Federal judges are the first line of defense against Trump’s barrage
Right now, Donald Trump and his acolytes are “flooding the zone” with various illegal, unconstitutional and unethical orders. If you’re somebody who cares about individual rights and the rule of law, you’re probably trying to keep your head above water.
That applies to just about everybody I know, love and work with. It’s very tempting to keep responding to the outrage du jour. It’s also a recipe for exhaustion.
What I really hope we can do in this new environment is focus on areas where we know how to win and how to make a difference. Fortunately, there are a number of them, including federal judicial nominations.
The critical role of judges is already in the spotlight in Trump’s first weeks in office. Trump’s reckless orders to do things like freeze federal spending, gut the civil service, end birthright citizenship — and wreck people’s lives — instantly ended up in federal court.
This is exactly what happened with his first-term travel ban, too, and it proves again that judges will be a deciding factor in whether Trump’s slash-and-burn agenda succeeds or fails.
That means Democrats have to do everything they can to stop the most egregious nominees from getting confirmed, hold senators accountable if they vote for unacceptable nominees and make it as difficult as possible for Donald Trump to inflict more damage on the federal judiciary.
The progressive advocacy community that’s built around federal judicial nominations is seasoned and strong. In Trump’s first term, advocates helped to block several nominees who would have brought appalling records to the bench.
Maybe you remember these people:
- Jeffrey Mateer in the Eastern District of Texas, who referred to transgender children as part of “Satan’s plan” and who spoke at a conference organized by a right-wing activist who called for gay people to be executed.
- Ryan Bounds in the 9th Circuit, whose history of race-baiting writing included gems like an accusation that diversity advocates at Stanford believe the “opponent is the white male and his coterie of meanspirited lackeys: ‘oreos,’ ‘twinkies,’ ‘coconuts,’ and the like.”
- Thomas Farr in the Eastern District of North Carolina, an attorney who defended a racist voter suppression law that was struck down in the 4th Circuit by judges noting that its provisions “target African Americans with almost surgical precision.”
- Brett Talley in the Middle District of Alabama, a lawyer who had never once tried a case in court and who appeared to defend the early Ku Klux Klan in online posts. He also had a hobby of ghost hunting, behavior that ordinarily would seem odd for a potential federal judge but actually seems insignificant compared to his other issues.
- And more: Gordon Giampietro in Wisconsin, John O’Connor in Oklahoma and Matthew Petersen in D.C.
I wish we could say that every Trump judicial nominee with extremist views — or a lack of qualifications — was defeated. Many weren’t, and they won’t be this time.
But every single one counts. And every fight counts. There should be no easy path to packing our courts with judges who do not believe that the laws and our Constitution protect all of us.
Trump has more than 50 lifetime judicial vacancies to fill. They include four critically important circuit-level seats. There will be more, and we might even see Supreme Court vacancies if far-right justices decide to step down.
Senate Democrats already know how high the stakes are for judges. Under President Biden, they confirmed 235 outstanding individuals to lifetime seats on the federal bench.
Now, coming into this new Trump administration, Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) stresses that these judges will be “one of our strongest — if not our strongest — barrier against what he [Trump] does.”
That’s true, and Democrats should be proud of the high standards they upheld for judges in Biden’s term. Those standards should not slip one iota. Democratic senators need to be reminded of that when they say they hope to “work with” the White House on judicial nominees. They must insist on filling vacancies with judges and justices with a demonstrated commitment to justice for all.
Svante Myrick is president of People for the American Way.
-
Trump administration funding freeze blocked by federal judge
A federal judge in Rhode Island has formally blocked the Trump administration's spending freeze, saying in it is likely a violation of the Constitution.ABC News - 2d -
Federal judge temporarily blocks Trump's funding freeze
A memo from the Office of Management and Budget ordering a freeze on federal assistance sparked confusion across the country earlier this week.CBS News - 2d -
Judge formally blocks Trump’s federal aid freeze
A federal judge blocked President Trump’s federal aid freeze Friday, finding that Democratic state attorneys general who sued are likely to prevail in their claims that it is illegal. U.S. ...The Hill - 2d -
Judge temporarily halts Trump's federal funding freeze
A federal judge in Washington, D.C., temporarily halted President Trump's federal funding freeze on Tuesday to allow further litigation. Nancy Cook, senior national political correspondent for ...CBS News - 5d -
Federal judge temporarily blocks Trump plan to pause federal aid spending
A federal district judge on Tuesday issued a one-week administrative stay in a case challenging the Trump administration’s plan to freeze federal aid. The Trump administration says its plan to ...NBC News - 5d -
Federal judge temporarily blocks Trump’s halt of federal grants and loans
Administrative stay pauses the government’s action, which would upend nearly every corner of US society, till Monday. A federal judge has temporarily blocked a Trump administration freeze of all ...The Guardian - 5d -
Federal judges slam Trump's Jan. 6 pardons
Following President Trump's sweeping clemency for Jan. 6 defendants, federal judges who presided over cases are letting their discontent be heard. CBS News digital politics reporter Melissa Quinn ...CBS News - Jan. 23 -
Trump plans barrage of Day 1 executive actions on border, energy, federal workforce
President-elect Trump is planning a barrage of executive actions on energy, the border and immigration enforcement on his first day in office, four sources told The Hill. Stephen Miller, incoming ...The Hill - Jan. 19 -
Federal judge allows red states to resume lawsuit against mifepristone
Three Republican-led states will be allowed to move forward with a lawsuit to restrict access to mifepristone, a Texas federal judge ruled Thursday, months after the Supreme Court rejected an ...The Hill - Jan. 16
More from The Hill
-
Marco Rubio taking over as acting head of USAID amid agency turmoil
Secretary of State Marco Rubio is being put in charge of the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) as the Trump administration mulls the future of the agency. Rubio told reporters ...The Hill - 43m -
Halting refugee services endangers new Americans
The decision to end remaining support for eligible refugees is not just cruel but shortsighted.The Hill - 52m -
Ocasio-Cortez: Musk 'raiding US classified information is a grave threat to national security'
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) on Sunday said she was alarmed by reports that tech billionaire Elon Musk was able to gain access to U.S. classified information, saying it poses a “grave ...The Hill - 57m -
Jeffries vows to use government shutdown fight to combat Trump orders
House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-N.Y.) said Monday that Democrats will use the coming battle over government funding as a vehicle to block President Trump’s early efforts to gut federal ...The Hill - 1h -
Warren presses Treasury secretary over Musk access to payments system
Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) sent a letter to Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent on Monday demanding to know what access Elon Musk was given to the federal payments system and what safeguards were ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
Marco Rubio taking over as acting head of USAID amid agency turmoil
Secretary of State Marco Rubio is being put in charge of the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) as the Trump administration mulls the future of the agency. Rubio told reporters ...The Hill - 43m -
Halting refugee services endangers new Americans
The decision to end remaining support for eligible refugees is not just cruel but shortsighted.The Hill - 52m -
Rubio says he is the acting head of USAID
Secretary of State Marco Rubio told reporter traveling in El Salvador with him that he is the acting administrator of the U.S. Agency for International Development and voiced his concerns about the ...NBC News - 56m -
Ocasio-Cortez: Musk 'raiding US classified information is a grave threat to national security'
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) on Sunday said she was alarmed by reports that tech billionaire Elon Musk was able to gain access to U.S. classified information, saying it poses a “grave ...The Hill - 57m -
Jeffries vows to use government shutdown fight to combat Trump orders
House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-N.Y.) said Monday that Democrats will use the coming battle over government funding as a vehicle to block President Trump’s early efforts to gut federal ...The Hill - 1h