Elon Musk was right — Social Security is a Ponzi scheme

There isn’t much these days that doesn’t fling the Democrats into a frenzy of fainting and pearl-clutching.

Want to cut waste, fraud and abuse from government spending? “Oh dear, how draconian!”

Want to secure the border and stem the flow of deadly fentanyl into our country? “Racist!”

The one sure way to guarantee Democrats will oppose something — anything, no matter how popular — is to have President Trump come out in favor of it. And this Pavlovian reaction was on full display when presidential adviser and multibillionaire Elon Musk recently called Social Security “the biggest Ponzi Scheme of all time.” Because that's what it actually is.

Honest people can take issue with some of the moves of Musk's Department of Government Efficiency. He has himself admitted they make mistakes, which is how you can tell this guy is not a politician. He has also established a track record of correcting its mistakes quickly — another sign that he does not fit in well.

On Social Security, however, Musk is simply correct, and just impolitic enough to say what no one wants to hear.

And liberals did not disappoint with their reaction to defend the program's moribund status quo. An opinion writer at NBC News offered a representative non-sequitur defense of how the program operates, arguing that "Social Security is a highly functioning, universal and exceptionally efficient part of the American social safety net. It’s the opposite of a Ponzi scheme."

But the problem is simple and mathematical. When the program started, there were 40 workers paying benefits for every retiree. Now, thanks to a combination of declining fertility, increased longevity and other factors, there are only 2.8 workers per retiree. And so right now, every penny collected from current workers, plus additional money Congress borrows against its rapidly emptying trust fund, is being funneled to the current retirees.

Does this sound familiar? It should, because this roughly is how Ponzi schemes work. They take new investors' money to pay returns to their earlier investors. For a while, people are happy because they are getting paid. But eventually, the scheme collapses, because there are too many people demanding payouts and not enough new contributors.

So no, Social Security isn't “the opposite of a Ponzi scheme.” It is just a Ponzi scheme whose collapse is still in the future.

Tellingly, the communist “People’s World” agrees with NBC News, writing, “Contrary to right-wing slander Social Security is the most efficient program in the United States and would be solvent for at least 75 more years if its wealthiest recipients paid a fair share of their taxes.”

Of course, Democrats have resisted every attempt to reform Social Security to increase its lifespan. The only solution they are willing to accept is a crippling tax increase. They have opposed means-testing, insisting that this would turn the program into welfare rather than an “investment” by enrollees, even though recipients receive more than they pay into it by quite a bit.

The largest, most serious push to reform the program came when President George W. Bush, proposed allowing younger workers to take a small portion of their Social Security withholdings and invest them in the stock market. It would also have had the added benefit of being heritable for their families. Social Security, aside from its modest survivors' benefits, is just plain gone after your retired loved one passes away.

The idea of investing only 5 percent of their withholdings, with the rest remaining in the traditional program, was denounced by Democrats at too risky and possibly leading to people being woefully short on resources in retirement due to the volatility of the stock market.

When Bush proposed enacting this reform in his second term, the Dow Jones Industrial Average stood at less than 11,000. Now it is north of 41,000, even after the downturn of the last few weeks. Just imagine how much better off the vast majority of participants would be if we had offered a voluntary investment option 20 years ago.

The truth is, Social Security is going broke the same way Ponzi schemes do. It has too many beneficiaries and not enough people paying into the system. Today's young workers risk funding others' retirement through Social Security only to be seriously shortchanged when they retire in 30, 20, or perhaps even just 10 years' time.

Some Democrats have been hoping to stave off the date of this scheme's collapse (and perhaps import a few new voters while they're at it) by throwing open our borders to find new contributors — never mind that this overwhelmed our social safety-net and indiscriminately put tens of thousands of dangerous criminals on our streets. But voters just recently rendered judgment on that plan.

Meanwhile, Republicans have helped the Democrats bring this problem to a crisis point by abandoning the reform position. Even Trump, no respecter of political taboos, has hesitated in the face of this problem. But at least some Republicans did try, at various points, to correct the mistakes of the past and stop the bleeding.

On this issue, the truth is no friend to Democrats, which is why they reacted with such vitriol to Musk's comments. But truth does not depend on anyone’s comfort level with it — it just is. And the truth is, if you ran your company’s retirement program the way the government runs Social Security, you would go to jail.

Derek Hunter is host of the Derek Hunter Podcast and a former staffer for the late Sen. Conrad Burns (R-Mont.).

Topics

Elon Musk Suggests DOGE Team Will Scrutinize Social Security and Entitlement Spending

In an interview with Larry Kudlow, Elon Musk claimed that fraud in Social Security and other major programs was “the big one to eliminate.”
The New York Times - 1d
Schumer assails Musk for claiming Social Security rife with fraud

Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer (N.Y.) on Tuesday slammed tech billionaire Elon Musk for claiming that Social Security is plagued by widespread fraud and that as many as 20 million “dead” ...
The Hill - 1d
Why Social Security’s Future Could Be in DOGE’s Hands

Trump promised that Elon Musk’s DOGE wouldn’t touch Social Security. But DOGE is already making cuts to the agency.
Inc. - 3d
Trump, Musk fuel fears of Social Security cuts with 'fraud' talk

President Trump and his billionaire adviser Elon Musk are ratcheting up false rhetoric about Social Security, repeatedly claiming the program wastes hundreds of billions of dollars in fraudulent ...
The Hill - 6h
White House renews Social Security pledge after Musk comments

The White House is trying to assure Americans that President Trump will not make cuts to Social Security and Medicare after adviser Elon Musk went after entitlement spending. {beacon} Health Care ...
The Hill - 17h
White House says Trump won't cut Social Security, Medicare after Musk remarks

The White House on Tuesday asserted President Trump would not cut Social Security or Medicare after tech billionaire Elon Musk's comments about the need to examine entitlement spending gained ...
The Hill - 1d
Ex-Social Security official describes ‘significant’ risk of sensitive data going to wrong hands under DOGE

Tiffany Flick, a former Social Security official, detailed what she sees as a “significant” risk of sensitive government data heading into the wrong hands under Elon Musk’s Department of Government ...
The Hill - 1d
Elon Musk’s X suffers multiple outages

Elon Musk's social media platform X experienced several outages on Monday
CNBC - 1d
Elon Musk says "massive cyberattack" is causing outages at X

Elon Musk's social media site X wasn't working for thousands of users on Monday, with the billionaire claiming a cyberattack.
CBS News - 1d
Elon Musk and Marco Rubio Share Awkward Social Media Embrace After White House Confrontation

Days after Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Elon Musk sparred at the White House, Mr. Rubio announced cuts to foreign aid that Mr. Musk had ordered.
The New York Times - 2d
Tesla faces backlash over Elon Musk's ties to Trump and far-right support

Tesla shares have plunged more than 47% since President Trump's inauguration as criticism mounts over Elon Musk's involvement in the administration and his statements backing far-right views. ...
CBS News - 1d
There Is a Liberal Answer to Elon Musk

Right-wing populism thrives on scarcity. The answer is abundance. But a politics of abundance will work only if Democrats confront where their approach has failed.
The New York Times - 2d
How Elon Musk's Trump support could hurt — or help — Tesla

Elon Musk is both the CEO of the largest U.S. EV maker and the right-hand-man to President Donald Trump. Bears say it's a disaster for Tesla, bulls say a boon.
CNBC - 1d
Musk blames Ukraine for X outage

Presented by Ericsson — Elon Musk said his social media platform X was targeted in a “massive cyberattack” on Monday and later claimed the attack was traced back to Ukraine. {beacon} Technology ...
The Hill - 1d
Social Security's plan to get overpayments back

The Social Security Administration (SSA) announced its plan to recover 100% of overpayments to beneficiaries. CBS News' Lindsey Reiser reports.
CBS News - 1d
How to calculate your Social Security tax obligations

Wondering what you'll pay in taxes on your Social Security benefits? Here's how to do the math.
CBS News - 21h
Believe in Elon Musk’s $1 trillion ‘waste and fraud’ jackpot when you see it

Musk is right about one thing: Absolutely no reasonable person should support waste or fraud in the federal government
MarketWatch - 4h
Musk blames 'massive cyberattack' for X outage

Elon Musk said his social media platform X was targeted in a "massive cyberattack" on Monday, prompting outages for thousands of users. "There was (still is) a massive cyberattack against X," Musk ...
The Hill - 1d
X sees major outages as Musk claims 'massive cyberattack' hit platform

Three separate outages appeared to hit Elon Musk's X social media site Monday, as the tech titan claimed it was suffering a "massive cyberattack."
NBC News - 1d
Elon Musk Says X Outages Were Caused by a Cyberattack From Ukraine

