Harris-backed filibuster change would ‘break’ the Senate, McConnell says
Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell lambasted a proposal from Vice President Kamala Harris that would eliminate the filibuster to pass abortion rights legislation — warning Democrats that they will rue the move when Republicans next control Washington.
“What they want to do is break the institution in order to achieve what they want to achieve,” he said in an interview Thursday.
McConnell spoke two days after Harris told Wisconsin Public Radio that “we should eliminate the filibuster for Roe” — in other words, changing the Senate’s rules to exempt a vote to restore the abortion rights guarantee under Roe v. Wade from the chamber’s usual 60-vote threshold for legislation.
Such a scenario would be likely only if Harris wins the presidency and Democrats keep the Senate and retake the House majority — currently a tall order for a party facing a tough Senate map. Notably, two former Democrats who blocked prior attempts to undermine the 60-vote rule — Sens. Joe Manchin (I-W.Va.) and Kyrsten Sinema (I-Ariz.) — are retiring.
But McConnell, delivering some of his most pointed and substantial criticism of a Harris proposal since she became a presidential candidate, said that the proposal would spell the end of the filibuster altogether, explaining that her suggested exemption for Roe would put the chamber down a steep and slippery slope.
“There's no way you can have a minor carve-out” for one issue, he said. “Because then you’ll come up with the next idea that’s more important than the rule — then, practically, it’s over.”
Democrats last tried to break the filibuster to pass voting rights legislation in the early years of President Joe Biden’s administration, when they had control of both the House and Senate. Manchin and Sinema’s opposition tanked that effort, but the 2022 Supreme Court ruling overturning Dobbs focused new attention on the rule — with Harris, a former senator, joining many other Democrats in backing filibuster changes in the immediate aftermath of the decision.
Such a move, Harris said Tuesday, would “get us to the point where 51 votes would be what we need to actually put back in law the protections for reproductive freedom and for the ability of every person and every woman to make decisions about their own body and not have their government tell them what to do.”
McConnell said that would permanently change the nature of the Senate, for the worse.
While at least some presidential nominations have been exempt from the filibuster for more than a decade, doing the same for legislation is a "totally different matter, he said: “The Senate was designed to do one of two things: Kill bad stuff or force a reasonable compromise — and that's what it's done all along.”
The Harris campaign did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
McConnell warned that if they adjusted the filibuster rules Democrats would then use simple-majority votes to entrench their power by admitting D.C. and Puerto Rico as states, likely adding four additional Democratic senators. “Then,” he said, they’ll “go after the Supreme Court.”
“So it would fundamentally, in my view, turn America to California,” he continued. “And I think that is a major structural change to the country.”
McConnell has long been a fierce defender of the Senate’s legislative filibuster, withstanding public pressure to change the rules during Donald Trump’s presidency and then openly encouraging Manchin and Sinema as they stood athwart their fellow Democrats’ recent push.
If Democrats do go nuclear, McConnell said Thursday, Republicans will also take advantage of the new system: “They never think about what might happen when the shoe is on the other foot.”
Asked what bills Republicans would pass without the filibuster, McConnell said, “I don't know, but I'm sure they wouldn't like it.”
Over the past decade, a similar dynamic played out over the use of the filibuster for Senate confirmations. In 2013, McConnell cautioned then-Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) not to break the filibuster for lower-level court nominations, which Republicans had been blocking.
“You’ll regret this, and you may regret this a lot sooner than you think,” McConnell said at the time.
When Republicans took the chamber a few years later, McConnell cited Reid’s rule change to justify going nuclear for Supreme Court nominations — helping Trump confirm three conservative justices in what’s become the most sweeping overhaul to the court in a generation.
Asked if he has any regrets about that move, McConnell said he did not.
“I said to my members, if a candidate like [Neil] Gorsuch — who is so obviously totally qualified — can't get 60 votes, there's nobody we can pick that we're comfortable with that can get confirmed,” he said. “And so we lowered the threshold for the Supreme Court.”
Like this content? Sign up for POLITICO's Playbook newsletter.
Date: |
-
Top stories - CBS News
How climate change is impacting fall foliage
Climate change affects the conditions that trigger tree leaves to change colors in autumn. CBS News climate correspondent Dave Malkoff explains the factors that contribute to fall foliage.54 minutes ago - Climate -
Top stories - BBC News
Losing children's ward would be 'devastating'
Families say they are worried following plans to reduce the number of beds on a children's ward3 hours ago -
World - The New York Times
Gender Identity Changes Must Be Recognized Across E.U. Borders, Court Rules
A man who changed his name and gender identity in Britain successfully challenged to have them legally recognized by Romania. “I’m representing everyone who is affected.”7 hours ago -
Business - Inc.
