Engaging Iran: Does Trump have a real plan?
For obvious reasons, in the ever-turbulent saga of U.S.-Iran relations, President Trump’s claim to have sent a letter to Iran’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, is the latest twist in a long-running drama. Trump’s announcement, made during a Fox Business interview, was characteristically brash.
“I wrote them a letter saying, I hope you are going to negotiate,” he said, adding that Iran could either “handle” the U.S. militarily or “make a deal.”
The president’s remarks were accompanied by his trademark mix of threats and vague promises, leaving observers to wonder whether this was a genuine diplomatic overture or merely another piece of political theater. Trump stated, "I wrote them a letter saying, I hope you are going to negotiate," before veering into an awkward gaffe — referring to "Khomeini" instead of Khamenei, mistakenly invoking the name of Iran’s long-deceased revolutionary founder.
Media reports claim that the letter had been "written" but not sent, while Iran’s government officials flatly denied having received any such correspondence. This episode underscores the performative nature of Trump’s diplomacy, where grand gestures often precede — or outright replace — substantive engagement.
This is not the first time a U.S. president has attempted direct outreach to Iran’s supreme leader. Barack Obama, in a more serious effort at diplomacy, sent two letters to Khamenei. Even Trump previously relied on intermediaries, such as former Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, who in 2019 delivered a message to Tehran only to have Khamenei reject it outright.
The leader’s refusal reflected a deep-seated distrust that has only grown since Trump unilaterally withdrew from the Obama administration's Iran nuclear deal — the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action in 2018 — dismantling years of multilateral negotiations and reimposing crippling sanctions on Iran. The timing of Trump’s claim about the letter is notable. Trump’s approach also suffers from a fundamental contradiction. On the same day he spoke about his desire for negotiations, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, promised even harsher economic restrictions on Iran.
Speaking at the Economic Club of New York, Bessent vowed that a second Trump administration would "shut down Iran’s oil sector and drone manufacturing capabilities" and further sever the country’s access to the international financial system.
This contradiction — the offer of dialogue alongside threats of escalated economic warfare — only further reinforces Iran’s skepticism toward any overtures from Washington. The Iranians have been very clear that they will not negotiate while being pressured. Khamenei has often called the talks with the U.S. “unwise, unintelligent and dishonorable” and this is in concordance with the cultural disposition of the Iranians who have been brought up to suspect the West.
From the 1953 CIA-sponsored coup that restored the Shah to the imposition of sanctions, Tehran has never seen Washington as anything but a country that wants only to take and has no intention of giving in return.
Trump has always had a combination of threat and compromise with respect to Iran. Although he claims to have a primary interest in preventing Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons, his actions suggest something different. After throwing away the nuclear deal — an agreement that put the most stringent nuclear material oversight program on Iran — Trump effectively pulled away the very mechanism of ensuring Iranian compliance. Instead, his administration adopted a policy of maximum pressure to induce Iran to give up its missile program and cut ties with regional powers such as Hezbollah and the Houthis.
Publicizing a letter before it reaches its intended recipient is an unusual diplomatic move, one that analysts suggest is more about optics than genuine diplomacy. If Trump were serious about negotiations, he would not simultaneously be threatening military action or boasting about crippling sanctions. Iran, having weathered years of economic isolation, is unlikely to be swayed by media theatrics.
Moreover, there is no clear evidence that Trump’s military threats carry much weight. A full-scale U.S. attack on Iran’s nuclear facilities would be quite challenging due to the fact that the country has spread out its nuclear facilities. Any such action would inevitably lead to a severe Iranian counter-response and further escalate the conflict in the region and beyond. The risks are much higher than the potential gains, and yet Trump continues to wield the threat of force as a rhetorical tool.
The broader context of U.S.-Iran relations suggests that Trump’s latest maneuver is unlikely to yield results. Washington’s withdrawal from the nuclear deal not only alienated Iran but also fractured Western unity on the issue. While European signatories initially attempted to salvage the deal, they eventually began imposing their own restrictions on Tehran, contributing to its slow demise.
In response, Iran started rolling back its own commitments in 2020, having concluded that the West had already abandoned its obligations. Iranian leaders, meanwhile, remain defiant. Foreign Minister Abbas Araqhchi dismissed reports of Trump’s letter, stating unequivocally that no such communication had been received. Iranian Parliament Speaker Mohammad-Baqer Qalibaf reinforced this stance, emphasizing that Tehran will not rely on U.S. engagement to resolve its economic challenges. Instead, he argued that Iran should focus on strengthening its domestic economy and fostering ties with non-Western powers.
Trump, for all his self-styled deal-making prowess, has yet to demonstrate a coherent strategy for dealing with Iran. His approach oscillates between threats and vague promises of negotiation, all while deepening Iran’s economic and military resolve. If his goal is to prevent Iran from advancing its nuclear program, his policies have thus far achieved the opposite. By dismantling the Iran nuclear deal, he removed constraints on Iran’s uranium enrichment.
