House Democrat: Trump Gaza proposal ‘makes no sense’

Democratic Rep. Gregory Meeks (N.Y.), the ranking member on the House Foreign Affairs Committee, said President Trump’s proposal for taking over Gaza “makes no sense.”

Meeks joined CNN on Wednesday to discuss the idea floated by Trump while meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that the U.S.

“It doesn’t make any sense,” he said. “It’s again, the president just going off on his own.”

Meeks noted there are several countries, like Egypt or Saudi Arabia, near Gaza that had the option to take over the region but did not do so. It would involve billions or trillions of dollars, “systematically remove people” from their homeland and would go against international norms, he said.

“It just makes no sense,” Meeks reiterated. “It’s a violation of law, and it is inhumane.”

Meeks told The Hill he believes taking over Gaza would be colonization, but it’s an idea he doesn’t take seriously at all.

“This guy just talks off the top of his head,” he said, adding, “It just doesn’t make any rational and common sense.”

The New York Democrat said the human impact needs to be examined, and there are many unanswered questions about Trump’s proposal.

“What’s going to happen to all of those people? He just said all the … Palestinians have to leave. And then there’s [another] question about what happens to those people. Do they come back? Do they have the right of return?” Meeks questioned.

The president’s remarks about Gaza on Tuesday were some of his most extreme comments on the topic, particularly as the nearly 2 million Palestinians hope to have their own state. Trump suggested the U.S. would develop the land but didn’t provide details on who would be able to live on the land.

Meeks said he believes Trump is attempting to cause chaos and move people’s minds away from things he is not doing.

“He’s not reducing the cost of food. He’s not making life better for the American people. He’s not making homes more affordable for people, reducing the cost of rent. He’s not doing any of those things that are affecting everyday lives of Americans,” he said on CNN.

Mike Lillis contributed.

Topics

White House defends Trump's Gaza takeover, resettlement proposal

The White House on Wednesday defended President Trump’s proposal for the United States to take control of the Gaza Strip amid blowback from Arab leaders and some Republicans. Press secretary ...
The Hill - 1h
'A surprising development': House GOP react to Trump's Gaza proposal

House Republicans responded to President Trump's comments about the U.S. taking ownership of the Gaza Strip. Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., called the claim "a surprising development," but believes ...
NBC News - 4h
Trump’s Proposal on Gaza Is a Risk for Egypt and Jordan

The Arab countries are among the top recipients of American military aid, but forcing Palestinians out of their remaining territory could destabilize the entire region.
The New York Times - 1h
Rubio on Trump’s Gaza Strip proposal: 'Make Gaza Beautiful Again'

Secretary of State Marco Rubio weighed in on President Trump’s proposal to take over the Gaza Strip, calling to “Make Gaza Beautiful Again.” “Gaza MUST BE FREE from Hamas,” Rubio posted to the ...
The Hill - 2h
Watch live: White House holds briefing amid fallout from Trump Gaza proposal

White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt will brief the press Wednesday afternoon, a day after President Trump floated the idea that the U.S. take over the Gaza Strip, as the war-ravaged region ...
The Hill - 3h
Takeaways From Trump’s Proposal for a U.S. Takeover of Gaza

President Trump said that the United States should take over Gaza and forcibly relocate two million Palestinians. Leaders in Gaza and Arab nations immediately rejected the idea.
The New York Times - 9h
Trump proposes ‘clean out’ of Gaza population

US president urges Egypt and Jordan to take in people from ‘demolition site’
Financial Times - Jan. 26