Democrats fight for Tester in Montana as Sheehy pulls away
Democrats are refusing to give up on Sen. Jon Tester’s (D-Mont.) reelection bid even as his chances appear bleak with just more than two weeks until Election Day.
To GOP senators and operatives, the writing has been on the wall for weeks about Tester — and the font has been getting larger by the day. They see little way back for the three-term Democrat in his fight with Republican Tim Sheehy, who leads by 7 percentage points, according to Decision Desk HQ/The Hill’s polling average.
But that has not dissuaded Democrats and outside groups, who are intent on keeping tens of millions of dollars in ad buys through Nov. 5 in Montana and maintain the race — on which control of the Senate hinges — is by no means over.
“We remain confident of Senator Tester’s ability to win the race in part because he’s so rooted in the state,” said JB Poersch, president of the Senate Majority PAC (SMP), the largest Democratic outside group backing Senate Democratic candidates.
The SMP is putting its money where its mouth is. According to ad-tracking data, the group spent $5.3 million last week to boost Tester and is set to drop a similar amount next week. Overall, spending by Tester and outside groups is almost evenly matched with the GOP’s spending level.
“Yes, we do. We think it’s viable,” Poersch continued.
Tester also gave himself a financial shot in the arm last week by posting a $30 million fundraising haul over the past three months. That could leave him with more than he can spend on the airwaves in the final weeks in one of the least expensive states on the Senate map.
However, the math is simple for the GOP: defeat Tester, and the Senate majority is almost assuredly theirs.
Republicans have other pickup opportunities, including in an increasingly red Ohio and a handful of battleground states. But none are as prime for the picking as Montana, which former President Trump carried by more than 16 percentage points four years ago.
That has made defeating the incumbent Democrat their top priority, especially after Sen. Joe Manchin’s (I-W.Va.) retirement put them on the doorstep of retaking the chamber.
Decision Desk HQ puts Sheehy’s chances of victory at 81 percent. But a number of Democrats, including those in the state, still see a close contest.
“I’m still not betting against Tester. That’s the bottom line,” one Montana-based Democratic strategist told The Hill. “He knows how to win close races and he knows how to turn out a vote. … That muscle memory is something I’m not going to bet against.”
“It’s definitely an uphill climb,” the strategist conceded.
Democrats maintain the GOP has become too confident in a state that is known to be tough to poll and where Tester has previously prevailed despite being down in the polls. That was especially true in 2012, the last time he ran in a presidential year.
“They’re clearly, in my view, making a mistake,” said Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.), who ran the Senate Democratic campaign’s efforts during Tester’s last reelection win. “Never count out Jon Tester.”
But there are still major questions for Tester to answer.
He hasn’t had to overcome quite such a big polling deficit before. And the Trump factor looms large.
According to the recent New York Times/Siena College survey, Trump leads Vice President Harris by 17 points in Montana — a tick higher than his 2020 margin, meaning Tester would need nearly 1 in 5 supporters of the former president to split their tickets and also pull the lever for him.
That also means he and Harris need to walk a fine line. Tester notably has not endorsed her and has tried to keep his attention on the state.
“The problem they have there is that Harris can be of no help to Tester. Republicans would probably love to see Harris go to Montana,” one Senate GOP member said.
It also remains to be seen whether Tester is able to turn out the reservations and the Native American population in the state, which he has been able to do in his past victories. Native Americans make up nearly 7 percent of the state’s population and represented 5 percent of the 2018 voter electorate when Tester was last on the ballot. He won a third term by 3.5 percentage points over Rep. Matt Rosendale (R-Mont.).
Democratic operatives believe turnout from reservations, Native Americans and tribes will be make or break for the Montana Democrat.
“Native American and reservation turnout will be a major factor in the outcome of this race. Sheehy certainly put his foot in his mouth with his comments about drunk Indians at 8 a.m.,” said the Montana-based Democratic strategist. “That’s really been a galvanizing thing across all tribal and native demographics.”
Sheehy has since said his remarks were “insensitive.”
The strategist also noted that Native American turnout dropped precipitously between Tester’s 2018 contest and the race four years later, which they chalk up to the lack of a top-of-the-ticket draw and a bad winter storm. But that has prompted native groups to redouble their efforts this cycle. Van Hollen recalled that turning them out “requires real effort.”
