Democrats fume over weak early response to Trump
Democrats are fuming about their party leadership's early response to President Trump.
Strategists say the reaction to Trump is inconsistent and not aggressive enough to combat Trump, who has taken a series of actions to remake the government.
In a whirlwind first two weeks in office, Trump has issued a string of executive orders, removed agency watchdogs and eliminated government diversity programs.
And while Democrats have begun to punch back, strategists say it’s not nearly enough, especially as a number of Democrats in the Senate join Republicans in confirming Trump's Cabinet officials.
“Democratic leadership acts like it’s permanently 2006, a year when, yes, we took back the Senate, but also before the Republican Party found a cult leader and lost its collective minds,” Democratic strategist Christy Setzer said. “We don't live in that world anymore. We have a lifelong conman and convicted felon in the Oval Office who tries every day to turn this country into a dictatorship; let's start acting like it.
“That means you can't be mad about Trump trying to freeze government spending in the morning, and vote for his Treasury secretary — who will destroy the economy — in the afternoon,” Setzer added. “Stop helping Trump.”
Another strategist put it this way: “Trump is eating us for lunch and for the most part, we're letting him.”
Frustrations mounted during a tense call last week between Democratic governors and Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer (N.Y.). Six Democratic governors, including Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker and Massachusetts Gov. Maura Healey, pressed Schumer to put up more of a fight against Trump’s agenda.
Healey specifically urged Schumer to slow down Senate votes and do more to stir up public opposition, per The New York Times, which first reported the call.
That produced an exasperated response from Senate Democrats, who spoke on the floor late into the night Wednesday to highlight the impact the funding freeze ordered by Trump’s budget office would have on communities around the country.
“I would say to my friend [Pritzker], as you would like to have a majority of governors, we would like to have the majority of senators. There’s a limit to how much we can we do,” Senate Democratic Whip Dick Durbin (Ill.) said.
Senate Democrats are divided over how hard they should fight to resist Trump’s agenda, with Democrats up for reelection in battleground states looking for areas of compromise.
Seven Democrats voted last week to confirm Kristi Noem as secretary of Homeland Security, where she will have oversight of Trump’s border security and immigration policies, including plans to deport hundreds of thousands of immigrants.
Sen. Chris Murphy (D-Conn.) is calling for Democrats to put up more resistance against Trump’s nominees. He slowed the confirmation process down last month by putting a hold on John Ratcliffe, Trump’s pick to head the CIA.
“I’m not voting for a single nominee while this crisis over federal spending persists, and I don’t think we should proceed to any legislation until Republicans stand up and start helping us protect democracy,” Murphy said last week, referring to Trump’s executive orders freezing broad swaths of federal funding.
Murphy argued that voters around the country won’t fully accept the alarms Democrats have raised about Trump’s agenda until they see Democratic senators and House members deploying every tactic they can to fight it in Washington.
“I do not think that we will be able to convince people that this is a serious, grave moment if we are helping them populate a deeply corrupt government and helping them pass legislation here,” he said.
Murphy noted that Doug Burgum, Trump’s pick to lead the Interior Department, will oversee the effort to expand oil and gas drilling on federal lands. He just got “a whole bunch of Democratic votes,” the senator said.
Twenty-five Democrats and Sen. Angus King (I-Maine), who caucuses with Democrats, voted to confirm Burgum Thursday.
“We are wondering why people out there are not rising up in the way that they did in 2017, even though Trump’s conduct is worse,” Murphy said. “I think they watch us supporting his policies and his nominees and come to the conclusion it must not be that bad.”
At the same time, Senate progressives were deeply frustrated with centrists who voted last month with Republicans to pass the Laken Riley Act, which mandates the federal detention of migrants accused of theft, burglary or assaulting law enforcement.
Democratic critics warned their colleagues it would worsen the problem of “mass incarceration” and likely sweep up children in mass detentions.
Some Democratic senators said they were frustrated that Schumer didn’t keep members of his caucus in line before they voted to take up that bill on the Senate floor, putting it on a fast-track to passing and getting signed into law as one of Trump’s first major accomplishments.
One Democratic senator acknowledged that Democrats were caught flat-footed.
“Look we have a bunch of freshmen who had already voted for Laken Riley in the House and were unwilling” to change their position on the bill, said the lawmaker, who described it as a “terribly written” law with “significant unintended consequences.”
“I don’t think we had a cohesive caucus response to that,” the senator added.
After the governor's call with Schumer on Wednesday, another Democratic senator bristled at the incoming criticism from those within their party.
“A lot of folks aren’t that familiar with the rules and they haven’t caught up to where we are. We cannot block a single nominee unless we get [four Republicans to vote no],” the senator said.
“We’ve got folks who want to vote for Republican nominees, [Sens. John] Fetterman [D-Pa.] and [Sheldon] Whitehouse [D-R.I.] and persuading them not to has been an important caucus win,” the lawmaker added. “We came close to defeating Hegseth,” referring to Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth.
“What more do they want us to do? Handcuff ourselves to lampposts and get arrested?” the senator asked incredulously.
