Democrats look to thwart another trans military ban under Trump
Two House Democrats are looking to block President-elect Trump from enacting another ban on transgender people serving openly in the military, reintroducing legislation Thursday that would prevent the armed forces from hiring or firing someone because of their gender identity or sex characteristics.
Trump, who on the campaign trail last year promised to reinstate a 2017 ban on transgender military service that President Biden repealed in 2021, began drafting an executive order restoring and expanding the policy following his November election win, The Times reported.
At a Turning Point USA event in December, Trump said he will sign an executive order “on day one” to “get transgender out of the military.”
Reps. Sara Jacobs (D-Calif.) and Eric Sorensen’s (D-Ill.) proposal, titled the Ensuring Military Readiness Not Discrimination Act, comes just days before Trump’s Jan. 20 inauguration.
“Kicking nearly 15,000 service members out of the military solely because of their identity would be catastrophic to our military readiness and recruitment,” said Jacobs, a co-chair of the Congressional Equality Caucus’s Transgender Equality Task Force. Her brother, Dylan, is transgender, and another sibling is gender nonconforming.
“Anyone willing and able to sacrifice to defend our country should be able to do so without fear of discrimination — period,” said Sorensen, one of 13 openly LGBTQ lawmakers in the House.
The exact number of openly transgender people serving in the military is unknown; the Department of Defense does not regularly collect data on gender identity.
A 2015 health-related survey conducted by the department found that roughly 6 in every 1,000 active-duty respondents identified as transgender. A follow-up survey released three years later did not report any information on service members' gender identity.
The Williams Institute, a public policy research organization affiliated with the University of California, Los Angeles School of Law, estimated in 2014 that roughly 15,500 transgender people were serving on active duty or in the guard or reserve forces, and another 134,000 were veterans. In 2018, the Palm Center, a think tank focused on gender, sexuality and the military, estimated 14,700 transgender troops are serving in the military.
Trump banned transgender service members through a series of posts in July 2017, writing on social media that the military “cannot be burdened with the tremendous medical costs and disruption that transgender in the military would entail.” He signed a memo the following month instructing the Department of Defense to stop accepting transgender people who want to enlist in the military, and a department policy issued in 2018 effectively banned trans people from serving at all.
The Palm Center estimated in 2017 that Trump’s policy would cost nearly $1 billion, far more than the roughly $15 million the Pentagon said it spent between 2016 and 2021 on treatment for gender dysphoria — severe distress that stems from a mismatch between a person’s gender identity and sex at birth.
Emily Shilling, president of SPARTA, a transgender military organization that has endorsed Jacobs and Sorensen’s bill, said any similar ban instituted by the incoming Trump administration could cost the government up to $18 billion in lost investments.
“If it were a fairly fast-moving ban, you would be pulling these individuals out of their units, leaving critical gaps in skill sets, experience, and leadership positions that you’re just not going to be able to fill with equivalent people anytime soon, especially given the shortfalls in recruiting,” Shilling told writer Erin Reed in November.
“If the incoming Trump Administration reinstates the transgender military ban and discharges all trans service members, it would take 20 years and cost $18 billion to replace the talent and expertise we’ve lost,” Jacobs said Thursday in a statement, referring to Shilling’s calculation.
Their bill, she said, “would ensure that Donald Trump can’t enact discriminatory policies in the military with the stroke of a pen or a tweet.”
The legislation faces near-impossible odds in the GOP-controlled House, which voted this week to ban transgender student-athletes from competing in women’s sports with the support of two Democrats. Biden signed legislation last month that in part prevents transgender children of service members from accessing gender-affirming care through the military’s health program.
Jacobs told HuffPost Thursday that “it’s doubtful” House Republicans will support her bill, which also failed to clinch any GOP support when Jacobs first introduced it in 2023.
“I know some of my Republican colleagues do really understand the sort of recruitment, retention and readiness challenges that we’re facing,” Jacobs told the outlet, adding, “I’m hopeful, but I think they’re all kind of falling in line at the moment.”
A spokesperson for the California lawmaker said Jacobs and Sorensen are working on collecting new cosponsors, but “we imagine it will be only Democrats who cosponsor it.”
In addition to SPARTA, the bill has the backing of the Human Rights Campaign, the nation’s largest LGBTQ advocacy group, and the Modern Military Association of America, an organization that advocates for LGBTQ military members, veterans and families.
