Efforts to save Department of Education move to courts

Defenders of the Department of Education are turning to the courts to save it after President Trump signed an executive order to abolish it and on Friday said he would move some of its most critical loan programs to the Small Business Administration (SBA).

Trump cannot abolish the department without an act of Congress, and it is not clear that legislation doing so could get through Congress.

Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-La.) nonetheless on Friday said he would seek legislation to end the department, even as Trump through executive action attempts to hollow out a government agency that had more than 4,000 employees just months ago.

“I expect that any actions to shutter the agency or to dismantle it will be challenged in the courts, and those challenges will prevail,” Julie Margetta Morgan, a former deputy under secretary of Education during the Biden administration, told The Hill earlier this month.

“I think the other thing to think about here is that the decision to dismantle the Department of Education is incredibly unpopular, and people need to continue to voice their concerns about that and their displeasure with the Trump administration’s efforts and to hold policymakers accountable," she added.

"See you in court” was a common theme among opponents as Trump ordered Education Secretary Linda McMahon to dismantle the department as far as she is legally allowed without an act of Congress.

The White House says “critical functions” of the department will still be met, with the president announcing Friday that he is shifting "the student loan portfolio" to the SBA and programs related to students with disabilities to the Department of Health and Human Services.

But the department is already facing pushback for its efforts to self-eliminate, including laying off half its staff earlier this month.

The legal challenges to Trump and McMahon's moves could quickly stack up. The courts have already hit Trump with multiple setbacks two months into his term, though the White House has voiced disdain for the judges ruling against his agenda.

“The courts are upholding the rule of law, that is their role. At the end of the day, we are the United States, because we abide by the rule of law. This administration has shown that it doesn't respect the rule of law; they are aiming more toward an autocracy, which is radically outside American values,” said Patrice Willoughby, chief of policy and legislative affairs for the NAACP.

“The department’s useful functions … will be preserved, fully preserved,” Trump said during Thursday's signing ceremony, surrounded by children at school desks and standing in front of a row of state flags. Specifically referring to Pell Grants, Title I funding and programs for students with disabilities, he added, "They’re going to be preserved in full and redistributed to various other agencies and departments."

“But beyond these core necessities, my administration will take all lawful steps to shut down the department. We’re going to shut it down and shut it down as quickly as possible."

The potential lawsuits would add to the growing fight the Trump administration is having with the judiciary as many of his executive orders have been halted or reversed by federal judges.

Trump is already calling for the impeachment of one judge who has displeased him, drawing a rare rebuke from Chief Justice John Roberts.

“I think there's an expectation that there will be a lawsuit, and this will go before the courts. [...] It takes a long time, and there's a real question on whether this administration wants to even comply with the court's decision. They seem to do it when it's on their behalf, but less so when the decision goes against them,” said Denise Forte, president and CEO at The Education Trust.

Johnathan Smith, chief of staff and general counsel for National Center for Youth Law, previously told The Hill his group was preparing to use "all the tools at our disposal, including litigation here, to respond" if moves were made to close the department.

And Keri Rodrigues, the president of the National Parents Union, said parents are watching the moves at the Department of Education closely and "the minute" the agency doesn't comply with congressional statute, the department "will be challenged in court."

In further dismantling the federal agency, McMahon will have to walk a tight rope in order to ensure it is complying with congressional requirements, and even some in conservative circles have expressed skepticism at the speed at which the administration is moving.

"There are good reasons to streamline operations at the department and even to shut it down entirely, but efforts to date have been too hasty. The cuts we've already seen will likely be disruptive in ways that weren't expected. Department leadership should take pains to carry out this order cautiously, ensuring that programs mandated by legislation are transferred to other agencies before the staffing reduction makes them impossible to administer effectively,” said Beth Akers, senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.

Trump could theoretically have an easier time in the courts if Congress is able to pass a law either eliminating the department or allowing for it to be weakened, but such a measure would require some Democratic support to clear the Senate, and not even all Republicans are on board.

“My sense is that congressional Republicans really don't want anything to do with this idea of dismantling the department right now [...] I just don't think this is the hill that anyone wants to die on today, other than President Trump. So, I don't think he's going to get the support from Congress that would be needed,” Akers said.

“I would say in practice, though, there's a lot of dismantling that can be done under the existing authority of the administration, and it may be de facto dismantled, even if it still exists in name,” she added.

Topics

Department of Education cuts half its workforce

The Department of Education cut half its workforce amid President Trump’s effort to abolish the agency. Trump touted the cuts, saying they shift responsibilities away from the federal bureaucracy ...
NBC News - Mar. 12
Trump’s order to dismantle education department sparks outrage: ‘See you in court’

Politicians and teachers unions condemn president’s effort to axe department, which can only be done by Congress. Teachers unions and Democratic politicians joined in denouncing Donald Trump ’s ...
The Guardian - 1d
Trump moves against Department of Education: What to know

President Trump signed an executive order Thursday directing Education Secretary Linda McMahon to dismantle the Department of Education as much as she can, carving a path of legislative and legal ...
The Hill - 2d
Watch live: Students rally against Trump moves to dismantle Department of Education

A group of student demonstrators are holding a "sit in" at the Department of Education on Friday to protest President Trump's executive actions to shutter the department. Trump on Thursday signed ...
The Hill - 1d
Dismantling Education Department could cause chaos, experts warn

Trump administration effort to wind down the Education Department could lead to frustration for millions of student loan borrowers, experts say.
CBS News - 15h
Department of Education lays off nearly half of workforce

The Department of Education announced Tuesday it was firing nearly half of its workforce, the latest Trump administration move to shrink the federal government that could face swift legal ...
The Hill - Mar. 11
CBC: Trump's Department of Education order part of 'rampage' against civil institutions

The Congressional Black Caucus (CBC) on Thursday strongly condemned President Trump’s executive order to dismantle the Department of Education, saying the move will only hurt the nation’s public ...
The Hill - 1d
DNC chair: Trump told students 'he doesn't give a damn about them' with move against Department of Education

Democratic National Committee (DNC) Chair Ken Martin said President Trump told students “he doesn't give a damn about them” with a recent move against the Department of Education. “Today, Donald ...
The Hill - 2d
Trump's move to dismantle education department was a conservative dream for decades

Conservatives in the US have long argued that control over education should lie with the states.
BBC News - 2d
Dem AGs sue over Trump administration’s Education Department layoffs

Democratic attorneys general in Washington, D.C., and 20 states sued Thursday over the Trump administration’s efforts to lay off nearly half of the Education Department workforce. Earlier this ...
The Hill - Mar. 13
Top House Democrats urge McMahon, Trump administration to reverse decision on Department of Education

Top House Democrats urged Education Secretary Linda McMahon and the Trump administration to reverse a Thursday move to begin dismantling the Department of Education. “Students, teachers, and ...
The Hill - 2d
Education Department investigating dozens of universities after DEI warning letter

The Education Department announced Friday it is investigating more than 50 colleges and universities over what it called "racial preferences" in academics or scholarships, a move that comes amid ...
The Hill - Mar. 14
GOP Rep. Mark Harris says Trump has done 'tremendous job' making case against Education Department

Rep. Mark Harris (R-N.C.) said on Tuesday that President Trump successfully made the case against the Department of Education during his 2024 campaign, leading more Republicans to support the ...
The Hill - Mar. 12
Trump’s Anti-DEI Effort Leads to Investigations at Dozens of Universities

The Department of Education announced investigations in a memo warning schools over DEI practices.
Inc. - 6d
Department of Education slashing nearly 50% of workforce; Steel and aluminum tariffs take effect

The Department of Education says half its workers are losing their jobs in a move that Education Secretary Linda McMahon says is meant to ensure "resources are directed where they matter most." CBS ...
CBS News - Mar. 12
Trump signs order to dismantle US education department

The move, which he promised to do on the campaign trail, is already facing legal challenges.
BBC News - 2d
Trump Cleaves Student Loan and Special Education Services From Education Dept.

