FISA renewal’s long and winding road to passage in the House
The perilous procedural path in the House to consider legislation (H.R. 7888), reforming and renewing the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA), is a tale worth telling, even if not always easy to follow.
Its twisting trail spanned four consecutive days last week, right up to mid-afternoon Friday, finally freeing members to catch their planes home. Even after the successful final passage vote, an unanticipated final procedural vote was called that had to be postponed until this week. That move prevented the bill from being sent immediately to the Senate. The existing FISA authorization expires tomorrow, April 19.
The most contentious part of FISA is section 702 which authorizes the surveillance of foreign nationals abroad, even though they may be communicating with U.S. citizens. That provision raised the hackles of privacy warriors on both the left and the right that would prove to be a major stumbling block.
The saga began last Tuesday afternoon when the House Rules Committee met to consider granting a special rule for the FISA bill and three unrelated measures (two of which were bumper-sticker resolutions denouncing the Biden administration’s immigration policies and opposing pressures on Israel). The FISA bill was brought by the leaders of the House Intelligence and Judiciary committees, though neither committee had formally reported the measure.
Several members testified in favor of making in order some 21 amendments they had filed with the committee several days before. Only six of those would make the final cut in the rule — two by Republicans and four by bipartisan groups of co-sponsors. The reported rule (H. Res. 1125), provided for two hours of general debate on the FISA bill followed by consideration of the six amendments.
When the special rule was called-up on the floor Wednesday it was hotly debated under the hour-rule (with time equally divided between the Republican and Democratic managers for the Rules Committee). Meantime, former President Donald Trump was busily kibbitzing from the sidelines with such subtle social media posts as, “KILL FISA!” Because the bill would extend FISA for five years, his main concern was that if elected president, he would not get a chance to revise the Act before his term ended.
Republicans only have a razor-thin majority in the House and cannot afford to lose more than two of their members if Democrats vote in unison the other way (which they usually do on special rules). In this instance, the GOP MAGA caucus was in high dudgeon, and 19 jumped their leadership’s ship, helping to kill the special rule 193-228, with all 209 Democrats voting “nay.” With that vote, the meat of the week’s work was stalled as leaders huddled to determine their next step.
Finally, the Rules Committee called a meeting Thursday evening to consider a second rule. What emerged was a special rule (H. Res. 1137) with a procedure that “self-executed” the adoption of an entire amendment in the nature of a substitute for the FISA bill. A “self-executing rule” is one that automatically affixes a provision to a bill with adoption of the rule, thereby avoiding a separate vote later. The essence of the substitute was to extend the FISA authorization for just two years, instead of five, thereby giving the former president and his House allies what they wanted. When the rule came to the floor Friday morning it was adopted on a party-line vote, 213-208.
After general debate on the bill was concluded, five of the six amendments were easily adopted. The most contentious amendment was a bipartisan amendment sponsored by Rep. Andy Biggs (R-Ariz.) and four other members of the Judiciary Committee, including its chairman, Rep. Jim Jordan (R-Ohio), and ranking member, Rep. Jerrold Nadler (D-N.Y.). The amendment would prohibit warrantless searches of U.S. person communications in the section 702 FISA database. It was defeated on a 212-212 tie vote.
The amendment was heavily lobbied against by President Biden’s national security team. All five House Democratic leaders voted against it as did three of the top five GOP leaders, including Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.).
The overwhelming vote of 273-147 on final passage of the FISA bill affirmed that the leadership had struck the right chord with the new procedural rule. Republicans voted 146-88 for the bill and Democrats 147-59.
As the chamber emptied for the day, two die-hard Republicans attempted to force a vote to reconsider the final passage vote. One of the GOP bill managers immediately offered a motion to table their motion. When a roll call vote was demanded, the Speaker pro tempore announced the vote would be postponed to a later date. That tabling motion was then adopted on Monday, 259-128, bringing the saga of the spy bill to an end in the House. But its fitful procedural path resembles more a “Pink Panther” cartoon than a serious legislative pursuit.