By imposing harsher sanctions, he strengthened hardliners in Tehran who argue that engagement with Washington is futile. Iran’s response to Trump’s letter — whether real or imagined — reflects a broader trend in its foreign policy. The Islamic Republic has long viewed negotiations with the U.S. as a trap, a means for Washington to extract concessions without offering meaningful guarantees. This perception has only hardened in the Trump era, with officials across Iran’s political spectrum voicing deep skepticism toward any overtures from Washington.
As Trump continues to flirt with the idea of renewed talks, the reality remains unchanged: meaningful diplomacy requires trust, consistency, and a willingness to compromise — qualities that have been in short supply these days.
Imran Khalid is a physician and has a master’s degree in international relations.
Topics
-
Trump says he sent a letter to Iran's supreme leader over country's advancing nuclear program
U.S. President Donald Trump says he sent a letter to Iran’s Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, something not immediately confirmed by the supreme leaderABC News - Mar. 7 -
An Emirati diplomat identified as having a letter from Trump meets with Iran's foreign minister
An Emirati diplomat earlier identified by Tehran as carrying a letter from U.S. President Donald Trump seeking to jump-start talks over Iran’s rapidly advancing nuclear program has met with Iran’s ...ABC News - 4d -
Iran’s Supreme Leader Rebuffs Trump’s Outreach Over Its Nuclear Program
Ayatollah Ali Khamenei decried “bullying governments” in an apparent response to a letter the White House sent to Iran earlier in the week.The New York Times - Mar. 9 -
Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei rejects talks with the U.S.
Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei said talks between the two countries would be aimed at imposing restrictions on Iranian missile range and its influence in the region.CBS News - Mar. 8 -
Iran’s supreme leader rails against Trump’s ‘bullying’ military threat
Ayatollah Khamenei says US demand to reopen talks on Iran’s nuclear programme is aimed at domination. Iran’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, has criticised what he described as bullying ...The Guardian - Mar. 8 -
Waltz: All options 'on the table' to ensure Iran does not have a nuclear weapon
National security adviser Mike Waltz said on Sunday that all options are “on the table” to prevent Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon. In an interview on ABC News’s “This Week,” anchor Martha ...The Hill - 20h -
Trump says he sent a letter to Iran urging negotiations on nuclear weapons
"There are two ways Iran can be handled, militarily or you make a deal. I would prefer to make a deal," Trump told Fox host Maria Bartiromo.ABC News - Mar. 7 -
Donald Trump: Iran will be held responsible for Houthi attacks
US president says consequences of any future attacks by Yemen’s Tehran-backed rebels will be ‘dire’. The US president, Donald Trump, has declared he will hold Iran directly responsible for any ...The Guardian - 6h -
Can Trump launch Iran nuclear deal 2.0 in second White House term?
Trump sent a letter to Iran's supreme leader expressing his desire for a deal.CNBC - 6d
More from The Hill
-
Trump says Hunter Biden will no longer get Secret Service protection
President Trump said Monday that two of President Biden's children — Hunter Biden and Ashley Biden — would no longer receive protection from the Secret Service. "Please be advised that, effective ...The Hill - 32m -
Trump-Musk allyship defies predictions
Welcome to The Hill's Business & Economy newsletter {beacon} Business & Economy Business & Economy The Big Story Trump-Musk allyship defies predictions President Trump's partnership with ...The Hill - 38m -
Judge lashes out at Trump admin over deportation flights
A federal judge lashed out at the Trump administration Monday for not turning around planes as Venezuelan migrants sued over a plan to deport them under the Alien Enemies Act, and refusing to ...The Hill - 39m -
Trump appoints Charlie Kirk, Walt Nauta, Michael Flynn to military boards
President Trump on Monday announced a slew of allies would be appointed to the Board of Visitors at the nation’s military academies, including lawmakers and conservative media personalities. Trump ...The Hill - 40m -
Trump talks tough on toxics but is rolling back rules
Click for more from The Hill. {beacon} Energy & Environment Energy & Environment The Big Story Trump talks tough on toxics but is rolling back rules President Trump has repeatedly said he’ll ...The Hill - 43m
More in Politics
-
Canadian Amb. to U.S.: 'Nothing is off the table' when responding to Trump tariffs
Canadian Ambassador to the U.S. Kristen Hillman joins Meet the Press NOW to discuss President Trump's threat to impose new tariffs on Canada in April.NBC News - 1h -
Schumer postpones book events due to 'security concerns' amid Democratic backlash over shutdown fight
NBC News Senior National Political Reporter Sahil Kapur joins Meet the Press NOW with the latest animosity between Democrats and Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) as the party fights ...NBC News - 2h -
Steve Kornacki: Democratic Party popularity hits new low in poll
NBC News National Political Correspondent Steve Kornacki joins Meet the Press NOW to discuss the key takeaways from the new NBC News poll looking into the Democratic Party and President Trump's job ...NBC News - 2h -
Trump signs executive order aimed at gutting Voice of America and six other federal agencies
President Donald Trump signed an executive order to gut the parent of U.S. government-funded media outlet Voice of America and six other federal agencies. NBC News' Aaron Gilchrist reports on the ...NBC News - 7h -
Chuck Schumer postpones book events due to 'security concerns' amid Democratic backlash over shutdown fight
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer is postponing several events across the country this week to promote his new book amid Democratic backlash to his handling of last week's government funding fight.NBC News - 8h