colleen J. Shogan.CBS News - 3d -
Transgender Americans sue over Trump passport policy
Seven transgender or non-binary Americans sued the Trump administration Friday over its new policy preventing people from obtaining passports with sex designations that match their gender ...The Hill - 3d -
Trump administration drops challenge in transgender care dispute
Click in for more news from The Hill {beacon} Health Care Health Care The Big Story DOJ flips on gender-affirming care SCOTUS case President Trump’s Department of Justice switched positions on ...The Hill - 3d -
My Favorite Argument for the Existence of God
We, ourselves, are part of the proof.The New York Times - 3d -
The Trauma of Losing Your Home in the Eaton Fire
Daniel Ramirez, a Times audio engineer, writes about the trauma of losing everything in the Eaton fire.The New York Times - 4d -
Travis Kelce: I owe everything to Andy Reid
Chiefs tight end Travis Kelce says no one has meant more to him than head coach Andy Reid.Yahoo Sports - 5d -
LinkedIn Is Testing an AI Tool That Could Transform How People Search for Jobs
The company says artificial intelligence could help surface jobs that remain hidden from typical search queries.Wired - 6d
More from The Hill
-
GOP senator: 'We have to' follow court decisions
Sen. Mike Rounds (R-S.D.) said “we have to” follow court decisions in the Trump administration’s various legal battles, even as top officials challenge the judicial actions. On Tuesday, Rounds was ...The Hill - 9m -
Warren, Waters question Fed chair on proposal 'upending' bank stress test framework
Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) and REp. Maxine Waters (D-Calif.) teamed up to question the Federal Reserve’s proposal to “upend” bank stress testing framework in a Monday letter in which they ...The Hill - 11m -
As Trump meets with India’s Modi, Bangladesh demands attention
Bangladesh’s recent descent into lawlessness poses a foreign policy challenge for President Trump, especially because his predecessor supported last August’s regime change there. The world’s most ...The Hill - 11m -
Vance, Bessent to meet with Zelensky amid Trump's push to end the war in Ukraine
Vice President Vance and Treasury Secretary Bessent are set to meet with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky amid the administration’s push for the war with Russia to end. Vance will meet with ...The Hill - 14m -
DOGE caucus Democrat: 'Elon’s been doing it all himself'
Rep. Jared Moskowitz (D-Fla.), a member of the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) caucus in the House, said members of Congress have so far been excluded from discussions about ways to ...The Hill - 25m
More in Politics
-
GOP senator: 'We have to' follow court decisions
Sen. Mike Rounds (R-S.D.) said “we have to” follow court decisions in the Trump administration’s various legal battles, even as top officials challenge the judicial actions. On Tuesday, Rounds was ...The Hill - 9m -
Warren, Waters question Fed chair on proposal 'upending' bank stress test framework
Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) and REp. Maxine Waters (D-Calif.) teamed up to question the Federal Reserve’s proposal to “upend” bank stress testing framework in a Monday letter in which they ...The Hill - 11m -
As Trump meets with India’s Modi, Bangladesh demands attention
Bangladesh’s recent descent into lawlessness poses a foreign policy challenge for President Trump, especially because his predecessor supported last August’s regime change there. The world’s most ...The Hill - 11m -
Vance, Bessent to meet with Zelensky amid Trump's push to end the war in Ukraine
Vice President Vance and Treasury Secretary Bessent are set to meet with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky amid the administration’s push for the war with Russia to end. Vance will meet with ...The Hill - 14m -
DOGE caucus Democrat: 'Elon’s been doing it all himself'
Rep. Jared Moskowitz (D-Fla.), a member of the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) caucus in the House, said members of Congress have so far been excluded from discussions about ways to ...The Hill - 25m