Double standards on corporate diversity initiatives undermine business success
Fostering workforces and leadership teams with diverse perspectives and backgrounds has become a priority across the American business landscape. Although government mandates on “Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion” receive much attention, as well as pushback, private sector approaches have a more constructive impact. Unfortunately, some bad actors threaten this progress.
Smart American businesses know that diversity can drive growth. Indeed, data shows that diversity broadly leads to better business performance and improves employee retention and recruitment. Having individuals from various backgrounds and perspectives on company boards of directors also drives profitability, increasing returns for investors.
For publicly traded companies, proxy advisory firms have come to play major roles in decisions at the board of director level, like proposals regarding strategy, governance, and indeed who is elected to the board itself. Investors, especially institutional investors, pay proxy firms to receive advice about shareholder votes.
But as they’ve grown, proxy firms are now wielding influence that is not always in the best interests of the companies they analyze.
Scholar Ben Zycher testified last year before Congress about the outsized role played by proxy advisory firms. Zycher explained that “regulatory actions by the Securities and Exchange Commission have created powerful incentives for firms and funds to retain proxy advisers and to adopt their recommendations, often on an automatic basis. The advisers themselves have weak incentives to consider the fiduciary interests of shareholders and fund participants, thus freeing them to indulge their own political preferences, at little or no cost to themselves.”
Recent actions taken by Institutional Shareholder Services, one of the two most powerful proxy advisory firms in the country, against Disney and medical technology company Masimo highlight these problematic dynamics and invited controversy.
In both instances, ISS recommended alternative board nominees over highly qualified candidates proposed by the companies.
At Disney, Institutional Shareholder Services backed Nelson Peltz, an activist investor, over Maria Elena Lagomasino, an executive with extensive governance experience and a long tenure on Disney’s board. Disney touted Lagomasino’s expertise in global brands and governance as critical to their strategic goals, while ISS favored an investor primarily focused on financial restructuring.
Similarly, at Masimo, Institutional Shareholder Services endorsed activist investor Politan Capital Management’s nominee William Jellison over Christopher Chavez, whose experience in the medical device industry, including achieving regulatory approvals, made him the ideal candidate in Masimo’s eyes.
The contrast illustrates a significant criticism of activist investors: By favoring their own narrow and short-term interests, activist investors like hedge funds often prevent companies from implementing changes that the companies see as benefiting employees, customers and long-term investors looking for stability.
The critical plot twist is that both candidates opposed by ISS are highly qualified Latinos, and that Institutional Shareholder Services has previously inserted itself in board decisions, actively pushing private companies to succumb to the demands of political activists in adopting Environmental, Social and Governance or ESG agendas, which often include diversity initiatives (albeit ones that revolve around rigid mandates).
The Disney and Masimo situations reflect a broader, systemic issue in how diversity is being prioritized — or neglected — by influential entities like Institutional Shareholder Services and business in general.
Diversity is not just a checkbox to be ticked. It is now a cornerstone of effective leadership and decision-making in today’s interconnected world. Latino representation on corporate boards is not just about numbers, it’s about bringing unique perspectives to the table—ones that reflects the experiences of a substantial and rising portion of our population.
U.S. Latino consumers are a significant economic force, commanding a $2.6 trillion GDP and driving consumption growth in virtually every mass consumer category. Despite these eye-opening economic contributions, and making up nearly 20 percent of the U.S. population, Latinos held just under 4 percent of board seats among Fortune 1000 companies in 2021. Clearly, more can be done — in the right ways.
Bypassing highly qualified Latino candidates is certainly not a constructive approach, and instead perpetuates the very inequities that diversity initiatives are supposed to address. The rejection by Institutional Shareholder Services of qualified Latino candidates demonstrates a hypocrisy that needs to stop.
True diversity in business leadership is essential to serving customers and reflecting the communities that businesses serve. But constructive diversity measures cannot be about fulfilling a mandate, they must be about recognizing and valuing the critical role that diverse leadership plays in driving innovation, understanding markets and promoting prosperity for all Americans.
Mario H. Lopez is the president of the Hispanic Leadership Fund, a public policy advocacy organization that promotes liberty, opportunity and prosperity for all.
Date: |
-
The Wall Street Journal - World
The Pain of Trying for a Baby Without Success
Most of the women I work with have spent everything they have.23 hours ago -
The Wall Street Journal - World
What's News: Business & Finance
What’s News: Business & Finance15 hours ago -
The Wall Street Journal - World
20-Somethings Learn to Love Their Corporate Jobs
‘Corporate girlies’ and guys boast about their jobs online, even the mundane parts.18 hours ago -
BBC News - Top stories
Rupert Murdoch's 'Succession' court battle begins
The court battle will determine the future of the billionaire's media empire.1 hour ago -
Financial Times - Business
Diverse Booker prize shortlist explores faultlines of our times
Some big names missing from a final six that includes the largest number of female authors in the fiction prize’s history49 minutes ago -
Financial Times - Business
The pension fund transfer business needs urgent scrutiny
Insurers are receiving a very handsome reward for such a low-risk business15 hours ago -
VentureBeat - Tech
Why data science alone won’t make your product successful
The lean-value approach is a framework with the potential to change how technology teams integrate AI insight with strategic planning.Yesterday -
Los Angeles Times - Entertainment
John Leguizamo applauds Emmys diversity in fervent speech: 'Our industry is making progress'
Here's the full text of John Leguizamo's speech on Hollywood's horrible track record of Latinx representation — and signs that the industry's inclusion problem is finally starting to improve.15 hours ago -
ABC News - Sports
Nathan Lukes' double in 8th pushes Blue Jays past Cardinals 3-2 to complete 3-game sweep
Nathan Lukes drove in the winning run with a double in the eighth inning as the Toronto Blue Jays beat the St. Louis Cardinals 3-2 on Sunday to complete a three-game sweep21 hours ago - MLB -
The Guardian - World
Tried for double murder and adored by the French left: the violent life and crimes of Pierre Goldman
He was a street-fighting revolutionary with a taste for flash cars and crisp shirts – a moralising bank-robber who was eventually gunned down in the streets of Paris. As a film recreates this ...15 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
It took years, but elite colleges are learning the value of institutional neutrality
Whatever one thinks of the war in Gaza, divestment should be avoided because it violates institutional neutrality and thereby damages the college or university as an institution.50 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
55 Democratic lawmakers ask Biden administration to expand Arctic protections
Sen. Ed Markey (D-Mass.) and Rep. Jared Huffman (D-Calif.) led a letter from more than 50 congressional Democrats calling on the Interior Department to expand federal protections in the Arctic. The ...1 hour ago - Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Harris meets with Teamsters as both parties court coveted endorsement
Vice President Harris joined the International Brotherhood of Teamsters for a roundtable Monday, as anticipation swirls around whom the union will endorse in the presidential race. Teamsters ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
Suspect in apparent assassination attempt of Trump has long history of legal troubles
The suspect in an apparent attempted assassination of former President Trump has long had run-ins with the law, court records show, a history that could be a factor as he stares down federal ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Bad actors already have your data, but there's something you can do about it
The NPD breach was one of the largest on record. It will not be the last.1 hour ago