Democratic strategist Rodell Mollineau, who served as a senior aide to the late Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.), said he is sympathetic to the frustration but noted that Democrats had a good week and found an opening to fire back at Republicans over federal funding.
“Democrats found an opening this week and exploited it,” Mollineau said, adding that Democrats “have to be ready for these kinds of moments.”
“There will be many pitches to swing at. We don't need to swing at every one,” he said.
But Mollineau cautioned that Democrats “can't fight with the old playbook.”
“They need to find new ways to find the audiences they need to reach and counter the administration's moves,” he said. “We need to be smart about where we fight and when we fight and how we fight to maximize our leverage.”
Topics
-
Democrats leave 'emergency' meeting vowing ‘street fight’ in response to Trump actions
House Democrats launched a multilateral effort Wednesday to combat the flood of executive actions from President Trump, vowing to punch back through legislation, lawsuits and a blitz of ...The Hill - 4d -
Democrats urge delay on Trump budget office nominee in response to funding freeze
Senate Democrats are demanding Republicans postpone a vote scheduled for Thursday on Russell Vought, President Trump’s nominee to head the Office of Management and Budget, after the budget office ...The Hill - 5d -
Kinzinger on Democrats' response to Trump's first week: 'Crickets'
Former Rep. Adam Kinzinger (R-Ill.) said President Trump’s first week in office was filled with “crickets” from Democrats who he claims did very little to oppose new executive actions. “I’ll be ...The Hill - 5d -
In Response to Trump Tariff Threat, Ontario Premier Calls an Early Election
Doug Ford, Ontario’s Conservative leader, has recently said that President Trump was “going to try to devastate our country” with a plan to impose tariffs on Canadian exports.The New York Times - Jan. 24 -
These Democrats helped hand Trump an early immigration win
Congress handed President Trump an early win on the issue of immigration with the passage of the Laken Riley Act by the House on Wednesday. While the bill was heavily backed by Republicans in both ...The Hill - Jan. 23 -
L.A. Fire Department officials face criticism over early wildfire response
The most dangerous of the winds in Southern California will be dying down over the next few hours, giving firefighters a much-needed break. Jonathan Vigliotti has new reporting on how some of them ...CBS News - Jan. 15 -
GOP plows ahead with Hegseth hearing as Democrats fume
Senate Armed Services Committee Democrats are fuming as Pete Hegseth, President-elect Trump’s controversial pick to lead the Pentagon, is set to head back to Capitol Hill Tuesday for his ...The Hill - Jan. 13 -
Democrats fume over Alito-Trump call
Senate Democrats are furious that President-elect Trump has reached out to conservative Justice Samuel Alito amid a push by Trump for the high court to halt his criminal sentencing. Alito has ...The Hill - Jan. 10
More from The Hill
-
Alicia Keys uses Grammy win to make impassioned plea for diversity: 'DEI is not a threat, it's a gift'
Alicia Keys used her remarks at the Grammy Awards late Sunday to make an impassioned plea for diversity, "This is not the time to shut down a diversity of voices. We've seen on this stage, ...The Hill - 24m -
McConnell: Trump pardons a 'mistake,' Jan. 6 'an insurrection'
Former Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) said it was a “mistake” for President Trump to pardon individuals convicted of crimes connected to the attack on the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021. ...The Hill - 27m -
Amazon's exit from Quebec is a wake-up call for workers' rights in the US
Amazon’s decision to close operations in Quebec wasn’t subtle. It sends an unmistakable message: if you unionize, we’ll leave.The Hill - 41m -
McConnell: Trump tariffs 'will drive the cost of everything up'
Former Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) is warning that President Trump’s 25-percent tariffs on Canada and Mexico “will drive the cost of everything up” and wondering, “Why would ...The Hill - 1h -
Army identifies third soldier killed in DC crash
The U.S. Army on Saturday identified the third soldier who died last week during a training mission that ended in a midair crash between an Army Black Hawk helicopter and an American Airlines ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
Trump draws backlash over tariffs, including from top Republicans
President Trump’s sweeping new tariffs on imports from China, Canada and Mexico is drawing widespread backlash including from key Republicans as those countries threaten to retaliate with tariffs ...NBC News - 20m -
Trump draws backlash over tariffs, including from top Republicans
President Trump’s sweeping new tariffs on imports from China, Canada and Mexico is drawing widespread backlash including from key Republicans as those countries threaten to retaliate with tariffs ...NBC News - 20m -
Alicia Keys uses Grammy win to make impassioned plea for diversity: 'DEI is not a threat, it's a gift'
Alicia Keys used her remarks at the Grammy Awards late Sunday to make an impassioned plea for diversity, "This is not the time to shut down a diversity of voices. We've seen on this stage, ...The Hill - 24m -
McConnell: Trump pardons a 'mistake,' Jan. 6 'an insurrection'
Former Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) said it was a “mistake” for President Trump to pardon individuals convicted of crimes connected to the attack on the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021. ...The Hill - 27m -
Amazon's exit from Quebec is a wake-up call for workers' rights in the US
Amazon’s decision to close operations in Quebec wasn’t subtle. It sends an unmistakable message: if you unionize, we’ll leave.The Hill - 41m