Don't saddle the military with an irrelevant climate mission
In a well-intentioned and idealistic op-ed published last week, a promising high school student argued that if combatting climate change were added to the U.S. military’s mission set, our armed forces would be more attractive to the author’s generation, which could reverse current recruiting shortfalls.
Respectfully, I feel obligated to put forward a counterpoint that draws on my extensive experience with this topic.
First and foremost, we must identify and address the root causes of the Department of Defense’s recruiting crisis. At the top of the list is declining eligibility. A 2022 study from the Pentagon showed that 77 percent of young Americans would not qualify for military service without a waiver due to being overweight, having a criminal record, or suffering from mental and physical health problems. These issues are beyond the scope of this op-ed, but options are being explored.
Another factor is that fewer young people are willing to serve in the first place. While the author’s proposed solution attempts to address this issue, there could not be a worse time for our armed forces to add extraneous responsibilities to their primary mission of deterring conflict and winning wars when deterrence is unsuccessful.
Two other recent op-eds in The Hill have made the alarming claim that World War III is already upon us, yet the Biden administration has yet to take the decisive and bold action necessary to win it. This is hardly hyperbole. China is rapidly preparing to move against Taiwan, Israel is surrounded by more than a dozen proxy forces backed by a nuclear-ambitious Iran, and Ukraine has crossed into the Kursk region of Russia, setting an Armageddon-bent Vladimir Putin back on his heels and forcing him to evacuate 180,000 civilians.
These are only the dangers closest to our door; now is not the time to rebrand the military as a “climate force.”
In fact, I have already detailed multiple times how the Defense Department climate plans praised by the author are not only misdirected but a dangerous distraction from the urgent deterrence necessary to address current threats.
I made this point during a Senate Budget Committee hearing earlier this year, testifying that the Pentagon’s focus on greenhouse gas emission reductions to mitigate climate change is a costly unforced error. Even if the entire planet were to cease emissions today, the Earth would continue to warm for several decades because of previous emissions. That is why I have urged the department to focus instead on adapting to climate change, which can be most effectively done by improving the military’s capability to observe and predict weather, water and ice.
A third point is that the author simply assumes that climate change is causing a wide range of unspecified consequences, all of which are negative. This is far too vague, imprecise and incomplete to justify revising Title 10 of the U.S. Code, which defines the role, mission and organization of America’s armed forces. This view has been influenced by the pervasive inaccuracies in the media, some scientific journals, and even congressional hearings regarding climate change. Far too often, implausible emissions scenarios are relied upon because of the extreme, albeit unlikely, outcomes they produce.
Finally, if a climate connection is desired to remedy the recruiting of our armed forces, we should simply amplify the stories of those in the service who do the most in making the military climate-ready. These are the Defense Department’s professional meteorologists and oceanographers who participate in the planning of every exercise and operation. This cadre of highly educated enlisted service members and officers and civilian scientists are just the type of highly trained experts to draw in the author’s Gen Z peers.
Retooling the U.S. armed forces with a climate mission is not the way to bring in more of the next generation. But if it helps, the department can showcase the soldiers, sailors, airmen and marines who already expertly assess climate, weather and ocean conditions for mission accomplishment. The Pentagon has been using these professionals to adapt to climatic conditions for decades, and they are the perfect candidates to put military recruiting back on track.
Rear Adm. (ret.) Tim Gallaudet is the former acting administrator and deputy administrator of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration; acting undersecretary and assistant secretary of commerce for Oceans and Atmosphere; and oceanographer of the U.S. Navy. He also served as the director of Task Force Climate Change in the Pentagon.
Date: | |
Tag: | Climate |
Topics
-
The Hill - Politics
Democrats seek to tax fossil fuel companies over climate change
A large group of Democrats is looking to force the fossil fuel industry to pay for climate change. Lawmakers unveiled a bill Thursday that would allow the Treasury Department to impose fees on ...3 hours ago - Climate -
The Wall Street Journal - World
Why Don't Harris Supporters Believe Her History?
Media folk are having difficulty comprehending her record.3 hours ago - Kamala Harris -
CNBC - Business
How one climate startup aims to use AI to protect the power grid
As fires intensify in the western U.S., utility companies are on the front lines to protect power lines, and AI is a big part of the process.4 hours ago - Climate -
ESPN - Sports
Norris: I don't expect Piastri to hand me wins
Lando Norris has said that while McLaren is now prioritising his championship aspirations, he will not expect Oscar Piastri to give up race wins.5 hours ago -
The New York Times - Top stories
Is Inequality the Key to the Climate Change Debate?
In his new book, the economist Thomas Piketty argues that the world can’t stop climate change without addressing issues of inequality.6 hours ago - Climate -
The Guardian - World
Entire Earth vibrated for nine days after climate-triggered mega-tsunami
Landslide in Greenland caused unprecedented seismic event that shows impact of global heating, say scientists. A landslide and mega-tsunami in Greenland in September 2023, triggered by the climate ...6 hours ago -
The Wall Street Journal - World
Senior Israeli Military Intelligence Official Resigns Over Oct. 7 Hamas Attack
Yossi Sariel, the commander of Unit 8200, the Israeli military’s largest and most important intelligence unit, told his commanders that he would step down in the near future, the military said.7 hours ago - Israel -
The Guardian - World
Natural History Museum plans revamp to become climate ‘catalyst for change’
Four galleries to be overhauled and two more spaces to reopen, including Fixing Our Broken Planet exhibition. The Natural History Museum in London has announced a major programme of transformation ...7 hours ago - Climate -
Yahoo News - World
Russia is counterattacking in Kursk and could be trying to split Ukrainian forces, military experts say
9 hours ago - Ukraine -
Yahoo Sports - Sports
Is there a world where Cowboys don't pay Parsons? Breaking down Dallas' next big deal
Micah Parsons is arguably the best pass-rusher in the NFL. After locking up Dak Prescott and CeeDee Lamb to massive extensions, will Dallas fork up a sack of cash?Yesterday - NFL
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
High levels of lead detected in 12 cinnamon brands, report finds
A new Consumer Reports investigation found elevated levels of lead in several brands of cinnamon powders and multi-spice blends that it tested.25 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
New Hampshire signs bill tightening voter ID laws for future elections
New Hampshire Gov. Chris Sununu (R) signed a bill that tightens voter ID laws in the state for future elections. The much-debated bill requires voters to provide proof of U.S. citizenship when ...42 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
GOP senators warn against House-driven government shutdown
Senate Republicans are letting the air out on House Republican efforts to pump up a partisan standoff over federal funding, which they fear could risk an embarrassing government shutdown a few ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
Trump proposes ending taxes on overtime pay
Former President Trump on Thursday called for ending taxes on overtime wages for individuals who work more than 40 hours a week, his latest proposal to slash individual taxes if he is reelected. ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Trump claims Haitian migrants ‘destroying’ way of life in Ohio city
Former President Trump on Thursday escalated his attacks on Haitian migrants in an Ohio city, days after he repeated a conspiracy on the debate stage that those migrants were eating pets. Trump ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump