Democrats might win over new voters using this one easy trick
In the wake of the only presidential debate, Vice President Kamala Harris is leading nationally. But former President Donald Trump is still twice as likely as Harris to win an Electoral College majority.
Recently Harris has been doubling down on the same tactics that worked for her in the debate, taunting Trump and baiting him. But that may not be enough for her to win. In fact, it could stiffen support for her opponent.
Voters tend to seek consistency with their beliefs. Pummeling them with facts and criticisms inconsistent with their beliefs may actually cause them to dig in. Democrats might want to reconsider their strategy and learn from an experiment that a team of Israeli psychologists conducted during the 2013 Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
To get beyond intractable, hardline support for the conflict, the researchers proposed a fruitful approach they called “paradoxical intervention.” Instead of bombarding voters with facts and opinions that challenged their entrenched support for continuing the fighting, they validated it, but with information that led them to discover for themselves what could be perilous about it. As Kahlil Gibran wrote in “The Prophet” a century ago, the teacher “does not bid you enter [his] house of...wisdom, but rather leads you to the threshold of your own mind.”
In the experiment, hawkish Israeli Jews were shown 30-second videos. Instead of asserting that the conflict threatened peace in the region and should stop, the videos argued Israel couldn’t afford not to continue the conflict, because continuation demonstrates the morality of Israel’s position and encourages unity. This counterintuitive approach did what more conventional messages couldn’t: It unfroze the Israelis’ insistence that the Palestinians were exclusively to blame for continuing the conflict.
That prompted center and right-oriented Israeli Jews to vote for more dovish political parties, and made them more open to compromise in order to reach a peaceful resolution, including eliminating Jewish settlements in the West Bank.
These changes were remarkably long-lasting, especially given the intense counter-messaging voters were subjected to during the period.
“Paradoxical intervention” might also help the 85 percent of white evangelical voters who identify with the GOP to drop their fealty to Trump by leading them “to the threshold of their own knowledge” that Trump’s professed devotion to the Bible and personal relationship with God is disingenuous and false campaign rhetoric.
This process could start with messaging that respects evangelicals’ devotion and their desire to have a devoted Christian in the White House. Then it could revisit videos like Trump discusses the Bible, Trump the Bible Salesman or Trump’s personal relationship with God. Validating their beliefs might take them to a threshold where they can recognize Trump’s palpable ignorance of the Bible and disrespect for their beliefs.
The same counterintuitive logic might help unfreeze conservatives’ obsession with smaller government and their support for hamstringing or dismantling most of the 439 federal agencies.
In this case, the "paradoxical intervention" could start by agreeing that abolishing or undermining federal agencies restores the balance of power and checks and balances among the three branches of government required by the Constitution. It could concede the point that allowing administrative agencies to make and enforce their own interpretations of the law (a hot topic given the recent Loper Bright decision) subjects the country to rulings by unelected bureaucrats whose decisions can be influenced by whoever is in the White House at the time.
Then, taking these views to their logical conclusion, it would propose federal courts hire the expertise they need to address the thousands of diverse, complex, pressing public interest issues Congress entrusted to the federal agencies. That should help Republicans recognize what they may already know deep down: This is an impossibility.
It's like the Aesop’s Fable about the old man who wants to be released from his difficult life and comes face to face with the Grim Reaper. Confronted with death, he learns the moral: “Be careful what you wish for.”
It’s a lesson evangelicals and conservatives might learn. But before that can happen, Democrats need to learn how to curb their knee-jerk opposition and show that they can appreciate the reasons of the other side.
Neil Baron is an attorney who has represented many institutions involved in the international markets and advised various parts of the federal government on economic issues.
Date: |
-
The Guardian - World
Harris to give speech on plans for the economy; major Muslim voter-mobilization group endorses VP – live
VP to outline more economic policies; Emgage Action says endorsement ‘is not an agreement with Harris on all issues’ but ‘honest guidance to our voters’. The only vice-presidential debate before ...20 minutes ago -
Financial Times - World
Poll tracker: Will Trump or Harris win the US presidency?
The FT tracks polling in every state and the possible paths to electoral college victory for Kamala Harris and Donald Trump11 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Wired - Tech
'The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom' Trades Tropes for New Tricks
Nintendo’s latest Legend of Zelda game proves the franchise’s namesake princess doesn’t need to pull off Link’s tricks to have a great game of her own.7 hours ago -
CBS Sports - Sports
Wojciech Szczesny to Barcelona? Why the retired former Juventus keeper might be tempted by a new challenge
Szczesny's retirement is a few months old, and with Mark-Andre ter Stegen injured he could be the perfect replacement1 hour ago -
Wired - Tech
Meta Teaches Its Ray-Ban Smart Glasses Some New AI Tricks
The onboard Meta AI agent can now set a reminder to buy whatever the camera is pointed at, among other enhancements.1 hour ago - Meta -
The Hill - Politics
House GOP feels déjà vu as new funding fight ends with no wins
House Republicans are feeling dejected as they prepare to kick yet another shutdown deadline down the road without securing major wins, an outcome some blame on their own dysfunction. Once again, ...9 hours ago -
ABC News - Sports
Padres clinch postseason berth with 4-2 win over NL West-leading Dodgers in opener of crucial series
Manny Machado started a game-ending triple play and the San Diego Padres clinched a postseason berth with a 4-2 victory over the NL West-leading Los Angeles Dodgers11 hours ago - MLB -
ABC News - Sports
Padres turn triple play to clinch playoff spot with 4-2 win over Dodgers
The San Diego Padres clinched a playoff spot Tuesday night when they stunned the Los Angeles Dodgers with a game-ending triple play to preserve a 4-2 victory over the NL West leaders11 hours ago - MLB -
ABC News - Sports
Wilson gets winning hit in 9th as A's open final series at Coliseum with 5-4 victory over Rangers
Jacob Wilson’s single with one out in the ninth inning gave the Oakland Athletics a 5-4 victory over the Texas Rangers on Tuesday night in the opener of their final series at the Coliseum13 hours ago - MLB
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Senate Democrat unveils legislation giving FDA oversight on CBD safety standards
A new bill could make it easier for the federal government to regulate legal hemp products and keep them out of the hands of Americans under the age of 21. Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) introduced the ...25 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
McConnell criticizes conservative 'cult of personality' around Viktor Orbán
Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell (Ky.) condemned members of his own party for embracing a “cult of personality” around Hungary’s authoritarian leader Viktor Orbán Wednesday on the Senate ...34 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Romney on possible Trump retribution: 'I would take him at his word'
Sen. Mitt Romney (R-Utah) said former President Trump should be taken seriously when he pledges to go after his political enemies if elected to another term in office. “I think he has shown by his ...36 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
2 injured in California courthouse explosion
Two people reported injuries after a California courthouse explosion Wednesday around 8:45 a.m. Police immediately cleared the scene at the Santa Maria Courthouse citing “two reports of ...45 minutes ago - California -
The Hill - Politics
Partisan election integrity gap at record high: Gallup
A record gap has opened up between Democrats and Republicans over their faith in the accuracy of the vote count in the presidential election, a new Gallup poll shows. The survey, conducted from ...52 minutes ago