From horsepower to electric vehicles, the market always beats mandates
Anyone familiar with Western agricultural history knows today’s emphasis on energy transitions is nothing new.
In the 1920s, farmers across the country switched from hay power to gas power. As a result, between 1920 and 1930, the population of horses in the United States fell by more than 6 million. That’s a lot of dog food.
The switch to tractors occurred because of one thing — economics. For example, the cost of spring plowing in 1920 with horses fell from $2.69 per acre to $2.07 with tractors; fall plowing from $3.04 to $2.13. All of this happened without the federal government’s helping hand.
About the same time as the switch from horses to tractors, remote farms and ranches were making another energy transition, from wood, coal and kerosene to electricity.
Between 1920 and 1935, households in remote locations purchased 1 million wind chargers. These were not the iconic windmills you can still see scattered across the Great Plains to pump water for livestock and crops, but were small propeller-driven generators, perched atop towers or buildings, that charged 6-volt batteries.
Leading the charge — pun intended — was Windcharger Corporation, which, at its peak, produced 2,000 “deluxe” models per day. The chargers sold for $44, $785 in 2024 dollars, and charged 6-volt batteries that could power small lights and other appliances, especially radios that connected people to the outside world.
Another energy transition driven by economics and convenience.
Windcharger Corp. sales of 750,000 units worldwide in its first 10 years — including the Great Depression — attracted a major injection of capital and dozens of competitors. Zenith Radio Corp. saw an opportunity to sell more radios and purchased a major share in Windchargerer. The company then dropped the price of a wind charger to $15, or $268 in today’s currency, if purchased with a Zenith radio.
So what happened to this market-driven energy transition? The death knell was part of the New Deal, the Rural Electrification Act of 1936. The act provided subsidized federal loans to companies willing to build powerlines to reach rural areas of the United States.
Better than sporadic wind power stored in batteries, these lines provided cheap, reliable “green energy” mainly from subsidized federal dams, such as Hoover and Grand Coulee. This energy transition was not driven by sound economics but by politics and subsidies.
The Biden administration’s plan for a “Clean Energy Economy" is no different. The president and fellow Democrats 2021 budget proposed $2 trillion in federal investment in technologies to fight climate change. The final budget that passed the House pared down that amount to $555 billion, still a lot of zeros."
Unlike the transitions from horses to tractors or kerosene to wind-generated electricity, this political transition shows little progress. In 2020, coal, natural gas and oil accounted for 79 percent of U.S. energy consumption and renewables and nuclear for 21 percent. By 2022, coal, gas, and oil accounted for 82 percent and renewables and nuclear 17 percent.
Progress?
The main reason there is no sign of an energy transition is the same reason for the progress in the 1920s — economics.
According to Bloomberg’s New Energy Finance forecast, Biden’s proposed spending leaves a “transition” spending gap of $6 trillion. That comes on top of a federal budget destined to leave our children debt-poor. Moreover, carbon-free electricity will be expensive. Even adjusted for inflation, wind and solar prices to consumers rose by more than 30 percent between 2018 and 2022.
Back to the future is the path to cleaner energy. That path will be paved with market-driven technology and consumer-driven demand.
Terry L. Anderson is the John and Jean DeNault senior fellow at the Hoover Institution at Stanford University.
Date: |
Filter
-
Honda plans to invest nearly $65 billion on its electric-vehicle strategy through 2030 as part of efforts to boost sales and production in the coming years.
Honda plans to invest nearly $65 billion on its electric-vehicle strategy through 2030 as part of efforts to boost sales and production in the coming years.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Chinese search-engine giant Baidu reported a drop in quarterly profit, but beat estimates, helped by stable online marketing revenue and rising sales from its AI Cloud business.
Chinese search-engine giant Baidu reported a drop in quarterly profit, but beat estimates, helped by stable online marketing revenue and rising sales from its AI Cloud business.The Wall Street Journal - World -
One Tech Tip: Protecting your car from the growing risk of keyless vehicle thefts
Auto technology has evolvedABC News - Tech -
‘I see my greedy in-laws as misogynists’: I was a stockbroker in the 1980s and always kept my money separate from my husband’s. Is such self-protection justified?
“The biggest surprise when we got married was that my husband’s family saw me as a paycheck, even though they are all educated.”MarketWatch - Business -
Is the move to electric cars running out of power?
There has been an unexpected slowdown in sales of electric cars. Could this be more than a blip?BBC News - Top stories -
Is the move to electric cars running out of power?
There has been an unexpected slowdown in sales of electric cars. Could this be more than a blip?BBC News - Top stories -
You Can't Always Get What You Want
Christians choose Trump for his policies, not for his religious standing.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Tariffs Push Up Costs. But Not Always Inflation
Biden’s decision to raise tariffs on roughly $18 billion of goods from China has revived a long-running debate in economics over who ultimately pays such tariffs.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Biden's HHS is trying to twist the Hyde Amendment to mandate abortion funding
HHS has taken a lot of aggressive positions under this administration, but this may be its most ludicrous.The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
3 killed in western New York after vehicle hit by Amtrak train
Amtrak Train 281 was traveling from New York City to Niagara Falls.CBS News - Top stories - New York
More from The Hill
-
Sullivan presses Netanyahu for a more focused military campaign in Gaza
White House national security adviser Jake Sullivan reiterated Biden administration pressure on Israel to limit its military operation in Gaza during a visit to the country on Sunday. Sullivan is on a combined trip to Israel and Saudi Arabia as ...The Hill - Politics - Israel -
Vance doubles down on praise for Viktor Orban's crackdown on universities in Hungary
Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio) stood by previous comments praising Hungarian President Viktor Orban for a regulatory crackdown on the country’s universities on Sunday, saying the U.S. should embrace a similar mindset. Orban, as part of anti-democratic ...The Hill - Politics -
Biden on Trump’s next Supreme Court pick: ‘Do you think he’ll put anybody who has a brain?’
President Biden asked the audience at an NAACP Detroit chapter dinner to consider whether they think former President Trump, if elected for a second term in the White House, would fill hypothetical vacancies at the Supreme Court with “anybody who ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
US to pull troops out of Niger by mid-September: Pentagon
The U.S. military will pull all of its assets out of Niger by mid-September, the Pentagon announced Sunday, after days of talks with the country’s military junta finalized a timeline. A group of military leaders executed a coup in Niger last year, ...The Hill - Politics -
Elon Musk debuts Starlink satellite internet service in Indonesia
Elon Musk traveled to Bali this weekend to officially launch Starlink, the SpaceX satellite internet service, in Indonesia this Sunday. At a launch event with ministers in a health clinic in Indonesia, Musk stressed the significance of providing ...The Hill - Politics - Elon Musk