Election fraud and the Bob Good Effect
![Election fraud and the Bob Good Effect](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/06/AP24082500423769-e1718791972670.jpg?w=900)
Last week began with allegations of election fraud by Rep. Bob Good (R) in Virginia's 5th Congressional District primary race, yet another false claim evincing a deeply troubling trend in American politics.
Good, trailing his Donald Trump-backed opponent, John McGuire, by a slim margin, has resorted to what strongly appears to be thoroughly baseless allegations of irregularities, including a debunked conspiracy theory about precinct evacuations due to fires.
We all need to stop and think about what’s going on here. What Bob Good is doing is furthering a pattern of behavior that has become increasingly common in recent years, particularly among candidates aligned with the Make America Great Again (MAGA) movement.
Good's actions mirror those of Trump, who famously contested the results of the 2020 presidential election without evidence. Trump began laying the groundwork for these claims months before the election, making over 150 statements about fraudulent ballots and the alleged dangers of mail-in voting starting in April 2020. After the election results began to indicate Trump's potential loss, he intensified his efforts to construct a narrative of a stolen election, claiming widespread fraud perpetrated by Democrats.
Despite the lack of concrete evidence to support these claims, the belief in a fraudulent 2020 election became a central tenet of the MAGA movement. This narrative persisted even after numerous investigations and court cases failed to substantiate any widespread fraud. The unwavering faith in these claims, despite factual refutation, demonstrates the power of belief over rational argument and evidence.
To have actual election fraud, we need illegal interference with the voting process that aims to manipulate the outcome of an election. To constitute actual election fraud, two key legal conditions must be met.
First, there must be intentional and deliberate action to subvert the electoral process. This can include activities like ballot box stuffing, voter intimidation, tampering with voting machines, or deliberately miscounting votes. The action must be willful and purposeful, not accidental or due to human error.
Second, the fraudulent activity must have the potential to affect the election results. While it's not necessary to prove that the fraud actually changed the outcome, there needs to be a reasonable possibility that it could have influenced the final tally. Additionally, the activity must violate specific election laws or regulations, which can vary by jurisdiction.
Historically, instances of genuine, widespread election fraud in the United States have been rare. When they have occurred, they've been thoroughly investigated and addressed. For example, the 1927 Poughkeepsie mayoral election saw widespread fraud, including ballot box stuffing and voter intimidation, leading to a new election. In 1997, a Miami mayoral election was overturned due to absentee ballot fraud.
Real election fraud in the United States is actually a very rare beast. These isolated incidents pale in comparison to the sweeping, unsubstantiated claims we see today. The current trend of crying "fraud" at the slightest hint of an unfavorable outcome threatens to undermine the very foundations of our democracy.
I see several important factors contributing to the prevalence of these baseless claims:
Political polarization
As the divide between political parties deepens, losing candidates find it easier to convince their base that the other side must have cheated.
Social media echo chambers
Misinformation spreads rapidly online, allowing conspiracy theories to gain traction quickly.
Erosion of trust in institutions
Declining faith in government and media makes people more susceptible to alternative narratives.
The Trump effect
The former president's persistent false claims about the 2020 election have normalized this behavior for many politicians.
Lack of consequences
Politicians who make false claims often face little to no repercussions, encouraging others to follow suit.
It’s hard to overstate the dangers of this trend to cry political wolf. It undermines public confidence in elections, potentially leading to decreased voter turnout and civil unrest. It also strains election officials and systems, diverting resources from genuine improvements to addressing baseless claims.
To combat this issue moving forward, we need a multi-faceted approach built on the foundation of carrots and sticks.
The first stick needs to be strong penalties for knowingly false election fraud claims. A big fine, at an absolute minimum, is a start.
But that’s only the start. We need to talk about what election fraud actually is so it’s not this amorphous, incomprehensible thing. Part of that needs to be far greater transparency in election administration, as well as actual and functional bipartisan condemnation of baseless fraud allegations.
The more we talk about what election fraud is and isn’t, the more we help people critically evaluate information that allows them to better understand what is on the line of politics and election administration and what is on the line of legal fraud.
Aron Solomon is the chief strategy officer for Amplify. He has taught entrepreneurship at McGill University and the University of Pennsylvania.
Date: |
Topics
Filter
-
Yahoo Sports - Sports
Yahoo Sports AM: The Caitlin Clark Effect
In today's edition: The Caitlin Clark Effect, $100M NBA players are on the horizon, Team USA's American football failure, and more. -
Yahoo News - World
Third defendant in Wirecard fraud case to testify for first time
-
The New York Times - Lifestyle
‘The Bear’ Gets a Glow Up. Is That a Good Thing?
Styles staffers talk about the show’s turn to fine dining and its flashy cameos. -
MarketWatch - Business
A Trump trade war won’t be good for the stock market, warns Dr. Doom
Nouriel Roubini, the economist who is nicknamed “Dr. Doom” for his often-gloomy predictions, says a Trump win could spark a stock-damaging trade war.Donald Trump -
NBC News - Top stories
Clothing chain Bob's Stores closing after 70 years
Bob's Stores, a longtime Northeast clothing store chain, announced this week that it is shutting down amid a bankruptcy filing. -
The Guardian - World
Moisés Caicedo’s form at the Copa América is good news for Chelsea
The midfielder has been Ecuador’s best player. They need him at his best against Argentina in the quarter-finals. By Ben McAleer for WhoScored. The pressure was on Moisés Caicedo to make an immediate impact following his big-money move last ... -
CBS News - Top stories
Bob Menendez's defense rests without senator testifying in bribery trial
Jurors are expected to have the case by the end of next week. -
NBC News - Politics
Sen. Bob Menendez declines to testify in his bribery trial as the defense rests
Defense attorneys in Sen. Bob Menendez’s federal bribery trial rested their case Wednesday without the New Jersey Democrat taking the stand. -
CNBC - Business
Romance scams cost consumers $1.14 billion last year. It's a 'more insidious' fraud, expert says
Cyber criminals are tapping into wealth accounts through human connection. Here's how to spot it and cut ties as soon as you can. -
Yahoo Sports - Sports
Disney CEO Bob Iger and Willow Bay close to purchasing controlling stake in NWSL club Angel City FC: Reports
Iger and Bay will replace Reddit co-founder Alexis Ohanian as majority owner of the team, which is worth a reported $300 million.
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Van Jones says Democrats are discussing 'how' to replace Biden, 'not whether'
Former Obama administration official Van Jones said Wednesday that Democrats, behind closed doors, are discussing “how” to replace President Biden at the top of the ticket, “not whether.” The CNN commentator said the Democrats who defend Biden on ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Former California Senator says Biden should get two weeks to prove himself after debate
Former California Sen. Barbara Boxer said President Biden should get two weeks to prove to the American people that he’s up for the job of president, amid concerns about his standing at the top of the Democratic ticket. In an interview with Los ...California -
The Hill - Politics
Majority of Americans don't think Trump will concede if he loses election: poll
According to a new poll, a majority of Americans said they do not “think” former President Trump is going to “accept the results and concede once the votes have been certified” if he does not win the upcoming presidential election. The CNN poll, ...Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Governors after Biden meeting: We have his back
A small group of Democratic governors affirmed their support for President Biden following a White House meeting with the president on Wednesday amid growing Democratic calls for him to drop out of the race. “The feedback was, we are all looking ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
White House explains 'We finally beat Medicare' debate flub
The White House on Wednesday explained what President Biden meant when he misspoke and said “We finally beat Medicare” in last week’s presidential debate. “He meant to say he beat big pharma,” White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre said in ...