Has Ukraine just won a timely triumph, or lost due to a tragic delay?
Winston Churchill probably never said that "Americans will always do the right thing, but only after exhausting all other options." Yet this sentiment has been vindicated once again with the recent congressional odyssey surrounding the $60.8 billion aid package for Ukraine.
The package, critical for Ukraine’s ongoing struggle against Russia's full-scale invasion, became ensnared for months in partisan wrangling and procedural delays, reflecting a troubling pattern in U.S. foreign policy. From its isolationist tendencies before World War II to its delayed response to modern global crises, America’s history is punctuated with hesitations that have cost lives and extended conflicts unnecessarily.
The analogy between the current Russo-Ukrainian War and the prelude to America's entry into World War II is both apt and distressing. Before Pearl Harbor, the U.S. grappled with isolationism, embodied by the America First Committee, which vehemently opposed American involvement overseas, even as European democracies fell to Hitler’s blitzkrieg. President Franklin D. Roosevelt faced significant opposition in supporting the Allies but managed to secure the passage of the Lend-Lease Act in March 1941, a crucial pivot from non-intervention to a stance that would eventually lead the U.S. into the war.
On Feb. 8, 1941, the U.S. House of Representatives cast a crucial vote on the Lend-Lease Act, which was pivotal for supporting Britain during World War II. The vote split largely along party lines: 236 Democrats supported the measure, while 135 Republicans voted against it.
Fast forward to today, when the legislative scenario appears strikingly similar. The $61 billion Ukraine aid package passed with substantial support from Democrats — 210 voted in favor. But the Republican vote was divided, with 101 supporting the aid and 112 opposing. This division within Congress not only reflects ongoing partisan dynamics but also the historical challenges faced by lawmakers when deciding on international aid.
These parallels are not just academic; they have real-world implications. Critics of the current aid package to Ukraine might argue that there is significant opposition within Congress, much like during the Lend-Lease debate. However, historical context shows that such divisions are not unprecedented. The scale of opposition faced by Lend-Lease was even more substantial, yet it passed and profoundly affected the course of World War II.
While legislators debated, Ukrainian lives were lost on the front line. Each day’s delay in receiving aid translates directly to more casualties and gives the Russian aggressor a continued advantage. The slow churn of the legislative process, while a feature of democratic governance, becomes a bug during times of urgent crisis.
Moreover, the rhetoric surrounding the aid often hints at a reluctance to fully commit to Ukraine’s defense capabilities. Discussions about what weapons systems to send and in what quantities often come with cautions against provoking Russia further. This hesitancy is not just a logistical matter but a moral one. It sends mixed signals to both allies and adversaries and potentially emboldens further aggression from Moscow.
Despite these frustrations, Ukraine remains profoundly grateful for the support it receives. Every tank, every missile, and every round of ammunition strengthens Ukraine’s ability to defend itself and push back against a brutal invasion that seeks not just territory but the erasure of Ukrainian identity and statehood.
Yet in Kyiv, the gratitude is alloyed with a certain resolve — a determination to remember the lessons of history and the costs of delayed action. Ukraine does not ask for American boots on the ground; it asks for the tools to defend its sovereignty and democratic choice. It is a request for respect and support in a fight not just for national survival but for the principles of international law and human dignity.
The passage of the aid package, though welcome, must not be the end of the story. It should be a prelude to consistent, timely, and unwavering support for Ukraine and the international order’s broader stability. This means not only providing military aid but also strengthening economic ties, supporting post-war recovery, and reinforcing diplomatic efforts to isolate aggressors.
The world, and particularly Ukraine, watches and waits to see if the U.S. will lead with the urgency this moment demands. In the theater of global politics, the U.S. has the opportunity to once again answer history’s call, not out of last-resort necessity but from a proactive commitment to justice and peace.
The congressional saga of Ukraine’s aid package is more than a political victory; it is a test of moral and strategic clarity. Will the U.S. learn from the past, or is it doomed to repeat it?
