Exclusive: ACLU asks Congress to investigate plans to fire 'probationary' federal employees
![Exclusive: ACLU asks Congress to investigate plans to fire 'probationary' federal employees](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/02/usaid_protest_020325gn09_w.jpg?w=900)
The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) is asking Congress to investigate the Trump administration's plans for “imminent mass layoffs” of as many as 200,000 employees hired within the last two years ago.
The letter comes as departments across government have been asked to assemble a list of employees still on probation after being hired. The probationary period lasts one or two years, depending on the agency.
The ACLU said Trump administration officials have “repeatedly made clear that they intend to reshape the federal workforce for their own partisan political purposes.”
“We respectfully urge that you investigate the Administration’s rationale and legal basis for these planned layoffs. … Mass layoffs of federal employees of the sort that have been reported to be under consideration are presumptively and inherently illegal,” the ACLU wrote to the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee.
The ACLU argues the law requires reviewing each employee’s performance on a case-by-case basis, while any large-scale firings would have to follow existing law for shrinking the workforce.
Despite their probationary status, the employees are still afforded much of the same protections as the broader federal workforce, meaning they must be informed of “inadequacies” in their performance before being fired.
“While the law allows for the termination of probationary employees for performance or conduct reasons, a mass firing on this scale without any sort of individualized assessment or following of Reduction in Force (RIF) procedures raises serious legal concerns,” the ACLU wrote to the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee.
“RIF decisions similarly cannot be motivated by partisan political reasons. Any effort to sidestep RIF procedures or apply political litmus tests to their employment status would violate federal law,” they added, noting reductions in force laws require a 60-day advance notice to employees.
The plan to remove probationary employees is just one of a number of sweeping actions to reshape the workforce.
The Office of Personnel Management has also offered nearly all government employees the option to take a buyout. Though the offer promises eight months of pay and benefits for those wishing to leave federal service, the proposed contract contains numerous conflicting statements and would leave employees with little recourse to challenge any fallout from the deal — including if it is not funded.
And President Trump also signed an order reigniting his Schedule F mandate, now dubbed Schedule P/C, that creates a new class of federal employees — directing agencies to reassign career policy staff to new positions where they could be hired and fired like political appointees.
The move has sparked fear the Trump administration will use the new employee class to remove career civil servants and replace them with political appointees, who would then have greater control over what have traditionally been nonpartisan roles.
The letter from the ACLU defended the current merit-based hiring system.
“Everyone in America relies on the professional and skilled federal employees who serve our communities,” it wrote.
“We need the people in these and so many other critical roles selected for their professionalism not for loyalty or cronyism. At this perilous moment, we urge that you make clear that the Trump Administration cannot violate existing laws and purge probationary employees government-wide based on partisan political objectives, rather than merit.”
More from The Hill
-
Environmental justice staff put on leave at EPA
{beacon} Energy & Environment Energy & Environment The Big Story Environmental justice staff put on leave at EPA The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has put more than 160 workers who ...The Hill - 33m -
Trump delayed tariffs on low-cost packages from China
President Trump signed an executive order this week that temporarily prevents low-cost packages from China from being slapped with his new tariffs. The move delays the suspension of the de minimis ...The Hill - 48m -
Judge to issue ‘very limited’ order temporarily pausing USAID purge
A federal judge said Friday he intends to temporarily block the Trump administration’s plan to place thousands of U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) employees on leave at midnight. ...The Hill - 1h -
Evening Report — GOP spending fight lands at Super Bowl
Presented by Becker & Poliakoff — President Trump and Speaker Mike Johnson will attend the game Sunday as unruly House Republicans squabble over spending {beacon} Evening Report TRUMP FIRST 100 ...The Hill - 1h -
Recap: Trump, Ishiba talk trade; Trump says we will have relations with North Korea
President Trump is hosting Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba on Friday in the second visit by a foreign leader to the White House this week. Trump will host a joint press conference with ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
Is the Trump administration's buyout offer to federal employees legal?
The legality of the Trump administration’s buyout offer is shrouded in uncertainty as questions remain over whether it is even valid without Congress’ approval.NBC News - 13m -
Environmental justice staff put on leave at EPA
{beacon} Energy & Environment Energy & Environment The Big Story Environmental justice staff put on leave at EPA The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has put more than 160 workers who ...The Hill - 33m -
Trump delayed tariffs on low-cost packages from China
President Trump signed an executive order this week that temporarily prevents low-cost packages from China from being slapped with his new tariffs. The move delays the suspension of the de minimis ...The Hill - 48m -
New Jersey, Virginia gubernatorial elections could give insight to voters’ stance on Trump agenda
Cook Political Report Senate and Governors Editor Jessica Taylor joins Meet the Press NOW to discuss the state of governor’s races in 2025 and 2026.NBC News - 1h -
Judge to issue ‘very limited’ order temporarily pausing USAID purge
A federal judge said Friday he intends to temporarily block the Trump administration’s plan to place thousands of U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) employees on leave at midnight. ...The Hill - 1h