House bill presumes Senate treaty role and undermines presidential discretion
It’s not every day that one house of Congress initiates legislation that tells the other house what its job should be. But that’s exactly what the House bill, No WHO Pandemic Preparedness Treaty Without Senate Approval Act, does.
The legislation, which cleared by the Rules Committee on Monday, would prohibit U.S. acceptance of a World Health Organization (WHO) pandemic prevention, preparedness and response agreement unless approved as a treaty by a two-thirds vote of the Senate.
The House Foreign Affairs Committee reported the measure July 11 by a party-line vote of 24-23. The bill’s title minces no words as to what it’s about: the “No WHO Pandemic Preparedness Treaty Without Senate Approval Act” — not an easily manageable acronym.
The bottom line is that any agreement reached on pandemic preparedness and response by the World Health Assembly, the governing body of the WHO, is “deemed to be a treaty that is subject to the constitutional requirement for Senate ratification by a two-thirds vote.
But the bill skips one essential: Article Il, Section 2 of the Constitution provides that the president “shall have power, by and with the advice and consent of the Senate to make treaties….” As the 2022 edition of The Constitution Annotated makes clear, the treaty-making power begins with executive negotiations with other nations. Once these are completed, “the President submits the treaty to the Senate.” The president’s decision to submit it for Senate approval is discretionary.
A treaty cannot be “deemed” to have been submitted by the president to the Senate. By omitting any presidential role once an agreement is reached, the pact somehow magically appears whole cloth in the Senate’s in-box for action. If approved by the Senate, it would still presumably have to be signed by the president for official ratification before the other parties to the agreement are notified.
In bypassing the White House initially, the bill precludes the possibility of the president adopting the measure as an international “executive agreement,” requiring no action by Congress. According to the Senate’s website listing, “About Treaties,” only 6 percent of the pacts negotiated with other nations are submitted to the Senate as treaties. The rest are finalized as executive agreements and signed by the president without Senate approval. The extraordinary House mandate on the Senate would surely be unprecedented if enacted, though the other body is unlikely to embrace the bill if it shows-up on its doorstep.
So, what is behind the House’s attempt to make this more difficult, urgent and complicated than needed? The Foreign Affairs Committee’s report, in its 11-paragraph “summary and purpose,” warns generally that it deserves treaty consideration because of its “potential breadth and intrusiveness.” Moreover, it’s because of “lingering public distrust of the WHO given its manipulation by the Chinese Communist Party and its deadly cover-up that contributed to the global COVID-19 pandemic.”
Citing the final report issued by the Foreign Affairs Committee’s minority staff in the previous Congress under then ranking, now chairman, Michael McCaul (R-Texas), the current report asserts “it is beyond doubt that the [Chinese Communist Party] actively engaged in a cover-up designed to obfuscate data, hide relevant health information, and suppress doctors and journalists who attempted to warn the world of the of the COVID-19 outbreak.”
In December 2021, the World Health Assembly established an Intergovernmental Negotiating Body to draft the pandemic accord. So far, negotiators have met nine times to consider various drafts. When negotiating authority expired in May without an agreement, the negotiating authority had to be extended until May 2025. The Foreign Affairs Committee report characterizes the attempted drafts to date as “aspirational slogans.” Secretary of State Antony Blinken said of the negotiations, “I don’t see that coming to a conclusion in the near term. There’s just not a consensus on it.”
The reason the Rules Committee was scheduled to consider the bill this past Monday, just 13 legislative days before the pre-election recess, is that this seems to be a “Get China theme week.” Four other anti-China bills cleared the Rules Committee Monday relating to: Confucius institutes and “Chinese entities of concern”; Chinese dominance of electric vehicles; protecting U.S. innovation from China; and protecting American agriculture from foreign adversaries (like China).
The Rules Committee also granted a rule on Monday for a six-month, stop-gap continuing appropriations bill — a must-pass bill before the Oct. 1 fiscal year drop-dead date to stave off a government shutdown.
It is sometimes difficult to understand what drives legislative scheduling decisions. When in doubt, look for a pattern of throwing messaging bills onto the floor as filler between taking-up essential legislation to keep the government and country operating.
Don Wolfensberger is a 28-year congressional staff veteran, culminating as chief-of-staff of the House Rules Committee. He is author of, “Congress and the People: Deliberative Democracy on Trial” (2000), and, “Changing Cultures in Congress: From Fair Play to Power Plays” (2018).
Date: |
Topics
-
ABC News - Top stories
Senate IVF bill fails again to advance on mostly party line vote
Senate Majority Leader Schumer wanted to put Republicans on record with their vote on IVF, which has become a flashpoint in the presidential election.1 hour ago -
The Guardian - World
Harris condemns Senate Republicans for blocking IVF bill; VP calls Ohio attacks a ‘crying shame’ – live
Vice-president says Republicans ‘have once again made clear’ they will not protect IVF access; Harris addresses anti-immigrant attacks in NABJ interview . As far as the election campaign is ...23 minutes ago - Republican Party -
The Hill - Politics
Republicans block Senate Democrats' IVF bill
Republicans on Tuesday blocked a bill that would have created a right to access in vitro fertilization (IVF) treatments and mandated that insurance plans cover the practice, deriding the vote as a ...1 hour ago - Republican Party -
The New York Times - Top stories
Senate Republicans Block I.V.F. Bill Again, Breaking With Trump
Democrats brought up the measure again to highlight Republican opposition to abortion rights and make the case to voters that the G.O.P. stance threatens access to reproductive health care.50 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politico - Politics
Senate Dems balk at Johnson's spending bill, but wait to release their own plan
September 10 -
The New York Times - Top stories
The Presidential Horse Race
Taking polls seriously can bring enormous benefits. The past few years have been a case study.10 hours ago -
Inc. - Business
Betting on U.S. Elections Undermines Confidence in Voting, Agency Says
TheCommodities and Futures Trading Commission continues its bid to keep New York startup Kalshi from taking money for election wagers.4 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Hunter Biden asks to push back gun sentencing a few weeks
Hunter Biden, the president’s son, on Tuesday asked the judge overseeing his criminal gun case to push back his upcoming sentencing by a few weeks. Biden asked to move the scheduled Nov. 13 date ...25 minutes ago - Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Watch live: Trump, Sarah Huckabee Sanders hold town hall in Michigan
Former President Trump will speak with voters in the storied auto manufacturing community of Flint, Mich., Tuesday evening at a town hall moderated by Arkansas Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders, who ...45 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Jason Carter says grandfather ready to 'turn page' on Trump era
Jason Carter, the oldest of former President Carter's grandchildren, said Tuesday that his grandfather is "excited" to vote for Vice President Harris and ready to "turn the page" on former ...47 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Klobuchar, Warner press tech leaders to take action against election-related disinformation
Democratic Sens. Amy Klobuchar (Minn.) and Mark Warner (Va.) sent a letter to major tech leaders on Tuesday, urging them to take "decisive action" against disinformation related to the 2024 general ...51 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Tensions rise after apparent Trump assassination attempt
Welcome to The Hill's Campaign newsletter {beacon} Campaign Report Campaign Report The Big Story Tensions rise after apparent Trump assassination attempt Another major event has shaken up the ...54 minutes ago - Donald Trump