President Trump said Friday that he was tasking other government entities with core functions of the Education Department as he moves to dismantle an agency conservatives have long criticized.
The New York Times - 1d
Department of Education staff told offices will be closed Wednesday

The email sent to Department of Education staff said offices will be closed "for security reasons."
CBS News - Mar. 11
Department of Education workforce slashed in half

The Department of Education says more than 2,100 civil service workers will lose their jobs. The department says all of its divisions are impacted by the reduction. NBC News’ Kelly O’Donnell ...
NBC News - Mar. 11
Trump signs executive order dismantling the Department of Education

Watch live coverage as President Trump holds an education event at the White House and signs an executive order that could lead to the dismantling of the Department of Education.
NBC News - 2d
What is the US Department of Education and what does it do?

Donald Trump signed an executive order to undo the federal department on Thursday. Donald Trump has taken the overwhelming step of undoing the Department of Education on Thursday by signing an ...
The Guardian - 2d
Education Department cutting nearly 50% of workforce

The Department of Education said staff affected by the job cuts would be placed on leave starting Friday, March 21.
CBS News - Mar. 12
Education Department cuts agency that measures student performance

Education Department cuts agency that compiles 'Nation's Report Card' and measures student performance.
ABC News - Mar. 13
States sue to block dismantling of Education Department

The lawsuit asks a judge to immediately pause the Trump administration's mass firings and declare that the dismantling of the Department of Education unlawful.
ABC News - Mar. 13
Education Department firings and the search for student Sudiksha Konanki: Morning Rundown

The Education Department is taking its first step toward a shutdown.
NBC News - Mar. 12
Fired Education Department worker: 'We got the sense that we were disposable.'

Joe Murphy worked at the Education Department for almost 20 years.
ABC News - Mar. 13
Trump targets Education Department and Steve Kornacki's NCAA picks: Morning Rundown

Donald Trump is expected to sign an executive order to close the Education Department.
NBC News - 2d
Why does Trump want to close the Department of Education?

President Donald Trump is on his way to fulfill another campaign promise of dismantling the Department of Education. The battle over federal involvement in local education is one that’s been ...
NBC News - 6d
Morning Report — Trump hails Education Department shrinkage

In today’s issue: The Education Department will be dismantled and give states greater autonomy over education, President Trump vowed during a White House event Thursday intended to showcase a ...
The Hill - 1d
Trump says student loans, special needs programs will be moved to new departments

President Donald Trump said Friday that the SBA will take on student loans and HHS will take on special needs and nutrition efforts.
ABC News - 1d
Trump signs executive order to begin dismantling Department of Education

President Trump has taken aim at the Department of Education, but shutting down the department entirely would require an act of Congress.
CBS News - 2d
First steps to dismantle Education Department begin

The Department of Education is cutting its workforce by nearly 50% as the Trump administration proceeds with plans to dismantle the agency. The bulk of the department's responsibilities include ...
CBS News - Mar. 12
Linda McMahon’s haphazard cuts to the Department of Education will be costly

The Trump administration would be wise to reverse course and implement a logical, evidenced-based approach to improving the Department of Education that does not harm children now or in the future.
The Hill - 5d
Trump to sign order Thursday dismantling Department of Education

President Trump is expected to sign an order on Thursday to launch the Department of Education's dismantling. A White House official told NewsNation that the anticipated executive order, first ...
The Hill - 3d
Trump signs executive order to dismantle the Education Department

Trump signed an executive order directing Education Secretary Linda McMahon to dismantle the department. Complete elimination would require congressional approval.
NBC News - 2d
Democratic Attorneys General Sue Over Gutting of Education Department

The Trump administration cut about half the agency’s work force, saying the move would enable it to deliver services more effectively. The attorneys general called the layoffs “reckless and illegal.”
The New York Times - Mar. 13
Department of Education cuts expected to have 'huge impacts' on teachers

After the Department of Education gutted nearly 50% of its workforce, educators have expressed deep concern -- not only for students' futures but for their own as well.
ABC News - Mar. 15
AFT sues Education Department over removal of IDR student loan applications

The American Federation of Teachers (AFT), one of the largest unions of educators in the country, sued the Department of Education Wednesday over the removal online of income-driven repayment (IDR) ...
The Hill - 3d
Warren warns of 'dire consequences' of Education Department firings for student loans

Sen. Warren urges Education Secretary Linda McMahon to reinstate Department of Education employees who were critical to the nation’s federal student aid process.
ABC News - 2d