Harris must flex her muscles on national security — and fast
As the United States sends soldiers to the Middle East and Israel wages brutal parallel wars against Hamas in Gaza and Iran-backed Hezbollah in Lebanon, the Democratic ticket of Kamala Harris and Tim Walz must quickly assert its foreign policy prowess.
As America’s potential first female president — and after Walz’s "shaky" performance on the debate stage — Harris must particularly flex her muscles to show she can dominate on the world stage.
The U.S. has been left behind as President Biden, Harris and their G7 allies fail to mediate an end to the rapidly escalating war in the Middle East. That lack of engagement reflects poorly on Harris, leaving her in an awkward position as she attempts to argue that she, Biden and the Democrats are the best poised to put out the tinder keg in the Middle East and protect the United States from retaliation, while expressing calibrated sympathy for Palestinian, Lebanese and Syrian civilians.
The timing of Israel’s lethal actions is not coincidental, coming just before the anniversary of Hamas's Oct. 7, 2023 murderous rampage into Israel from Gaza, which killed more than 1,000 people and resulted in the kidnapping of more than 250 Israeli civilians, soldiers and children. Hamas and its fellow pro-Palestinian terrorist groups still hold 101 hostages, their fate in limbo as Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu wages his war on Hamas and Hezbollah and its proxy supporter, Iran.
Poll after poll reveals that national security is a top priority for voters, after economic security. In a Pew Research Center poll released in February, 63 percent of voters said that “defending against terrorism” was a top policy priority, second only to 73 percent who said the most important policy priority is “strengthening economy.” In a more recent Pew poll, taken last month, foreign policy was the fourth top issue for voters, after the economy, health care and, interestingly, Supreme Court appointments.
Harris has attempted to position herself as a security expert both in her speeches and symbolically, but insufficiently so. She got off to a good start in her debate with former President Trump, taunting her Republican opponent for exchanging “love letters with Kim Jong Un” and having such a close relationship with Russia’s Vladamir Putin that, if he were in office now, “Putin would be sitting in Kyiv right now.”
Indeed, her hawkish stance won her the endorsement of more than 700 national security and military leaders from both sides of the aisle. But with just weeks to the elections, and security looming on voters’ minds as the Middle East devolves, Harris must leverage those endorsements to convince voters in the middle that she has the capacity to tackle the major global crises that she will confront if she takes office, including Israel, Ukraine and Iran.
Otherwise, she could easily lose this tight race.
According to RealClearPolitics, an average of recent polling from seven key swing states shows Trump is up by 0.1 percentage points. The former president is predicted to win Electoral College ballots in the seven swing states with 219 votes, compared to 215 votes for Harris.
To win over voters, Harris could frame her national security message through the lens of 9/11, given the similarities in scope and scale of the attacks on 10/7. Although the presidential debate fell just the day before the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attack, surprisingly, Harris didn’t harken back to one of the most powerful moments in our history to bring home to Americans what this election is really about — protecting America’s national security and democracy.
Trump didn’t mention 9/11 either, but he did tell television viewers in the “spin room” that he’d be attending the memorial services in New York the next day. Harris was also at the services in Manhattan, along with Biden and other leaders. Even there, the vice president won in optics, thanks to Trump’s controversial companion, Laura Loomer, a far-right personality who last year shared a video with the irresponsible conspiracy theory that “9/11 was an Inside Job!” Even Republicans like Sen. Lindsay Graham advised Trump to distance himself from Loomer, who posted a social media message after the 9/11 ceremony that “the White House will smell like curry” if Harris is elected president.
The chaos in Trump’s brand — his lack of focus, punctuated by bizarre messages about cats and dogs and, now, curry — gives Harris an opening to differentiate herself as a coherent leader of strength. She should use the historical lens of the 9/11 attacks to communicate her focus on security, powerfully incorporating it into her final campaign speeches.
In future speeches, she must tell voters that she participated in the memorial services in New York to commemorate the 23rd anniversary of the tragedy of Sept. 11, 2001, reminding them that nearly 3,000 innocent Americans had been killed in the worst terrorist attacks in history on U.S. soil.
Harris must connect 9/11 to 10/7, explaining why the issue of national security is so important — and why these elections are so important. And she must make clear why our global alliances, which her opponent scorns, mocks and wants to destroy, are so important.
Indeed, the White House’s national security communications adviser, Adm. John Kirby, just made that point in a conversation with CNN host Jake Tapper. Kirby said the White House had been concerned about a direct confrontation between the U.S. and Iran “almost from the beginning,” with the conflict now widening into a regional war.
