Harris should promise to elevate FEMA head to Cabinet
With Hurricane Milton making landfall in Florida, as the nation is still embroiled in intense relief efforts for victims of Hurricane Helene, concern over a lack of resources at the Federal Emergency Management Administration has become a critical point of discussion. To make a long story short, FEMA has been denied important resources both recently and in decades past, making post-hurricane federal relief a long-standing national weakness.
The single best thing to improve disaster response would be to reorganize FEMA into its own federal department (currently it sits within the Department of Homeland Security), substantially increase its funding and bring on additional personnel. The increased resourcing is mostly a congressional matter, which sadly makes it less plausible, especially given congressional Republicans recent balking at additional FEMA funding on both the eve of and in the immediate aftermath of Helene.
However, some of the important organizational improvements could be made through executive action. While the establishment of federal departments happens via legislation, the creation and restructuring of some federal agencies is a power of the president. Some are still created by acts of Congress, but others, like the Environmental Protection Agency, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and FEMA were created by executive order, which means that the president can (generally, with limitations) move those to a different department, make them independent (a la the EPA), change who their lead reports to, and adjust their missions.
President Biden could attempt such a change now, but reorganizing FEMA in the middle of hurricane season seems like inviting trouble. But FEMA can’t be allowed to continue to wallow in the back of public consciousness — the next president needs to take a hard look at this. There’s little hope that Trump, who talks abut nuking hurricanes, would have any interest in such minutiae, but Vice President Kamala Harris should; in addition to being good policy innovation, it would bring immense political upside.
One part of Project 2025 calls for the dismantling of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (which includes the National Weather Service and National Hurricane Center) and another calls for gutting FEMA’s resources. Now is the best time to champion a different vision.
Harris could call out Project 2025 by proposing a merger between FEMA and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration into an independent administration, making its head a Cabinet member, and giving it increased resources. The FEMA director has been elevated to a cabinet-level post once before: under President Clinton in 1996. Even that relatively small step could make a huge difference.
As it currently stands, Cabinet meetings often lack a dedicated voice on matters of emergency management. Updates about FEMA pass through the secretary of Homeland Security, who typically has a more law-enforcement oriented background. Elevating the director to Cabinet level would give him or her a more direct line to the president, more public visibility and more weight when he or she asks Congress for money. This is why emergency managers urged President Obama to move FEMA out of DHS and make the director Cabinet level.
The symbolism also matters, as elevating the director to the Cabinet would establish what a priority FEMA and its work have. For Harris, it creates the opening to say “they want to take away the tools FEMA has to help people hit by disaster, but I want to give them more tools, a bigger voice in my administration, and more prominence.”
Treating natural disasters that are worsening due to climate change means giving experts a real voice and real power. Good policy, good politics — that is, if the Harris camp is open to it.
Dylan Gyauch-Lewis is a senior researcher at the Revolving Door Project. She leads RDP’s Economic Media Project.
Date: | |
Tag: | Kamala Harris |
-
Politics - The Hill
FEMA head: Volume of misinformation 'starting to go down'
Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) Administrator Deanne Criswell said the volume of misinformation surrounding Hurricane Helene and Hurricane Milton is starting to drop. “We're still seeing ...Yesterday -
World - The New York Times
Israel’s Security Cabinet to Meet to Discuss Response to Iran Attack
The cabinet was expected to authorize Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Yoav Gallant, the defense minister, to initiate a retaliatory attack at their discretion, officials said.4 hours ago - Israel -
Business - Inc.
Trump Promises Lower Taxes for Americans Working Abroad
The GOP candidate’s newest campaign pledge would cut the IRS bill for citizens working overseas, expanding the current $126,500 exemption.2 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Top stories - BBC News
Where is Hurricane Milton now?
Milton hit western Florida near Siesta Key, with US officials warning of "life-threatening" storm surge.3 hours ago -
Top stories - BBC News
No apology for paedophile head's victims
Liz Saville Roberts says a duty of care was owed to children in education.45 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Ocasio-Cortez promises 'brawl' if 'billionaires' force out Lina Khan
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) vowed Wednesday there would be a “brawl” if wealthy Democratic donors attempt to force Federal Trade Commission (FTC) Chair Lina Khan out of a potential ...Yesterday -
Business - The New York Times
Trump Keeps the Tax Cut Promises Coming, Now for Americans Abroad
Former President Donald J. Trump said in a statement that he would seek to end the “double taxation” of Americans overseas.18 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Top stories - CBS News
Patrick Riccards on debunking Hurricane Helene FEMA misinformation
Misinformation about FEMA aid for Hurricane Helene victims continues to spread, with new conspiracy theories alleging government weather manipulation and land grabs in North Carolina. Patrick ...Yesterday -
Top stories - CBS News
FEMA administrator on Hurricane Milton concerns, preps for landfall
FEMA administrator Deanne Criswell talks with "CBS Mornings" about the dangers of Hurricane Milton as it nears landfall in Florida. She advises people to listen to their local officials regarding ...Yesterday
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Trump tells Detroit he'll make car loan interest tax-deductible
Former President Trump on Thursday laid out his pitch to strengthen the auto industry in an economic address in Detroit, proposing to make interest on car loans fully tax deductible, pledging to ...36 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
US approves temporary imports of IV fluids as hospitals grapple with storm-related shortages
Federal health officials have approved the import of certain IV fluids from overseas as hospitals across the country scramble to deal with a Hurricane Helene-inflicted shortage. The shortage ...41 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Trump swipes at Detroit during speech in Motor City
Former President Trump on Thursday bashed the city of Detroit as a “mess” and called it a developing area during a speech in the Motor City. The former president spoke at the Detroit Economic Club, ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
OpenAI sees continued attempts to use AI models for election interference
OpenAI has seen continued attempts by cybercriminals to use its artificial intelligence (AI) models for fake content aimed at interfering with this year’s elections, the ChatGPT maker said in a new ...1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
Whoopi Goldberg on Trump 'stupid View' remarks: 'How dumb are you?
"The View" co-host Whoopi Goldberg slammed former President Trump after he called the talk show "stupid" and then suggested that she's "really dumb." “As I watch that stupid 'View,' where you have ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump