Has Jack Smith botched the Trump indictments?
The legal system has utterly failed to disqualify former President Trump from office. Whether he becomes the next president is now anybody’s guess.
Much of the fault may be laid at the feet of special counsel Jack Smith, who has pursued Trump with the zeal of Inspector Javert, but has thus far come up empty handed.
The open-and-shut case involving Trump’s mishandling of the classified Mar-a-Lago documents has been dismissed on unprecedented legal grounds involving Smith’s standing to prosecute him. The Washington case involving Trump’s conspiracy against democracy is back to the start, with Smith losing on immunity in the Supreme Court.
Straining to right a listing ship, Smith has filed a 165-page, procedurally irregular dump of his grand jury materials, containing evidence that Trump cannot refute. The filing obviously flouts the internal Justice Department rule that “Federal prosecutors … may never select the timing of any action, including investigative steps, criminal charges, or statements, for the purpose of affecting any election.”
So Smith has not played it by the book. Veteran prosecutor Elie Honig calls the brief “Smith’s October Cheap Shot.” It is certainly a late hit.
None of the facts in Smith’s submission are game-changing reveals. The narrative is the same as before, with the new details only fleshing out the case under the guise of trying to get around the Supreme Court’s immunity decision. Obviously, the aim is to blacken Trump further on the eve of the election.
We now have new details on Trump’s effort to pressure Vice President Mike Pence to throw the election his way; Trump’s phone use and use of Twitter as the Capitol was attacked; and his conversations with family members about efforts to contest his electoral defeat, ostensibly after he knew he had lost.
Most damning is Trump’s callousness when informed of the peril his vice president encountered at the hands of the mob he unleashed. He posted to Twitter that Pence had lacked the “courage” to do what was right. The mob became enraged, and the Secret Service took Pence to a secure location. Trump’s reaction: “So what?”
What’s sauce for the goose ought to be sauce for the gander. Democrats, justly outraged in 2016 by FBI Director James Comey’s explosive revelation that Hillary Clinton’s emails were found on the laptop of Anthony Weiner, husband of Clinton aide Huma Abedin, on the brink of the election should have a similar reaction to Smith’s filing. Both prosecutors violated the long-standing Justice Department practice not to take investigative steps just before an election. The reasons for the rule not to mix politics with law enforcement are obvious. Neither revelation served any legitimate law enforcement purpose. Smith could have waited a month. There was no hurry.
This was not the only prosecutorial mistake Smith has made. He is a bloodhound who can’t catch the hare. He took more than 2 1/2 years to indict Trump over Jan. 6 in the first place. Did he not think that Trump would make motions, seek delays and throw a monkey wrench into his timetable under the venerable principle that I learned in the U.S. attorney’s office decades ago? “No trial, no conviction.”
Then he brought the slam-dunk Mar-a-Lago documents case in Florida. He could have brought it in Washington. The jury pool in Florida would be favorable to Trump. In 2020, Trump won Florida with 51.2 percent of the vote. In Washington, he won just 5.4 percent. Was Smith nuts?
Florida was the home of Trump-friendly Judge Aileen Cannon, twice rebuked by the 11th Circuit for off-the-wall rulings on the Mar-a-Lago search warrant. Cannon’s bias in favor of Trump was so self-evident that two federal judge colleagues advised her to decline the case when it was assigned to her. Smith bet he could avoid Cannon in Florida, but badly miscalculated the odds. Smith’s chances of landing before Cannon, because of the peculiarity of local rules, were 1 in 3. It was a sucker's bet, and Smith crapped out.
Smith also overprosecuted his case. He did not need to join Trump’s valet, Walt Nauta, and his Mar-a-Lago property manager, Carlos De Oliveira, as co-defendants with Trump. It only complicated discovery and played into Trump’s strategy of delay. Smith should have anticipated that Nauta and De Oliveira would argue with some force for time for document review and discover. The two could have been indicted separately. The evidence against Trump’s agents would have been admissible against Trump in a trial where Trump was the only defendant.
So Smith is left spinning wheels, desperately seeking to save two cases that will obviously be dismissed if Trump is elected. And if Vice President Harris is elected, the cases may go away anyway.
Smith’s clock management has been pathetic. He is just about to hear the final whistle.
James D. Zirin, author and legal analyst, is a former federal prosecutor in New York’s Southern District. He is also the host of the public television talk show and podcast Conversations with Jim Zirin.
Date: | |
Tag: | Donald Trump |
Topics
-
Politics - The Hill
Harris campaign highlights Jack Smith revelations in Trump case in new ad
Vice President Harris’s campaign highlighted Special Counsel Jack Smith’s unsealed filing in an ad new on Monday to argue that former President Trump’s actions on Jan. 6, 2021 were worse than the ...8 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Top stories - CBS News
Supreme Court won't hear dispute involving Jack Smith and Trump's X data
Special counsel Jack Smith obtained in January 2023 a court-authorized warrant for information associated with former President Donald Trump's X account as part of its election interference probe.7 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Supreme Court won’t take up challenge to Jack Smith’s Trump Twitter data access
The Supreme Court on Monday declined to take up a challenge by social platform X, formerly known as Twitter, to court rulings that forced the platform to turn over data on former President Trump’s ...7 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Lifestyle - The New York Times
Maggie Smith’s Face Has Something to Teach Us
Age is the ultimate luxury.4 hours ago -
Sports - CBS Sports
Cowboys' Tyler Smith has hilarious, NSFW reaction to Jalen Tolbert's game-winning TD catch vs. Steelers
Tolbert stepped up to produce best game of his career, catch the game-winning TD after getting the wind knocked out out of him4 hours ago - NFL -
Politics - The Hill
Trump: Israel has to 'get smart' about supporting him
Former President Trump said Monday Israel has to “get smart” about supporting him and suggested Jewish people have not adequately backed him after he took several pro-Israel actions while in ...4 hours ago - Israel
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
White House, Fox News' Peter Doocy spar over Helene response
White House press secretary Karine Jean Pierre and Fox News reporter Peter Doocy sparred on Monday over the Biden administration's response to the damage and destruction wrought by Hurricane ...35 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Sen. Rubio: Milton looks 'almost identical' to worst-case storm scenario for Florida
Florida Sen. Marco Rubio (R) said Monday that Hurricane Milton looks “almost identical” to a worst-case storm scenario presented to him for the Sunshine State. “Several years ago I asked [the ...44 minutes ago - Florida -
Politics - The Hill
Al Pacino claims he almost died of COVID: 'I was gone'
During a podcast appearance on The New York Times’ “The Interview," Al Pacino claims he once nearly died of COVID.48 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Costco gold bars are selling out as prices for the precious metal break records: Survey
Move over, gas and hot dogs. Costco shoppers are snatching up the store's 1-ounce gold bars despite the market's lofty price for the precious metal.1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
FTC antitrust case against Amazon moves forward, several state claims dismissed
The Federal Trade Commission’s (FTC) antitrust case against Amazon will move forward, but several state claims against the e-commerce giant were dismissed, according to a newly unsealed ruling. In ...1 hour ago