Topics
-
Democrats grill Trump budget pick
Welcome to The Hill's Business & Economy newsletter {beacon} Business & Economy Business & Economy The Big Story Trump’s pick for budget chief faces fire in hearing Democrats grilled Russell ...The Hill - 1d -
'It just didn't click': Jets look at another rebuild after disappointing season
Big names, like quarterback Aaron Rodgers, don't translate to wins for New York in 'gut wrenching' year.ESPN - 5d -
Gloom and pessimism take hold of Democrats as they look for new leaders
Questions about the viability of a female presidential candidate rise after a crushing presidential defeat. Democrats are harboring strong feelings of stress and gloom as the new year begins. And ...The Guardian - 5d -
Tennis looks ‘cooked’ as Australian Open starts under giant doping cloud
“I haven’t done anything wrong.” So read the back-page headline on Saturday’s Melbourne Age, above a plaintive-looking photograph of world No1 Jannik Sinner.Yahoo Sports - 5d -
Wall Street looks forward to a bonfire of capital and climate rules under Trump
Profits are poised to dominate in a new era shorn of years of hard-won regulatory restrictions. When some of the biggest banks on Wall Street reveal their full-year earnings this week, they will ...The Guardian - 5d -
Democrats warn party must look beyond 'blue wall' to win
When Democrats lost the White House in November, and watched the Senate flip and the House remain in Republican control, they immediately set their sights on the next fight in 2028. But some ...The Hill - Jan. 9 -
Democrats still underestimate Trump
Despite his greatest political win, and arguably America’s greatest presidential recovery, Trump’s opponents continue to act as though his success is a fluke.The Hill - Jan. 7 -
Democrats under fire for not sounding alarm earlier on Biden
Democratic leaders and lawmakers are coming under growing scrutiny for not blowing the whistle sooner on what is widely perceived to be President Biden’s decline during the final two years of his ...The Hill - Jan. 7 -
Democrats look for places to work with Trump 2.0
Democrats say one thing is certain: 2025 won't be 2017, when it comes to the start of the Trump administration. Two months after their grueling and disappointing White House loss to ...The Hill - Jan. 4
More from The Hill
-
Eric Adams to meet with Trump ahead of his inauguration
New York City Mayor Eric Adams (D) is set to meet with President-elect Trump in Florida on Friday just days ahead of Trump's inauguration next week, according to Adams’s aide. “Tomorrow, Mayor ...The Hill - 2h -
Former FEMA director to Congress: 'Give it back its independent agency status,' direct access to president
Former director of the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) Michael Brown said that Congress should give the disaster relief agency back its “independent agency status,” allowing it direct ...The Hill - 2h -
Biden won't enforce TikTok ban: Reports
Reports allege that President Biden will not enforce the TikTok ban slated to take effect on Sunday, just one day before the presidential inauguration, according to multiple reports, including by ...The Hill - 3h -
Biden says he spent too much time on policy, not enough on politics
President Biden said that he spent too much time on policy and not enough time on politics while reflecting on his presidency in his final interview just days away from leaving office. Biden sat ...The Hill - 3h -
Biden says goodbye to the troops
Welcome to The Hill's Defense & NatSec newsletter {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story Bien says goodbye to the troops President Biden on Thursday ...The Hill - 4h
More in Politics
-
Eric Adams to meet with Trump ahead of his inauguration
New York City Mayor Eric Adams (D) is set to meet with President-elect Trump in Florida on Friday just days ahead of Trump's inauguration next week, according to Adams’s aide. “Tomorrow, Mayor ...The Hill - 2h -
Former FEMA director to Congress: 'Give it back its independent agency status,' direct access to president
Former director of the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) Michael Brown said that Congress should give the disaster relief agency back its “independent agency status,” allowing it direct ...The Hill - 2h -
Biden won't enforce TikTok ban: Reports
Reports allege that President Biden will not enforce the TikTok ban slated to take effect on Sunday, just one day before the presidential inauguration, according to multiple reports, including by ...The Hill - 3h -
Georgia senator arrested after trying to enter House chamber
Georgia State Sen. Colton Moore, a Republican, was arrested when he tried to enter the state House chamber after a previous ban.NBC News - 3h -
Biden says he spent too much time on policy, not enough on politics
President Biden said that he spent too much time on policy and not enough time on politics while reflecting on his presidency in his final interview just days away from leaving office. Biden sat ...The Hill - 3h