The billionaire’s social media site X suffered outages, and Tesla’s stock tanked on Monday.
The New York Times - 1d
Here's what to know about Social Security's new overpayment rule

The policy could lead to hardship for some elderly Americans, Social Security advocates say. Here's what to know.
CBS News - 1d
How Elon Musk Uses Internet Slang to Marshal His Army of Online Fans

Mr. Musk uses online slang to marshal his 200 million social media followers in support of his efforts to gut the federal government. But he might be reaching his limits.
The New York Times - 5d
Social Security payments scrutinized by DOGE amid search for fraud

DOGE is sifting through Social Security payments in an anti-fraud effort that has some worried the administration could deny payments to vulnerable older Americans.
ABC News - 2d
How the Social Security Administration plans to take back overpayments to Americans

The Social Security Administration plans to take back overpayments to beneficiaries from their upcoming checks. CBS MoneyWatch associate managing editor Aimee Picchi has more.
CBS News - 19h
Senators to Trump Social Security nominee: 'You will be responsible' if benefits are interrupted

As the Social Security Administration cuts staff, that could impact the agency's ability to pay millions of benefit checks each month, Democratic senators warn.
CNBC - 2h
Elon Musk calls Sen. Mark Kelly a 'traitor' over his social media posts in support of Ukraine

Kelly, a former Navy combat pilot, responded to the tech billionaire’s remark by saying “he’s not a serious guy” and should “go back to building rockets.”
NBC News - 1d
Elon Musk’s Neuralink Files to Trademark ‘Telepathy’

The brain implant company cofounded by Elon Musk is moving to trademark several product names, including Telepathy and Telekinesis.
Wired - 4d
Unions ask court to stop DOGE from accessing Social Security data of millions of Americans

A group of labor unions asked a federal court for an emergency order to stop DOGE from accessing sensitive Social Security data.
NBC News - 4d
Rules for repaying Social Security benefits are about to get stricter. Here's what to know

Social Security beneficiaries who receive more money than they are owed will now face a 100% default withholding rate from their monthly checks, the agency said.
CNBC - 1d
Elon Musk Has Wanted the Government Shutdown

Sources tell WIRED that Elon Musk has wanted a government shutdown in part because it would potentially make it easier to eliminate the jobs of hundreds of thousands of federal workers.
Wired - 23h
Elon Musk's feud with OpenAI CEO Sam Altman, explained

Elon Musk's legal dispute against OpenAI could affect the future of one of the most prominent leaders in artificial intelligence.
Los Angeles Times - 2d
What Elon Musk’s Suit Says About Trump and Power

When Elon Musk puts on a nice suit, it has a way of looking like a demotion.
The New York Times - 19h
Trump defends Elon Musk, DOGE cuts to federal workforce

President Trump defended Elon Musk and DOGE over the weekend after reported rifts between Musk and Cabinet members. CBS News White House reporter Olivia Rinaldi has more.
CBS News - 2d
Million-dollar wage earners have already stopped paying into Social Security for 2025

In 2025, Social Security payroll taxes apply to wages up to $176,100. Workers with $1 million in annual wages have already stopped paying those taxes for the year.
CNBC - 4d
Rules for repaying Social Security benefits are about to get stricter. Here's what to know.

If you receive more Social Security benefits than you are owed, you may face a 100% default withholding rate from your monthly checks once a new policy goes into effect.
NBC News - 1d
Tesla facilities across the country attacked in protest of Elon Musk

A wave of anti-Tesla attacks have occurred as Elon Musk takes a leading role in President Trump's cost-cutting task force known as DOGE.
CBS News - 3d
'SNL' taps into cynicism over Elon Musk's White House influence

Questions about tech investor Elon Musk's extraordinary influence in President Donald Trump's White House found answers that doubled as punchlines on "Saturday Night Live."
NBC News - 3d
Sen. Mark Kelly says Elon Musk is "not a serious guy"

Elon Musk called Sen. Mark Kelly a "traitor" after the Arizona Democrat posted on X about his recent trip to Ukraine.
CBS News - 21h
Trump buys a Tesla from Elon Musk at the White House

President Donald Trump bought a Tesla from Elon Musk at the White House. Trump declared the vehicles “beautiful” and in particular praised the company’s unusually designed Cybertruck.
NBC News - 18h