Democrats: Get out of Washington and into the real world
Martha Mitchell was once one of the most famous women in America. A conservative socialite from Pine Bluff, Ark., and wife of President Nixon’s attorney general, she was known for her sharp wit and even sharper tongue. Time put her on its cover, calling her a “figure of ridicule to liberals and a public embarrassment to many a traditionalist Republican.” She was the “Mouth of the South,” the second-most in-demand GOP speaker after Nixon himself.
But when she spoke the truth about Watergate, Nixon’s allies tried to destroy her. They labeled her crazy, mocked her in the press, and even drugged and held her against her will. Her name now defines the Martha Mitchell effect, which occurs when someone tells the truth but is dismissed as delusional because it sounds too outrageous to believe.
Democrats are quickly falling victim to the Martha Mitchell effect.
For years, we’ve been sounding the alarm on Donald Trump — his corruption, his attacks on democracy, his reckless rhetoric. Much of the country tunes us out. Why? Because when everything is an outrage, nothing is.
We’ve become Martha Mitchell, shouting into the void, convinced that if we just scream louder, voters will finally listen. Worse yet, we keep pulling the wrong fire alarm, so to speak. Instead of making the case for how we’ll actually improve people’s lives, we’ve positioned ourselves as defenders of democracy— a message that might resonate in Washington and in college faculty lounges, but not in the places where elections are decided. And that’s not on the voters — that’s on us.
We’re fighting the wrong battles in the wrong places
Take USAID, for example. When Trump gutted it, Democrats predictably rushed to defend it. And where did we hold our big press conference? Outside a government building in Washington, D.C., talking about the importance of foreign aid. We framed this as a threat to democracy.
Voters didn’t hear that. What they did see and hear was: Here are some more Washington insiders defending more Washington bureaucracy.
Meanwhile, where are the Republicans? Everywhere. Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem is inexplicably riding a horse at the border. Phil McGraw, former host of the daytime talk show “Dr. Phil,” is tagging along with ICE agents on immigration raids. And earlier this month, President Trump became the first sitting president to attend a Super Bowl.
Where are the Democrats?
I’ll tell you where we should have been. As Rahm Emanuel recently said, we should have been in grocery stores across America this weekend protesting the rising costs of eggs (which have blown past record highs) and putting the blame where it belongs — on Trump.
Here’s the thing about pocketbook issues: Voters don’t need to be reminded of them. They experience them every single day.
My grandmother, who lives on Social Security, knows when the price of eggs goes up. My brother and his family of five know when gas prices inch up. My parents’ small business feels it every time health insurance premiums rise.
Voters don’t need us to point these things out, but we do need to ensure they know who is responsible — and what Democrats are going to do about it.
I have two lessons Democrats need to learn from this. The first is to stop pretending the system isn’t broken. Voters already believe Washington is failing them. Pretending otherwise makes us look out of touch. Bill Clinton understood this in 1992, when he ran to “end welfare as we know it.” He positioned himself between Republicans who wanted to eliminate welfare and Democrats who wanted to protect a clearly broken system as it was.
Four years later, he signed the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act, shifting control of welfare to the states and ending six decades of federal government dominance. In doing so, he also preserved critical support for those in need. He didn’t just defend the status quo, he reformed it. And voters rewarded him.
If Democrats refuse to acknowledge that our government isn’t working the way it should, Republicans will keep making the case that we’re the problem — and voters will believe them.
The second lesson is to stop sounding the alarm and start offering solutions. The Martha Mitchell Effect isn’t just about being dismissed — it’s about being dismissed because of how you sound.
The message from that press conference outside USAID didn’t land in living rooms across America. Most voters didn’t even know what USAID was, and even those who did struggled to understand why its funding cuts were an existential crisis. Once again, we pulled the fire alarm when all Americans saw was a controlled burn.
When we constantly sound the alarm over crises that don’t affect people’s daily lives, we come across as disconnected at best and hysterical at worst. Eventually, voters stop listening. They don’t want a party that just yells about threats to democracy or reflexively defends a broken status quo. They want leaders who focus on the issues that matter to them — who understand their struggles and actually work to make their lives better.
Democrats need to get out of Washington and into the real world. If we don’t, we'll become just another Martha Mitchell.
Brad Howard is a Democratic strategist who is the founder and president of Corcoran Street Group and who currently serves on the District of Columbia’s Advisory Neighborhood Commission. An Obama administration alumnus, he previously served as chief of staff to former Rep. Stephanie Murphy (D-Fla.), and as spokesperson for the House Blue Dog Coalition; U.S. Rep. Mike Ross (D-Ark.); and New Orleans Mayor Mitch Landrieu.
Topics
-
Reeling Texas Democrats Get a Rare Sight: Their National Chair
Though victory in the state feels farther away than ever, some Democrats, including their new leader, say Texas could still be a key part of their party’s future.The New York Times - 6h -
World champion Dubois out of Parker fight with illness
Heavyweight Daniel Dubois' world title defence against Joseph Parker on Saturday is in doubt with reports that the champion is ill.BBC News - 10h -
TikTok's top artist Yeri Mua gets real on immigration, Bellakath beef
The reggaeton mexa star spoke with De Los during the U.S. leg of her Traka Tour.Los Angeles Times - 23h -
The World Is in a Polyester Crisis. One Company Is Trying to Recycle a Way Out
The European company Reju may have developed the polyester recycling technology the textile industry needs. The question is whether the world is ready for it.Wired - 6h -
Unit Network raises $18M for decentralized platform enabling real-world and digital asset trading
Unit Network, a decentralized financial ecosystem enabling tradING of real-world and digital assets through tokenization, has raised $18 million.VentureBeat - 1d -
Daniel Dubois pulls out of world title fight with Joseph Parker due to illness
British heavyweight was due to defend title on Saturday Martin Bakole steps in to face Parker as replacement Daniel Dubois has withdrawn from his IBF world heavyweight title defence against ...The Guardian - 22h -
It’s Trump’s economy now — and businesses are anxious about tariffs and Washington upheaval
A burst of optimism among companies after Donald Trump won the U.S. presidential election has faded as business leaders grapple with potentially negative policies of the new White House.MarketWatch - 2h -
'Indiscriminate’ Pentagon cuts unnerve Democrats
{beacon} Welcome to The Hill's Defense & NatSec newsletter {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story 'Indiscriminate’ Pentagon cuts unnerve Democrats Democrats ...The Hill - 17h -
Democratic governors push back against Trump
With Democrats in the minority in Washington, D.C., it could be up to governors to mount the party's opposition to President Trump's agenda. Ofirah Yheskel, director of external affairs for the ...CBS News - 18h -
Whole Hog Politics: Democrats learn the limits of resistance
On the menu: COVID-19 at root of Gen Z move to the right; Vivek readies battle for Ohio; Kemp brushes back Greene; A very big fish story It may be fitting that President Trump has been in a ...The Hill - 7h
More from The Hill
-
Eric Adams's trial adjourned indefinitely as judge weighs dropping charges
The federal judge overseeing New York City Mayor Eric Adams’s (D) criminal case indefinitely delayed his April trial as he considers a controversial effort by President Trump’s Justice Department ...The Hill - 15m -
Nixon didn’t break the Constitution. Will Trump?
2025 obviously is different from 1973.The Hill - 25m -
Levin defends Zelensky, Ukraine amid sharp words from Trump
Conservative pundit Mark Levin of Fox News on Wednesday sought to defend Ukraine President Volodomyr Zelensky, who has come under days of criticism from President Trump over the Ukraine war. Levin ...The Hill - 32m -
Pepperdine University says Mindy Kaling's new Netflix series 'misappropriated' its basketball team
Pepperdine University has filed a lawsuit against Netflix and Warner Bros. Discovery over Mindy Kaling’s upcoming show "Running Point,” alleging trademark infringement regarding its basketball ...The Hill - 44m -
Hamas’s failure to return Israeli mother’s body strains ceasefire
A tenuous ceasefire between Israel and Hamas has been strained by outrage over Hamas’s alleged transfer of an unknown body to Israel in the place of Shiri Bibas, the Israeli mother who was ...The Hill - 48m
More in Politics
-
Eric Adams's trial adjourned indefinitely as judge weighs dropping charges
The federal judge overseeing New York City Mayor Eric Adams’s (D) criminal case indefinitely delayed his April trial as he considers a controversial effort by President Trump’s Justice Department ...The Hill - 15m -
Nixon didn’t break the Constitution. Will Trump?
2025 obviously is different from 1973.The Hill - 25m -
Levin defends Zelensky, Ukraine amid sharp words from Trump
Conservative pundit Mark Levin of Fox News on Wednesday sought to defend Ukraine President Volodomyr Zelensky, who has come under days of criticism from President Trump over the Ukraine war. Levin ...The Hill - 32m -
Pepperdine University says Mindy Kaling's new Netflix series 'misappropriated' its basketball team
Pepperdine University has filed a lawsuit against Netflix and Warner Bros. Discovery over Mindy Kaling’s upcoming show "Running Point,” alleging trademark infringement regarding its basketball ...The Hill - 44m -
Hamas’s failure to return Israeli mother’s body strains ceasefire
A tenuous ceasefire between Israel and Hamas has been strained by outrage over Hamas’s alleged transfer of an unknown body to Israel in the place of Shiri Bibas, the Israeli mother who was ...The Hill - 48m