Don't trust the lies on diversity, equity, and inclusion in medicine
![Don't trust the lies on diversity, equity, and inclusion in medicine](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/07/medical_school-2043605750.jpg?w=900)
President Biden’s health has become a central issue, not least because many feel that the Democratic leaders misled the country on his vigor. I feel a similar sense of betrayal by those same leaders who advocate for the supposed beneficial effects of diversity, equity and inclusion or DEI in medicine.
The field of medicine has always been held to be the most trustworthy profession of all. Physicians are supposed to be the hardest working, most skilled and diligent caretakers of our health. Yet the DEI movement is drawing ideological lines in an environment that should be apolitical, eroding trust along the way.
In March, I introduced the EDUCATE Act to ban identity-based mandates at medical schools and accrediting institutions. Since its introduction, there has been a significant propaganda campaign by DEI apologists and liberal academics to keep the curtain closed and claim, “all is well in medical education.” Yet, as Queen Gertrude in “Hamlet” exclaimed, “The lady doth protest too much.” These declarations are too excessive and insistent to be believed.
It is complete folly, and dangerous, to believe that the selection and education of our future doctors should be based upon social justice parameters and identity politics.
If anyone speaks up against this, he or she is labeled a “bigot," "racist," "misogynist,” or whatever leftist attack word can be spat at them. The bottom line is that medicine should be about the patient, not the social identity of the physician.
When doctors make medicine about themselves, or their political affinity, they are degrading the very profession they took an oath to defend, and it will ultimately lead to patient harm.
We have witnessed the waiving of Medical College Admission Test scores for students to enter medical school. On medical school applications, prospective medical students check every identity politics box in hopes of a competitive advantage.
DEI apologists love to argue patients prefer to go to doctors who look like them. Perhaps, in some instances this is true. However, the logical conclusion of this position is segregation in the classroom and the doctor’s office.
In the classroom, precious time is being diverted from coursework to accommodate the addition of ideological classes. For example, UCLA Medical School, a once highly respected institution, has required students to take a “Structural Racism and Health Equity” course. It comes as no surprise that nearly a quarter of students in the school’s class of 2025 cannot pass basic medical exams. Social media is full of videos these days of medical students boasting that they failed their exams but that, “‘they will be a doctor anyway.” Where is the patient in all of this?
Disparities undoubtedly exist in medicine, and I’m deeply committed to addressing them. The current strategies prescribed to fix these imbalances are unmoored from reality and dangerous. I have spent the last 35 years serving a rural and heavy minority practice area to personally make a difference, not an urban Northeast, liberal echo chamber.
In all my years as a physician, I have never been more worried about the future of medicine. I cannot stand by and allow it to be corrupted by a political peer pressure campaign. The sinister movement to inject racial and political division into medical schools not only contradicts the principles of treating all patients equally and without partiality, but also materially impacts patient care and fosters distrust in our health care system.
We already have a severe physician workforce shortage; inserting politics into the field will degrade it further. Sadly, it will take a decade to see the clinical results of these horribly misguided policies and by that time it will be too late.
The push to implant DEI into every facet of our lives, including medicine, suggests that identity politics matter more than merit and work ethic. It is a Trojan horse for redistribution, segregation and racial division masquerading as a noble pursuit to stamp out oppression and offer everyone a fair shot at life.
Meaningful civil progress does not require deception to build a coalition of support. Although many who endorse the DEI movement may be well-intentioned, in medicine, the end results will be disastrous for the patient. The patient is what doctors are supposed to care about most.
Greg Murphy represents the 3rd District of North Carolina.
Date: |
Filter
-
CBS News - Top stories
Is Boeing recovering the public's trust?
The aviation behemoth built a reputation as the gold standard, but has been under scrutiny from regulators and the public alike after deadly crashes of its 737 Max, and another incident involving a door panel blowing out mid-flight. -
CBS News - Top stories
Can Boeing recover the public's trust?
Founded in 1916, Boeing built a reputation as the gold standard in aviation design. But the storied company has been under scrutiny from regulators and the public alike after the 2018 and 2019 crashes of its 737 MAX, resulting in 346 deaths, and ... -
The New York Times - Top stories
What Makes the U.K. Exit Poll So Trusted
The first indication of results on British election nights has earned an unusually high reputation. Those behind it say that’s because of a big decision 20 years ago.United Kingdom -
The New York Times - World
Labour Wins Back the Trust of Jewish Voters
Keir Starmer had made rooting out antisemitism from the Labour Party’s ranks a goal of his leadership. -
The Wall Street Journal - World
The S&P 500 Isn't as Diverse as It Used to Be. Here's Why That Matters.
As tech and financial stocks have come to dominate the index, volatility and interest-rate sensitivity have picked up. -
The Wall Street Journal - World
Modi's Ruling BJP Party in India Has a Diversity Problem
The prime minister needs to muster support from Indians who aren’t Hindus to secure his legacy.India -
Financial Times - Business
Ukraine withdraws from parts of Chasiv Yar as Russia advances
Pullout highlights challenge facing Kyiv as Russian offensive intensifies and US military aid has been slow to arriveUkraine -
The Wall Street Journal - World
Private-Equity Insiders Offer Their Summer Reading Picks
Among this year’s recommendations: a novel on Shakespeare’s marriage, a book on doing business in Putin’s Russia, a take on ‘magical overthinking’ and two works by industry veterans. -
The Wall Street Journal - World
Private Equity's Diverging Deal Making and Fundraising Outlooks
Views on the industry often depend on which side of the market the firm occupies.
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
A long-game strategy to fix our broken Supreme Court
Republicans excelled at the long game, finally succeeding in a decades-long campaign to take full control of the Supreme Court. -
The Hill - Politics
Senate Democrat: Time to have Biden’s back
Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto (D), who represents the key swing state of Nevada, on Monday urged her colleagues and fellow Democrats to rally behind President Biden despite growing calls within the party for him to abandon his reelection bid. “Joe ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Democrat calling for Biden to drop out: 'He looks very frail'
Rep. Mike Quigley (D-Ill.) defended his call for President Biden to drop out of the 2024 race, arguing Monday it is not about loyalty but rather being "pragmatic" to ensure there is a "very strong" candidate at the top of the Democratic ticket. ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Columbia deans removed over texts that officials say included antisemitic tropes
Multiple deans at Columbia University have been removed from their positions after texts were revealed that were antisemitic in nature, according to a message from the school’s president Monday. President Minouche Shafik wrote in a letter to the ... -
The Hill - Politics
The Hill's 12:30 Report —Biden to potential Dem rivals: Try me
Presented by GE Aerospace — 💰 Plus: Michael Bloomberg's med school donation {beacon} 12:30 REPORT It’s Monday. What’d I miss last week? 😅 Here's what's happening today: President Biden called into MSNBC’s “Morning Joe” and sent a letter to ...