Expel Hungary from of the European Union
It’s high time for the European Union to deal with the one member-state that obviously doesn’t belong in the EU: Hungary.
Prime Minister Viktor Orbán’s government rejects just about all the values and principles the EU stands for while remaining the recipient of European largesse. Hungary is getting a free ride.
Article 2 of the Treaty on European Union states that it "is founded on the values of respect for human dignity, freedom, democracy, equality, the rule of law and respect for human rights, including the rights of persons belonging to minorities. These values are common to the member states in a society in which pluralism, non-discrimination, tolerance, justice, solidarity and equality between women and men prevail.”
Orbán’s semi-authoritarian regime openly flouts freedom, democracy, the rule of law, minority rights, pluralism, tolerance and justice. It has repeatedly made it clear that it prefers the company of dictators such as Russia’s illegitimately elected president, Vladimir Putin, to that of the “degenerate West.”
Human rights watchdog Freedom House accuses Prime Minister Viktor Orbán’s Fidesz party of effecting "constitutional and legal changes that have allowed it to consolidate control over the country’s independent institutions." It adds that Fidesz has passed anti-immigrant and anti-gay policies, "as well as laws that hamper the operations of opposition groups, journalists, universities, and nongovernmental organizations that are critical of the ruling party or whose perspectives Fidesz otherwise finds unfavorable.”
Ideally, the EU should show Hungary the door. Unfortunately, there is no mechanism for that. But Article 7 suggests a substitute for expulsion: suspension of Hungary’s voting rights.
As with everything in the EU, the procedure is cumbersome, involving multiple votes by both the European Parliament and Council, some of which need to represent over half of the European population. As Paragraphs 2 and 3 of Article 7 state, “The European Council … may determine the existence of a serious and persistent breach by a member state of the values referred to in Article 2” and “may decide to suspend ... the voting rights of the representative of the government of that member state in the Council.”
So a mechanism exists. All that’s needed is the requisite political will — or the realization that Orbán is progressively transforming the EU into a laughingstock.
Suspending Hungary’s voting rights would bring several immediate advantages. For starters, Europeans could simply ignore Orbán’s incessant ravings against U.S. philanthropist George Soros and Orbán’s love affair with Putin. Some degree of sanity would be reintroduced to EU debates.
Second, the EU could finally do whatever its member states insist they want to do, whether with respect to immigration or minority rights or the Russo-Ukrainian War. The last issue — along with the question of Ukraine’s accession to the EU — could finally be dealt with swiftly and efficiently, without Orbán’s unconstructive interference and indifference to Putin’s violation of international law and everything the EU stands for.
Third, suspending Hungary’s voting rights would send a powerful signal to other EU states, such as Prime Minister Robert Fico’s Slovakia, that the EU takes its core values seriously. Not incidentally, this message would also reach President Trump’s and Putin’s ears.
Suspension just might incline Hungary to follow in Brexit’s footsteps and leave. That would be a shock to the EU, but it would eliminate the expense of supporting an ungrateful country, make the institution more efficient and isolate Orbán.
Alternatively, the dread of being severed from Brussels’s generosity might just inspire Hungarians to kick Orbán out — either at the ballot box or by means of what dictators fear most: people power. Hungary could then become again what it was in 1956 and 1989 — a fighter for freedom and democracy.
Alexander J. Motyl is a professor of political science at Rutgers University-Newark. A specialist on Ukraine, Russia and the USSR, and on nationalism, revolutions, empires and theory, he is the author of 10 books of nonfiction, as well as “Imperial Ends: The Decay, Collapse, and Revival of Empires” and “Why Empires Reemerge: Imperial Collapse and Imperial Revival in Comparative Perspective.”
