Democrats shouldn’t be so sanguine about Kamala's 'Root Causes' strategy
In recent weeks, the vice president’s defenders have been eager to point out that Kamala Harris was never the “border czar,” responsible for securing America’s wide-open Southern border. Instead, they claim, she was only in charge of addressing the “root causes” of migration in Central America.
Even if that were true, the vice president’s supporters shouldn’t be so keen to brag about it.
In 2021, the Biden administration launched the “Root Causes” strategy, a lofty initiative led by Vice President Kamala Harris which purported to address the challenges of mass migration through U.S. development aid to Central America. Three years and $3 billion later, however, the impact of Harris’ root-causes initiative is practically indiscernible.
USAID points to dubious and unfalsifiable metrics as evidence of the success of the “Root Causes” strategy, obfuscating its meager impact, saying its support “helped create or sustain more than 70,000 jobs” in Northern Central America since 2021. During a recent congressional hearing, USAID officials even touted an increase in H-1B visas for Central Americans as a top achievement of the Root Causes strategy.
The reality is that the Biden administration’s 2021 plan was not new, but a simple repackaging of failed development strategies used for decades with added emphasis on liberal wish list priorities. Aid programs for controversial climate change, social activism, gender ideology, labor unions and regional journalism were added to a series of other priorities that were admirable but ultimately tangential to the challenge of mass migration, such as gender-based violence, workers’ rights and corruption.
This controversial liberal activism, especially on gender ideology, not only failed to fix the migration crisis, it actually hurt U.S. relations in the region and generated backlash from with Central America’s socially conservative leaders and people. But even without its progressive foibles, Vice President Harris’s plan to address the “root causes” of the migration crisis was on shaky ground from the outset.
Consider the ineffectiveness of economic development as a solution to the migration crisis, for example. Mexico has benefitted from deep trade integration with the U.S. for decades, helping it achieve a GDP per capita more than twice that of Guatemala and nearly three times that of Honduras. Still, Mexican nationals remain the largest group of new illegal migrant arrivals to the U.S. Even if Vice President Harris were somehow able to massively accelerate Central American economies, the lesson from Mexico is that illegal migration will continue to flow.
Another folly of Vice President Harris’ “root causes” strategy is its failure to contend with the reality of hundreds of thousands of migrants arriving to Latin America from Asia and Africa before making their way to the U.S. Should we also seek to massively increase aid to these regions to address their root causes? No. To do so would waste further billions more and likely yield even poorer results.
There is simply no alternative to a secure border when it comes to combatting illegal migration. The first step for the next administration must be to stop outsourcing the problem to the development industry or the Mexican military and instead exert control over the U.S. border.
Additionally, the next administration should fundamentally rethink its development aid strategy in Latin America, aligning it toward vital U.S. economic and national security interests to ensure its effectiveness. The first Trump administration made important strides toward this goal by focusing on increasing hemispheric trade and investment rather than pouring billions of taxpayer funds into failed social programs, but much remains to be done.
Congress can also play a fundamental role toward this goal by demanding accountability for aid funds and ensuring that development funds are not hijacked by controversial social activism.
What won’t work is four more years of Vice President Harris’s “root causes” strategy, which was poorly conceived and had predictably poor outcomes. Rather than bragging about it, the U.S. should learn from its failures and craft a strategy that addresses the migration crisis head on and helps put Central America on a sustainable path.
Andres Martinez-Fernandez is a senior policy analyst in Heritage’s Allison Center for National Security. Heritage is listed for identification purposes only. The views expressed in this article are the authors' own and do not reflect any institutional position for Heritage or its Board of Trustees.
Date: |
Topics
-
The Hill - Politics
Democrats are reclaiming the flag — and it’s about time
It's time for all Americans to take it back and display it as the symbol it was meant to be: the flag of one nation, indivisible.6 hours ago -
CBS News - Top stories
What we know so far about shots fired near Trump
The FBI is leading the investigation into what it said "appears to be an attempted assassination attempt" of former President Donald Trump on Sunday. Trump is "safe and unharmed" after Secret ...21 hours ago - Donald Trump -
BBC News - Top stories
What we know about the Trump attack
The reported suspect, Ryan Routh, is in custody.15 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The Guardian - World
Fentanyl was killing their friends – and no one was talking about it. So these teens stepped up
As fake pills send teen overdose deaths skyrocketing, these high schoolers are filling an information void with films and peer-to-peer education. Eli Myers was only 15 when his close friend and ...3 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
Trump golf club shooting: what we know so far about apparent assassination attempt
Donald Trump said he was safe after what the FBI said appeared to be an assassination attempt at the former US president’s West Palm Beach golf club. Follow live for latest updates Full ...19 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The New York Times - Top stories
Inflammation May Be the Root of Disease
How one drug might work for weight, fertility and dementia.10 hours ago -
Financial Times - World
America needs a better strategy on semiconductors
Export controls have their place, but they should not be allowed to choke innovation15 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Kamala Harris clearly won the debate. But will it matter?
Ultimately, the data highlights the fact that Harris’s debate performance, while impressive, is unlikely to drastically turn the tides in her favor.6 hours ago - Kamala Harris -
CBS News - Top stories
Kamala Harris working to secure Teamsters Union endorsement
Vice President Kamala Harris is in Washington Monday for a roundtable with labor leaders at the Teamsters headquarters. The Teamsters Union still hasn't endorsed a candidate for the 2024 ...4 hours ago - Kamala Harris
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
It took years, but elite colleges are learning the value of institutional neutrality
Whatever one thinks of the war in Gaza, divestment should be avoided because it violates institutional neutrality and thereby damages the college or university as an institution.43 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
55 Democratic lawmakers ask Biden administration to expand Arctic protections
Sen. Ed Markey (D-Mass.) and Rep. Jared Huffman (D-Calif.) led a letter from more than 50 congressional Democrats calling on the Interior Department to expand federal protections in the Arctic. The ...58 minutes ago - Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Harris meets with Teamsters as both parties court coveted endorsement
Vice President Harris joined the International Brotherhood of Teamsters for a roundtable Monday, as anticipation swirls around whom the union will endorse in the presidential race. Teamsters ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
Suspect in apparent assassination attempt of Trump has long history of legal troubles
The suspect in an apparent attempted assassination of former President Trump has long had run-ins with the law, court records show, a history that could be a factor as he stares down federal ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Bad actors already have your data, but there's something you can do about it
The NPD breach was one of the largest on record. It will not be the last.1 hour ago