Democrats eager to fight Vance over ObamaCare rollback
Republican vice presidential nominee Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio) said he wants to roll back ObamaCare’s protections for people with preexisting conditions, reopening a fight that’s repeatedly burned Republicans in the past — and one Democrats are eager to have.
During a campaign rally in North Carolina on Wednesday, Vance described a plan to remove federal regulations from the health care system but still ensure people get the coverage they need.
“We're gonna actually implement some regulatory reform in the health care system that allows people to choose a health care plan that works for them,” Vance said.
He added the idea would be to “allow people with similar health situations to be in the same risk pools," meaning sicker people would have to buy different insurance plans from people who were healthy.
“That’s the biggest and most important thing that we have to change,” Vance said.
His remarks during the rally expanded on comments he made in an interview on NBC’s “Meet the Press” last week, where he said former President Trump doesn’t believe in a “one-size-fits-all” approach that puts “a lot of people into the same insurance pools.”
Vance did not offer any other details, so it’s not clear if his remarks represent an official Trump campaign health plan, but Trump aides have said he and Vance are broadly aligned on health care. Vance also said he’s “learned his lesson” about speaking for Trump, as he previously needed to walk back comments about Trump vetoing a national abortion ban.
On the presidential debate stage, Trump said he had “concepts of a plan” to replace the health law if it were repealed, drawing ridicule from Democrats. Trump’s official platform doesn’t mention ObamaCare at all.
In attempting to fill in the blanks of Trump’s plan, Vance described the same “high-risk pools” championed by conservatives in the House when they were crafting an ObamaCare replacement bill in 2017.
Democrats were more than happy to point out the echoes.
“This looks to me like what amounts to a de facto repeal of one of the protections everyone says they’re for around here,” Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) said during a Senate Finance Committee hearing last week.
“The concepts proposed by JD Vance are a prescription for discriminating against those with preexisting conditions,” he added.
The Harris campaign was also quick to amplify Vance’s comments.
“There should be no doubt about Donald Trump’s commitment to end the Affordable Care Act — he and House Republicans tried doing it over 60 times,” Harris spokesperson Joseph Costello said in a statement.
“Now, one of the ‘concepts’ he’s bringing back is his plan to rip away protections for pre-existing conditions, throw millions off their health care, and drive up costs for millions of Americans with pre-existing conditions.”
The Affordable Care Act, or ObamaCare, has experienced a significant political renaissance.
Almost as soon as the law was passed in 2010, it became an albatross for Democrats. It cost them control of the House and Senate, and Trump pledged to “repeal and replace” the health law on his way to winning the presidency in 2016.
But after Trump and congressional Republicans failed to repeal the law in 2017 by a single vote, its popularity soared. Democrats won back control of the House in the 2018 midterms in part by campaigning on protecting preexisting conditions.
When Trump was elected in November 2016, just 43 percent of adults supported ObamaCare, according to a tracking poll conducted by the nonpartisan health research group KFF. The most recent poll published in May showed 62 percent of respondents view the law favorably.
“I think there is a broad consensus across geography, party, age, ethnic group, that people should not be denied or discriminated against based on their preexisting conditions,” said Anthony Wright, CEO of the health advocacy group Families USA. “And yet, this is where we are. It is bizarre that we're still talking about it.”
Vance’s ideas are not unique to the Trump campaign.
For instance, the fiscal 2025 budget proposal from the Republican Study Committee, which includes most of the House GOP caucus, recommends removing many of the existing protections for people with preexisting conditions, including allowing states to offer separate risk pools for younger, healthier people.
Experts have said high-risk pools can work in theory if they are sufficiently subsidized by the government. For more than 35 years, before the Affordable Care Act passed, red and blue states alike used high-risk pools to cover people with expensive medical conditions separately from the rest of the insurance market.
But the pools lacked sufficient funding and so rarely succeeded in covering people who needed insurance the most.
“I have yet to see an example of them ever being done right,” Wright said.
Polls show voters want to hear about plans to lower health costs. And according to a KFF tracking poll released earlier this month, voters trust Vice President Harris to do a better job than Trump on health costs by a 48-to-39-percent margin.
Democratic groups are also painting Trump as an “existential threat” to drive voters to the polls.
The Democratic-aligned group Protect Our Care is launching a “Lower Costs, Better Care” bus tour on Sept. 23 across battleground states. They want to highlight the efforts of the Biden-Harris administration while also “sounding the alarm about the threat Donald Trump and MAGA Republicans pose to American health care.”
Date: |
Topics
-
BBC News - Top stories
'Awesome' to fight Verstappen and Hamilton - Norris
Lando Norris beats title rival Max Verstappen to pole position in a dramatic qualifying session at the Singapore Grand Prix.11 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
8 Democrats vote to ax Biden’s EV rule
Eight Democrats voted with House Republicans in favor of overturning a Biden administration rule that’s expected to force automakers to make a significant portion of their fleet electric. The ...2 days ago - Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
House Democrats’ campaign arm raises $22M in August
The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee (DCCC), House Democrats' campaign arm, raised $22 million in the month after President Biden dropped out of the presidential race. “The DCCC raised ...2 days ago -
The New York Times - Top stories
Mike DeWine: I Don’t Recognize the Springfield That Trump and Vance Describe
I have lived my entire life near this city. Our people and our history deserve better than to be falsely portrayed.Yesterday - Donald Trump -
The Guardian - World
Trump and Vance’s Springfield smear is a microcosm of their entire campaign | Sidney Blumenthal
The Republicans desperately need to distract voters away from abortion. They’ve now found the perfect new scapegoat. After Donald Trump ’s disastrous debate with Kamala Harris on 10 September he ...2 days ago - Donald Trump -
The Guardian - World
Ohio’s Republican governor condemns Trump and Vance for Springfield claims
Mike DeWine criticizes pair in New York Times op-ed for repeating racist claims about Haitian immigrants. Ohio’s Republican governor, Mike DeWine, on Friday criticized former US president Donald ...Yesterday - Donald Trump -
The New York Times - Top stories
JD Vance to Appear With Tucker Carlson, Who Amplified False Holocaust Claims
The Republican vice-presidential nominee will share a stage with Mr. Carlson, who was criticized for interviewing a writer who falsely claimed the Holocaust was not an intentional act of genocide.21 hours ago -
NBC News - Politics
Vance says allegations against Mark Robinson 'aren't necessarily reality'
Sen. JD Vance reacted to the bombshell report about Mark Robinson, the Republican candidate for governor in North Carolina, saying that the allegations against Robinson "aren't necessarily reality."16 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Pennsylvania Democrat stresses need for bipartisanship in probe of Trump assassination attempts
Rep. Chrissy Houlahan (D-Pa.) said Sunday that it is critical for the bipartisan task force investigating the assassination attempts against former President Trump to work swiftly and in a ...51 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Rubio says he trusts field FBI agents to probe Trump shooting attempts, but notes ‘history’ of bias from leadership
Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.), vice chair of the Senate Intelligence Committee, said he trusts rank-and-file FBI agents to do their jobs as they probe the apparent shooting attempts on former President ...58 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Kirby says Israel cease-fire talks ‘not achieving any progress’
National Security spokesperson John Kirby said Sunday that cease-fire talks with Israel and Hamas have not been “achieving any progress” in recent weeks. Kirby joined ABC’s “This Week,” where he ...1 hour ago - Israel -
The Hill - Politics
Move fast and break things? Not again, and not with AI.
Don’t buy what Zuckerberg is selling.1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
Ahead of Trump assassination attempt hearing, leaders say security not doing enough
Reps. Mike Kelly (R-Pa.) and Jason Crow (D-Colo.) joined ABC’s “This Week” ahead of their hearing Thursday about former President Trump’s assassination attempt. They argued that the Secret Service ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump