House GOP braces for bitter fight over the power to oust a speaker
House Republicans are gearing up for an intra-party war early next year over the ability to defenestrate a speaker. While the majority of Republicans despise the tool, which has single-handedly caused repeated chaos this Congress, a number of conservatives are prepared to fight to keep it.
Speaker Mike Johnson and other leadership allies have openly signaled that they want to raise the number of members required to force a vote on deposing a speaker; currently, a single lawmaker can call for a referendum. But that fight is inextricably tied to Johnson’s ambitions to remain speaker — the members who want to see the rule to remain as it is are some of the same ones who haven’t committed to supporting his bid for the gavel, and they’re not afraid to leverage that power.
It’s not hard to see why most Republicans want to change the rule. The so-called motion to vacate allows a small faction of lawmakers to highly influence the agenda and strips power from leadership. Johnson himself has publicly said that the tool has “harmed this office and our House majority.”
Right now, there are enough conservatives who oppose changes to block any adjustments to the status quo. In interviews with POLITICO, five Republicans said they believe that group is big enough that it would also be highly difficult to change the rule next year. One GOP lawmaker said there are at least eight members who will automatically oppose any adjustments.
Of course, House Republicans have to keep control if they want to set the rules — but if they succeed in November, it all sets the stage for a huge fight in the coming months. The debate would not only influence whether Johnson could be speaker in the next Congress, but also leadership’s power to shape the conference’s agenda over the wishes of frequently rebellious hardliners. In short, if Johnson or other leaders can’t overcome the right flank’s red line, they’re set for another potentially chaotic Congress.
Members of the ultra-conservative House Freedom Caucus, as well as some hardliners outside of the group, are having private discussions about what they want to see in the rules package next year. That includes keeping the current ouster rule at the same threshold.
“I think it’s going to be very difficult to change,” Rep. Chip Roy (R-Texas) said. “I think we’re just going to have to just move forward.”
Another Freedom Caucus member, granted anonymity to speak candidly, was more direct: “If they are going to go back to the way things were pre-McCarthy, then I don’t care who the speaker is, they will have that same fight.” That’s a reference to the 15 rounds of ballots it took former Speaker Kevin McCarthy to secure the gavel.
Meanwhile, a larger segment of the conference wants the rule overhauled. Republicans in and out of leadership are calling for a hard reset on the power dynamics that have plagued their conference since January 2023, when they believe McCarthy bent too far to his right flank. The vast majority of House Republicans see another extended speakership brawl, like the three-week episode triggered by McCarthy’s ouster, as a nightmare scenario.
Still, reality favors the hardliners here. Johnson has a basic math problem — he only has a three-vote margin, so he doesn’t currently have the votes within his own conference to raise the ouster threshold. His best chance is growing his majority significantly in November, which could be a tall order. Democrats will vote in unified opposition to a GOP rules package in January, meaning Johnson can only depend on Republican votes.
“It depends on how big the majority is,” Rep. Morgan Griffith (R-Va.), who has his own ideas about how to change the motion to vacate rule, said about leadership’s chances of successfully batting down hardliners.
He added of rules and leadership battles generally: “If we have a majority of 15 ... there’s not going to be any successful fights.”
Private discussions about rule changes go beyond the motion to vacate. While conservatives have their own conversations behind the scenes about how to further empower rank-and-file members, centrists and leaders are gaming out their own plans with an eye towards limiting potential chaos in the next Congress.
Conservatives, for their part, want to place new limits on what bills can pass under the higher two-thirds suspension threshold, a tool that GOP leadership has used several times this Congress to leapfrog holdouts and rely on Democratic help, particularly to pass spending bills.
Meanwhile, a group of centrists has been discussing their own rules ideas — including the formation of a formal working group that was first reported by POLITICO. Those proposals include setting repercussions for members who vote against bringing a GOP bill to the floor, a tactic conservatives used against both McCarthy and Johnson to repeatedly sink leadership priorities.
Republicans, including members of leadership, are separately discussing raising the threshold for a so-called discharge petition, a procedural mechanism that can force floor action on a bill if it reaches 218 signatures, regardless of leadership objections.
Still, it’s the rules regarding ousting a speaker that would likely grab the most attention in the GOP’s potential rules fight. And everyone is already seemingly dug in.
Republicans can set a higher ouster threshold as part of their own internal conference rules debate in November — like they did after the 2022 election. But that’s just the opening act; the House’s rules aren’t official unless they’re adopted by a full chamber vote in January. Last time, conservatives refused to vote for McCarthy until he made several of their demanded changes to the rules, including lowering the speaker-ousting threshold to one member, which were ultimately adopted.
“I agreed with what we did in conference,” said Rep. David Joyce (R-Ohio). “There has to be a better standard than just having a couple of renegades joining with the other side.”
Rep. Don Bacon (R-Neb.), another centrist, has floated that leadership should make a deal with Democrats, asking the other party to help raise the motion-to-vacate threshold in exchange for giving them more seats on committees.
“I would make the deal and put that thing behind me,” Bacon said. “But I got huge push back: ‘You can’t make a deal with Democrats.’”
Conservative Rep. Ralph Norman (R-S.C.) said in a brief interview that he does not support raising the threshold, adding “there’s a group of us,” mainly within the Freedom Caucus, that are already looking at the ouster rule and others “pretty carefully.” Asked if he thinks the threshold will change come January, he replied: “I don’t think it will.”
Further complicating matters for Johnson and other leaders: A broader group of Republicans would like to see changes to the motion to vacate, but not to the fact that just one member can force the vote.
