How hurricanes threaten forests — and the carbon markets that depend on them
A single hurricane barreling into New England forests can undo decades of carbon storage, a new study has found.
As climate change heats oceans and fuels hurricanes, worsening storms with higher-speed winds are reaching ever deeper into the region's woodlands, according to findings published on Wednesday in Global Change Biology. Now, just one big storm can knock down as many as 10 percent of standing trees in the heavily forested region.
Small increases in wind speed led to exponential increases in damage, the researchers found. An 8 percent increase drove up the number of high-destruction areas by more than 10 times; a 16 percent increase by more than 25 times.
The findings spell trouble for forest carbon markets, which aim to sell “credits” generated by storing carbon from the atmosphere in the growing bodies of trees.
With so many corporations looking to carbon credits as a means to “offset” their greenhouse gas emissions, the carbon credit market — of which forestry is a major part — is expected to grow to $100 billion by the end of the decade, and a quarter trillion by midcentury, according to Morgan Stanley.
As they grow, U.S. forests currently pull down the equivalent of about 15 percent of the nation’s fossil fuel emissions, according to the Department of Agriculture. The agency and state partners have sought to encourage markets in which landowners can sell the carbon stored in their growing forests on regional and international markets.
There is a lot of controversy over whether carbon offsets truly reduce emissions. But any version of carbon offset schemes rests on the idea that carbon is being permanently removed from the atmosphere — which requires the trees to keep standing.
“If we are going to rely on forest carbon as a primary tool to mitigate climate change—which seems to be the dominant direction that policies and voluntary/compulsory carbon markets are going in—we have to adequately account for the risks to this forest carbon from disturbances,” said coauthor Shersingh Joseph Tumber-Dávila of Dartmouth College and Harvard Forest.
Tumber-Dávila’s work shows that forest carbon storage companies face insolvency, rather like a bank without enough capital reserves to cover a sudden run on deposits.
"Current carbon market policies are incredibly insufficiently buffered against these risks, with a single hurricane having the capacity to emit the equivalent of 10[-plus] years of carbon sequestration from New England Forests," he said.
To put those numbers into perspective, he noted that in California’s regulated carbon market — the U.S.’s largest — “less than 3% of carbon credits are set aside to mitigate catastrophic risks.”
If the trees fall — in storms or fires — those carbon offsets are wiped out. That’s been a serious problem for West Coast companies like Green Diamond, which received millions of dollars from tech companies seeking to offset their fossil fuel use with forest protection — only to have destructive wildfires fueled by climate change rip through their forests, according to Oregon Public Broadcasting.
That project, the broadcaster reported, ”depended on live trees. Year after year, they would act like worker bees, collecting carbon dioxide and — with the aid of the sunlight and water — use photosynthesis to store more of it in their wood.”
But in one fire, the company lost live trees that held down 3.3 million metric tons of carbon dioxide — the equivalent of the annual emissions from the tailpipes of 700,000 cars.
The Global Change Biology study expands this survey beyond wildfires and into the damage caused by storms.
Unlike that done by fires, however, this damage isn’t instantaneous: fallen trees take up to two decades to become a net source of emissions — countering the carbon stored by the forest regrowing around them — and up to a century to fully break down.
Nonetheless, the writers expressed caution about the future of New England's forests on a heating planet — not to mention their utility as a financial instrument for companies unable to cut emissions.
A single storm, Tumber-Dávila noted, “is likely to deplete what is set aside for risks over 100 years."
Date: |
Filter
-
How Markets Are Reacting, in Five Charts
Take a look at how various assets are performing after the release of the April jobs report: U.S. stock futures, the 10-year Treasury yield, Brent crude, gold and the U.S. dollar.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Forest charged by FA as Clattenburg leaves club
Nottingham Forest and manager Nuno Espirito Santo are charged with misconduct by the FA as Mark Clattenburg leaves the club.BBC News - Top stories -
'It's special': Chemistry powers Knicks past 76ers in Game 6
An epic first-round series between New York and Philadelphia ended with yet another epic game. Would you expect anything less?Yahoo Sports - Sports - NBA -
Interest rates are staying high—how to make them work in your favor
The U.S. Federal Reserve is keeping its benchmark interest rate at its current decades-long high. Savers and borrowers can take advantage of the moment.CNBC - Business -
Hudson-Odoi seals precious victory for Nottingham Forest at Sheffield United
Nottingham Forest took a significant step towards Premier League safety as two goals from Callum Hudson-Odoi and another from their captain, Ryan Yates, piled more misery on bottom-placed Sheffield United. The victory moved Forest three points ...The Guardian - World -
Student protests threaten to overshadow commencements
Pro-Palestinian student activists have one last opportunity to make a big impact before campuses are barren for the summer: commencement. Tens of thousands of families and friends will flock to campuses across the country starting this weekend ...The Hill - Politics -
Klopp tears into TNT Sports; Clattenburg resigns from Forest role: football news –as it happened
News from all the Premier League press conferences as the outgoing Liverpool manager fired another broadside at the TV companies, among other stories. Nottingham Forest: Nuno Espirito Santo expects his side’s Premier League relegation battle to go ...The Guardian - World -
Burnley 1-4 Newcastle, Sheffield United 1-3 Nottm Forest: Premier League clockwatch – as it happened
Nottingham Forest took a huge step towards safety with a 3-1 win at Sheffield United as Burnley slumped to a damaging loss against a rampant Newcastle. Live scoreboard: Saturday’s results and latest scores The Blues are in the third tier for the ...The Guardian - World - Premier League -
My two adult kids have had to move back home. Should I be charging them rent – and if so, how much? | Sue Elliott-Nicholls
They face spiralling costs and insecure work, so I’m glad to help them. But I can’t afford the big rise in my cost of living. Thank goodness for the “bank of mum and dad”: now there’s an expression to make me a bit sick in my mouth. I am the ...The Guardian - World -
Yellen argues that undercutting democracy threatens economic growth
Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen will argue in a Friday speech that democracy is under threat and that undercutting it will, in turn, threaten economic growth.MarketWatch - Business
More from The Hill
-
Lindsey Graham sends UNC counter protesters Chick-fil-A for 'protecting Old Glory'
Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) said he is sending Chick-fil-A to counter protesters against pro-Palestinian protesters at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (UNC) Saturday. “I’m so proud of the courageous young men at @UNC that ...The Hill - Politics -
Democrats should fear ‘lawfare’ tactics being turned against them
Unhinged partisan politics is quickly propelling our nation down the path of the normalization of the weaponization of law to take out a political opponent — a path that is destructive to all.The Hill - Politics -
Bush, Omar compare Gaza war protest police responses to Kent State Massacre on 54th anniversary
Progressive Reps. Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.) and Cori Bush (D-Minn.) compared police responses to ongoing pro-Palestinian protests on college campuses across the country to the Kent State Massacre on its 54th anniversary Saturday. “54 years ago, the ...The Hill - Politics -
Cindy McCain: There is 'full-blown famine' in northern Gaza
World Food Programme Director Cindy McCain sat down for an interview with NBC’s “Meet the Press” host Kristen Welker to discuss the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, saying there’s ‘full-blown famine' in northern Gaza. “Whenever you have conflicts like ...The Hill - Politics -
Arizona high court reverses ruling against GOP on sanctions over 2020 election challenge
The Arizona Supreme Court reversed a lower court ruling that put sanctions on the Arizona Republican Party, after the state spent time and money defending its 2020 election procedures. The court ruled unanimously Thursday to overrule the trial ...The Hill - Politics