How senators can restore the world’s greatest deliberative body
Today’s Senate is dysfunctional by any measure. The “world’s greatest deliberative body” now spends most of its time voting on routine presidential nominations to the executive and judicial branches.
When the Senate does consider legislation, most senators feel they have little substantive input. Bills are crafted by party leaders behind closed doors, and the majority leader — often in consultation with the minority leader — brings those bills directly to the Senate floor, bypassing committee consideration. Floor debate is truncated and tightly controlled, and amendments are usually prohibited.
Rank-and-file senators in both parties are increasingly frustrated with this situation, which affords them few opportunities to represent their constituents and achieve their policy goals. For example, former Sen. Mark Begich (D-Alaska) did not get a vote on a single amendment he proposed during his six years in the Senate.
The Senate wasn’t always this dysfunctional. The institution earned its moniker — “The world’s greatest deliberative body” — because its rules once empowered all senators to participate in the legislative process.
Consequently, interested senators in both parties traditionally played an active role in shaping legislation in committee and on the Senate floor. Floor debates would often last for weeks when the Senate considered controversial bills. And senators almost always had the opportunity to offer amendments during those debates.
In practice, the Senate operates quite differently today. Although today’s senators have the same powers as their predecessors — the rules haven’t changed — they regularly defer to their leaders to set the agenda and structure action on the floor.
Both majority- and minority-party senators let the majority leader decide what bills will be considered on the Senate floor. Once on a bill, the majority leader typically files cloture to end debate preemptively, before senators have even had the opportunity to speak on it, much less filibuster it.
At the same time, the majority leader routinely "fills the amendment tree" — that is, he proposes multiple meaningless amendments in order to prevent other senators from offering substantive amendments to the bill. The average senator is reduced to saying “yea” or “nay” and perhaps making remarks.
Senators — Democrats and Republicans alike — are not powerless; they can make the Senate great again. Any senator could simply stop deferring to the party leaders to manage the institution however they like. But doing so would be a major change and there aren’t many experienced senators who are familiar with navigating a decentralized and freewheeling Senate successfully.
A better path would be for senators to cut a deal that affords them more opportunities to act as lawmakers. Next month’s Senate leadership elections present an option for senators to do that.
Newly elected members will gather with incumbent lawmakers in both parties to select their leadership teams and to adopt party rules. While doing that, they should condition their votes for chamber leadership on promises to allow more debate and votes on amendments.
Republicans have the most leverage in their leadership election since the current GOP leader — Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) — has decided to step down from the top spot. No one has secured sufficient support to succeed McConnell, which gives the rank-and-file leverage to extract concessions from the candidates.
While the Democratic leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) is running unopposed for another term in his party’s top spot, rank-and-file Democrats still must select him before it is official.
The Senate operates mostly on precedents and informal agreements, meaning senators should not get bogged down in abstruse discussions of reforms to legislative procedure. Mostly, they just need to formulate their wishes and then secure commitments from whomever they pick as leaders.
But before any of that can happen, senators will need to shift their mindset. The majority and minority leaders are not the bosses of a nominations and legislation factory. Senators are not assembly line workers. They are lawmakers, and the majority leader and minority leaders should work for them.
James Wallner is a senior fellow at the R Street Institute. Kevin R. Kosar is a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.
Date: |
-
Business - Inc.
What Your Business Can Learn From the World’s Greatest Mathematician’s View of AI
When a person dubbed the “world’s greatest living mathematician” talks about AI it’s worth listening and taking some lessons for your company.Yesterday -
Entertainment - ABC News
Netflix series explores women's dreams in the body-slamming world of Japanese pro wrestling
“The Queen of Villains” is a typical coming-of-age tale about a young woman’s road to empowerment and self-discovery — except it all takes place in the body-slamming, arm-twisting world of Japanese ...9 hours ago - Netflix -
World - ABC News
Netflix series explores women's dreams in the body-slamming world of Japanese pro wrestling
“The Queen of Villains” is a typical coming-of-age tale about a young woman’s road to empowerment and self-discovery — except it all takes place in the body-slamming, arm-twisting world of Japanese ...9 hours ago - Netflix -
World - The Guardian
The scandal of food waste – and how we can stop it
Every informed observer agrees that food waste and loss must be reduced if we are to feed all humans. What’s stopping us?. In traditional societies, little to no food goes to waste. Every edible ...14 hours ago -
Business - MarketWatch
Here’s how economic issues could help Republicans take back the U.S. Senate
The ouster of the incumbent Democratic senator in Ohio or Montana in November’s election could set the stage for a Republican-run Senate. What are the economic issues that are threatening Sens. ...3 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
How the US can help Lebanon move past Hezbollah
The current ruling class in Lebanon must overcome its own Stockholm syndrome.Yesterday -
Top stories - CBS News
How living in extended-stay hotels can affect the health of poor kids
Living in extended-stay hotels, often a last resort for low-income families trying to avoid homelessness, can lead to or exacerbate various children's physical and mental health issues, advocates say.9 hours ago -
World - The Guardian
‘We may see a 70-yarder’: NFL kickers are excelling. How much better can they get?
The league is seeing successful kicks that once seemed unimaginable become routine. What’s behind the upsurge in performance?. In the first 70 years of its existence, the NFL saw two successful ...10 hours ago - NFL
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
FEMA chief: Trump accusations 'completely false'
Deanne Criswell, administrator of the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), pushed back on former President Trump’s “completely false” claims that the agency lacks on-the-ground personnel in ...48 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Blinken should press China for answers on 300 in-process intercountry adoptions
China's decision to end intercountry adoptions will result in more children with medical special needs spending their childhood in orphanages instead of with loving families, and Secretary of State ...58 minutes ago - China -
Politics - The Hill
Hogan launches ad hitting Alsobrooks on crime
Larry Hogan (R), Maryland’s former governor turned Senate candidate, released a campaign ad Tuesday targeting his opponent, Prince George’s County Executive Angela Alsobrooks, and her record on ...59 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Watch live: Biden delivers remarks on lead pipes in Wisconsin
President Biden will deliver remarks in Milwaukee Tuesday, touching on the administration’s work replacing lead pipes and job creation. Biden has committed to replace every lead pipe in the nation ...1 hour ago - Joe Biden -
Politics - The Hill
FAA issues safety alert over Boeing 737 rudders
The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) issued a safety alert Tuesday for certain Boeing 737 planes, citing the potential risks of jammed rudder movements. The agency said a recent event occurred ...1 hour ago