This aid not only supports Ukraine but also serves as preemptive peacekeeping to deter further Russian aggression, potentially sparing the U.S. from deploying troops to defend NATO allies in the future. It's a strategic investment in global stability, aiming to prevent a larger conflict where the stakes and costs would be significantly higher for the U.S. and its allies.
Maksym Skrypchenko is president of the Transatlantic Dialogue Center.
Date: | |
Tag: | Ukraine |
Topics
Filter
-
Has Wenger finally won the culture war over big money in football?
The Frenchman raged over the game’s super-rich when in charge of Arsenal. His hopes of a more level playing field may come to fruition. For much of the final 14 of his 22 years at Arsenal, Arsène Wenger was a study in frustration. The free thinker ...The Guardian - World -
My property-tax bill spiked 40%. I fought the city — and won. Can I get tax write-offs for my time and costs?
Mad about your property taxes? Join the club.MarketWatch - Business -
Top Boy and Happy Valley triumph at TV Baftas
The final seasons of Top Boy and Happy Valley were among the big winners at the Bafta TV Awards.BBC News - Top stories -
The Rogue Prince Of Persia Has Been Slightly Delayed, Thanks Partly To Hades 2
Prince of Persia fans will have to wait a little longer for the next spin-off to arrive, as Evil Empire has announced that The Rogue Prince of Persia has been slightly delayed beyond its planned May 14 release date. This is partly due to the Dead ...GameSpot - Tech - United Kingdom -
Super Netball scoreboard chaos forces extra-time after 50-minute delay
The Lightning had one-goal win overturned due to score errorThe Giants snatched first victory of season 86-80 in overtimeThe Giants have broken their Super Netball duck with a controversial and chaotic 86-80 overtime win over Sunshine Coast at Ken ...The Guardian - World -
Thousands evacuated due to British Columbia wildfire
Fort McMurray residents in neighbouring Alberta, Canada are also under an evacuation alert due to a blaze.BBC News - Top stories -
Key Bridge controlled demolition postponed due to weather
The controlled demolition of the largest remaining steel span of the collapsed Francis Scott Key Bridge in Baltimore has been postponed because of weather conditions.CBS News - Top stories -
Not the First Time Biden Has Threatened Israel
Menachem Begin’s reply in 1982 should have made clear that Israel will defend itself with or without America’s help.The Wall Street Journal - World - Joe Biden -
The man who took on the coal industry to save a forest - and won
Alok Shukla has spent years fighting to protect a key Indian forest from mining companies.BBC News - Top stories -
Putin replaces long-time defense chief as Russia takes ground in Ukraine
Russia's Vladimir Putin has replaced his minister of defense Sergei Shoigu as he begins his 5th term in office and as his war in Ukraine heats up.CBS News - Top stories - Ukraine
More from The Hill
-
China doesn’t need to invade to achieve Taiwanese unification
China is more likely to pursue a “short of war coercion campaign,” as we call it, centered on political and economic warfare accompanied by limited kinetic action than an invasion of Taiwan for three main reasons:The Hill - Politics - China -
Why Biden isn’t on the November ballot in Ohio — yet
Ohio state legislators are scrambling to get President Biden on the November ballot after members failed to break a legislative impasse this week. State law says presidential candidates need to be certified with the state 90 days before the ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Why Biden is holding back heavy bombs from Israel
The heavy bombs that President Biden has held back from sending to Israel have been a major point of controversy in the Gaza war, as a key tool for Israel’s decimation of the territory. Biden has paused a shipment of some 3,500 bombs, which ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Morning Report — US-Israel relations sour; Cohen testifies today
Seven months into Israel’s war against Hamas in Gaza, relations between Israel and the United States are growing frostier. President Biden and his senior advisers are cautioning Israel against a planned full-scale invasion of the southern Gaza ...The Hill - Politics - Israel -
Federal corruption trial of Sen. Bob Menendez set to start Monday
Sen. Bob Menendez, the three-term New Jersey Democrat who once chaired the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, is set to stand trial on federal bribery and obstruction charges starting Monday. Two New Jersey businessmen who allegedly traded ...The Hill - Politics