How to ensure Trump's new inspectors general are watchdogs, not lapdogs

President Trump’s wholesale firing of 18 inspectors general, including myself, (IGs) raises questions about the future of government oversight, transparency and accountability.

IGs are the so-called “watchdogs” inside federal agencies. Their job is to prevent and detect waste, fraud and abuse inside their agencies through fair, objective and independent oversight. Their offices produce audits, inspections and evaluations, and conduct criminal and ethics investigations to promote effectiveness and efficiency throughout the federal government.

When I was inspector general of the U.S. Department of the Interior and the chair of the Council of Inspectors General, I viewed myself and my IG peers as the taxpayers’ representatives inside our agencies.

The cornerstone of IG efficacy is independence. For 40+ years, the entire construct of IG oversight rests on our neutral and objective assessment of federal programs and operations. If IGs are viewed by our agencies, Congress or the American public as beholden to one political party or ideology, then no one would trust our reports, findings or recommendations for improvement.

So one of the critical questions from the spate of IG firings is what comes next? Accounting for all vacant IG positions that are appointed by the president, there are 25 IG vacancies. It is critical that President Trump nominate qualified individuals to those positions — not just in the sense of technical competence, but also in their willingness to conduct fair, objective and independent oversight for the American people.

As the chair and vice chair of the Council of Inspectors General for the past four years, I led the panel of IGs who make recommendations to the White House about who would be successful IGs. We interviewed well more than 100 candidates over those years and made dozens of recommendations — and declined to recommend dozens of others.

Here are some touchstones that we saw to assess whether a candidate is likely to be a successful Inspector General, one who fulfills the role in the way it was designed and as the American people deserve. I hope the president and White House staff will consider these concepts as they review potential nominees for these crucial positions.

Moreover, I hope that the relevant Senate committees — and indeed the American people — will examine President Trump’s IG nominees through the prism of these considerations. They are obviously not guarantees, but experience in these areas will increase the likelihood of success as an Inspector General.

First is competence, essentially the ability to do the job. The Inspector General Act lays out several requirements for inspectors general: the president shall appoint IGs “without regard to political affiliation and solely on the basis of integrity and demonstrated ability in accounting, auditing, financial analysis, law, management analysis, public administration or investigations.”

But these are broad, provide little guidance and frankly miss the mark in several ways. IG nominees should be comfortable with the bread and butter matters for IGs: government auditing and criminal investigations, not to mention federal appropriations law, procurement and grant oversight and a host of ethics rules.

In addition, serving as an inspector general is much more than bean-counting; it can require extensive engagement with Congress and the executive branch. Therefore, substantive experience with navigating the halls of Congress and the byzantine executive branch will help lay the foundation for success.

Notably, experience in the IG or oversight community is not essential. We have seen successful IGs from outside the government, but it is crucial that they have a deep appreciation of the role of oversight and how IGs add value to their agencies.

Another good harbinger for success as an IG is meaningful leadership experience. Remember that these positions set the vision for their organizations, determine organizational priorities and can lead staffs of hundreds — if not thousands — of professionals.

In my experience, IGs run into trouble not from the substantive work, such as their audits, inspections or investigations, but rather from bad leadership choices. Over and over, we have seen IGs who founder largely because they never led an organization before. That in turn can lead to problems with their oversight, but it usually starts with leadership ineptitude, not inadequate audit or investigatory experience.

They are simply ill-prepared to chart a course and articulate priorities for hundreds of employees, communicate with staff of different disciplines, hold a senior executive accountable for their division’s performance, make hard calls on budgets involving tens or hundreds of millions of dollars and engage with stakeholders like Congressional committees.

Leadership skills should not be on-the-job training, especially not in these high-stakes positions. I would therefore urge the president to nominate candidates with substantial leadership on their resumes and encourage the Senate as it engages throughout the confirmation process to evaluate nominees based on their meaningful leadership experience. In short, a candidate without substantial leadership roles should throw up significant red flags.

The final — and perhaps most critical — issue is independence. This is the single most important element of a successful inspector general: the ability to provide fair, objective and independent oversight. IGs not only have to be apolitical but the American public and stakeholders in Congress and the federal government must also perceive them as apolitical.

For instance, the Department of the Interior, where I served as inspector general, has extensive jurisdiction over oil and gas production on federal lands. If I had written social media posts with “Drill, baby, drill!” would Congress view my reports on the Department’s wind and solar energy efforts with any credibility?

On the flip side, if my Instagram feed were replete with climate change activism, the American public would surely take my recommendations about oil and gas leasing programs with a grain of salt. Similarly, my credibility would be shot if I were a financial donor or bundler for one presidential candidate or, as a lawyer, I represented a family member of a candidate.

With that in mind, I would urge the president to nominate individuals who do not have issues in their past that would undermine their independence or the perception thereof. That means social media posts, sizeable political donations or partisan activity, speeches, client representations or similar elements that would cause a reasonable person to question their findings and recommendations.

Moreover, I would encourage the Senate and the American public to scour IG nominees’ records for these tell-tale signs of a lack of independence.

These three areas — competence, leadership and independence — should be the focal point for IG nominations. In my experience reviewing hundreds of IG candidates for the past four years, these should be the touchstones for evaluating potential IGs going forward, in all administrations regardless of political party.

Nominating leaders who fit the bill in these three areas will certainly raise the likelihood of appointing effective watchdogs, not lapdogs.

Mark Greenblatt was inspector general of the United States Department of Interior from August 2019 until January 2025. He also served as chair of the Council of the Inspectors General on Integrity and Efficiency from 2023-2024 and as vice chair from 2022-2023.

Topics

The N.H.L.’s Lost Generation of Olympians

“All of a sudden, it’s 2025 and you realize you don’t have another chance,” Tyler Seguin said.
The New York Times - 1h
How Musk and Trump are flooding the zone

Musk raids a dizzying swath of agencies with the goal of ‘slashing waste and fraud’ as the two deploy brinkmanship. Hello, and welcome back to TechScape. This week in tech: Elon Musk and Donald ...
The Guardian - 2h
How Dirty Is That AI? Salesforce Launches a New Tool to Show You

The AI Energy Score attempts to quantify the environmental harm of AI models. Here’s how to use it.
Inc. - 22h
Tuesday Briefing: Trump’s New Tariff Fight

Plus, Kendrick Lamar’s Super Bowl show.
The New York Times - 23h
'Significant inaccuracies' found in AI-generated news summaries: BBC

The BBC issued a February report that found “significant inaccuracies” with news summaries generated from artificial intelligence (AI) engines including OpenAI's ChatGPT, Microsoft's Copilot, ...
The Hill - 3h
How Vanderbilt's 18 point guards are eschewing labels, surging past expectations under new coach Mark Byington

Mark Byington is orchestrating one of college basketball's top turnarounds in Year 1 at Vanderbilt
CBS Sports - 3h
How Trump is Using Language to Target Transgender Rights

President Trump has signed five executive orders targeting transgender rights since coming to office. What’s striking about these executive orders isn’t just the sheer volume of policies that might ...
The New York Times - 4h
Pressley on Trump promise to lower costs: ‘How’s that going?’

Rep. Ayanna Pressley (D-Mass.) slammed President Trump over his promise to lower everyday costs for Americans, asking “How’s that going?” “Donald Trump ran on a promise to bring down costs for ...
The Hill - 6h
'It's a golden generation of Welsh pundits, not Welsh players'

Chris Ashton and Chris Jones explain why Wales are in turmoil - before Warren Gatland's exit as head coach was announced.
BBC News - 8h
There will be no exemptions to new tax on metals, says Trump

The move threatens to have a big impact in Canada, a major source of the metals in the US.
BBC News - 12h
Judge temporarily reinstates fired ethics watchdog

Hampton Dellinger filed a lawsuit claiming President Donald Trump illegally dismissed him last week.
NBC News - 16h
As Musk, Trump administration target CFPB, Democrats defend consumer watchdog

The agency is at a virtual standstill as Elon Musk's DOGE and the White House's Russell Vought take over.
ABC News - 20h
Trump’s New Tariffs Target Foreign Metals

Also, Elon Musk led a bid to buy OpenAI. Here’s the latest at the end of Monday.
The New York Times - 21h
Trump signs off on new steel and aluminum tariffs

President Trump on Monday signed proclamations to bolster tariffs on all steel and aluminum imports into the United States and crack down on attempts by China and Russia to evade penalties. Trump ...
The Hill - 21h
How Trump's tariffs are a political tool

President Trump's expected tariffs on steel and aluminum could impact U.S. allies around the world. CBS News' Weijia Jiang breaks down how Mr. Trump's tariffs are part of his political arsenal.
CBS News - 23h
How far is Trump willing to go on Gaza plans?

President Trump is insisting on his Gaza plans and comparing them to a real estate development for the future. CBS News senior White House correspondent Weijia Jiang reports.
CBS News - 1d
How Trump's steel, aluminum tariffs will affect Americans

President Trump is set to announce a new round of tariffs that will impact steel and aluminum prices. Kristin Myers, the editor-in-chief of ETF.com, joins CBS News with more on how American ...
CBS News - 1d
Labour peer calls for UK attorney-general Hermer to quit

Lord Glasman’s criticism comes as tensions rise between liberal and conservative wings of Sir Keir Starmer’s party
Financial Times - 1d
How Trump’s tariffs could impact the price of gold

Tariffs aren’t necessarily bullish for the yellow metal.
MarketWatch - 1d
EU ponders how to respond to a fresh Trump onslaught

Brussels can’t do the rapid pre-emptive retaliation that Canada and Mexico threatened
Financial Times - 1d
Trump, Putin, Xi and the new age of empire

The leaders of America, Russia and China are now all committed to territorial expansion
Financial Times - 1d
Women’s college basketball power rankings: How is UCLA reaching new heights?

One of the most impressive runs in recent memory came to an end Sunday, as Texas halted South Carolina’s 57-game winning streak in SEC play. The Gamecocks had gone more than three seasons without a ...
Yahoo Sports - 1d
How the New Trump Era Has Upended Florida Politics

The recent feud between Gov. Ron DeSantis and the Legislature over immigration is a sign of more jockeying to come among Republicans over the next two years.
The New York Times - 1d
EU watchdog warns of resistance to Brussels’ bid to slash red tape

Esma chair says national pushback to harmonising rules risks undermining its push to become a European SEC
Financial Times - 1d
Trump’s acting chief of federal financial watchdog orders staff to pause activity

Russell Vought is now acting head of CFPB, created in wake of 2008 financial crash to supervise financial companies. Russell Vought, Donald Trump’s newly installed acting head of the US Consumer ...
The Guardian - 2d
Trump enters new chapter with Rupert Murdoch

“Rupert Murdoch is in a class by himself, he’s an amazing guy,” President Trump said of the conservative media magnate, who sat smiling in the Oval Office this week as the newly elected president ...
The Hill - 2d
The best Grenfell memorial would be ensuring it never happens again

If the remains of the west London tower block come down, it should prompt more and better building for social housing
Financial Times - 2d
How environmental groups are responding to Trump's executive orders

Environmental nonprofits are gearing up to challenge the number of actions President Donald Trump has issued since he took office.
ABC News - 3d
How Trump, Musk and Bezos could preserve humanity from an asteroid strike

At the moment, humanity has all of its eggs in the planet Earth basket.
The Hill - 3d
Eye on America: Starter home struggles and the sandwich generation’s retirement woes

In Texas, we examine how a shortage of millions of homes for sale is driving up demand and squeezing out families looking to purchase starter homes. And in Massachusetts, we hear from members of ...
CBS News - 3d
Chemical weapons watchdog delegation meets with Syria's new leaders

A delegation from the global chemical weapons watchdog has arrived in Damascus to meet with Syria’s new leaders for the first time since the fall of former President Bashar Assad
ABC News - 3d
How will 'whirlwind' ambassador to US try to charm Trump?

As Peter Mandelson takes up the role of ambassador to the US, No 10 is determined the UK builds a strong relationship with Donald Trump.
BBC News - 3d
How Japan sparked Trump's 40-year love affair with tariffs

As a young real estate developer in New York, Trump said a rising Japan was ripping off the US.
BBC News - 3d
How New Orleans is preparing for Super Bowl LIX

President Trump will be inside the Superdome in New Orleans on Sunday night to watch the Eagles and Chiefs in the Super Bowl. Michael Hecht, CEO of Greater New Orleans Inc. and Super Bowl LIX ...
CBS News - 3d
How Trump is testing checks and balances through Elon Musk's DOGE

NBC News' Laura Jarrett looks at whether there are legal paths to block recent moves by President Trump and Elon Musk's Department of Government Efficiency.
NBC News - 3d
How New Orleans Is Using the Super Bowl to Make Upgrades

The Big Easy will host the Eagles, the Chiefs, and Kendrick Lamar on Sunday.
Inc. - 4d
Here’s how Democrats should fight back against Trump | Margaret Sullivan

Democrats in a new generation are punching back hard. And, in so doing, showing their colleagues how to overcome their reputation for dithering. It’s easy to be disgusted with the Democratic party ...
The Guardian - 4d
How Saquon Barkley went from expendable in New York to invaluable in Philadelphia

Saquon Barkley’s transformation from expendable in New York to invaluable during Philadelphia’s run to Sunday’s Super Bowl did not happen over the course of just one offseason.
NBC News - 4d
Review: Lauren Graham shines in Tubi's generational comedy 'The Z-Suite'

Tubi's first original comedy series stars Lauren Graham as the head of a New York ad agency, at least until the Gen-Z social media team takes over.
Los Angeles Times - 5d