Describing the U.S. support for Israel as “iron-clad,” Kirby pointed out, “This is an ally, this is a partner. And they are under attack every single day.” He added, “If we were here in the United States facing those kinds of missiles, those kinds of drone attacks from neighboring countries, I can guarantee that the American people would want to make sure that we are doing what we can to protect them. And we are going to continue doing what we can to protect the Israeli people.”
A reminder of the tragedy of 9/11 with the parallel of 10/7 would allow Harris to argue why it’s now so important to support NATO and America’s allies in their time of need. Like any relationship, it’s a long-term investment. Harris can then hammer home that the many senior national security leaders who have briefed her over the years say she is ready for the job.
To end her new national security speeches, Harris should say that, today, the enemy is both foreign and domestic. Russia, Iran and China are engaging in malign foreign influence in an insidious attempt to corrupt U.S. elections and threaten U.S. and European sovereignty. Americans must fight hard to defeat them.
She could end her reflections with a call to all Americans to remember the lessons of 9/11 and 10/7 forever, to teach their children and grandchildren about these tragedies, to heed their lessons and to remember that with strength — specifically, her strength — comes security.
Chitra Ragavan is an executive leadership coach and strategic adviser to CEOs and thought leaders. A former national correspondent for NPR and U.S. News & World Report, she has served previously as a senior adviser to the CEO at Palantir and a C-suite executive at technology firms.
Date: |
Topics
-
World - The Guardian
Harris hits back at Republican’s remarks about her lack of biological children
Democrat responds on Call Her Daddy podcast to Arkansas governor saying she has nothing ‘keeping her humble’. US politics – live updates Kamala Harris hit back at the Republican Arkansas ...3 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Slim Harris lead narrows over Trump in post-VP debate national survey
Vice President Harris’s slim national lead over former President Trump narrowed after the vice presidential debate last week, a survey published Monday found. Harris is leading Trump by 2 ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Top stories - CBS News
Trump economic plan would add more national debt than Harris' plan, analysis finds
A report from the nonpartisan, nonprofit Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget found that both Kamala Harris and Donald Trump would add to the national debt with their economic plans. But the ...39 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Trump agenda would add twice as much to national debt as Harris's: Budget group
A new estimate finds that former President Trump’s tax and spending plans could add twice as much to the national debt as those brought by Vice President Harris, amounting to more than $7 trillion ...31 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
World - The Guardian
We must insist that out of the October 7 tragedy must come lasting peace | Jo-Ann Mort
Friends of mine in the Israeli peace camp express the hope that out of such great tragedy could come a peaceful resolution. October 7 is a day of mourning. For Israelis, it is a reminder they ...2 hours ago -
Business - MarketWatch
The next Social Security COLA increase won’t be enough to solve this crisis.
Millions of older adults already can’t afford housing, food or healthcare.39 minutes ago -
Business - The New York Times
Growing Cannabis and Opium Poppies May Be Key to U.S. Securing Access to Medicine
After supply chain disruptions that made critical medicines scarce, a federal effort is underway to ensure domestic stocks of pharmaceutical ingredients.27 minutes ago -
Top stories - CBS News
Kathy Bates shocked to learn she did thank her mother in her Oscar speech
Academy Award-winner Kathy Bates was certain she had neglected to mention her mom when she accepted the Oscar for "Misery" 33 years ago – until "Sunday Morning" showed her video proof.1 hour ago -
Lifestyle - The New York Times
Paris Hilton Expands Her Walmart Offerings With a New Handbag Line
A new line of handbags expands the offerings of her brand at the big-box chain. Plus, rare Birkenstocks and a pink suit you may have seen.2 days ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Abandon Harris campaign endorses Jill Stein
The “Abandon Harris” group pushing for voters to protest Vice President Harris over the conflict in Gaza is endorsing the Green Party’s Jill Stein in the presidential race. The group, formerly ...25 minutes ago - Kamala Harris -
Politics - The Hill
Schumer: Oct. 7 'will go down in infamy'
Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.), the highest-ranking Jewish elected leader in American history, marked the first anniversary of the Oct. 7, 2023, attacks in Israel as a “day that will ...31 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Trump agenda would add twice as much to national debt as Harris's: Budget group
A new estimate finds that former President Trump’s tax and spending plans could add twice as much to the national debt as those brought by Vice President Harris, amounting to more than $7 trillion ...31 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
How the US can help Lebanon move past Hezbollah
The current ruling class in Lebanon must overcome its own Stockholm syndrome.31 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Charlamagne tha God knocks Republicans over false Helene response claims: 'Everything can't be politicized'
Charlamagne tha God is speaking out against what he describes as "lies created by the GOP" surrounding the federal government's response to Hurricane Helene. "It's actually nuts that at a time like ...38 minutes ago - Republican Party