Harris promised to be ‘pragmatic’ — that means dropping Lina Khan at the FTC
The Biden administration’s most activist regulator may soon need a job — unless the next president taps Federal Trade Commission Chair Lina Khan to stay on for another term.
With the controversial FTC chair’s tenure having ended on Sept. 26, it will be up to the next president to decide whether Khan will have another four years leading the agency tasked with antitrust enforcement and consumer protection. Vice President Kamala Harris vowed in front of the Economic Club of Pittsburgh last week to be “pragmatic” if elected and not be “constrained by ideology” in how she governs. Given this noble pledge, she must show Khan the door.
President Biden's choice of Khan to lead the FTC was an exciting one. Khan, now 35, was and still is young, energetic, and ideologically motivated. She is representative of a critical new generation of Democrats who want to take up the mantle of trustbusting, taking aim at large tech firms.
Since then, Khan has taken the FTC to war against Microsoft, Meta, Google and Amazon, as well as against corporate mergers between handbag companies, hotels, and grocery stores.
The most bizarre and revealing defeat for Khan came in court against Microsoft for its effort to merge with Activision-Blizzard, the video game company behind Call of Duty. The case came about because of the FTC’s shift in focus away from obvious harm to the consumer, modeled by her revamped mission statement for the agency. Khan’s FTC removed language stating its commitment to not hindering legitimate business activity while playing its role as watchdog.
Put more simply, even if a corporate action is known to be legal, Khan will make you fight for it in court.
When you watch Khan’s recent "60 Minutes" feature, this theme is front and center. Khan says “We’re doing our job, enforcing the law.” She is then interrupted by Lesley Stahl, who adds, “You are. [Businesses are] afraid you’re going to tie them up in court, cost them a lot of money, and they’re saying it’s just not worth it.” Khan nods along. Stahl also asks, “If someone just says, ‘I’m not going to go forward,’ that’s a win?” to which Lina Khan replies, “That’s right.”
The FTC under Khan has made it the position of the federal government to oppose reflexively and antagonize all mergers, treating any market consolidation with hostility. That posture amounts to a corporate tax on mergers and acquisitions.
Candidate Harris shares Khan’s proclivity for blaming inflation and higher prices of gadgets and groceries on corporate misbehavior. But if Harris wins the presidency, she will have done so on the promise of understanding middle-class concerns. You don’t see Harris campaigning in the suburbs against one-day Amazon Prime deliveries and Prime Day deals on televisions, which is exactly what Khan is up to in her case against Amazon.
Donald Trump, if he wins in November, will certainly fire Khan, but Harris would have to contend with a tough reconfirmation battle for Khan to keep the job. Khan would struggle to maintain the same level of Republican good faith she received at the start of the Biden administration. High-profile defeats in federal court and agency resignations, including a commissioner's public rebuke in the pages of the Wall Street Journal, would be the main event of a confirmation hearing, and seriously degrade any wavering support for Khan to continue leading the FTC.
Before grabbing the top spot for antitrust enforcement, Khan was a fresh face with a paper trail of hot takes on how to break up Amazon. Today she’s a federal official with spurned former colleagues willing to speak out against her “disregard for the rule of law and due process” and Federal Employee Viewpoint Survey results showing a dramatic drop, from 87 percent to 49 percent, on the question of whether “senior agency officials maintain high standards of honesty and integrity” within the FTC.
Khan has broken trust and morale within the agency while simultaneously performing on "60 Minutes" and Comedy Central’s "The Daily Show" as a media darling and anti-capitalist icon.
There is nothing “pragmatic” about Khan. It’s why she was hired — to throw the kitchen sink at corporations and test the constraints of congressional oversight of the FTC. She did just that. Were she to retain Khan, Harris would betray her message of common-sense government responsive to policy results.
Biden brought Khan into the fold for what you could call “bold, persistent experimentation” around antitrust, and it has been a failure. Harris can be a fresh leader by correcting that mistake.
Stephen Kent is the media director of the Consumer Choice Center.
Date: |
Topics
-
Top stories - The New York Times
Biden Promised Federal Support for Survivors of Helene
Also, Liz Cheney is campaigning tonight with Kamala Harris. Here’s the latest at the end of Thursday.2 days ago - Joe Biden -
World - Yahoo News
Pakistan deploys army in capital to tackle protests by Khan’s party
2 days ago - Pakistan -
World - Yahoo News
Tensions in Pakistan as ex-premier Khan’s party continues protest
Yesterday - Pakistan -
Top stories - BBC News
'Botched insulation means mushrooms grow on my walls'
MPs and Citizens Advice urge the government to address regulation of the sector.2 days ago -
World - The Guardian
‘The ultimate reminder’: readers on what their tattoos mean to them
With number of Britons getting inked on the rise, people share the memories, loved ones and values that inspired them. After Ed Sibley’s mother died in January he had a mug of tea tattooed on his ...2 days ago -
World - Financial Times
India is getting serious about wine. What will that mean?
The latest hobby enjoyed by affluent Indians might give producers reason to be cheerfulYesterday - India -
Top stories - CBS News
What September's strong jobs report means for you
A blockbuster jobs report for September sent stocks to record highs. The economy added 245,000 jobs last month, according to the Labor Department, exceeding the expectations of most economists. ...Yesterday -
Politics - The Hill
Passport processing wait times drop again
U.S. passport processing time has been reduced by two weeks at most, the State Department announced Thursday. The Bureau of Consular Affairs said wait times for both online and paper applications ...2 days ago -
Sports - ESPN
PSG's manager defends decision to drop Dembélé
Paris Saint-Germain manager Luis Enrique had no qualms about dropping Ousmane Dembélé for disciplinary reasons, saying that he did it for the good of the team.Yesterday
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Watch live: Trump holds rally in Wisconsin amid tight race
Former President Trump will hold a rally in Juneau, Wis., his fourth event in the swing state in eight days, as the race for the White House remains close with less than a month until Election Day. ...21 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Israel’s moral dilemma and the tragedy of war
The tragic irony here is that while Israel is scrutinized for the civilian casualties that occur despite its precautions, its adversaries are celebrated by their supporters for the very suffering ...1 hour ago - Israel -
Politics - The Hill
Combatting antisemitism and ensuring that no one faces danger alone
Rabbi Benjamin Goldschmidt, the son of the chief rabbi of Moscow, reflects on the rise of antisemitism in New York City and calls for increased security funding and the passage of the Antisemitism ...1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
Automation takes center stage in port negotiations
Dockworkers and longshoremen with the International Longshoremen's Association (ILA) are underscoring a fear being felt across various industries: Will robots replace them at their jobs? The ...1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
Schiff supports Israeli strike on Iranian ballistic missile factories
Rep. Adam Schiff (D-Calif.), the leading candidate for his state's Senate seat, said he would advise Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to strike Iranian ballistic missile factories. In an ...1 hour ago - Israel