Feds' historical preservation rules desperately need an update
Every year, 120,000 federal agency actions, $8.8 billion in private renovation spending and tens of thousands of construction projects across America hinge on the interpretation of just 17 sentences, last updated almost 30 years ago.
These sentences are the secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, and they govern how virtually all historic preservation projects are designed and carried out.
At their best, these standards help preserve the historic buildings, homes, schools and places of worship that form the soul of our communities. But when applied too rigidly and without regard to the needs of communities, they become yet another source of red tape and an obstacle in efforts to expand housing, retrofit buildings for energy efficiency, and spur economic growth.
Like old buildings themselves, historic preservation standards need to be modernized to ensure they’re meeting today’s needs.
As chair of the federal historic preservation agency, I have heard from countless people about the surprising hold these rules have on our communities, and the pressing need to update them. It could be a main-street business owner trying to spruce up her storefront, a church board hoping to adapt a worship space for new uses, a family eyeing solar panels for its historic bungalow, a city leader planning to restore an old schoolhouse as a community asset, or a developer transforming an unwanted office building into housing.
By their telling, these obscure federal rules have been applied to increase costs and delay or even prevent projects altogether. That’s because decisionmakers at all levels have taken a conservative approach to interpreting the standards, sometimes unnecessarily prioritizing historic materials over people and the communities they’re seeking to rebuild.
Earlier this month, I issued a 600-page report describing key issues related to the standards, drawing heavily from comments submitted to my agency. It represents the views of thousands of organizations and individuals. In lurid detail, the comments revealed that strict interpretations of the standards have hindered economic growth and environmental sustainability. Moreover, inconsistent interpretations by the many institutions applying the standards erodes confidence in preservation-related processes.
The commenters told of how decisions about paint color choices and other inconsequential matters put millions of dollars of private capital at risk. They reported creative plans for school auditoriums that have been thwarted by boards that barred them from subdividing such large spaces for housing. They conveyed denials of small-scale rooftop solar energy projects, energy-efficient window replacements, and insulation — even in chilly New England.
For years, the developers who brave the risks and challenges to do rehab projects have sounded the alarm about these issues. In their comments, the developers sought clarity, consistency, and fairness. They weren’t alone. Such comments also poured in from preservation leaders, including the largest municipal preservation agency — the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission — as well as state officials and federal agencies collectively own and steward hundreds of thousands of historic properties.
The comments confirm that we preservationists are thinking critically about the field from within, and that we are ready to collaborate on necessary change.
The federal government, which sets the tone and creates the interpretations used by state, local, and private parties, must and will lead the charge. The Department of the Interior can address some of the issues with the current standards by issuing new, bright-line rules that would allow more housing conversions and solar energy projects, among other things. The department must also tackle the standards themselves, rewriting them to improve our climate-related response. In particular, explicitly approval of the relocation of historic properties could give shoreline communities more options as they try to stay one flood ahead of the rising seas.
My agency, which is independent of Interior, is already updating the way we interpret the standards for the federal housing projects that we regulate. Consistent with our task of advising on historic preservation policy, we will also convene conversations in the preservation community about how we can do better at the federal level.
Ironically, in looking at the standards with a fresh eye, we’re actually returning to the roots of the federal historic preservation program: the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966. It said that the federal government should ensure that “our historic property can exist in productive harmony and fulfill the social, economic, and other requirements of present and future generations.”
When we rebalance our practices in light of these values, we’ll see more of our historic places reinvigorated for the next generation.
Sara C. Bronin chairs the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation, an independent federal agency that promotes the preservation of our nation's diverse historic resources and advises the president and Congress on national historic preservation policy.
Date: |
Filter
-
Trucks carrying desperately needed aid are rolling across a newly U.S. built pier into Gaza
Trucks carrying desperately needed aid are rolling across a U.S.-built pier into Gaza. U.S. officials say this could mean up to 150 truckloads a day will get to the besieged Palestinian territory.CBS News - Top stories -
As Supernatural Claims Spread Online, Vatican Updates Its Rules on Them
People have long claimed sightings of the Virgin Mary or bleeding crucifixes, and some endorsed by the Roman Catholic Church have become hugely popular pilgrimage destinations.The New York Times - World -
Eye on America: Protecting and preserving the environment
In California, we learn how the site of past environmental disasters could be a key to America’s clean energy future. Then in Florida, we explore restoration efforts to reverse years of devastation in the Everglades. Watch these stories and more ...CBS News - Top stories -
Taking on Trump: Biden’s desperate debate strategy
Joe Biden has no choice but to debate Donald Trump.The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Desperate Biden must debate to win — but there are risks
Trump’s campaign has to guard against dirty tricks.The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
The Fed's Miracle Is Finally Back on the Table
Inflation is lower after months of hot readings, and investors love it.Inc. - Business -
The pivotal role of a tiny hydropower plant in preserving the Colorado River's future
A sprawling water district that serves residents, ranchers and recreators on the Western Slope of the Rocky Mountains is preparing to invest a mammoth $98.5 million on a tiny hydropower plant in a bipartisan, multi-sectorial effort to help secure ...The Hill - Politics -
Scientists make potential breast cancer breakthrough after preserving tissue in gel
Ability to preserve tissue in a special gel solution for at least a week will help doctors identify most effective drug treatments. Scientists say they have a made a potentially “gamechanging” breakthrough in breast cancer research after ...The Guardian - World -
Live Updates: P.G.A. Championship
Xander Schauffele and Collin Morikawa were tied for the lead entering Sunday’s final round.The New York Times - Sports -
Sources: Arsenal, Chelsea set for historic U.S. tour
Arsenal and Chelsea are set for preseason tours of the U.S., including a friendly against each other in Washington, D.C., sources told ESPN.ESPN - Sports - Premier League
More from The Hill
-
'We need it to be faster,' says Ukraine's ambassador about arms shipments
The Ukrainian ambassador to the U.S. urged American leaders on Sunday to speed up shipments of arms and aid to the country as it struggles to defend against the Russian military. “There is no such thing as fast enough when we are up against such a ...The Hill - Politics - Ukraine -
Who is Ebrahim Raisi, the missing president of Iran?
The condition of Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi remains unknown Sunday after his helicopter crashed in the rural and mountainous border region between Iran and western Azerbaijan. Iranian state media IRINN reported that the crash site had not yet ...The Hill - Politics -
Several nations offer support, prayers to Iran in wake of president's helicopter crash
Several leaders in Asia and Europe offered their support and prayers to Iran as the country continues rescue operations for a helicopter that crashed while carrying Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi on Sunday. Raisi was traveling in Iran’s East ...The Hill - Politics - Iran -
White House hits back at Stefanik after she blasts Biden in Israel
The White House hit back against House Republican Conference Chair Elise Stefanik’s (R-N.Y.) speech before the Israeli government’s legislative body on Sunday, when she attacked President Biden for his policy approach to Israel and the war in ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Biden addresses NAACP in Detroit: Watch live
President Biden will give remarks Sunday at a campaign event with the NAACP in Detroit, Mich., following his commencement speech at Morehouse College, where the president made his first appearance on a college campus since the start of the ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden