How serious are they? Colo. leftists sold out their climate commitments for a paltry $140M
That the environmental left is relentless is not news, but the current machinations on policies intended to suppress fossil energy production in Colorado are fascinating.
Under a compromise being negotiated between Gov. Jared Polis (D), the state's oil and gas producers and the environmental left, production fees estimated at $140 million per year (based on future crude oil and natural gas prices) will replace three bills before the legislature and three ballot measures, all of which are attempts to squeeze the oil and gas producers.
Senate Bill 24-159 would have prohibited permits for new oil and gas drilling by the end of 2029. Proponents argued that such a ban was necessary to “counteract climate change” — a silly claim, given that elimination of all Colorado greenhouse gas emissions would reduce global temperatures in 2100 by less than 0.003 degrees Celsius, going by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency climate model. That bill was rejected by the legislature in March, but it remains harmful in terms of incentives for investment in the state. After all, it could come up again.
Senate Bill 24-165, ostensibly about air quality, is really an effort to severely restrict the use of internal combustion vehicles. It would force a wholesale shift to electric vehicles that are fundamentally impractical for Colorado. It would also freeze fossil fuel “preproduction” (drilling, fracking, and flowback) operations for five months of every year in regions that are in nonattainment with current air quality standards. The legislation says, groundlessly, that the fossil production sector is a “key” source of smog, but nowhere is there even an assertion that the five-month shutdown would yield any beneficial impacts to air quality at all.
House Bill 24-1338 would formalize the application of “environmental justice” to emissions policies, including possible limits on various industrial operations, even if those attendant overall emissions are consistent with existing regulatory requirements. The implicit assumption is that air quality should be equal in every neighborhood; but that is preposterous, due to geographic and other factors. It is a sad reality that lower-income households gravitate toward less desirable (and thus less expensive) areas. That is just an implication of being poor.
Here is another reality: Less production of fossil energy means higher prices for energy and most other goods and services. The data are unambiguous that increases in the cost of living yield adverse effects far more serious for lower-income groups than for others. The proposals are incontrovertibly regressive.
House Bill 24-1330, would prohibit permits for fossil production operations in “disproportionately impacted” communities. Amazingly, that term is not defined in the legislation, so any such permits would be subjected to endless litigation, endless delay, and an obvious decline in investment in the production of efficient energy.
The three ballot measures, respectively, would impose strict liability for environmental damages stemming from fossil production, allow anyone to sue to enforce existing regulations, and enshrine a right to a “healthy environment,” whatever that means. Taken as a whole, these are a full-employment act for the lawyers, the massive costs of which will be borne by the fossil producers narrowly, and by the entire Colorado economy more broadly.
Put aside all the lofty rhetoric about climate change and clean air and environmental justice and a “healthy environment.” According to the environmental left, the legislation and the ballot initiatives are needed to protect those values, yet somehow they and their allies in the legislature are willing to forgo all of that in exchange for $140 million per year.
Does this not speak volumes?
In 2022, $16.5 billion in oil and gas production was about 3.4 percent of Colorado's gross state product. Colorado lawmakers would be wise to examine the longer-term effects of similar policies actually enacted in California, including various “climate” restrictions on fossil energy development and a de facto ban on fracking. Between 1985 and 2022, California crude oil output fell by more than two-thirds, and natural gas output fell by 73 percent.
And for what? No one can claim that the decline in California fossil energy production has had the slightest effect on climate. Suppose Colorado “succeeds” over time in reducing oil and gas output by an amount yielding, say, a 1 percent to 2 percent reduction in the state's economic output. That would be equivalent to a recession, endured in the pursuit of virtually no environmental improvement at all.
What are these Colorado politicians thinking?
Benjamin Zycher is a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.
Date: | |
Tag: | Climate |
Filter
-
Microsoft Plans Boldest Games Bet Since Activision Deal, Changing How 'Call of Duty' Is Sold
The software company will add the latest installment of the hit videogame series to its Game Pass subscription service at launch.The Wall Street Journal - Tech - Microsoft -
Weka scores $140M to supercharge AI workloads with ‘dynamic data pipelines’
With this funding, Weka will augment its cash reserves from previous rounds and work towards scaling the business to meet the demand for AI infrastructure in the wake of the generative AI boom.VentureBeat - Tech -
48 Stories Of How People Found Out Their Partner Was Cheating On Them That Range From Heartbreaking To Straight-Up Unhinged
Yahoo News - World -
This Pride Month, Companies Must Decide: Are They Truly Committed?
Despite the recent DEI backlash, many companies are moving forward with Pride Month celebrations. Here are three tips for honoring the occasion.Inc. - Business -
Walmart chia seeds sold nationwide recalled due to salmonella
Private-label food supplier recalls 32-ounce pouches of Great Value Organic Black Chia Seeds because of potential contamination.CBS News - Top stories -
As GTA 6 Approaches, GTA 5 Passes 200 Million Copies Sold
As part of Take-Two's latest earnings briefing, the company announced new sales figures for Grand Theft Auto V and Red Dead Redemption II, and both are juggernauts.. GTA V has now sold more than 200 million copies, which is up from 195 million in ...GameSpot - Tech -
My father ‘deliberately and hurtfully’ cut my late sister’s two kids out of his will. How can I ensure they get their fair share?
“How can I best do this in such a way that nobody is penalized from gift taxes and other costs?”MarketWatch - Business -
The Kind of Climate Models That Insurers Need
Economics can help with a joined-up understanding of climate risks as the insurance industry reinvents itself.The Wall Street Journal - World - Climate -
Republican Jewish Coalition commits to raising $5M for Trump reelection
A major Republican grassroots Jewish group is pledging to raise at least $5 million for former President Trump's reelection campaign, calling it the organization's "largest effort" to shore up Jewish support. The Republican Jewish Coalition (RJC) ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Authorities continue hunt for 2 people who committed 'archeological theft'
Authorities are looking for two people who they say committed “archeological theft” at a U.S national park in Moab, Utah.ABC News - Top stories
More from The Hill
-
Arizona poll finds trouble for Biden vs. Trump
A new poll shows some trouble for President Biden's chances against former President Trump in Arizona — a state that Biden carried in 2020. A new CBS News poll found Trump leading Biden by 5 percentage points in Arizona, with 52 percent support ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Rubio predicts Trump 'won't get to sign' federal election ban
Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) on Sunday predicted former President Trump will not have the opportunity to sign a national abortion ban even if he is reelected and wanted to, arguing the issue will never enough support in Congress. When asked on NBC ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Child care can cost twice as much as rent in these 11 states: See the numbers
It’s no secret that child care is expensive – but in some U.S. states, it can cost at least twice as much as rent for families with more than one kid.The Hill - Politics -
Ron Johnson says he doesn't trust polls showing Trump beating Biden in Wisconsin
Sen. Ron Johnson (R-Wis.) on Sunday brushed off the recent polls showing President Biden's slight lead over former President Trump in his home state of Wiscoin, noting he does not trust early polling. "Well, as somebody who has run statewide three ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Biden decries Gaza humanitarian crisis at Morehouse, winning applause
President Biden decried the "humanitarian crisis in Gaza" in his commencement address at Morehouse College on Sunday, which marked his first appearance on a college campus since student protests erupted nationwide over the Israel-Hamas war. ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden