For panicking Democrats, the Electoral College may finally be an asset
![For panicking Democrats, the Electoral College may finally be an asset](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/07/biden_joe-2159654363.jpg?w=900)
Since President Biden’s poor debate debate performance on June 27, Democrats have been openly panicking and discussing his replacement at the top of the ticket on November's ballot. Many seek a more persistently lucid candidate — names mentioned include Vice President Kamala Harris and California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D).
So far, Biden has resisted stepping aside, asserting that one bad night shouldn’t disqualify him from running for reelection. Others point to fast-approaching ballot access deadlines as good reasons to avoid changing horses mid-stream. Their fear: If Biden steps aside but there’s no single replacement candidate yet, the Democratic presidential line in several states will be essentially blank.
In the worst case scenario for Democrats, Biden will be their candidate but will become incapacitated in some fashion between ballot finalization and the election.
Ironically, Democrats can put their minds at ease — and effectively refute Republican claims of illegal shenanigans — by fully embracing the opportunities afforded them by the institution the Constitution lays out for presidential elections: the Electoral College.
Such an embrace might seem fanciful after the Democrats’ quarter-century war on the Electoral College, which began in earnest after the contested 2000 election. Then-Senator-elect Hillary Clinton (D-N.Y.) called for the Electoral College’s abolition three days after Election Day that November. She reiterated her position after the 2016 election, when she herself lost in the Electoral College while receiving more individual votes nationwide.
Other prominent Democrats, from Al Gore to Pete Buttiegieg, have made their disdain for the system known. Democratic voters also don’t like it.
But hear me out.
Let’s say Biden’s name is on the ballot in all 50 states and Washington, D.C., but he — voluntarily or otherwise — agrees that he’s not up to serving a second term. Most politicos today seem to think that would nuke Democrats’ chances, because people will vote for Biden in November, and he can’t be replaced. Game, set, match for Donald Trump, right?
Wrong. No one in the U.S. votes for a candidate to be president. Americans in all 50 states and the District of Columbia vote for slates of electors, who in turn (usually) vote for the candidate they pledge to vote for.
Democrats can forge ahead with Biden. If he becomes unable to run at any point — even if it’s as late as Halloween — all Democrats need to do is direct their slates of electors to vote for someone else when they meet in each sate capital on Dec. 15. It could be Harris, Newsom or anyone else the party agrees on.
This elector-swap approach benefits Democrats in numerous other ways. The prospect of a raucous open convention in Chicago should send Democrats running for any alternative. It allows Biden, Democrats’ consistently best-polling challenger to Trump, to stay in the race longer.
With much of the vote already in weeks before Election Day due to early voting, Democrats can bank votes with their best candidate longer, switching only when absolutely necessary — potentially after the election, but before Dec. 15.
To be sure, some states’ laws require the slate of electors to vote for the specific candidate to whom they are pledged. But the penalties for an elector not voting his or her pledge lack teeth. Most states, such as Arizona or Michigan, simply replace an elector who violates his or her pledge with another person. If every Democrat in the state simply agrees to vote for the party’s alternative to Biden, the swap will render the penalty a nullity.
What’s more, there’s a direct historical analogue to the situation Democrats find themselves in today. In the waning weeks of the 1912 presidential campaign, Republican vice presidential nominee James Sherman passed away. Republican Party officials simply directed Republican electors to vote for Nicholas Butler for vice president. They voted for Butler, whose name had appeared on no state’s ballot, without issue.
For Democrats to implement the plan, it would require something they’ve been loath to do since the 2000 election: Admit that the Electoral College system has merit. Ironically, their preferred system — direct popular election — would put them in a far tighter bind than they are in now. Direct election would limit them to a potentially unavailable Biden or Harris, the only two names on state ballots.
The Electoral College, in contrast, gives Democrats vastly more freedom to choose a youthful, energetic and appealing alternative candidate at the time that works best for them.
James Sieja is associate professor of government at St. Lawrence University in Canton, N.Y.
Date: |
Filter
-
Financial Times - World
The UK’s new electoral map in charts
The results are in — what have we learned? -
MarketWatch - Business
How Kamala Harris’s policies could differ from Biden’s, if she’s the Democratic nominee
If President Joe Biden were to bow out of the White House race, Vice President Kamala Harris is widely viewed as mostly likely to take his place as the Democratic nominee. So what would her policy proposals look like?Joe Biden -
BBC News - Top stories
Liz Truss and Rees-Mogg among big-name Tory losses
The former prime minister was among high-profile losses as the Tories slump to a historic defeat.United Kingdom -
The New York Times - Business
Things to Bring to College That You Can’t Buy at Target
They won’t add bulk to the car or much cost to the bill, but they’ll help keep your college student safer. Pepperoni is also involved. -
The New York Times - Sports
An N.F.L. Star Hit Rock Bottom at Rikers Island. Now, He’s a Different Person.
Mark Gastineau spent his career in the spotlight. At 67, he lives with the reverberations of the life he once led, without the attention.NFL -
The Wall Street Journal - World
You Won't Believe College Football This Season
Conference realignment, no more Coach Saban and Coach Harbaugh, and an expanded playoff. The game has never been in a more turbulent state.College Football -
NBC News - Top stories
How punishing Britain’s Conservatives turned into an election victory for Labour
THETFORD, England — With its historic, flint-clad houses and pleasant fields, Thetford is an unlikely scene for an electoral bloodbath. -
MarketWatch - Business
Nvidia is starting to act like its own asset class
Shares of Nvidia Corp. are growing increasingly disconnected from the average stock in the S&P 500, prompting one analyst to quip that the chip designer is starting to behave like its own asset class. -
MarketWatch - Business
Trump Media to buy assets of WorldConnect Technologies in all-stock deal
Trump Media & Technology Group on Wednesday said it will acquire substantially all of the assets of WorldConnect Technologies.Donald Trump
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Whitmer says she doesn't like seeing her name mentioned as possible Biden replacement
Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer (D) said in a new interview that she doesn't like seeing her name mentioned as a possible replacement for President Biden if he leaves the presidential campaign. “It’s a distraction more than anything,” she told The ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
America’s vulnerable global moment
America faces a leadership crisis at home when it is at a crossroads in a rapidly changing and increasingly volatile world. -
The Hill - Politics
Boeing to plead guilty to felony in 737 Max crashes: DOJ
Boeing has agreed to plead guilty in the criminal case over two deadly crashes involving its 737 Max jetliners, the Department of Justice (DOJ) said in a Sunday night court filing. Under the deal, which still requires a federal judge's approval, ... -
The Hill - Politics
The Supreme Court has some explaining to do in Trump v. US
The ruling causes enormous confusion over the nation's most fundamental laws and principles, with little guidance on how courts and juries should apply it.Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Americans evenly divided over whether Trump should face prison time in hush money case: Poll
Americans are nearly evenly split over whether former President Trump should face prison time for his felony conviction in the New York hush money case, a new poll found. According to the survey from the AP-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research, ...Donald Trump