Hegseth makes clear that Trump will sell out Ukraine
During last year’s presidential election, supporters of President Trump sought to reassure skeptics that his rhetoric on Ukraine was just an electoral pose. David Kramer, a Bush-era State Department official, told Vox that Trump had no desire to see Ukraine defeated: “The last thing that Trump is going to want there would be a chaotic collapse, a la Afghanistan 2.0.”
No one should have been fooled. The evidence was there to indicate that a Trump victory would mean a drastic reduction of military and financial assistance to Ukraine and intense pressure for an end to the conflict, no matter what the terms. Anyone who is now surprised was not listening.
Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth confirmed this approach last week in Brussels at a meeting of the Ukraine Defense Contact Group, an alliance of 57 countries and the European Union that coordinates military assistance to Kyiv. His message was simple: The war “must end,” and the U.S. was willing to offer substantial concessions to win over Vladimir Putin.
America is turning its back on Ukraine. Hegseth stated that returning to the pre-2014 borders with Russia “is an unrealistic objective,” Ukraine’s potential membership of NATO is not “a realistic outcome of a negotiated settlement,” policing a ceasefire will fall to European militaries and “as part of any security guarantee, there will not be U.S. troops deployed to Ukraine.”
Putin must scarcely believe his luck. The Trump administration’s position means Russia will almost certainly retain the Ukrainian territory it has seized — about one-fifth of the country — and can exercise an effective veto over Ukraine’s future foreign policy, with NATO membership off the table.
The icing on Moscow’s cake is the disavowal of further American interest or involvement in the region. Ukraine is now only a problem for European governments.
Compounding this is Trump’s unilateral engagement with his Russian counterpart, of whom he has often spoken with adolescent admiration. They had a “lengthy and highly productive” conversation and “agreed to have our respective teams start negotiations immediately.” Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky was “informed” of the conversation after the fact. Trump said he and Putin had “agreed to work together, very closely, including visiting each other’s nations,” though an initial face-to-face meeting will take place in Saudi Arabia in the “not too distant future.”
It is within Trump’s rights to conclude that a protracted war of conquest in eastern Europe is not an American concern. He is unquestionably wrong to describe it as “totally unnecessary,” as the families of the more than 100,000 Ukrainian soldiers and civilians killed following Russia’s invasion know. But from the Oval Office, the steppes around Kharkiv and Donetsk must seem very distant.
Trump and Hegseth should be honest about the consequences of their policy choices. If the settlement they have sketched out were imposed on Ukraine now, Putin would learn some valuable lessons. First, Putin would conclude that armed aggression against a neighbor, including probable war crimes and crimes against humanity, pays off if prosecuted with sufficient determination.
An estimated 250,000 Russian soldiers have been killed (four times America’s losses in Vietnam) but in return Russia occupies about 20 percent of Ukraine, including Crimea and its vital warm-water naval base at Sevastopol. Ukrainian membership of NATO is off the table, and the U.S. has demonstrated that it is no longer committed to the defense of Europe or to Article Five of the North Atlantic Treaty, which governs collective security.
The weekend’s Munich Security Conference brought together world leaders and military chiefs, including Vice President JD Vance and Secretary of State Marco Rubio. Yes, Munich — the parallels with Britain and France’s 1938 surrender of Czechoslovakia to the Nazis are unavoidable. Hegseth has denied that America is “betraying” Ukraine, insisting that “stopping the killing … will require both sides recognizing things they don’t want to.”
But the likely conclusion does not represent an equitable peace. The Kremlin has paid in blood to refine its playbook and measure the West’s endurance. This is not just about Ukraine, because Putin knows now what he could before only guess: that if — or, more likely, when — his territorial ambitions turn towards the Baltic states, Poland, Georgia or any country within what he calls Russia’s “near abroad,” he has a stunning opportunity to assert military dominance over them — or worse.
The U.S. has decided it no longer has a strategic interest or any moral commitment to its allies. After all, if Trump covets Greenland and the Panama Canal, why should Putin be denied a few choice cuts in the great carve-up?
Eliot Wilson is a freelance writer on politics and international affairs and the co-founder of Pivot Point Group. He was senior official in the U.K. House of Commons from 2005 to 2016, including serving as a clerk of the Defence Committee and secretary of the U.K. delegation to the NATO Parliamentary Assembly.
Topics
-
Hegseth rules out NATO membership for Ukraine in peace deal with Russia
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth said Wednesday that he does not believe Ukraine joining NATO is “realistic,” as the Trump administration looks to broker an end to Russia’s war in the country. ...The Hill - Feb. 12 -
Hegseth rules out Ukraine NATO membership in any ceasefire with Russia
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth says the U.S. will no longer be the "primary guarantor of security in Europe," which he said must step up to secure Ukraine.CBS News - Feb. 12 -
Trump-Putin Call Was ‘No Betrayal’ of Ukraine, Hegseth Says
The call has raised concerns among some European leaders that Ukraine could effectively be sidelined in any peace negotiations.The New York Times - Feb. 13 -
The US could sell out Ukraine like France and Britain sold out Czechoslovakia
Appeasement did not deter Hitler, and it will not deter Putin.The Hill - 1h -
Trump says he will speak to Hegseth about his comments on Ukraine
President Trump told reporters he would speak to Pete Hegseth about his comments on the Russia-Ukraine conflict and the criticism the defense secretary has faced from GOP Sen. Roger Wicker.NBC News - 5d -
Trump ices Europe out of Ukraine peace plan
Donald Trump says negotiations on ending the conflict will start ‘immediately’. Will Europe and Ukraine play along?Financial Times - 5d -
Trump says he wants to negotiate about Ukraine. It's not clear if Putin really does
Nearly three years after President Vladimir Putin invaded Ukraine, his troops are making steady progress on the battlefieldABC News - Feb. 8 -
Vance, Rubio scramble to sell Trump's half-formed Ukraine peace plan: ANALYSIS
VP Vance and Secretary of State Rubio are meeting with Ukraine's Zelenskyy.ABC News - 6d -
The heartlessness of the deal: how Trump’s ‘America first’ stance sold out Ukraine
The US president does not care who controls east Ukraine, so long as he can access the rare earth minerals underneath. Europe live: latest news updates from the Munich security conference In ...The Guardian - 6d
More from The Hill
-
2 students arrested for allegedly plotting 'mass casualty attack' at Houston school, FBI says
Two high school students have been arrested for planning what authorities are calling a “mass casualty attack” at a Houston high school.The Hill - 40m -
IRS lays off 6,700 employees, torpedoing Democratic enforcement boost
The IRS fired 6,700 employees on Thursday, a government official told NewsNation, the sister television network of The Hill. The employees were designated as probationary, meaning they were working ...The Hill - 42m -
Trump administration to investigate California high-speed rail project
Federal officials will be investigating California's high-speed rail plans, with the goal of determining if a portion of the project merits $4 billion in taxpayer funds, the Department of ...The Hill - 54m -
Integrating Russia into the Western security framework is key to long-term stability
The West must make a difficult but necessary choice: to work towards a security order that includes, rather than isolates, Russia.The Hill - 1h -
New York sues major vape companies for targeting kids, teens
New York is suing some of the largest vape distributors for allegedly fueling the country’s youth vaping epidemic. New York Attorney General Letitia James announced the lawsuit against 13 major ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
2 students arrested for allegedly plotting 'mass casualty attack' at Houston school, FBI says
Two high school students have been arrested for planning what authorities are calling a “mass casualty attack” at a Houston high school.The Hill - 40m -
IRS lays off 6,700 employees, torpedoing Democratic enforcement boost
The IRS fired 6,700 employees on Thursday, a government official told NewsNation, the sister television network of The Hill. The employees were designated as probationary, meaning they were working ...The Hill - 42m -
Trump administration to investigate California high-speed rail project
Federal officials will be investigating California's high-speed rail plans, with the goal of determining if a portion of the project merits $4 billion in taxpayer funds, the Department of ...The Hill - 54m -
Integrating Russia into the Western security framework is key to long-term stability
The West must make a difficult but necessary choice: to work towards a security order that includes, rather than isolates, Russia.The Hill - 1h -
Senate confirms Kash Patel to lead FBI
Politico - 1h