Democrats need to make a compelling case to win back America

Slightly more than one month into President Trump’s second term, Democrats have yet to figure out how to effectively counter him and make a compelling case to the public.

Indeed, despite the multitude of opportunities that Trump has handed Democrats, the party writ large appears unable to muster anything more than “procedural opposition” as M. Gessen described it.

To be sure, this is not a new problem, but it is an increasingly urgent one.

Since 2016, Democrats have spent more time opposing Donald Trump than they have developing and articulating a clear and compelling vision for the country.

As a result, voters have little idea what Democrats stand for, only who they stand against.

If Democrats hope to right the ship and regain at least one chamber of Congress next year — or the White House in three — they must begin with a messaging strategy that speaks to the issues voters care about: the economy, public safety and border security.

They should start with the primary reason Trump won last November, the economy.

Trump made Americans’ economic pessimism and anger over inflation a centerpiece of his campaign, convincingly portraying Democrats as the party of elites who were out of touch with everyday Americans.

Thus far, however, Americans do not feel Trump has delivered on his promises.

Only 39 percent of Americans approve of Trump’s handling of the economy, whereas a majority believe the economy is on the wrong track, per Ipsos polling. That is a significant opportunity for Democrats, but they must meet voters where they are.

They must explain to voters — in a way that avoids talking down to them — that Trump’s tariff policies and trade wars will exacerbate inflation and do nothing to improve people’s financial situation. More than that, Democrats must formulate and communicate their own concrete plans to cut inflation and increase access to job training or vocational schools.

In that same vein, Democrats must be strategic in how they attack the newly created Department of Government Efficiency.

The concept behind DOGE — that the federal government is wasteful, bloated and excessive — is backed by 59 percent of voters, according to Reuters-Ipsos polling.

Unsurprisingly, Americans believe that the government spends too much and is wildly inefficient, but there are genuine concerns here that Democrats can speak to.

Rather than objecting to every cut DOGE intends to make, or blindly vowing to fight the agency, as some did, Democrats should be selective. Framing DOGE’s efforts as threatening to individuals' federal benefits is significantly more likely to be successful.

In fact, the same Reuters-Ipsos polling bears this out. Fifty-eight percent of Americans say they’re concerned their Social Security benefits or student loan payments could be affected by DOGE.

Speaking to those fears and presenting their own DOGE-type effort to reduce the size and scope of government that is more targeted, would be much more beneficial for Democrats than simply trying to defend an ever-expanding federal bureaucracy and federal budget.

To that end, Democrats would be wise to recognize that Americans want strong border security and do not want an uncontrolled flow of illegal migrants. Along with the economy, anger over President Biden’s handling of immigration was key to Trump’s victory.

There is a middle ground between supporting Trump’s more extreme policies — such as using the military to forcibly deport entire families — and the open border policies pushed by progressives.

Democrats need to make a compelling case that they too support a secure border and the removal of criminal migrants. Working with Republicans to advance commonsense immigration policies neutralizes the GOP’s weaponization of this critical issue.

Just as importantly, Democrats need to make their case in a way that resonates.

As Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear recently told Politico, they need to “start talking like real human beings” instead of using “sanitized language,” particularly on social issues.

The influence of elites and the progressive left has taken the Democratic Party far out of the mainstream on issues such as social justice, transgender rights, and more.

Ultimately, the 2024 election made it clear that Democrats’ oft-repeated appeals to the foundations of democracy and the threat Trump posed do not move voters.

Instead, voters want elected officials who get things done and improve their lives, and they believed Trump was better able to do this than Kamala Harris.

Effectively making a case to the contrary will require Democrats to understand that Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) was wrong when he recently said what Americans most want from their party is to “beat Trump.”

What Americans really most want is a middle-class meritocracy strategy that is inclusive and promotes broad-based social uplifting of the American people, not an elitist party too consumed by its hatred for one man that it ignores the voters.

Frankly, if Democrats believe that voters will reward them simply for opposing Trump, rather than presenting their own alternative arguments, they will remain out of power for years, much like the period between 1980 and 1992, which was dominated by the Republican Party.

Then, in 1992, Former President Clinton, recognized that the party needed to reclaim the mantle on policies that Americans cared about.

That being said, Democrats will be unable to do so if they cannot articulate a competing agenda, one built on improving people’s economic situation and addressing key issues.

Pollster Douglas E. Schoen is a partner with the public opinion company Schoen Cooperman Research based in New York and co-author of the book, “America: Unite or Die.”

Topics

Democratic governors push back against Trump

With Democrats in the minority in Washington, D.C., it could be up to governors to mount the party's opposition to President Trump's agenda. Ofirah Yheskel, director of external affairs for the ...
CBS News - 3d
Europe Prepares to Face Russia as Trump’s America Steps Back

Europeans are debating additional funding and contemplating troops in Ukraine as American support appears ever more at risk.
The New York Times - 3h
To make lasting changes, Trump should talk to these 6 Democrats

President Trump's willingness to work with Democrats on immigration policy could be a step towards permanent changes, but his window for cooperation may be closing as Republican leadership ices ...
The Hill - 2d
Devils Stars Make Franchise History In Blowout Win

The New Jersey Devils played the Nashville Predators on Feb. 23, and it could not have gone better. The Devils defeated Nashville by a 5-0 final score and are now tied with the Carolina Hurricanes ...
Yahoo Sports - 3h
Luigi Mangione headed back to court for NYC murder case

Luigi Mangione, the man accused in the killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson in New York City, is headed back to court for a status hearing in his case. CBS News' Katrina Kaufman reports.
CBS News - 2d
Musk may be the wedge Democrats need to separate Trump from his working-class base

Elon Musk is dominating the media and the political landscape, with his influence over President Trump and his role in the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) raising concerns about his ...
The Hill - 23h
The stock market is expensive. But there’s still one bull case not priced in, says Bank of America.

Bank of America says heavily regulated sectors have yet to fully rally
MarketWatch - 3d
Texas measles cases are up, and New Mexico now has an outbreak. Here's what you need to know

The measles outbreak in rural West Texas has grown to 58 cases as of Tuesday
ABC News - 5d
Do you need to make $100,000 to buy a home? Census data says yes

The median income for new homebuyers has increased sharply since the Covid pandemic and surpassed six figures, according to an NBC News analysis of U.S. Census Bureau data.
NBC News - 2d
Canada’s ice hockey win over Trump’s America was her soft power laid bare | Colin Horgan

Trump can try to co-opt hockey. But Thursday showed that wherever where you’re from, when you step onto the ice, something about you will always be Canadian. Canada beat US 3-2 on McDavid’s ...
The Guardian - 3d
If we want to win the 5G war with China, we need to fully embrace American capitalism

The race to dominate 5G technology is a decisive battle for economic supremacy in the 21st century. Unfortunately, the U.S. has fallen behind.
The Hill - 3d
Ohtani throws a 2nd bullpen session as he makes his way back to the mound for the Dodgers

Shohei Ohtani threw his second bullpen session of spring training on Tuesday
ABC News - 5d
Crypto and big tech’s backing pays off as Trump makes tech-friendly moves

Flurry of directives relaxes regulations and drop lawsuit – and billionaires who donated to Trump are ready to benefit. The millions that US tech companies invested in currying favor with Donald ...
The Guardian - 2d
US politics briefing: Trump administration warns Kyiv and picks up court win in mass firings case

From the Trump administration’s latest moves abroad and in the US – here are the key US politics stories from Thursday at a glance. Thursday saw a judge rule that the Trump administration can ...
The Guardian - 3d
MLS award predictions: Can Lionel Messi win MVP with Inter Miami, and Gregg Berhalter's coach of the year case

Plus which L.A. star will lead the league in scoring, and what high-profile signing is set to flop
CBS Sports - 2d
Sears scores 30 and No. 4 Alabama bounces back after 2 losses with 96-83 win over No. 17 Kentucky

Mark Sears scored 30 points and No. 4 Alabama came from behind for a 96-83 win over No. 17 Kentucky
ABC News - 1d
College basketball scores, winners and losers: Kansas, Alabama bounce back with big wins after bad losses

The teams and players celebrating and the ones sulking after the last Saturday of the season before March arrives
CBS Sports - 1d
‘America is now an adversary’

Plus, inside the UK's 'right-wing Davos'
Financial Times - 3d
President William McKinley's America

Our 25th president loved tariffs, and oversaw an expansion of U.S. territory around the globe. But William McKinley is best remembered as being one of the four presidents that was assassinated.
CBS News - 1d
America Has a Rogue President

The firing of three judge advocate generals is one more element of this administration’s attack on the rule of law.
The New York Times - 7h
‘I’d never loved it so much’: Ukrainian woman who felt compelled to return home

On the third anniversary of Russia’s invasion, Yuliya Danilina talks about her decision to return to Ukraine despite the risks – and the legacy of occupation she found. ‘I felt paralysed by ...
The Guardian - 10h
A Book Club for Bewildered Democrats

Democrats will have no shot at containing Trump if they don’t first understand why voters turn to him.
The New York Times - 2d
America has turned on its friends

Donald Trump’s abandonment of allies is real and will endure
Financial Times - 2d
Democrats won’t fight Trump’s tariff policies. On trade, Trump is a Democrat.

President Donald Trump's recent trade policy has been met with surprising support from congressional Democrats, despite his protectionist policies being more aligned with progressive Democrats than ...
The Hill - 21h
'Indiscriminate’ Pentagon cuts unnerve Democrats

{beacon} Welcome to The Hill's Defense & NatSec newsletter {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story 'Indiscriminate’ Pentagon cuts unnerve Democrats Democrats ...
The Hill - 3d
Ben Jennings on the myth of America’s past – cartoon

Continue reading...
The Guardian - 3d
Trump’s revolution will end badly — for himself, and for America

Unintended consequences will appear, problems will arise and sooner or later the whole project will come to a standstill.
The Hill - 3d
America's Russia policy is a failure of critical thinking and foresight

This persistent inability to appreciate the thinking exposed by another great power is especially striking given that Russia’s policies have not changed at all since the days of Ivan the Terrible ...
The Hill - 1d
What Trump’s Deportation Plans Mean for Central America

Deporting migrants to Central American countries removes many political and legal hurdles for the Trump administration. How far can the practice go before these nations reach a breaking point?
The New York Times - 7h
Ignoring science for profit will have deadly consequences for America

We cannot sell out their climate future for the continued profits of powerful business interests.
The Hill - 3h
Need a New Roof Fast? This Company Can Help

Two industry outsiders say they’re the first to bring the roof-buying process online.
Inc. - 3d
Trump suggests Musk needs to be 'more aggressive'

President Trump suggested in a new post that tech billionaire Elon Musk, one of his closest allies, needs to be “more aggressive" — presumably referring to his efforts to slash spending, downsize ...
The Hill - 2d
Europeans will need to decide which Russian sanctions to keep

And they should identify those they are willing to lift in order to secure a just and durable peace in Ukraine
Financial Times - 1d
Salah: Liverpool's 'big guys' need another title

Mohamed Salah said Liverpool's modern-day legends "need another title" after they swatted aside Manchester City at the Etihad on Sunday.
ESPN - 4h
Whole Hog Politics: Democrats learn the limits of resistance

On the menu: COVID-19 at root of Gen Z move to the right; Vivek readies battle for Ohio; Kemp brushes back Greene; A very big fish story It may be fitting that President Trump has been in a ...
The Hill - 3d
To stop Trump, Democrats must reinvent themselves

Democrats can’t beat Trump and the populist right with the discredited progressive playbook they’ve been following since 2016.
The Hill - 3d
Democrats struggle to reverse Trump's gains with Latinos

Democrats are struggling to reverse the rightward shift among Latino voters seen in November, when President Trump made significant gains with the once reliably blue voting bloc. While a majority ...
The Hill - 19h
Democrats demand Trump nominee commit to Fed independence

US president’s pick to head Council of Economic Advisers has argued the central bank is at odds with US constitution
Financial Times - 7h
Angry Democratic donors turn off the flow of money

Democrats are anxious to rebuild their party on the heels of President Trump’s victory in November. But they have a major problem as they try to refashion their brand: The money isn’t there. ...
The Hill - 6h