Senators Seek Harsher Crackdown Against Boeing Executives
Democratic Sens. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts and Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut want the Justice Department to hold former Boeing leaders criminally liable for safety faults.8 hours ago -
Sports - CBS Sports
NFL could soon be making another rule change involving the new kickoff: Here's what Roger Goodell had to say
The NFL commissioner sounds pretty convinced that the new kickoff rule is going to undergo at least one change9 hours ago - NFL -
Business - CNBC
CVS is under pressure and considering a breakup. Here's why that could be risky
A breakup would be a stunning reversal for CVS, which has spent tens of billions of dollars on acquisitions to turn itself into a one-stop health destination.10 hours ago -
Business - Financial Times
Fifa rules on player transfers break EU law, says top court
Verdict in favour of Lassana Diarra could disrupt multibillion-dollar transfer market that underpins European game10 hours ago - European Union -
World - The Guardian
Eddie Howe says Newcastle leaving St James’ Park would feel like a betrayal
Owners to decide whether to expand or build new ground ‘We would be losing something special,’ says manager Eddie Howe has indicated a preference for Newcastle remaining at St James’ Park rather ...10 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Rosh Hashanah: An opportunity for change in the Middle East
This Rosh Hashanah, let us take bold steps forward, recognizing that lasting change is not just possible — it is imperative.10 hours ago -
World - The Guardian
Football Daily | Lassana Diarra and the day transfers (possibly) changed forever, yeah?
Sign up now! Sign up now! Sign up now? Sign up now! . “The day the world changed, yeah?” So said honorary Guardianista Nathan Barley as he flaunted his Geek Pie haircut on the streets of east ...11 hours ago -
Tech - GameSpot
Ubisoft Is Reportedly Considering A Major Change To Its Structure
Ubisoft and Tencent are reportedly considering different options in order to stabilize the business and prevent further stock-price drops.. According to Bloomberg , Ubisoft's Guillemot family and ...11 hours ago -
Top stories - CBS News
Breaking down the verdict in the Tyre Nichols case
A jury on Thursday delivered a mixed verdict for the three former police officers in the fatal beating of Tyre Nichols. All of them were convicted of witness tampering related to the cover-up, but ...12 hours ago -
Top stories - BBC News
Will carbon capture help the UK tackle climate change?
Will the plan announced today make a difference to the planet and is it worth the huge price tag?12 hours ago - United Kingdom -
Politics - The Hill
The Ships for America Act would be good for the Navy as well
It is hardly a secret that the U.S. Navy’s shipbuilding program is in the doldrums.13 hours ago -
Sports - ESPN
Saints' Carr would welcome reunion with Adams
Saints quarterback Derek Carr said he would love the chance to play with former teammate Davante Adams again.20 hours ago -
World - The Wall Street Journal
Nightmares of a Chinese Invasion Inspire Taboo-Breaking Entertainment in Taiwan
Through TV, books and a board game, the island’s entertainment industry is embracing a topic it avoided for decades.21 hours ago -
World - Financial Times
Pension tax breaks: what’s in the Budget firing line?
Analysts lay out the range of options at the chancellor’s disposal as Starmer warns of ‘decisions’ on the horizon21 hours ago -
Business - Financial Times
Pension tax breaks: what’s in the Budget line of fire?
Analysts lay out the range of options at the chancellor’s disposal as Starmer warns of ‘decisions’ on the horizon21 hours ago -
Lifestyle - The New York Times
A Welcome Break on ‘One of the Hardest Days’ of Her Life
Mary Kathryn Burke was ready for a drink after her mother was admitted to the hospital. Jonathan King messaged her at the right time.21 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Boris Johnson says Trump presidency would have prevented Ukraine invasion
Former British Prime Minister Boris Johnson suggested that Donald Trump's presidency would have prevented Russia from invading Ukraine in 2022. Johnson said that Ukraine’s resistance is ...Yesterday - Ukraine -
Top stories - CBS News
Trump-backed mass deportations would cost billions, report says
Former President Donald Trump has long shared plans for mass deportations if he returns to office, but how much would that cost? A new report from the American Immigration Council has some ...Yesterday - Donald Trump -
Tech - VentureBeat
XenTag: Changing the game for collectible products
CONTRIBUTOR CONTENT: XenTag is providing brands and creators with a unique solution to break creative barriers and introduce superior, limited-edition products into their product lines. After ten ...Yesterday -
Business - Inc.