Don Wolfensberger is a 28-year congressional staff veteran, culminating as chief of staff of the House Rules Committee in 1995. He is author of, “Congress and the People: Deliberative Democracy on Trial” (2000), and, “Changing Cultures in Congress: From Fair Play to Power Plays” (2018.) The views expressed are solely his own.
Date: |
Topics
Filter
-
Senate advances House-passed foreign aid package toward final passage
Politico - Politics -
Passage: In memoriam
"Sunday Morning" remembers some of the notable figures who recently left us, including keyboardist Mike Pinder, of The Moody Blues.CBS News - Entertainment -
House Democratic leaders said they would block any effort to oust Speaker Johnson, moving to protect the Republican from retaliation by his hard-right flank after the passage of a foreign-aid package that included funding for Ukraine.
House Democratic leaders said they would block any effort to oust Speaker Johnson, moving to protect the Republican from retaliation by his hard-right flank after the passage of a foreign-aid package that included funding for Ukraine.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Saturday Sessions: Charley Crockett performs "Solitary Road"
A descendent of American folk hero Davey Crockett, Charley Crockett was raised in a Texas trailer park. He bought his first guitar in a pawn shop and taught himself how to play it. In 2015, he started releasing records independently. Fourteen ...CBS News - Entertainment -
For This Soccer Team, Every Game Is a Road Game
Shakhtar Donetsk hasn’t been able to play at home since 2014 due to war and instability in the Donbas region of Ukraine. But the club hasn’t stopped winning either.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Microsoft to power data centres with big Brookfield renewables deal
Purchase of 10.5GW of electricity highlights rising energy needs of AI and cloud computingFinancial Times - Business - Microsoft -
A Steady Stream of Road Trips Made Falling in Love Easy
As Deborah Yarchun and Benjamin Parr traveled across the country during the pandemic, their bond became stronger at each stop.The New York Times - Lifestyle -
Microsoft signs deal to invest more than $10 billion on renewable energy capacity to power data centers
Microsoft and Brookfield Asset Management will develop 10.5 gigawatts of renewable energy, in a deal they describe as the largest of its kind.CNBC - Business - Microsoft -
Greene's bid to topple Johnson veers closer to backfiring
The Georgia Republican now has to make a choice: Either don't call the ouster vote, or force one and watch it fail. Both options risk hurting her politically.Politico - Politics -
Senate overwhelmingly passes long-delayed Ukraine and Israel aid
Politico - Politics - Ukraine
More from The Hill
-
Americans widely opposed to Roe ruling nearly 2 years after it was overturned: Poll
Americans still widely oppose the Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade, ruling women do not have a federal right to an abortion, according to a new poll released Wednesday. In the CNN poll, conducted April 18-23, nearly two-thirds (65 ...The Hill - Politics -
House panel threatens to subpoena Biden's Labor chief over return-to-work plan
Chairwoman of the House Education and the Workforce Committee Virginia Foxx (R-N.C.) on Wednesday threated to subpoena Acting Secretary of Labor Julie Su for information regarding the department's return-to-work plan. In a committee hearing ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Biden’s worst-case economic scenario is unfolding at the worst possible time
The economic growth that the administration hoped would at least outstrip inflation’s increase — and reverse some of that cumulative effect — is not.The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Most in new survey worried about inaccuracies, misinformation being reported during election
Most Americans in the new survey are worried about inaccuracies and misinformation being reported during the 2024 election. Over half of Americans, 53 percent, said they are “extremely” or “very” concerned that news outlets will report inaccurate ...The Hill - Politics -
Biden to travel to Detroit for NAACP dinner
President Biden will travel to Detroit this month to give remarks at a NAACP dinner, a Biden campaign official confirmed to The Hill. The president is set to travel to swing state Michigan on May 19 and will speak at the NAACP Detroit Branch's ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden