‘High Noon’ for Judge James Boasberg at the Constitution corral

The job of federal district court judge is a prestigious lifetime appointment. But even in normal times, it is a lonely job, because judges’ rulings are theirs and theirs alone.

These are not normal times. Look at District Judge James Boasberg, an Obama appointee who is the chief judge of the federal district court in D.C. He presides over a lawsuit challenging the mass deportation of Venezuelan nationals in U.S. custody to El Salvador. The Trump administration, claiming that the Venezuelans are gang members, issued a proclamation deporting them pursuant to the Alien Enemies Act of 1798.

In response to an emergency lawsuit on behalf of the deportees, Judge Boasberg ordered the government to delay the deportation flights until he could rule whether the deportations were authorized by the act, which has been invoked just three times in American history and only in wartime.

Instead, the Trump administration set up a constitutional showdown by flying the Venezuelans to El Salvador in apparent defiance of Boasberg’s order. Trump called the judge a “radical left lunatic” and demanded his impeachment, while MAGA allies attacked his family.

In a rare rebuke, Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts pointed out that it has been recognized for centuries “that impeachment is not an appropriate response to disagreement concerning a judicial decision. The normal appellate review process exists for that purpose.” Trump again suggested impeachment, in keeping with his style of head-butting until his opponent backs down and Trump owns him.

Things are not going that way. Instead, Trump, the bully in the bully pulpit, is in a federal judge’s wheelhouse, where obedience to court orders and accountability for violating them is a core principle.

Boasberg called the use of the Alien Enemies Act “incredibly troublesome” and suggested that the Trump administration “rushed” to get the deportees out of the country to evade judicial review. He has relentlessly pressed the government attorneys to explain whether the deportation flights took off after he issued his order: “I will get to the bottom of whether they violated my order — who ordered this and what the consequences will be.”

Boasberg is especially isolated because the ordinarily robust restraints of checks and balances in a three-branch government are failing now that the Republican-controlled Congress has all but left the field. Trump has also intimidated Big Law firms such as Paul Weiss, who might have mounted vigorous lobbying campaigns to defend the rule of law.

Consider another isolated federal district judge: Frank Johnson, an Eisenhower appointee in Alabama during the Civil Rights Era. Johnson desegregated the state’s schools and ordered authorities to allow the 1965 Civil Rights march from Selma to Montgomery. He endured death threats, social ostracism and for 15 years needed round-the-clock protection by U.S. Marshals — but never backed down.

For an avatar, look to Hollywood’s Will Kane, the marshal of the town of Hadleyville, played by Gary Cooper in the great western “High Noon.” The murderer whom Kane once jailed has been pardoned and is on his way to kill him, arriving on the noon train where his gang waits at the station. While the frightened townspeople hide, Kane’s Quaker wife Amy (Grace Kelly) pleads with her husband, “Don’t try to be a hero.” He replies, “I’m not trying to be a hero.” Kane, with unexpected help from Amy, kills the murderer and his gang.

As the townspeople emerge from their homes, Kane looks at them contemptuously, throws down his badge and leaves town with Amy.

Boasberg isn’t trying to be a hero. He’s only doing a tough job. And we shouldn’t be hiding in our homes.

Gregory J. Wallance was a federal prosecutor in the Carter and Reagan administrations and a member of the ABSCAM prosecution team, which convicted a U.S. senator and six representatives of bribery. He is the author of “Into Siberia: George Kennan’s Epic Journey Through the Brutal, Frozen Heart of Russia.”

Topics

Who Is James Boasberg, the Judge Trump Wants to Impeach Over Deportation Flights?

President Trump has called for Judge Boasberg to be impeached after he ruled against the administration over the president’s efforts to use a law from 1798 to speed deportations.
The New York Times - Mar. 18
DOJ misses deadline to provide answers on deportation flights

Judge James Boasberg ordered the government to provide information by noon today.
NBC News - 5d
Judge in deportations case says US government lawyers 'disrespectful'

Judge James Boasberg says the legal questions round the handling of the deportations are "incredibly troublesome".
BBC News - 4d
House Republicans eye hearings on Judge Boasberg, bill to rein in federal judges

As President Donald Trump's battle with the judiciary escalates, House Republicans are eyeing ways to rein in judges from blocking parts of his agenda.
ABC News - 15h
Judge Grants the Government Another Day to Share Details on Deportation Flights

Judge James Boasberg has asked the government to tell him what time two planes took off from U.S. soil and from where, what time they left U.S. airspace and what time they landed in El Salvador.
The New York Times - 6d
Republican files impeachment against judge who ruled against Trump deportations

Rep. Brandon Gill (R-Texas) introduced a resolution to impeach U.S. District Judge James Boasberg, who over the weekend ordered the Trump administration to halt deportations of Venezuelans whom it ...
The Hill - Mar. 18
Judge vows to ‘get to the bottom’ of whether Trump administration violated deportation flight order

A federal judge chastised a Justice Department attorney Friday, expressing doubt about the legality of the Trump administration's use of the Alien Enemies Act. U.S. District Judge James Boasberg ...
The Hill - 4d
Judge calls DOJ's deportation flight submission 'woefully insufficient'

The Justice Department provided a submission in writing Thursday in response to U.S. District Judge James Boasberg's request for information.
ABC News - 4d
Judge gives Trump administration 1 more day to turn over deportation flight info

U.S. District Judge James Boasberg gave the Trump administration a one-day extension to turn over information about deportation flights that left the country Saturday, as the government suggests it ...
The Hill - 6d

‘High Noon’ for Judge James Boasberg at the Constitution corral

Topics

Related

Who Is James Boasberg, the Judge Trump Wants to Impeach Over Deportation Flights?

DOJ misses deadline to provide answers on deportation flights

Judge in deportations case says US government lawyers 'disrespectful'

House Republicans eye hearings on Judge Boasberg, bill to rein in federal judges

Judge Grants the Government Another Day to Share Details on Deportation Flights

Republican files impeachment against judge who ruled against Trump deportations

Judge vows to ‘get to the bottom’ of whether Trump administration violated deportation flight order

Judge calls DOJ's deportation flight submission 'woefully insufficient'

Judge gives Trump administration 1 more day to turn over deportation flight info

More from The Hill

Democrat wins Pennsylvania special election, handing party control of state House

Less than 1 in 5 favor US annexing Canada, Greenland: Survey

Waltz questions how the Atlantic editor 'somehow' got 'sucked into' the Signal chat

House Democrat: Hegseth shared classified info to make up for 'personal inadequacies'

Trump officials face records lawsuit over Signal chat

More in Politics

Mike Waltz takes 'full responsibility' for military plans text group

Mike Waltz takes 'full responsibility' for military plans text group

Lawyer says Social Security is in "very scary situation" as issues hit agency

Lawyer says Social Security is in "very scary situation" as issues hit agency

Report: Pentagon warned employees about using Signal