Griffith, for example, floated what he described as a “hybrid” model: Keeping the current ability for any one member to trigger an ouster vote, but limiting how often it can be used. He proposed that it couldn’t be used against a new speaker for his or her first six months on the job, and setting a period of time before it could be used again if one is brought up and fails.
Some supporters of the current rule have floated that they would be willing to discuss raising the threshold in exchange for other priorities. Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-Fla.) has said he would be open to raising the motion-to-vacate threshold in exchange for ethics and campaign finance reforms — though it’s far from clear such an offer would move the larger group of holdouts.
And Roy, while cautioning that “all things can be discussed,” said that a change “would “have to come with something, if it changes at all.”
“I think it is an uphill climb to change it,” he added.
Date: | |
Tag: | House |
Topics
-
World - The New York Times
Displaced Gazans Brace for Another Harsh Winter
15 hours ago -
Business - The New York Times
I.M.F. Says Inflation Fight Is Largely Over but Warns of New Threats
Yesterday - Inflation -
Health - ABC News
White House says health insurance needs to fully cover condoms, other birth control
2 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
CNN host, GOP senator tangle over Trump's reported praise of Hitler
5 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Lifestyle - The New York Times
The Fight Over the Chrysler Building Escalates
10 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
House Republicans brace for leadership scramble
14 hours ago - Republican Party -
Top stories - ABC News
GOP-led probe disputes ex-White House aide's House Jan. 6 testimony about note
Yesterday -
Top stories - NBC News
Health plans should pay for over-the-counter birth control at no cost, White House proposes
2 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
GOP senator: Trump energy helped push Steelers to victory over Jets
2 days ago - Donald Trump -
Top stories - ABC News
GOP lawsuit against overseas votes draws ire from military families
2 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
White House proposes insurers cover cost of over-the-counter birth control
2 days ago -
Sports - Yahoo Sports
Ohtani, Dodgers on their way to World Series after ousting Mets
3 days ago - MLB -
World - Yahoo News
Malaysia Minister Braces for Backlash Over Fuel Subsidy Revamp
3 days ago -
Top stories - BBC News
Yellow warnings in place as Storm Ashley hits
3 days ago -
World - The Guardian
Middle East crisis live: Netanyahu vows revenge on Iran proxies after drone attack on his house
4 days ago - Iran -
Top stories - The New York Times
The Fight Over Ballots Has Already Begun in Wisconsin
4 days ago -
Top stories - BBC News
Why fight for justice isn't over in India's 'horrific' widow-burning case, 37 years on
4 days ago -
Business - The New York Times
CVS Ousts Karen Lynch as C.E.O. and Shares Fall
5 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
Former GOP adviser: White House race is Harris's to lose
5 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
Democrats in tight House races ride Harris fundraising momentum to outpace GOP
6 days ago -
Business - Financial Times
The tech sector should brace for further turbulence
6 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
GOP senator: House GOP whip 'surrendering' before year-end spending battle
6 days ago -
Tech - GameSpot
The PS6 And Next Xbox Shouldn't Fight Over Teraflops, Former Sony Boss Says
6 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
GOP cringes over Trump’s vow to wield military against opponents
6 days ago - Donald Trump -
Top stories - BBC News
‘You stole the election’: Nervous volunteers on frontline of conspiracies
6 days ago -
Top stories - NBC News
Democrats flooded with cash in fight for Congress as the GOP tries to stretch its money
October 16 -
Top stories - NBC News
An AI-powered bot army on X spread pro-Trump and pro-GOP propaganda, research shows
October 16 -
Business - MarketWatch
Reality show star who lived with 4 ‘sister wives’ is stuck in a bitter feud with exes over Arizona cabin
October 16 -
Top stories - NBC News
Hakeem Jeffries pitches calm governance over chaos as Democrats seek the House majority
October 15 -
Top stories - NBC News
Kari Lake's fraud claims drive Arizona lawyers away from GOP's 'election integrity' operation
October 15 -
Politics - The Hill
Nathan Wade appears for House deposition; Willis blasts GOP
October 15 -
Top stories - CBS News
Over 90% of power restored in parts of Florida ravaged by Hurricane Milton
October 15 - Florida -
Politics - The Hill
House Republican fights for his political life in Arizona swing district
October 15 -
Top stories - NBC News
Where Speaker Johnson sees the GOP's path to victory: From the Politics Desk
October 14 -
Politics - The Hill
Pennsylvania Republican fights to keep seat in tense House battle
October 14 -
World - Financial Times
FirstFT: China launches large military exercises near Taiwan
October 14 - China -
Business - Financial Times
Pakistan security services pressured utilities over government power deal
October 13 - Pakistan
More from Politico
-
Politics - Politico
The POLITICO race to watch: Nebraska’s 2nd
Yesterday -
Politics - Politico
Internal GOP poll shows trouble for Peltola in Alaska
2 days ago -
Politics - Politico
Law enforcement missed ‘pivotal moments’ to engage Trump gunman, House panel finds
2 days ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - Politico
What if it's President Harris, but a GOP Senate? That's her allies' fear.
3 days ago -
Politics - Politico
Anti-Trump Republicans wade into key down-ballot races with Democratic endorsements
October 16 - Republican Party
Latest in Politics
-
Politics - The Hill
Kamala Harris gets Insane Clown Posse endorsement
38 minutes ago - Kamala Harris -
Politics - NBC News
Trump campaign slams comments by Biden
1 hour ago - Joe Biden -
Politics - NBC News
Harris seizes on critical comments about Trump from his former chief of staff
1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - NBC News
Harris says Trump is 'increasingly unhinged' and blasts his reported praise of Hitler as dangerous
1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Giuliani spokesperson says former mayor 'unfairly punished' by having to hand over assets
1 hour ago