Hubris and conceit: Why Musk is having so much trouble as czar
A disruptive president bent on reshaping federal government operations pushed and even broke longstanding constitutional and legal norms. It created confusion and worry in the public and the halls of Congress. The president even selected one of the wealthiest individuals in the U.S. to head a newly created government entity, under questionable legal authority.
No, we're not talking about President Trump, but about Woodrow Wilson. In 1917, he established the War Industries Board and named Wall Street financier Bernard Baruch to head it. Baruch was given sweeping powers to oversee material production for the war effort, all under a newly formed entity not authorized by Congress.
Wilson would not be the last president to utilize what became known as White House “czars” — executive branch officials appointed by the president without Senate confirmation but given significant decision-making authority to affect spending and administer or coordinate programs, departments and agencies.
We say this not to provide evidence that what is currently happening in the federal government with Elon Musk and the so-called Department of Government Efficiency is normal — only that czars represent a larger phenomenon to give presidents more independence from Congress and unilateral control over government operations.
Many are surprised by the way the Republican-controlled Congress has acquiesced and even supported DOGE’s activities. But this is not the first time that Congress has done little or nothing to challenge presidential authority to create offices, usurp legislative power or otherwise centralize power in czar positions. Under Wilson, a Democratic Congress enabled the president’s unprecedented use of power. Under President Franklin Roosevelt, another Democratic Congress voiced little objection as he unilaterally established the Office of Production Management and other czar positions.
In 1943, Congress tried to rein in Roosevelt’s free-wheeling use of presidentially created entities by seeking to require Senate confirmation for certain executive positions. Although the bill died in the House that year, Congress later passed a law that denied funding to any presidentially created entity that had been in existence for one year and lacked a clear statutory basis to exist.
Despite the law, czars keep being appointed. Both political parties have at times objected to them. Republican lawmakers and conservative pundits loudly objected to the President Barack Obama’s use of czars. Today, we see Democratic and liberal groups not only questioning Musk but also suing in federal court to challenge DOGE’s constitutional and legal authority.
There is bipartisan support for improving government efficiency. Such thinking is not new — academics, lawmakers and even presidential staff members have been highlighting the systemic design problems in the federal government for decades. Various presidentially created commissions have studied and developed plans to overhaul the executive branch, with all concluding that our government’s structure is outmoded and ineffective.
Going back to the early 1970s, a commission created by President Richard Nixon recommended consolidating the existing 12 departments (now 15) into four super-departments, to maximize efficiency and coordination. That did not happen, but the commission’s general conclusion remains valid: The expansion of government structures and personnel in a piecemeal fashion created inefficiencies and management challenges at the federal level.
Despite the consensus that the federal government needs to be reformed, the approach of using a single, high-profile individual such as Musk to spearhead sweeping reforms unilaterally — such as cutting spending and firing employees — is not the most thoughtful or effective solution.
As with any large organization, the federal government is a complex system with a long history and many interrelated parts that need to be studied and analyzed before beginning the process of redesign. This complexity requires any effort to overhaul the system to be methodical and nuanced. Unilateral actions, driven by a czar with no expertise in government or in the particular functions of the many departments and agencies, risk overlooking important interconnected aspects or causing unintended consequences that could exacerbate the very inefficiencies being targeted.
Musk represents a pernicious feature of the modern presidency, born in hubris and conceit, that the executive has all the answers and need not be constrained by supposedly outmoded constitutional and legal considerations. Congress must wake up from its slumber and take the lead in addressing these governance challenges.
This need not be partisan. Republicans in Congress protested Obama’s czars. In now embracing Trump’s vastly more expansive use of this position because they might like the policy outcomes, they are setting a precedent for a future Democratic president to do the same to advance policies they detest.
Congress needs to get back to checking presidential overreach in use of executive powers, without regard to fear or partisan favor.
Mitchel A. Sollenberger is professor of political science at University of Michigan-Dearborn. Mark J. Rozell is dean of the Schar School of Policy and Government at George Mason University. They are co-authors of “The President’s Czars: Undermining Congress and the Constitution.”
-
Why These Oscars Mean So Much to Brazil
The best picture and best actress nominations for “I’m Still Here” have inspired national pride in a country whose culture has long been overlooked.The New York Times - 4d -
Why U.S. Women Skiers Are So Much Better Than the Men
“We need some strong super successful male athletes to pull up that next generation,” the chief of sport performance for the U.S. ski and snowboard team said.The New York Times - 2d -
Comedian Mae Martin wrote a rock album. When the world's chaotic, 'So much of life doesn't have a punch line'
The nonbinary Netflix star's debut LP, 'I'm a TV,' nails elder-millennial indie vibes. In a revanchist backlash, music was a balm.Los Angeles Times - Feb. 25 -
Why Musk and Vance want you to have more babies
With few exceptions, in every country where women can choose to have few or no children, that is exactly what they are doing.The Hill - 4d -
Elon Musk is a proven danger to good science, but the Royal Society won’t say so. That’s why I resigned | Kit Yates
It is vital to act, and I urge colleagues to do so. How can we stand by and laud this man while he undermines scientific integrity?. Fellows of the Royal Society met yesterday to discuss, as they ...The Guardian - 8h -
Why coffee is so expensive these days
The price of coffee is at a 50-year high and climate change and global demand may be to blame. Peter Goodman, a global economy reporter at The New York Times, joins CBS News with more.CBS News - 6d -
Why Is Egg Shopping So Unpredictable?
Some stores have none, others plenty, at all kinds of prices. Chalk it up to the complexities of how a once-ubiquitous staple arrives on shelves.The New York Times - 6d -
Why is the flu so bad this year?
The U.S. is in the midst of its first “high severity” flu season in seven years. Flu activity has slowed in recent weeks, but experts warn that the season isn’t over yet.NBC News - 4d -
The Rubiales-Hermoso court case revealed so much – and the story is not complete yet
Luis Rubiales’ trial for the non-consensual kiss of Jennifer Hermoso during the medal ceremony of the 2023 Women’s World Cup final lasted a fortnight. Within a week of its conclusion, a verdict was ...Yahoo Sports - Feb. 24
More from The Hill
-
Trump's trade war wallops stock market
The stock market has suffered through a two-day selloff after President Trump went forward with imposing steep new tariffs on Canada and Mexico. The Dow Jones Industrial Average closed Tuesday with ...The Hill - 42m -
GSA identifies hundreds of 'non-core' federal properties amid Trump admin's DOGE cuts
The General Services Administration (GSA) on Tuesday released a list of nearly 450 federal buildings it may seek to sell — including major real estate like the headquarters of the Justice ...The Hill - 47m -
In shift, hardline conservatives signal openness to stopgap to avert shutdown
Hardline House conservatives are signaling an openness to supporting a continuing resolution to keep the government open later this month — a notable shift from their usual stance against stopgaps ...The Hill - 59m -
Booker tells Musk he’s behind social media campaign: Keep your Cybertruck
Sen. Cory Booker (D-N.J.) on Tuesday revealed he was behind a social media campaign involving nearly two dozen Democratic senators after tech billionaire Elon Musk offered a Tesla Cybertruck to the ...The Hill - 1h -
Ben Shapiro launches effort asking Trump to pardon former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin
Conservative media figure Ben Shapiro launched a petition calling on President Trump to pardon former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin, who was convicted in the 2020 murder of George Floyd. ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
Trump's trade war wallops stock market
The stock market has suffered through a two-day selloff after President Trump went forward with imposing steep new tariffs on Canada and Mexico. The Dow Jones Industrial Average closed Tuesday with ...The Hill - 42m -
GSA identifies hundreds of 'non-core' federal properties amid Trump admin's DOGE cuts
The General Services Administration (GSA) on Tuesday released a list of nearly 450 federal buildings it may seek to sell — including major real estate like the headquarters of the Justice ...The Hill - 47m -
How to watch Trump's address to Congress tonight
President Trump will address a joint session of Congress tonight, marking his first speech to both chambers since he returned to office. Here's how to watch his 2025 address.CBS News - 57m -
In shift, hardline conservatives signal openness to stopgap to avert shutdown
Hardline House conservatives are signaling an openness to supporting a continuing resolution to keep the government open later this month — a notable shift from their usual stance against stopgaps ...The Hill - 59m -
Booker tells Musk he’s behind social media campaign: Keep your Cybertruck
Sen. Cory Booker (D-N.J.) on Tuesday revealed he was behind a social media campaign involving nearly two dozen Democratic senators after tech billionaire Elon Musk offered a Tesla Cybertruck to the ...The Hill - 1h