Harris’s tax cut plan shows how startup costs cripple entrepreneurs
Kamala Harris announced her latest economic proposal last week — an increase in the maximum up-front tax deduction for new business startups to $50,000.
This higher deduction is intended to offset the costs that entrepreneurs face in their first year of operation. Those costs, according to widely cited research by Shopify, can climb to $40,000 when accounting for everything from product and shipping costs to staff payroll and marketing.
While the debate around Harris’s proposal will likely center around the question of “Is this tax deduction a good idea,” it might be more productive to ask two questions: “How did we get to that $40,000 figure in the first place? And can government do anything to bring that number down?”
It turns out that’s a question many cities and states are finally beginning to ask, as the cost, complexity and frustration of the licensing, permitting and inspection processes at the state and local level continue to climb for new small businesses.
The Cities Work project — a nonpartisan project that helps cities streamline their business startup process that is part of my organization — found that starting a small mom-and-pop restaurant in one of 20 cities across the country could cost more than $5,000 in permit and license fees alone, a number that jumps to more than $20,000 in cities like San Francisco.
A barbershop can require an average of 55 different regulatory steps, spread across eight different government agencies — and that’s assuming the entrepreneur can get through the process without making any mistakes or redoing any of the required paperwork.
Shopify’s research found that nearly a quarter of all small business startups cite these types of license and permit fees as “unexpectedly costly,” expressing surprise at often duplicative requirements between different levels of government red tape.
Those are costs that entrepreneurs often have a difficult time anticipating or budgeting for, as few cities are able or willing to lay out the process in full before business owners begin applying for permits, leading many to abandon the process midway through as fees add up or delays lead to more rent costs without any revenue to offset them.
As one entrepreneur from Kansas City put it, “Over a year-and-a-half of me going to City Hall and not taking no (for an answer). Imagine how many people stopped at the no. We lost so many (small businesses) because of that initial no.”
The good news is that there are policy solutions to these challenges that local and state governments can enact without waiting for a new tax bill to get through Congress.
This year, Washington, D.C. funded the BEST Act, a law that cut duplicative and unnecessary business license categories, reduced high licensing fees and eliminated fees for new businesses with less than $10,000 in revenue their first year.
But progress elsewhere can be slow.
In Maryland, a bipartisan coalition of state representatives introduced a bill earlier this year that would have cut first-year filing fees for some businesses entirely. It died in committee. And a 2023 Nevada bill that would have waived veteran-owned businesses’ licensing fees for their first five years of operation never even got a hearing.
Reforms like these often force policymakers to make a sacrifice in the short term (lost revenue from reduced license and permit fees) to benefit everyone in the long term (through increased entrepreneurship, economic opportunity and more tax revenue). But the evidence we’ve seen from previous reforms suggests it’s a sacrifice worth making.
In 2012, Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel launched a massive business licensing reform effort that eliminated license types by 60 percent, saving businesses $2 million. At the time, Chicago was considered an outlier even among large cities with intense licensing requirements with 117 types of licenses.
More reforms followed in 2017, and a Harvard case study found the efforts “resulted in dramatic improvements to the regulatory process for small businesses and entrepreneurs and a significant improvement in the business climate.
And despite short-lived dips in licensing revenue in 2013 and business tax revenue in 2014, Chicago quickly recovered and appeared to be holding steady well above pre-licensing reform years until 2020 when the COVID-19 pandemic disrupted the global economy. In fact, revenues were already bouncing back as of 2022, and just two to three years after Emanuel’s initial reform efforts, licensing revenue was already higher than in pre-reform years.
When it comes to helping the country’s entrepreneurs, particularly those starting small or micro businesses, city officials don’t have to wait around for an act of Congress or a presidential election to save the day.
They have the power to make it cheaper, faster and simpler to start a new business in America today. Streamlining outdated, costly and duplicative regulatory burdens is the first step.
Chad Reese is the associate director of activism at the Institute for Justice.
Date: |
Topics
-
World - The Guardian
Kemi Badenoch’s maternity pay comments show how ‘hopelessly out of touch’ Tories are, TUC says – UK politics live
Leadership rivals Jenrick, Cleverly and Tugendhat reject her comments, as row over her ‘excessive’ claim escalates. Q: Do you agree with Kemi Badenoch that some cultures are less valid than ...2 hours ago - United Kingdom -
Politics - The Hill
An American Marshall Plan for Haiti
Haitians deserve the freedom, dignity and respect that comes with a secure and prosperous nation.1 hour ago -
Business - Inc.
5 Tips Entrepreneurs Needs to Find the Right Business Coach
You can grow personally and professionally if you take the time to identify what you need and who can best help.6 hours ago -
Top stories - The New York Times
Studying at an English-Speaking University? In Quebec, That May Cost Extra.
Quebec says a new policy to charge some students higher tuition at top universities in Montreal is needed to preserve the province’s French identity.34 minutes ago -
Business - MarketWatch
Stock-market rally faces crucial question: Will jobs data back case for big Fed rate cuts?
Stock-market investors got what they wanted when the Federal Reserve delivered an extra-large September rate cut — the risk now is that strong jobs data in the week ahead could be too much of a ...3 hours ago - Federal Reserve -
Business - Financial Times
Birdlife threat blows Scotland’s offshore wind plans off course
Energy giant says delays in receiving consent are barrier to progress as politicians and campaigners warn of environmental impacts15 hours ago -
World - Financial Times
Will the US jobs report show signs of economic recovery?
Market Questions is the FT’s guide to the week ahead8 hours ago -
Lifestyle - The New York Times
Loewe and Courrèges Show What to Wear Next
A brilliant Loewe collection, some good ideas from Courrèges and Junya Watanabe, and a step forward at Alexander McQueen.10 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
To save Georgian democracy, Biden should sanction the country's oligarchs
The U.S. has imposed new sanctions on the Georgian government and ruling party, but they do not go far enough to target the oligarch Bidzina Ivanishvili, who has been accused of authoritarian and ...24 minutes ago - Joe Biden -
Politics - The Hill
Kirby: ‘State Department does not feel a need for’ American evacuations from Israel, Lebanon
White House national security communications adviser John Kirby said in a Sunday interview that the “State Department does not feel a need for” evacuations from Israel and Lebanon. “And if the ...32 minutes ago - Israel -
Politics - The Hill
Pompeo says US wrong to seek cease-fire, Israel should ‘finish the job’
Former Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said it’s wrong for the United States to seek a cease-fire between Israel and Hamas and instead should tell Israel to “finish the job.” “We should be saying ...48 minutes ago - Israel -
Politics - The Hill
Coons 'glad' Zelensky, Trump met but said it was a 'strikingly awkward moment'
Sen. Chris Coons (D-Del.) said he was glad former President Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky met but noted there was a “strikingly awkward moment” when Trump mentioned Russian ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Mark Kelly: IDF sent 'powerful message' to Hezbollah with death of leader
Sen. Mark Kelly (D-Ariz.) said the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) sent the Iranian-backed Lebanese militant group Hezbollah a “powerful message” with the death of its leader. “Well, I think the IDF ...1 hour ago