Student Loan Forgiveness Gets a Major Break from Federal Judge
U.S. District Judge J. Randal Hall ruled that Georgia failed to show it would be harmed by student loan forgiveness.Yesterday -
World - ABC News
Kosovo's leader says Russia prevailing in Ukraine would threaten 25 years of peace in the Balkans
Kosovo's prime minister says that the Balkan region has enjoyed the greatest degree of peace, freedom and democracy in its history in the past 25 yearsYesterday - Ukraine -
Sports - The New York Times
Michael Jordan Is Suing NASCAR. It Could Change the Sport Forever.
If successful, Jordan would be credited with something that was recently unthinkable, a columnist for The Athletic writes.Yesterday -
Politics - The Hill
Van Jones: Melania Trump breaking with GOP on abortion 'bizarre'
CNN political commentator Van Jones in an interview Thursday called a video from former first lady Melania Trump in which she appears to take a stance in favor of abortion rights "bizarre." "This ...Yesterday - Donald Trump -
Entertainment - Los Angeles Times
NOFX aren't breaking up, they're retiring — and it's probably for the best for everyone involved
Singer Fat Mike Burkett says it is time for the band to call it quits, but not before playing three final L.A.-area shows this weekend.Yesterday -
Business - Financial Times
JD Vance ‘crazy’ for refusing to accept 2020 election result, Republican Senate candidate says
Larry Hogan fears the party’s candidates for Congress could lose because of Trump’s divisive rhetoricYesterday -
Tech - Wired
OpenAI’s ChatGPT Breaks Out of Its Box—and Onto a Canvas
ChatGPT’s new canvas interface can suggest improvements to writing and code as well as make in-line changes.Yesterday -
World - The Guardian
What atrocity would Israel have to commit for our leaders to break their silence? | Owen Jones
To avenge 7 October, crimes of all kinds are condoned. But politicians should take note: the British public disagrees. Consider these two parallel universes. One is Gaza, the scene of some of the ...Yesterday - Israel -
Top stories - CBS News
Hurricane Helene relief funding up in the air with Congress in break
Federal relief funds for recovery from Helene are in limbo with Congress still in recess. President Biden is pushing for lawmakers to regroup soon as many in the Southeast struggle without power ...Yesterday -
Top stories - The New York Times
Trump Says He Would Try Again to Revoke Haitian Immigrants’ Protections
He again disparaged Haitians in Springfield, Ohio, and said he would end their legal status in the country and send them back. His first attempt to do that failed.Yesterday - Donald Trump -
Sports - The New York Times
Can a New Knicks Star Change the Balance of Power in the N.B.A.?
The Boston Celtics are the reigning champions, but no team had a louder offseason than the Knicks, a columnist for The Athletic writes.Yesterday -
Sports - CBS Sports
Panthers' Andy Dalton says friendship with Bryce Young has grown since QB change, thankful for his support
Carolina's offense has been more productive with Dalton under centerYesterday - NFL -
World - Yahoo News
KLM plans changes to lower costs, improve operating results
Yesterday -
World - The Guardian
The Lassana Diarra case: what is it and will it change football like Bosman?
A court verdict could lead to players walking out on contracts without their clubs being compensated. The court of justice of the European Union (CJEU) will deliver a verdict on Friday in the case ...Yesterday -
Politics - Politico
Senate Democrats are suddenly extremely interested in Texas and Florida
September 25 - Florida -
Politics - Politico
Senate passes bill boosting security for presidential nominees
September 24
More from Politico
-
Politics - Politico
Supreme Court to take up Mexico’s lawsuit against US gunmakers
Mexico alleges that gunmakers have contributed to drug cartel violence.9 hours ago -
Politics - Politico
Capitol police chief: New intel bureau is key as Congress threats rise
Yesterday -
Politics - Politico
Johnson slams Biden-Harris admin for ‘hypocritical’ Israel stance
The Republican speaker said the administration’s “weak” foreign policy contributed to escalating violence in the Middle East on Tuesday.3 days ago - Israel -
Politics - Politico
Biden: Congress 'may have to' come back to approve Helene relief
4 days ago - Joe Biden -
Politics - Politico
Rubio defends Trump's approach to Russia-Ukraine war
“I'm not on Russia's side — but unfortunately the reality of it is that the way the war in Ukraine is going to end is with a negotiated settlement,” he said.5 days ago - Donald Trump