Garland contempt vote scheduled for next week
House impeachment investigators will meet next week to vote on whether to hold Attorney General Merrick Garland in contempt as part of their quest to gain access to an audio recording of an interview conducted with President Biden during his classified documents probe.
House Judiciary Chair Jim Jordan (R-Ohio) and House Oversight Chair James Comer (R-Ky.) have a transcript of Biden’s interview with special counsel Robert Hur, but the Justice Department has held back from sharing the audio files.
The substance of the recording has little to do with their impeachment investigation into Biden. But the panels have nonetheless sought the audio as well as two documents found in his home that dealt with Ukraine.
The Justice Department has twice urged the committees not to escalate the matter, and last month said the two chairs requested the information based on “political purposes that should have no role” in determining which law enforcement files are shared.
“It seems that the more information you receive, the less satisfied you are, and the less justification you have for contempt, the more you rush towards it,” Carlos Uriarte, head of legislative affairs for the Justice Department, wrote to Jordan and Comer last month.
The department declined comment Tuesday morning but has taken the stance that turning over its investigative files would have a chilling effect as they seek cooperation across various probes.
House Republicans have defended their interest in the audio, saying that the format contains “revealing verbal cues” and that “a subject’s pauses and inflections can provide context or evidence of whether a subject is evasive or suffers from a ‘poor memory.’”
“The Department’s unsupported speculation about the Committees’ motives in insisting that you produce the audio recordings has no bearing on your legal obligation to produce the subpoenaed materials,” they wrote last month.
The contempt vote, if approved, would go from the committee to the full House floor.
Though censure of a sitting Attorney General would be remarkable, it would likely have little practical effect: contempt votes largely act as a referral to the Justice Department, which then weighs whether there are grounds for contempt of Congress charges.
The coming hearing is not the first time that the two chairs have threatened contempt as part of their impeachment investigation.
Last summer the duo was prepared to hold FBI Director Christopher Wray in contempt over access to the FD-1023 file memorializing an interview with a bureau informant who alleged Biden accepted a bribe while serving as vice president.
The informant has since been arrested on charges related to fabricating the claim.
An attorney general has been held in contempt only twice before.
In 2012, Attorney General Eric Holder was held in contempt for refusing to turn over documents related to the Operation Fast and Furious, where law enforcement failed to intervene as some 2,000 guns were sold.
The department took no further action against Holder.
Trump-era Attorney General Bill Barr was also held in contempt for skirting a subpoena dealing with changes made to the Census form, and the department likewise took no additional action.
Biden’s interview with Hur focuses on how documents from his tenure as vice president ended up in his home and in an office he used once leaving the administration.
The interview was the basis for Hur’s conclusion that Biden would likely be perceived as “an elderly man with a poor memory” by a jury, even as he likewise wrote that he failed to find sufficient evidence to support any charges.
The Justice Department insists its decision to withhold the recording is not political, but rather consistent with their prerogative of protecting their investigations.
“The decision to sit down with investigators and prosecutors should not include a tacit invitation for the Committees to participate, comment, or apply selective hindsight,” Uriarte wrote last month.
“It would be severely chilling if the decision to cooperate with a law enforcement investigation required individuals to submit themselves to public inquest by politicians.”
Date: |
Filter
-
House panels vote to hold Garland in contempt
Two House committees on Thursday advanced measures to hold Attorney General Merrick Garland in contempt of Congress in an effort to censure him for failing to turn over audio recordings of the president. A last-minute move from President Biden to ...The Hill - Politics -
Inherent contempt and a lawsuit: House GOP plots next steps against Garland
Politico - Politics -
House committee votes to recommend Garland be held in contempt of Congress
The House Judiciary Committee has voted to recommend Attorney General Merrick Garland be held in contempt of Congress after refusing to hand over audio recordings of President Biden's interview with special counsel Robert Hur.NBC News - Politics -
House committees consider Garland contempt of Congress charges
Various House committees are considering contempt of Congress charges against Attorney General Merrick Garland after he advised President Biden to invoke executive privilege to block access to a taped interview in the classified documents case. ...CBS News - Top stories -
Merrick Garland contempt resolution clears House panel
The House Judiciary Committee advanced a resolution Thursday to hold Attorney General Merrick Garland in contempt of Congress. CBS News congressional correspondent Scott MacFarlane reports.CBS News - Top stories -
Why House Republicans want to hold Merrick Garland in contempt
A House panel voted Thursday to advance a resolution holding Attorney General Merrick Garland in contempt of Congress. CBS News congressional correspondent Scott MacFarlane reports.CBS News - Top stories - Republican Party -
Garland contempt resolution clears House panels as Biden asserts privilege
The Justice Department said Thursday morning that the president was asserting executive privilege over the recordings with special counsel Robert Hur.CBS News - Politics - Joe Biden -
Biden asserts executive privilege over Hur recordings as GOP seeks to hold Garland in contempt
President Biden is asserting executive privilege over recordings of his interview with special counsel Robert Hur, according to letters sent from the White House and Justice Department to two GOP-led House committees. Congressional Republicans ...CBS News - Top stories - Joe Biden -
AG Garland admonishes GOP-led contempt effort over Biden-Hur recordings
Attorney General Merrick Garland took questions from reporters Thursday as two Republican-led House committees consider a contempt of Congress resolution against him. Garland has defied the committees' requests for audio recordings of former ...CBS News - Top stories - Joe Biden -
WNBA charter flights to be fully set by next week
All WNBA teams will be using the league's new charter flight program by early next week, a spokesman told ESPN.ESPN - Sports - WNBA
More from The Hill
-
Crockett offering 'bleach blonde' t-shirts following spat with Greene
Rep. Jasmine Crockett (D-Texas) is launching "A Crockett Clapback Collection" of t-shirts meant to raise money for Democratic candidates following the attention on her clash with Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.). Crockett wrote on social media ...The Hill - Politics -
10,000 daily steps was a marketing ploy: Do you really need to hit it?
Getting 10,000 steps a day started as a marketing ploy — so is it really something to aim for?The Hill - Politics -
In the shadow of the college protests is a generation’s collective identity crisis
The West is struggling with a collective identity crisis.The Hill - Politics -
Ron Johnson presses for Secret Service to push protest zone farther from GOP convention
Sen. Ron Johnson (R-Wis.) on Sunday said he is urging the Secret Service to push the protest zone farther away from the Republican National Convention in Milwaukee in an effort to prevent conflict at the event. "The Secret Service -- they use ...The Hill - Politics -
Stefanik, Fox News anchor spar over NYT report questioning her support of Trump
Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-N.Y.) on Sunday pushed back against "Fox News Sunday" anchor Shannon Bream for referencing a report that questioned her past support of former President Trump as her name continues to be floated as his vice-presidential ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump