Harris-backed filibuster change would ‘break’ the Senate, McConnell says
Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell lambasted a proposal from Vice President Kamala Harris that would eliminate the filibuster to pass abortion rights legislation — warning Democrats that they will rue the move when Republicans next control Washington.
“What they want to do is break the institution in order to achieve what they want to achieve,” he said in an interview Thursday.
McConnell spoke two days after Harris told Wisconsin Public Radio that “we should eliminate the filibuster for Roe” — in other words, changing the Senate’s rules to exempt a vote to restore the abortion rights guarantee under Roe v. Wade from the chamber’s usual 60-vote threshold for legislation.
Such a scenario would be likely only if Harris wins the presidency and Democrats keep the Senate and retake the House majority — currently a tall order for a party facing a tough Senate map. Notably, two former Democrats who blocked prior attempts to undermine the 60-vote rule — Sens. Joe Manchin (I-W.Va.) and Kyrsten Sinema (I-Ariz.) — are retiring.
But McConnell, delivering some of his most pointed and substantial criticism of a Harris proposal since she became a presidential candidate, said that the proposal would spell the end of the filibuster altogether, explaining that her suggested exemption for Roe would put the chamber down a steep and slippery slope.
“There's no way you can have a minor carve-out” for one issue, he said. “Because then you’ll come up with the next idea that’s more important than the rule — then, practically, it’s over.”
Democrats last tried to break the filibuster to pass voting rights legislation in the early years of President Joe Biden’s administration, when they had control of both the House and Senate. Manchin and Sinema’s opposition tanked that effort, but the 2022 Supreme Court ruling overturning Dobbs focused new attention on the rule — with Harris, a former senator, joining many other Democrats in backing filibuster changes in the immediate aftermath of the decision.
Such a move, Harris said Tuesday, would “get us to the point where 51 votes would be what we need to actually put back in law the protections for reproductive freedom and for the ability of every person and every woman to make decisions about their own body and not have their government tell them what to do.”
McConnell said that would permanently change the nature of the Senate, for the worse.
While at least some presidential nominations have been exempt from the filibuster for more than a decade, doing the same for legislation is a "totally different matter, he said: “The Senate was designed to do one of two things: Kill bad stuff or force a reasonable compromise — and that's what it's done all along.”
The Harris campaign did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
McConnell warned that if they adjusted the filibuster rules Democrats would then use simple-majority votes to entrench their power by admitting D.C. and Puerto Rico as states, likely adding four additional Democratic senators. “Then,” he said, they’ll “go after the Supreme Court.”
“So it would fundamentally, in my view, turn America to California,” he continued. “And I think that is a major structural change to the country.”
McConnell has long been a fierce defender of the Senate’s legislative filibuster, withstanding public pressure to change the rules during Donald Trump’s presidency and then openly encouraging Manchin and Sinema as they stood athwart their fellow Democrats’ recent push.
If Democrats do go nuclear, McConnell said Thursday, Republicans will also take advantage of the new system: “They never think about what might happen when the shoe is on the other foot.”
Asked what bills Republicans would pass without the filibuster, McConnell said, “I don't know, but I'm sure they wouldn't like it.”
Over the past decade, a similar dynamic played out over the use of the filibuster for Senate confirmations. In 2013, McConnell cautioned then-Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) not to break the filibuster for lower-level court nominations, which Republicans had been blocking.
“You’ll regret this, and you may regret this a lot sooner than you think,” McConnell said at the time.
When Republicans took the chamber a few years later, McConnell cited Reid’s rule change to justify going nuclear for Supreme Court nominations — helping Trump confirm three conservative justices in what’s become the most sweeping overhaul to the court in a generation.
Asked if he has any regrets about that move, McConnell said he did not.
“I said to my members, if a candidate like [Neil] Gorsuch — who is so obviously totally qualified — can't get 60 votes, there's nobody we can pick that we're comfortable with that can get confirmed,” he said. “And so we lowered the threshold for the Supreme Court.”
Like this content? Sign up for POLITICO's Playbook newsletter.
Date: |
Topics
-
Top stories - BBC News
Girl told schoolmates she'd stab teacher - court
The teenager previously admitted the triple stabbing, but denies attempted murder.2 minutes ago -
Top stories - BBC News
Policeman feared Chris Kaba would kill, court told
A Met Police marksman is accused of the murder of Chris Kaba who was shot in a car in south London.45 minutes ago -
Business - MarketWatch
Why the ‘debasement trade’ lifting bitcoin and gold may continue, says JPMorgan
The financial alternatives to the dollar may have further room to run, says a JPMorgan team.50 minutes ago -
Business - MarketWatch
Eli Lilly’s weight-loss and diabetes drugs are no longer in shortage, says FDA
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration said Eli Lilly’s diabetes and weight-loss drugs marketed as Zepbound and Mounjaro are no longer in shortage signaling that the company has succeeded in ...52 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Democratic senator worried Netanyahu trying to 'influence' U.S. election
Sen. Chris Murphy (D-Conn.) says he’s worried that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu may be trying to influence the U.S. presidential election by showing little interest in striking a peace ...56 minutes ago -
Business - MarketWatch
This shipping stock is ‘in an enviable position’ for a protracted port strike, says analyst
While a prolonged strike at East Coast and Gulf ports would spell bad news for the U.S. economy, it could provide a boost to shipping company Global Ship Lease Inc., according to Liam ...1 hour ago -
World - Yahoo News
Scholz says more eastern Germans should hold top jobs in companies
1 hour ago -
Top stories - BBC News
Interest rates cuts could be more aggressive, Bank of England governor says
Governor Andrew Bailey hints that borrowing costs could come down faster if inflation stays in line.1 hour ago -
World - The Guardian
Melania Trump says she forced Donald to drop hardline immigration policy
Ex-first lady says she told Trump to stop separating children from parents and addresses jacket controversy in book. Melania Trump describes in her new memoir how she made her husband, then ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
World - Yahoo News
Never forget negative aspects of German reunification, says Scholz
1 hour ago - Germany -
Top stories - BBC News
Around-the-world cruise still waiting to say 'au revoir' to Belfast
Villa Vie Residences' Odyssey set sail on Monday but it has yet to leave Northern Ireland waters.1 hour ago -
Business - MarketWatch
European car makers have hit a low point, Barclays says
Barclays analysts said the problems facing European car makers in China have been factored in, meaning they could now be set for a rebound1 hour ago - Europe -
Top stories - NBC News
Special counsel says Trump ‘resorted to crimes’ to stay in office
In a new court filing special counsel Jack Smith is detailing new evidence in the case against Donald Trump, saying the former president “resorted to crimes” to stay in office after his 2020 loss ...2 hours ago - Donald Trump -
World - Yahoo News
Three Hamas leaders killed months ago, IDF says
2 hours ago -
World - The Guardian
The Lassana Diarra case: what is it and will it change football like Bosman?
A court verdict could lead to players walking out on contracts without their clubs being compensated. The court of justice of the European Union (CJEU) will deliver a verdict on Friday in the case ...4 hours ago -
World - The Guardian
Starmer repaid freebies to restore trust in politics, minister says
Sarah Jones suggests PM believes he should be held to higher standards now he is in government. UK politics live – latest updates Keir Starmer has repaid thousands of pounds in freebies to ...4 hours ago -
Tech - ABC News
World ski body and UN weather agency team up to help winter sports plan for climate change
Winter sports are facing a long-time crisis because of climate change and the International Ski and Snowboard Federation has teamed up with the United Nations weather agency4 hours ago - Climate -
Tech - The Wall Street Journal
SoftBank's Son Says Artificial General Intelligence to Be Achieved in a Few Years
SoftBank Group Chief Executive Masayoshi Son said he believed artificial general intelligence, in which computers have human-level cognitive abilities, would be achieved in two to three years.4 hours ago -
Business - Financial Times
UK consumers in ‘good shape’ ahead of Christmas, says Tesco boss
Britain’s biggest supermarket chain raises profit outlook on rise in sales as inflation eases5 hours ago - United Kingdom -
Politics - CBS News
Harris says she won't ban fracking
Vice President Kamala Harris said she won't ban fracking natural gas.15 hours ago - Kamala Harris -
Top stories - The New York Times
How the VP Candidates Talked About Climate Change
Tim Walz said climate change is real, but boasted about high U.S. levels of oil and gas production. JD Vance called climate change “weird science.”18 hours ago - Climate -
Top stories - NBC News
Vance's high-risk pool health insurance plan: Would it help or harm sick patients?
What are high-risk pools for health insurance? JD Vance proposed high risk pools for people with pre-existing conditions during the vice presidential debate.18 hours ago -
Politics - NBC News
Vance's high-risk pool health insurance plan: Would it help or harm sick patients?
What are high-risk pools for health insurance? JD Vance proposed high risk pools for people with pre-existing conditions during the vice presidential debate.18 hours ago -
Politics - NBC News
Trump says crime is out of control. The numbers tell a different story.
Donald Trump says crime is rising. But several years of national data tell the opposite story: Crime is falling in cities and towns across the United States.21 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - CBS News
Trump says he would veto a federal abortion ban
Former President Donald Trump posted to social media during the vice presidential debate that he would not support a federal abortion ban.Yesterday - Donald Trump -
Entertainment - CBS News
Coldplay on their record-breaking world tour: "We're having such a great time"
During a stop on their "Music of the Spheres" global tour, which Billboard calls "the biggest rock tour of all time," Chris Martin, Will Champion, Guy Berryman and Jonny Buckland talk about their ...3 days ago -
Entertainment - CBS News
Coldplay on their record-breaking world tour
Twenty-five years after their first hit record, Coldplay's current world tour, which Billboard calls "the biggest rock tour of all time," has earned more than a billion dollars and sold more than ...3 days ago -
Health - The New York Times
Acadia Healthcare Says It Faces New Federal Investigations
Shares of the company, one of the largest chains of for-profit psychiatric hospitals, were down 25 percent at one point.5 days ago -
Politics - Politico
Gaetz says he will no longer voluntarily cooperate with House Ethics probe
6 days ago -
Politics - Politico
AOC says Eric Adams should resign
6 days ago -
Politics - Politico
Senate Democrats are suddenly extremely interested in Texas and Florida
September 25 - Florida -
Politics - Politico
‘A perfect storm of stunning failure’: Senate probe finds huge Secret Service errors at Trump rally
September 25 - Donald Trump -
Politics - Politico
Senate strikes agreement to clear funding patch on Wednesday to thwart government shutdown
September 24 -
Politics - Politico
Senate passes bill boosting security for presidential nominees
September 24
More from Politico
-
Politics - Politico
Johnson slams Biden-Harris admin for ‘hypocritical’ Israel stance
The Republican speaker said the administration’s “weak” foreign policy contributed to escalating violence in the Middle East on Tuesday.Yesterday - Israel -
Politics - Politico
Rubio defends Trump's approach to Russia-Ukraine war
“I'm not on Russia's side — but unfortunately the reality of it is that the way the war in Ukraine is going to end is with a negotiated settlement,” he said.3 days ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - Politico
Opponent of Rep. Anna Paulina Luna charged with threatening her in 2022 primary
Candidate claimed in a recorded call with an activist that he would send a Russian and Ukrainian hit squad to kill her.5 days ago -
Politics - Politico
Senior House Dem joins calls for Eric Adams to resign
5 days ago -
Politics - Politico
Republicans have a message for Zelenskyy: Stay out of US politics
Trump’s allies on the Hill and beyond are sensitive to any perceived slights against the former president.6 days ago - Republican Party