Ed Martin is the wrong person to investigate Biden-era prosecutors
A newly-appointed U.S. attorney is putting an unfortunate twist on the the satirist Juvenal's ancient question: “Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?” — “Who will guard the guards themselves?”
Edward R. Martin, Jr., became the interim U.S. attorney for Washington, D.C. after previously defending many Jan. 6 protestors. Within hours of his appointment, Martin opened an investigation into whether his office, under Biden-era leadership, engaged in misconduct in prosecuting the Jan. 6 cases, many involving crimes of violence against police officers.
His view is that federal prosecutors overcharged the cases, and he seeks to ascertain whether the prosecutors were improperly politically motivated to do so.
The premise for examining prosecutors’ work in the Jan. 6 cases is that the Supreme Court, in a 6-3 decision, set aside one of the charges brought against a Jan. 6 protestor. The court found that the federal trial court and appeals court had interpreted the federal obstruction-of-justice law too broadly. The court let stand the defendant’s conviction on six other counts, including assaulting a federal officer.
It is shocking for federal prosecutors to be suspected of misconduct for bringing charges based on what was, in retrospect, an overly broad reading of a criminal law. It has never been the department’s policy to adopt conservative readings of criminal laws.
Over the years, the Supreme Court has overturned federal criminal convictions on many occasions where it concluded that prosecutors stretched the law, including in prosecutions of politicians for mail fraud and bribery. But no one — least of all the leadership in the Department of Justice — has seriously questioned prosecutors’ motives in bringing these cases.
Particularly in the Jan. 6 cases, it seems plain that the prosecutors proceeded in good faith, given that their reading of the law was shared by the lower court judges and three Supreme Court justices.
In situations where there is a good reason to think federal prosecutors may have abused their vast power, it is critical to investigate and, if misconduct is discovered, to hold the errant prosecutors accountable. The question in such cases is, who should undertake this task?
Ordinarily, this assignment goes to either of two offices in the Department of Justice — the Office of Professional Responsibility or the inspector general. The career government lawyers in those offices have experience investigating potential misconduct by Department of Justice personnel.
Just as importantly, they can be trusted to do this work objectively, because they do not have direct political ties. Further, these offices are themselves subject to oversight — by Congress in the case of the inspector general, and by the attorney general in the case of the Office of Professional Responsibility.
Martin’s decision to initiate and oversee the investigation of his predecessor’s work, rather than to refer the matter to the Department of Justice officials responsible for investigating prosecutorial misconduct, is troubling in several respects.
One problem is his own evident conflict of interest in commencing an investigation of prosecutors whom he opposed as a defense attorney. But even if he had not participated on the criminal defense side of Jan. 6 cases, Martin’s role as President Trump’s political appointee would raise concerns about his own political bias.
Equally problematic is Martin’s proximity to the president. It is reasonable to conclude that Trump’s political appointees would share his personal and political interest in discrediting the Jan. 6 prosecutions. Far from neutral watchdog, Martin would seem to have a political axe to grind. If he, or those under him, conclude there was prosecutorial misconduct, many will be skeptical because of his evident bias.
More troubling still is the message this sends to all federal prosecutors. Prosecutors will now worry, as they should, about retaliation if they make unpopular decisions in politically sensitive cases. Because law and justice itself often require such politically inexpedient choices, the Department of Justice will be significantly less effective.
Prosecutors are generally trained to make decisions about whom to investigate, whether to initiate criminal charges and which charges to bring, whether to offer a plea bargain, what sentences to seek after obtaining a conviction, and other important decisions according to norms and practices of the legal profession and the Justice Department. These norms are designed to minimize bias and improper considerations. Prosecutors are taught to apply law to facts and treat like cases alike. They are trained not to consider inappropriate factors, such as partisan political considerations.
But it will be hard for federal prosecutors to ignore political considerations after a new U.S. attorney, without cause, seeks to unearth prosecutorial misconduct in cases that are anathema to the new president, who closed out the cases by issuing hundreds of pardons. The glaring if unstated message is that prosecutors’ future work will be subject to a political litmus test.
If future prosecutors, acting independently, investigate or prosecute the sitting president’s allies, or fail to pursue that president’s foes, those prosecutors can expect their decisions to be reviewed and to face adverse employment action. If they want to keep their jobs, they will use their power to weaken Trump’s political opponents while emboldening his allies to commit crimes with impunity.
Who then should investigate possible misconduct by Biden-era prosecutors? If we care about democratic principles and the rule of law, the answer plainly should not be, “Trump’s latest political appointee.”
Bruce Green is a professor at Fordham Law School, where he directs the Louis Stein Center for Law and Ethics and Rebecca Roiphe is a professor at New York Law School, where she directs the Institute for Professional Ethics.
Topics
-
Mexico authorities order factory cleanup after Guardian toxic waste investigation
Inquiry uncovered health problems in neighborhood near Monterrey-area plant that processes US hazardous waste. Mexican environmental regulators say they have discovered 30,000 tons of improperly ...The Guardian - 4h -
‘They came to the wrong neighborhood’: Residents confront demonstrators with Nazi flags near Cincinnati
A group of nearly a dozen people displaying swastika flags on an Interstate 75 overpass near Cincinnati, Ohio, left after being confronted by angry residents.NBC News - 18h -
Trump touches on tariffs, DOGE and Jan. 6 investigators in press conference
NBC News' Yamiche Alcindor reports on what President Trump discussed in his wide-ranging press conference with the prime minister of Japan. Reporters questioned the president on DOGE's actions, ...NBC News - 1d -
New Hampshire man is 2nd person known to be living with a pig kidney
A New Hampshire man has become the second person known to be living with a pig kidneyABC News - 1d -
Consumer Advocacy Group Launches Investigation Into Trump’s Meme Coin
Public Citizen urged federal agencies to recommend stopping of the sale of the meme coin $Trump.Inc. - 1d -
'SNL50' anniversary special will feature Dave Chappelle, Steve Martin, Bad Bunny, McCartney and more
The “Saturday Night Live” 50th anniversary special will include guest appearances by Tom Hanks, Sabrina Carpenter, Bad Bunny, John Mulaney, Dave Chappelle and numerous other stars who’ve been ...ABC News - 2d -
Western Illinois faces UT Martin, looks to end road slide
Western Illinois heads into a matchup with UT Martin as losers of three straight road gamesABC News - 13h -
I was wrong to say Bazball is a cult. It’s actually a death cult | Barney Ronay
As defeats pile up Brendon McCullum’s brand of cricket now has the feel of a cool music video on the deck of a sinking ship. Two summers ago, with interest in the England Test team’s seductive new ...The Guardian - 14h -
FBI gives in to justice department demand for list of January 6 investigators
Agency submitted list, excluding names, of up to 6,000 agents involved in investigating 2021 Capitol attack. US politics live – latest updates The FBI has complied with a US justice ...The Guardian - 1d
More from The Hill
-
Kemp keeps Republicans on edge as he mulls Georgia Senate bid
Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp (R) is at the center of intense speculation as Republicans wait to see whether the popular two-term governor will run against Sen. Jon Ossoff (D-Ga.) next year. Republicans ...The Hill - 40m -
Trump's hero's welcome
Welcome to The Hill's Business & Economy newsletter {beacon} Business & Economy Business & Economy The Big Story Dockworkers union chief credits Trump for deal The head of the dockworkers union ...The Hill - Jan. 9 -
Springfield sues neo-Nazi group over rhetoric about Haitians during 2024 election
The city of Springfield, Ohio, which faced a wave of threats last year following false accusations that Haitian migrants living in the town were "eating pets" of U.S. citizens, filed a lawsuit ...The Hill - 49m -
House passes International Criminal Court sanctions bill over Israeli arrest warrants
Welcome to The Hill's Defense & NatSec newsletter {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story House passes bill to sanction ICC over Israeli arrest warrants The ...The Hill - Jan. 9 -
Missing Alaska flight found with no survivors: What to know
A small commuter aircraft that crashed in western Alaska Thursday was found on sea ice on Friday, with officials announcing that all 10 individuals aboard died. This incident marks one of the most ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
JD Vance Aced His First Test. The Next One Will Be Tougher.
The vice president wrangled a few holdout senators. Now he’s faced with taming an unruly House.Politico - 8h -
Judge blocks DOGE from accessing personal data at Treasury
A federal judge has temporarily blocked Elon Musk and his new Department of Government Efficiency from accessing sensitive treasury department records, including the personal data of millions of ...NBC News - 9h -
‘They came to the wrong neighborhood’: Residents confront demonstrators with Nazi flags near Cincinnati
A group of nearly a dozen people displaying swastika flags on an Interstate 75 overpass near Cincinnati, Ohio, left after being confronted by angry residents.NBC News - 18h -
Trump's sweeping agenda is hitting legal roadblocks
The courts are slamming the brakes on some of President Donald Trump's efforts to quickly trim and transform the federal government.NBC News - 18h -
New Time cover shows Elon Musk at the Resolute desk
Time published its latest cover featuring an image of Elon Musk sitting behind the Resolute desk in the Oval Office. NBC News' Garrett Haake has more on the cover and President Trump's reaction.NBC News - 19h