Despite the polls, Democrats say they have plenty to attack Sheehy on. In addition to his comments about Native Americans, Democrats are going after his out-of-state ties and questions surrounding a gunshot wound. Sheehy says he sustained it in Afghanistan as a Navy SEAL, but other accounts say he accidentally shot himself in Glacier National Park.
Two more stories questioning his account emerged Friday.
Van Hollen likened the race to Sen. Susan Collins’s (R-Maine) win in a blue state four years ago after one survey after another predicted she would lose to Democrat Sara Gideon.
“It’s just an example of when things get very tight, it all comes down to the ground game,” Van Hollen said, lauding Tester’s efforts on that front.
However, the race is a catch-22 of sorts for top Democratic groups. They face the question of whether to keep money in the race, even as the polling drifts away from them, that could be spent to boost battleground-state incumbents or to fund long-shot bids in Texas and Florida, or to pull money and redistribute it in other states, essentially conceding the majority.
"We're pleased that Schumer is still spending in Montana. It's looking like a lost cause for them,” said one GOP operative involved in Senate races. “But obviously we'd love for them to accept defeat and completely pull out.”
Date: |
-
Top stories - The New York Times
The Hard Truth About Montana and Jon Tester’s Senate Race
The state’s changing electorate and America’s polarized politics have turned Montana’s Senate race into the most consequential of the year.5 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
Tester posts $30 million fundraising haul as Sheehy rises in polls
Sen. Jon Tester’s (D-Mont.) campaign raised $30 million during the third quarter of 2024 as he tries to reverse GOP momentum in the state and nab a fourth full term in office, according to filings ...4 days ago -
Sports - ESPN
Stewart wreaks 'havoc' as Liberty win to tie series
Breanna Stewart scored 21 points and Betnijah Laney-Hamilton added 20 to help the New York Liberty beat the Minnesota Lynx 80-66 on Sunday in Game 2 of the WNBA Finals.6 days ago -
Top stories - The New York Times
Harris Fights to Restore a Splintering Democratic Coalition
Defections from Black and Latino voters are making Kamala Harris more dependent on white, suburban voters — and complicating her path to victory.6 days ago -
Sports - CBS Sports
Biggest questions for MLB playoffs on Thursday: Can Dodgers pull away in NLCS, Guardians avoid 3-0 hole?
Aaron Judge will try to get going in ALCS Game 3 and why the Mets are not in a 'must-win' game at Citi Field3 days ago - MLB -
Top stories - NBC News
Democrats flooded with cash in fight for Congress as the GOP tries to stretch its money
Democrats in key Senate and House races once again posted huge fundraising numbers, vastly outspending their Republican opponents from July through September.3 days ago -
Top stories - BBC News
Democrats travel deep into Trump country in fight for prize state
No Democrat has won North Carolina since 2008, but polls show they have a chance - if they can beat Republicans on their home turf.Yesterday - Donald Trump -
Top stories - CBS News
Montana Jordan and Emily Osment on returning for "Georgie and Mandy's First Marriage"
Montana Jordan and Emily Osment return to the small screen in Georgie and Mandy's First Marriage, a sequel to "Young Sheldon." The comedy follows the couple as they balance the challenges of ...4 days ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Graham on Republicans supporting Harris: 'What the hell are you doing?
Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) on Sunday questioned Republicans who take issue with former President Trump’s “rhetoric” and have decided to back Vice President Harris’s presidential bid instead. “To ...51 minutes ago - Republican Party -
Politics - The Hill
Trump works the drive-thru at Pennsylvania McDonald’s
Former President Trump on Sunday stepped behind the counter at a McDonald's in Pennsylvania, working the drive-thru for a short time after he spent weeks mocking Vice President Harris's past ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Raffensperger denies voter fraud amid Georgia’s historic early-vote turnout
Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger (R) denied there is voting fraud happening in the state as it sees historic early-voting turnout this month. Raffensperger weighed in on claims made by ...1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
Obama's comments reveal what the Democratic Party thinks about the Black electorate
Former President Barack Obama and Vice President Kamala Harris have criticized Black men for not being excited about the Democratic Party, citing a perceived lack of support for women in politics.1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
Top 5 ways education would look different under Harris vs. Trump
Education issues have flown under the radar this election cycle despite both major candidates having big ideas about how the K-12 and college systems should work. From student loans to ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump