Democrats look to put Republicans in a bind on IVF
Senate Democrats are trying to put Republicans in a bind as Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) plans to hold another vote on in vitro fertilization access this week, a move that comes after former President Trump’s call for insurance companies to cover such treatments divided his supporters.
Democrats have felt the wind at their back on the subject for months, and Trump’s call is prompting a second vote on the same bill in a matter of months.
“As you probably noted, abortion and choice were leadoff topics in the debate, and former President Trump went to great lengths to assert himself as a champion of IVF, which came as a surprise to many people,” Senate Majority Whip Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) said. “I think it’s important to give a record vote on the issue. This is going to be a major issue in the campaign.”
“It’s just the issue du jour, so I don’t take that very seriously,” Durbin said, putting it in the same category as Trump’s call to eliminate taxes on tips.
Trump and Republicans for months have tried to rebuff the Democratic narrative that the GOP doesn’t support IVF. They are also quick to note that the trigger for the nationwide IVF discussion was a court in Alabama — not any GOP-led legislature — and that the state’s Republican-led Legislature almost was quick to pass a legislative fix.
But that hasn’t stopped Democrats from tying IVF in with their months-long push on reproductive rights that has tripped up Republicans.
“It’s interesting that IVF is even an issue because Republicans have always been for more babies,” Sen. Markwayne Mullin (R-Okla.) said. “Republicans didn’t start this.”
Only two Republicans — Sens. Susan Collins (Maine) and Lisa Murkowski (Alaska) — voted with Democrats in June when Sen. Tammy Duckworth’s (D-Ill.) proposal came to the floor, and senators are widely expecting a similar outcome next week.
Nevertheless, some Democrats see Trump’s latest stance as an opportunity to gain ground on the idea of mandating coverage for IVF treatments with Republicans in the chamber and believe the former president could be the pick to unlock support, even if it doesn’t change the vote count next week
“Donald Trump coming out of the blue and saying this is something he supports might give us that opportunity,” Sen. Tim Kaine (R-Va.) said.
While that opportunity almost certainly won’t be in the coming days, it could be the case if Trump wins in November — and at first blush, many Republicans are not shunning the idea of mandating insurance coverage of the practice in some way shape or form.
In fact, a number of Republicans from across the ideological spectrum are signaling openness to the possibility, though they caution that it all comes down to how any specific bill is written.
“I’ve thought about this. I agree with President Trump. It’s an expensive medical procedure,” said Sen. Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va.), a member of GOP leadership. “It’s something that bears looking into.”
The likes of Sens. Kevin Cramer (R-N.D.), Eric Schmitt (R-Mo.) and Mullin — all ardent Trump backers — believe the idea is prudent and that it is a fight worth having if the ex-president once again occupies the White House.
“I’m very open to that. I’d be a hypocrite if I wasn’t. I think most of us feel that way,” Cramer said, cautioning that the Senate GOP conference has not discussed Trump’s call en masse or the expected vote since they returned from the August recess last week.
However, there are some Republicans who have made clear they are less than enthused with a government or insurance mandate.
Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) indicated he does not back the plan “because there’s no end to that” and pressed that he would prefer a means-tested tax credit instead.
Sen. Thom Tillis (R-N.C.) told reporters this week he is a “little bit hesitant” on the idea of a mandate, especially as Congress stares down the expiration of the 2018 tax cuts and must deal with those more immediately before dealing with how to pay for this type of IVF coverage.
As leaders know, it’s a point of contention in the conference.
“The mandate part of it is … a challenging issue for lots of reasons,” said Sen. John Thune (R-S.D.), who is running to become the top Senate Republican next year. “Not the least of which, what it does to insurance costs. We put a lot of mandates on insurance companies as it is already. We’ll have, I assume, a fairly robust conversation about that.”
Democrats, though, are not holding their breath — especially when it comes to Trump during the height of election season.
“I think they’re all waiting for Trump to tell them what to do,” Duckworth told The Hill, likening it to the bipartisan border security deal he helped kill. “I don’t think any of them are willing or brave enough to go out on their own on this.”
Date: | |
Tag: | Republican Party |
Topics
-
The Hill - Politics
Republicans block Senate Democrats' IVF bill
Republicans on Tuesday blocked a bill that would have created a right to access in vitro fertilization (IVF) treatments and mandated that insurance plans cover the practice, deriding the vote as a ...Yesterday - Republican Party -
CBS News - Top stories
Senate to vote on IVF package as Democrats look to corner GOP
The Senate is set to vote Tuesday on legislation to protect access to IVF as Democrats look to draw attention to Republican senators' positions.Yesterday -
CBS News - Top stories
Latest news from Capitol Hill as Democrats move on IVF, Republicans work on government shutdown
Lawmakers on Capitol Hill are working to push forward their agenda in Congress. Senate Democrats hope to vote on legislation for in vitro fertilization protections, and House Republicans are ...Yesterday -
The Hill - Politics
Republicans sink IVF bills. Again.
Presented by Plan B One Step — Republicans derided the bill as a show vote {beacon} Health Care Health Care The Big Story Republicans sink IVF bills. Again. In a repeat of this past June, ...Yesterday - Republican Party -
CBS News - Top stories
Senate Republicans block legislation to protect IVF access
Senate Republicans on Tuesday blocked legislation designed to protect access to in vitro fertilization, or IVF, across the U.S. CBS News congressional correspondent Scott MacFarlane has the details.Yesterday - Republican Party -
The Hill - Politics
Democrats block Cruz attempt to pass GOP IVF bill
Democrats on Tuesday blocked an attempt by Republican Sens. Ted Cruz (Texas) and Katie Britt (Ala.) to pass a GOP in vitro fertilization (IVF) access bill through unanimous consent, repeating a ...Yesterday -
NBC News - Top stories
Republicans block another vote on IVF protections as Harris makes it a 2024 issue
Senate Democrats forced a vote on the Right To IVF Act, but it was blocked by Republicans who called it unnecessary and said they support in vitro fertilization.Yesterday - Republican Party -
ABC News - Health
Senate Republicans again block legislation to guarantee women's rights to IVF
Republicans have blocked for a second time this year legislation to establish a nationwide right to in vitro fertilization, arguing that the vote is an election-year stunt after Democrats forced a ...23 hours ago - Republican Party -
The Guardian - World
Senate Republicans block bill to ensure IVF access for second time
Measure falls short of 60-vote majority as Democrats highlight election issue after Alabama court decision. US politics – live updates Senate Republicans voted on Tuesday afternoon to block ...Yesterday - Republican Party -
The Guardian - World
Trump appears at town hall in Michigan; Walz says Trump lost thousands of North Carolina jobs – live
Donald Trump will speak at town hall in Flint; Kamala Harris running mate suggests Trump’s ‘concept’ of a healthcare plan is ‘weak’. As far as the election campaign is concerned, this week the ...23 hours ago - Donald Trump
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
RFK Jr. says he's helping Trump pick leaders of FDA, NIH, CDC
Former independent presidential candidate and antivaccine advocate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said that former President Trump wants him to choose leaders for key public health agencies if he wins the ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
EPA retaliated against three scientists, says watchdog
Presented by TerraPower — The Environmental Protection Agency’s internal watchdog has found that the agency retaliated against three staffers for expressing different scientific opinions. {beacon} ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
House GOP torpedoes Speaker Johnson’s funding bill
House Republicans voted down Speaker Mike Johnson's proposal to fund the government, leaving the path to averting a shutdown unclear and putting Johnson in danger of disappointing former President ...1 hour ago - House -
The Hill - Politics
Congress races to patch $3B Veterans Affairs shortfall
Lawmakers are moving quickly to pass emergency legislation to plug a roughly $3 billion shortfall facing the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA), as officials warn veterans' and survivors' benefits ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
EPA officials retaliated against 3 scientists, watchdog says
The Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) internal watchdog has found that top agency officials retaliated against three staffers for expressing different scientific opinions. The employees who ...1 hour ago