Topics
-
Orbán says Hungary will poll citizens on Ukraine's EU membership
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán says Hungary will poll its citizens on Ukraine’s potential future membership in the European UnionABC News - Mar. 7 -
Protesters block traffic in Hungary in opposition to law banning LGBTQ+ Pride events
Several thousand protesters have blocked a major thoroughfare in Hungary's capital, opposing a law that effectively bans LGBTQ+ Pride events and restricts the right to assemblyABC News - 2h -
Why Indonesia's new military law is alarming pro-democracy activists and rights groups
Indonesia’s Parliament has unanimously voted to pass a controversial revision of its military law that will expand the armed forces’ role in civilian affairs despite growing opposition from ...ABC News - 4d -
Former DOJ attorney: Trump ‘determined’ to demolish the rule of law’
Liz Oyer, a former pardon attorney for the Department of Justice (DOJ), said she believes President Trump is “determined” to “demolish the rule of law.” Oyer, who was ousted from the DOJ earlier ...The Hill - Mar. 18 -
Fears for human rights as Peru passes ‘simply brutal’ anti-NGO law
Experts say legislation will prevent vulnerable people from accessing justice in latest government-backed crackdown. Human rights groups in Peru have voiced alarm over a controversial anti-NGO law ...The Guardian - Mar. 14 -
Trump threatens big tariffs on European Union's alcohol
President Trump is threatening a steep tariff on all alcohol from the European Union after a retaliatory tariff on popular U.S. goods was announced. CBS MoneyWatch correspondent Kelly O'Grady reports.CBS News - Mar. 13 -
Democracy Is on the Line in Israel and America
The rule of law is in danger in both America and Israel if some red lines are not drawn and defended.The New York Times - Mar. 17 -
Democrats: Defend the rule of law, not oligarchs
Enforcing the laws on behalf of consumers, workers and small businesses isn’t just the right thing to do — it is also a powerful political signal.The Hill - Mar. 14 -
Details on Trump's threat of 200% tariff on alcohol from European Union
The Dow lost more than 500 points Thursday and the Nasdaq dropped more than 300 as investors reacted to President Trump's threat to impose a 200% tariff on European Union exports of wine, ...CBS News - Mar. 14
More from The Hill
-
Clinton World takes victory lap after Trump war plans group chat
When the news broke on Monday that a group of top Trump administration officials had convened a text chat to discuss classified information including war plans, those who worked for Hillary Clinton ...The Hill - 41m -
Trump orders declassification of FBI’s Russia investigation
President Trump on Tuesday signed a memorandum directing the declassification of FBI files related to the investigation into his 2016 campaign's potential ties to Russia. The memorandum calls for ...The Hill - 3h -
In Trump versus the Constitution, Congress is backing the wrong side
We urgently need our courts and our elected officials, Democrats and Republicans, to reaffirm the checks and balances designed to prevent abuses of power by any president.The Hill - 1d -
Carville on Schumer CR vote: ‘This might turn out to be a wiser decision than people think’
Democratic strategist James Carville weighed in on Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer’s (N.Y.) decision to vote in favor of the House GOP-led continuing resolution, saying it might turn out to ...The Hill - Mar. 18 -
Trump brushes off group chat controversy as Democrats rail at Cabinet
President Trump offered the rare acknowledgment of a slipup by his Cabinet on Tuesday as Washington was gripped by the fallout from a stunning group chat-gone-public. Democrats assailed two members ...The Hill - 49m
More in Politics
-
White House will make sure Signal group chat incident never happens again, says top GOP lawmaker
House Majority Whip Rep. Tom Emmer (R-Minn.) joined Meet the Press NOW to discuss the group chat in which members of the Trump administration discussed plans to launch airstrikes against Houthi ...NBC News - 1h -
Steve Kornacki: Wisconsin Supreme Court race will test Democrat’s off-year turnout 'advantage'
NBC News National Political Correspondent Steve Kornacki digs into battleground Wisconsin ahead of the state’s Supreme Court election.NBC News - 1h -
Trump administration has 'very little concern' with national security team after group chat leak
NBC News Correspondents Vaughn Hillyard and Courtney Kube join Meet the Press NOW to discuss the fallout after the editor-in-chief of The Atlantic was mistakenly added to a group chat with White ...NBC News - 2h -
Trump defends national security team after journalist added to chat on Yemen strike
President Trump defended his national security team as an "amazing group" after a journalist from The Atlantic revealed he was inadvertently added to a Signal chat about military plans for strikes ...NBC News - 3h -
Thune says Senate may hold hearings on Houthi strike chat
Senate Majority Leader John Thune said he expects the Senate Armed Services Committee to hold hearings and question national security officials involved in a Signal group chat discussing U.S. ...NBC News - 3h