How Ukraine can create a credible deterrent against Russia outside of NATO
![How Ukraine can create a credible deterrent against Russia outside of NATO](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/06/zelensky_ukraine_040324-2128592892.jpg?w=900)
At the Washington summit this July, NATO will reiterate its promise, first made at the 2008 Bucharest summit, to bring in Ukraine. But it will not offer a formal invitation to join or a concrete path to membership. As a consolation, the U.S. has just signed a bilateral security arrangement with Ukraine, which will, however, fall far short of the commitment to collective defense Kyiv desperately seeks.
It is time for NATO to be honest with itself and Kyiv: Membership does not lie in Ukraine’s future. President Joseph Biden has been emphatic: He is not going to start World War III to defend Ukraine. That takes membership off the table as long as Ukraine is fighting Russia. Otherwise, NATO would find itself at war with Russia from the moment it joined, as the president has also vowed to defend “every inch” of NATO territory.
Some Western leaders suggest that Ukraine could join once the war has ended. That is doubtful. Confidence that NATO’s collective defense guarantee would deter Russia from attacking Ukraine is misplaced. Ukraine occupies a unique place in Russians’ political imagination, unlike that of any other country that has joined the alliance since the end of the Cold War. Russian leaders are convinced that their preeminence in Ukraine is essential to their own security.
Russian President Vladimir Putin himself believes that Ukrainians and Russians are one people who should be united in one state.
The likelihood that Russia would test NATO’s commitment to Ukraine would undoubtedly suffice to persuade at least one ally to break the consensus needed to admit Ukraine and accept the looming risk of war with Russia.
That ally might turn out to be the U.S. Indeed, given growing resistance among Republicans to further security assistance to Ukraine, any administration would be hard-pressed to muster the constitutionally required two-thirds of the Senate in support of membership.
The qualms about Ukraine’s membership should not be surprising. NATO’s dirty secret is that since the end of the Cold War, it has never admitted a country it thought it might have to defend against Russian aggression. The first two waves of expansion in 1999 and 2004, which brought in all the former members of the Warsaw Pact, the Baltic States and Slovenia occurred when NATO and Russia were focused on building cooperative relations.
Subsequent waves took in Western Balkan states, which were separated from Russia by other NATO members. They might have been vulnerable to Russian interference in their domestic affairs, but not to an armed attack that would have triggered NATO’s commitment to collective defense.
The recent admission of Finland and Sweden may appear to be an exception. But these two Nordic states had strong military forces and long experience of cooperation with NATO. Unlike the other new members, they have actually fortified NATO from the moment they joined. Rather than being called to defend them, NATO is more likely to call on them to help defend other allies.
If NATO membership is a bridge too far, what should Ukraine do? Sweden offers a model that could be adapted to its current circumstances. During the Cold War, Sweden was formally a neutral country, with a formidable defense-industrial sector and a capable military. But it also enjoyed close security and intelligence cooperation with the U.S. and other NATO allies. That cooperation was kept secret at the time, but the Soviets were doubtless aware of it. And that knowledge acted as a powerful deterrent to military aggression.
Even as the war rages on, the West should be helping Ukraine become an updated version of Cold-War Sweden. That would entail increased support for rebuilding Ukraine’s defense-industrial sector and training its military forces, as well as close security and intelligence cooperation. Such arrangements are included in the bilateral agreements the U.S. and other allies have signed with Ukraine or soon will. They need to be fully resourced to ensure a steady flow of support for at least the next decade.
Helping Ukraine will also entail cooperation in reforming its economy and political system to meet European standards — the Swedish model worked in part because Sweden was a strong democracy with an efficient market economy. In this light, European Union accession talks, which should begin soon, are critical to Ukraine’s long-term security.
With sufficient time and Western help, Ukraine can forge a credible deterrent against Russia outside of NATO. But it never will so long as NATO holds out the illusion of membership and tempts Ukraine to pursue it. It’s long past time to abandon that fantasy and focus on what is feasible and sufficient for Ukraine’s security.
Thomas Graham, a distinguished fellow at the Council of Foreign Relations, was senior director for Russia on the National Security Council staff during the George W. Bush administration.
Date: | |
Tag: | Ukraine |
Topics
Filter
-
ABC News - World
Ukraine's convicts offered release at a high price: Joining the fight against Russia
Ukraine is expanding its military recruiting to cope with battlefield shortages more than two years into fighting Russia’s full-scale invasionUkraine -
The Wall Street Journal - World
NATO to Establish Kyiv Post, and Seeks to 'Trump-Proof' Ukraine Aid
The alliance will station a senior civilian official in Kyiv, among a raft of new measures designed to shore up long-term support for Ukraine that are expected to be announced at the summit in Washington next week, U.S. and alliance officials say.Ukraine -
The Hill - Politics
Ukraine is taking the fight to Russia in Africa, Syria
Ukraine's military intelligence has been conducting operations in Africa and the Middle East to reduce Russian military potential, and Maj. Gen. Kyrylo Budanov has been leading the charge to fight Russia anywhere it can be found.Ukraine -
Inc. - Business
How Team Memes Create Elite Corporate Cultures
A few intentional shifts to your language will build the type of workplace your people never want to leave. -
CBS News - Top stories
How Texas migrants are using baseball to create community
A community in Texas is bringing together migrants and America's pastime. Ken Molestina explains. -
The Wall Street Journal - World
A failed murder plot is one of a series of incidents that show how Vienna has emerged as Russia's new espionage hub in Europe after capitals there expelled 600 spies posing as diplomats in the wake of the invasion of Ukraine.
A failed murder plot is one of a series of incidents that show how Vienna has emerged as Russia’s new espionage hub in Europe after capitals there expelled 600 spies posing as diplomats in the wake of the invasion of Ukraine. -
Yahoo News - World
4 NATO countries are calling for a defense line along Europe's 700-mile border with Russia and Belarus
Russia -
Yahoo News - World
Zelensky urges supporters to give Ukraine free hand to strike Russia
Ukraine -
CBS News - Top stories
Ukraine accuses Russia of targeting its culture, heritage and identity | 60 Minutes
Ukraine has accused Russia of deliberately destroying cultural property. Investigators say Russian forces target churches, libraries, museums, and monuments as part of a war on Ukraine’s identity.Ukraine
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Stormy Daniels on second Trump term: 'Shouldn't we all be worried about that?'
Adult film actress Stormy Daniels posed a question in a Tuesday interview about how widespread the concern for a second term for President Trump in the White House should be. “Shouldn’t we all be worried about that?” Daniels responded when MSNBC ...Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Paramount, Skydance reach tentative merger deal
Paramount’s parent company, National Amusements, has come to a tentative deal on a possible merger with media conglomerate Skydance. Paramount had previously reportedly stopped talks with Skydance on a merger and news about talks crumbling came ... -
The Hill - Politics
Harris backs Biden as Democratic nominee, says they'll beat Trump again
Vice President Kamala Harris on Tuesday doubled down on her support of President Biden amid calls for him to withdraw from the 2024 presidential race after his poor debate performance last week against former President Trump. “Look, Joe Biden is ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
1 in 3 Democrats say Biden should step aside: Poll
Nearly a third of Democrats believe President Biden should end his reelection bid following his lackluster debate performance against former President Trump last week, according to a new poll. A Reuters/Ipsos poll, published Tuesday, found 32 ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
CNN host pushes back on Thompson's defense of Biden debate performance
CNN anchor Jake Tapper on Tuesday rebuked Rep. Bennie Thompson's (D-Miss.) defense of President Biden's poor debate performance, arguing it was more than "just a bad debate." When Tapper asked how concerned he was about Biden's standing in the ...Joe Biden